WWE: 13 Times Vince McMahon Went Way Too Far

By Alex Gordon /

The name Vincent Kennedy McMahon will surely go down in history as the man who changed professional wrestling forever. Undoubtedly, the man will be remembered as one of the greatest promoters of all time, not just within the wrestling industry, but in all of combat sports and show business as a whole, with his modern counterpart/rival Dana White picking him as one of the best. McMahon has always been a divisive figure, with some hardcore aficionados claiming what he promotes is no longer truly wrestling, but now sports entertainment, a term which the WWE themselves coined. It cannot be argued however, the great success that McMahon has achieved within this field. Since the acquisition of his Father's business in 1982, Vince has built stars and created moments that will last forever, he's staved off competition and prospered through boom periods. However, that isn't to say he has never made any mistakes or had a bad idea. For every Hulk Hogan or Rock there's a Nathan Jones. For every red hot angle such as Mr. McMahon Vs Steve Austin, there's an Invasion. For every genuinely funny skit (though these are rare) such as the anger management classes, there's Hornswoggle blowing up Coach. So, as you can imagine, coming up with the top 13 moments Vince went too far took a lot of whittling down. Most involve Vince directly whilst a few clearly have his fingerprints all over them. Some of these are simply angles that jumped the shark or jokes that you just know nobody found funny except Vince McMahon, whilst others are moments that are deeply disrespectful and some that should simply never have happened.

13. Mae Young Gives Birth To A Hand

I just, I don't even know where to begin with this. Fair play to Mae Young, she seemed to be game for almost anything. How many 77 year old woman would be up for being powerbombed through a table? Mae always had a real passion for the business and was happy to be involved, unfortunately this led to her participating in some pretty horrendous segments that scream "Vince finds this hilarious". In the year 2000 Mae began a storyline in which she was dating WWE superstar Mark Henry, which eventually led to her being pregnant. When the big day finally came, Mae gave birth to a healthy rubber hand. What? I don't even get how that's supposed to be funny. Maybe being slammed through a table twice when pregnant had something to do with it...

12. Vince's Son Is ... Hornswoggle

Another of the jumping the shark moments as opposed to anything nastier, in the fall of 2007 the WWE were running an angle that Vince had an illegitimate child running around, and that Vince himself didn't know the identity. They even built it up over a few weeks as a huge mystery before the day of the big reveal. They went as far as gathering the entire roster in the ring before they were systematically eliminated one by one, before the big reveal was that Vince's love child was none other than Hornswoggle. I mean, really? This actually could have been a genuinely solid angle if they'd put some more thought into it, and despite the ridiculousness of it all, could have given a solid rub to an up and coming superstar by positioning him as the offspring of McMahon. It was just a bad angle and despite Triple H's hysterics in the ring upon the reveal (worst fake laughter ever by the way), I suspect the only person who found it that amusing was Vince himself.

11. Vince Stages His Own Death

Even as I write this entry, I'm unsure whether it actually warrants its position. It's not one of the worst angles ever conceived but unfortunately, it became a victim of another tragic event. On June 11th in 2007, the final segment of Raw saw Mr. McMahon entering his limousine before it exploded, presumably killing him. The WWE website reported it as a legitimate explosion and the angle was set to play out over a number of months before a big return. However, due to the harrowing Chris Benoit double murder-suicide, Vince returned within 2 weeks. Due to situation, it would have been highly insensitive had Vince continued with this ploy, after the deaths of 3 people linked closely to the company.

10. Heidenreich "Assaults" Michael Cole

A truly terrible angle (I refuse to call it a comedy bit, though no doubt that's what it was intended as) where Heidenreich imprisoned Michael Cole in a restroom. It's never outright said what was going on, but watch that clip and it's pretty obvious what they were shooting for. Heidenreich had recently returned to Raw in 2004, after a little seasoning on OVW, and was working with a psychopath gimmick where he'd do crazy stuff and read hateful poetry, talk about super psychotic. In an interview years later, Heidenreich stated that he believed it was a bit that came to Vince McMahon in a dream one night. Insert your own jokes here.

9. Vince Vs. God

Now, I personally didn't find this angle bad at all, but then again I'm not religious in any way shape or form, and I know people who found it highly offensive. At Backlash 2006, the team of Vince and Shane O' Mac took on Shawn Michaels and his partner God. Conceived as a way of making fun of Shawn Michaels born again Christianity, "God" was represented by a spotlight which slowly made its way to the ring, with Vince even instructing the referee to check God for any foreign objects. As a Brit, it didn't phase me, but in America where Christianity is still more prevalent in everyday society than it is here, that's a hell of a way to alienate a large chunk of your audience. But hey, at least Vince had fun.

8. The Kiss My Ass Club

First off, who makes a video compilation of the kiss my ass club? There are some strange folks out there. Anyway, the kiss my ass club was something conceived by Vince after the breakdown of the WCW/ECW alliance, for people to prove their loyalty to him. I don't know about you guys, but in 2001 there was nothing I wanted more in my wrestling program than to see a guy in his late 50's go bare ass on T.V. and humiliate people, just because. All in all, there are 6 members of the fabled club - William Regal, Jim Ross (more on his tumultuous relationship with McMahon later), Shawn Michaels, Shane McMahon, Mick Foley and Hornswoggle. The entire thing screams McMahon vanity project but hey, if my glutes look as good as his at that age I may start my own club.

7. Trish Stratus Barks, Then Strips

This segment arrived after a series of months in which Vince and Trish had been dating, before he announced that she was merely a toy who he had became bored of playing with. The following week he set out to demean her in some outlandish ways, making her get on all fours in the ring and bark like a dog, and then forcing her to strip down to her underwear. Oh Vince, you're such a card. Hey, you know what would be a great angle? To publicly humiliate one of our most prominent female talents in a seriously degrading way. That makes total sense. I mean, it's the 21st century, who doesn't want to see some female disempowerment? A pretty classless segment, though the Heyman commentary whilst it was ongoing will always amuse me.

6. Vince Wins The WWF Title

WCW got a serious amount of flack for putting their belt on non-wrestlers (Vince Russo and David Arquette) , so I never understood why I hardly heard any criticism for the same thing happening in WWE. Look, I know Vince vacated the belt the very next night, and there was a LOT of interference in the match, but still. I've always been in favour of seriously long championship reigns by the top guys. Hotshotting a belt all over the show serves only to devalue it in the eyes of the consumer, and to put it on a non-wrestler is disrespectful to the business, and the guys who bust their ass to try and win it. Then you realise, it was Vince's idea to put the belt on Vince. That makes a bad situation even worse, he should know better but hey, guess he wanted to have a title run. It cheapens the belt and insults the great champions of wrestling such as Bruno Sammartino and Pedor Morales. Also more negