WWE: 11 Things That Killed The Attitude Era

WWE completely fell apart in 2001 and would never recover.

By Grahame Herbert /

The 1998 to 2001 period in the WWF was a critical and commercial success, with nearly every show feeling like 'must watch' television. Then in spring of 2001 it felt like everything changed. Creatively the company started to dip, leading to commercial recession too. By 2002 the product was in freefall, Mania buy rates had been rising year on year since the mid 90's, WrestleMania X8 was the first one in a long while not to top the previous year. Much loved characters and storylines were gone, attempts to introduce new stories and wrestlers being consistently misjudged. The once "popular", "trendy", "cool" wrestling fandom was now the reserve of "geeks" and "nerds". Just why did the WWF go from being the hottest pop culture subject of the late 90's into being a ridiculed joke in the mid 2000's? Why did they have a mainstream audience one year and only a niche fandom the next? Thousands and thousands of people just stopped watching wrestling. Whereas wearing a wrestling shirt had once made you 'badass' it now made you a loser. The popular audience that left is now refereed to as the 'casual fans', and WWE remains desperate to woo them back. Before we get into how the popularity collapsed, let's make note of how the original boom formed. It was off the back of a creative revolution in the WWF, an emphasis on edgier, sexier content. Adult males liked the new more violent wrestling show, leading to the popularity trickling down to the youth audience. If college kids think it's cool, it must be cool right? That perception spread and spread, the shock and awe violence of the WWF leading to a surge of viewers. Things like Mick Foley falling off a cage roof, The Rock talking about candy asses, Steve Austin drinking beer... people hadn't seen anything like it before. The feud of working man Steve Austin against Heel chairman Vince McMahon along with great matches such as Kurt Angle vs Triple H made the WWF unmissable. Then the company seemingly fell apart over night. Here's the 10 things that ruined the mainstream popularity and ultimately killed the Attitude Era.

11. The Focus Changed From Gimmicks To Actual Wrestling

We start with a controversial and little considered point, part of the reason WWF stopped being cool is because they cut back on the gimmicks and tried to push wrestling matches more. While that seems odd, and us serious fans love in-ring matches, the majority of the casual audience far prefer gimmicks. For all the plaudits the Attitude Era gets, it was actually really heavy on gimmicks over in-ring quality. The little watched Smackdowns of the mid 2000's had way more in-ring wrestling than anything in the Attitude Era ever had. When wrestling started getting featured more prominently than McMahon family dramas, that's when many people just switched off. The popular audience simply preferred the soap opera element. The perfect example of how WWF changed their focus from gimmicks to wrestling is WrestleMania main events. Take a look at the main event of Mania 15 and Mania 2000. It was basically just a brawling cluster, mixed in with run ins from Mick Foley and the McMahons. Even Mania 17's classic match was all about Vinnie Mac at the end. Fast forward to WrestleMania X8 and whereas previous Mania shows pushed 'characters' like Austin and Rock, this show was headlined by more formal 'wrestlers' in the form of Chris Jericho and Triple H. The WWE's focus on wrestling over gimmicks went even further as the decade progressed, with the likes of Brock Lesnar, Eddie Guerrero, Kurt Angle and Chris Benoit all being used as top guys. It is great for the purist wrestling fans to see matches, but for mainstream popularity, the WWE has always relied on gimmicks. The decision to move away from soap opera elements in favour of athleticism was sadly a costly one.

10. The Burden Of Smackdown

When the WWF first hit its hot streak they only had a two hour Raw to worry about each week. All resources could easily be focused on a concise package, WWF creative only had to think about scripting 8 hours of TV each month. Is it any wonder that feuds made more sense back then? The creative team had less work to do and more time to do it in. Compare that to nowadays and WWE creative have five hours TV to script in just one week - almost as many hours as they used to spend an entire month on. A contributing factor to the faltering Attitude Era was the October 1999 debut of Smackdown. It's partly the reason why Vince Russo left the company, believing that it was too much TV to be working on. You can knock Russo as much as you like, but it can't be denied that the WWF was firing on all cylinders with him leading creative. He was proved right that the addition of Smackdown was too much work, because within two years of its debut we had seen a decline in the WWF overall. Raw in particular was nowhere near as good and actually became WWE's inferior show for a while in 2002 to 2004. The Monday Night brand only improved in recent years because WWF basically abandoned Smackdown to an afterthought. The expansion of workload ultimately undermined the successful formula the WWF had been working on. Fans had too much wrestling on their plate and with falling standards of quality soon started abandoning ship.

9. The Distraction Of The XFL

In addition to the internal expansion seen in late 1999, the WWF was also expanding outwardly, Vince McMahon planning the XFL in 2000 with the first season finishing in 2001. Is it just coincidence that the WWF noticeably took a critical and commercial slide during Vince's focus on his new football league? You suspect not. The XFL was an expensive and complex operation. WWE lost $35 million on the failed venture, putting in substantial time to match the hefty financial investment. What do you think Vince McMahon was thinking about more in late 2000 / early 2001, the WWF which was a success taking care of itself, or the XFL which was flailing and needed saving? The thing is, as Vince dedicated more time to addressing the XFL, the WWF stopped taking care of itself. All of a sudden we had illogical storylines cropping up on Raw. The shows seemed less cohesive, getting lost in booking folly. It all looked as if the WWF wasn't getting planned or operated as well, which we suspect could have been down to the XFL investment. It wasn't long before fans switched off Raw just as they had switched off the football league. The association of failure resonates, Vince found that he had as many problems on the wrestling front as he did the football front.

8. The Downfall Of WCW

Such was the importance of WCW's demise on the WWF product that we're going to need two points to cover it. Firstly we should address the 'downfall of WCW' and in the next page we will address the 'implementation of WCW into the WWF'. The demise of WCW was an obvious indicator to WWF that the popularity of wrestling was about to be ruined. While part of WCW's woes were down to viewers choosing to watch the WWF, and also down to WCW's creative pitfalls, you can also say that the death of the company was a sign that wrestling popularity in general was on the way down. When business had been hot, the industry had managed to retain a fanbase across three different promotions: WWF, WCW and ECW. The fact that two of these entities had gone out of business by early 2001 wasn't just a sign of the WWF being dominant, it was a sign that wrestling was no longer a 'cool' thing to watch. Just like the dot com bubble, the wrestling bubble had burst. Another part of this being a reason for the WWF's loss of popularity is that they lost their main and only competitor. Vince no longer had to try hard to win viewers over, people simply had no other wrestling to watch. An obvious malaise set into WWF creative, they certainly weren't the same as they had been when they had competition. They no longer needed to think to outsmart anyone, they got lazy, fans got bored.

7. The Implementation Of WCW In WWF

The second part of the WCW venom into industry popularity was that the WWF found themselves lumbered with the remnants of a toxic brand. They had bought the assets and numerous WCW contracts but most of these were tainted goods. What can you really do with a Buff Bagwell? To compound this the WWF then made their own mistakes in how they booked the few valuable WCW commodities. Raw very quickly turned into an absolute cluster, too many characters, too many stories, too much of it illogical. The entire atmosphere became confused and fans didn't know what to make of it. Vince's thought process was too simplistic, he simply went about burying the WCW name and value. The company did an impressive buyrate of 700,000 for the Invasion PPV, which proved fans did want to see WCW vs WWF, but ultimately over time the fans switched off. By the end of 2001 the WWF had lost its "cool" factor. The March to December odyssey of WCW in WWF was undoubtedly a contributing factor, a narrative which ultimately made fans lose the plot and switch off.

6. The Rock Going To Hollywood

The April to July absence of The Rock in 2001 was a major factor in WWF losing popularity. How could it not be? This was the biggest pop culture icon the WWF had, whereas Austin may have been the bigger draw, Rock definitely had more fame, appearing in everything from Star Trek to Wyclef Jean songs. By spring 2001 it was clear that The Rock had evolved beyond being a wrestler. He had became bigger than the WWF. His absence after WrestleMania 17 was a clear indication of the way things were headed, like Hulk Hogan in the past era, Rock would now be cutting back on wrestling to appear in more films. Many fans looked on this and decided that the story they'd been enjoying had now concluded, so they closed the book shut on the WWF. With the main character gone, fans figured it was time to move on. Many people only watched for The Rock and with him gone the show was just less interesting. You could even argue that the WWF never got popular, The Rock got popular, people watched for him. The difference he has made in Mania buyrates in the last few years reflect that he is indeed a specific draw for popularity.

5. The Triple H Injury

Losing The Rock wouldn't have appeared too damaging to the WWF when they first evaluated the situation. After all, they still had Triple H, the man who had became widely regarded as the best in the business during a successful 2000 main event run. This is when bad fortune conspires against Vince McMahon. A month after losing The Rock to Hollywood, the WWF lost Triple H to a year long quad tear injury. There was still Steve Austin, but we'll comment more on him later in this feature! Basically the company had lost their top two guys in the space of a month. Austin had been absent for most of 2000, it was the young Rock and Hunter who had been holding the fort. Now both were gone. Fans were suddenly left with a WWF product which was a shadow of the presentation they'd been watching a year earlier. By the time Triple H returned in January 20002, many of the WWF's boom period audience were gone.

4. Overbooking

How much is too much? That's what the WWF couldn't quite grasp as their boom period wore on. They kept having to get more and more creative to keep being able to top what they did last time. That meant they eventually started clutching at straws. We had stupid matches such as 'the kennel from hell', a steel cage inside a cell with dogs inside. We had McMahon family members in nearly every segment, Stephanie McMahon getting a push which was in overdrive. Eventually fans tired. There's a term called 'jumping the shark' which stems from an episode of 'Happy Days' in which The Fonz water skied over a shark, representing the moment the show went from popular broadcast about friends hanging in a diner into over the top ridiculousness. WWF by late 2000 had started to 'jump the shark'. The simple feuds which had originally engaged us had now been blown up into silly things that made us want to switch off. Where you once had factions such as DX or The Nation, in 2001 you now had groups like Right To Censor. Creatively the WWF had lost it. Too many run ins, too many swerves, too many turns. Even things like the violence and blood had lost all impact, getting done so regularly that fans just didn't care any more. When Mick Foley was retired at No Way Out 2000 it felt like just any other match. Looking back now on WWE Network it stands as mega violent. WWF's booking in the period had robbed the company of meaning, everything was getting so overdone that fans had started to stop caring.

3. The Story Concluded

Part of the reason the WWF declined in popularity might have nothing to do with negative factors, it might simply be a case of the story naturally concluding. All engaging narratives can't go on forever, there's a beginning, a middle, and an end, when it's over it's over. This is pretty much what can be seen to have happened with the WWF, they hooked the audience in 1998 with blue collar Steve Austin taking on white collar Vince McMahon, by 2001 the story was complete and fans moved on (more on the heel turn later!) Even with The Rock, Triple H and Mick Foley (WWF's other top characters), their story had been told and finished too. We watched as Foley's career ended, we rejoiced as The Rock became The People's Champion, we bought into Triple H's year of dominance in 2000. When all that concluded it was the natural time for fans to move on. We started to get repeats of angles and matches, which is perhaps another reason fans stopped watching. We'd seen it all before, it was obvious that the originality of the era had expired. The WWE themselves kind of subscribe to this belief, noting in conference calls that pro wrestling is a cyclical product which goes through peaks and troughs. By the end of 2001 the natural lifecycle of the success began in 1998 was over. Maybe it wasn't even a cycle, maybe it was just a fad, passing through pop culture and remaining unique to its time.

2. The Austin Heel Turn

The Attitude Era story concluded and what happened next? Stone Cold Steve Austin turned heel, joining forces with the evil Mr McMahon. Popular opinion has it that this single moment was the death of WWF's popularity, the true 'jumping of the shark', the signal that the show we loved was no longer what it once was. You can understand why the Austin heel turn killed the popularity of wrestling. It would be like the church suddenly reinventing Jesus Christ as a womanising murderer, that's tantamount to what the WWF did, they completely disillusioned their audience by presenting a well defined character in a totally out of whack way. You can't sell something which makes no sense, all narrative drama must have logic to work, creative rules must be obeyed. The WWF didn't do that with Austin and it the entire company paid the price. A direct observation can be made of WWF's popularity before the Austin heel turn and the declining fortunes after the heel turn. The most popular star of the era had basically been killed off, part of the audience dying with it.

1. The Combined Factors

Ultimately, you can't single out just one of these points in the feature. We ranked them, but really they all combine to make one big reason why the WWF popularity waned: a culmination of mistakes along with unavoidable realities. Of course the company was going to suffer, they basically lost all three of their biggest stars - Hunter to injury, Rock to Hollywood, Austin to heel character oblivion. With three main eventers basically finished, they then had to contend with the swirling drama of absorbing WCW. This confused and over-faced the audience even more, it added to the growing problem of overbooking. Then you have the reality that the industry was just in a downward trend anyway (as WCW and ECW dying proved), the fad of wrestling has simply expired from its lifespan. In fact, the WWF actually did really well to manage three hot years. Throw in the fact that Vince was also pushing a new show in Smackdown and a new brand in the XFL, as well as trying to steer his product away from gimmicks to athleticism, and you have the perfect storm of reasons why the WWF so suddenly went from popularity to moderate interest.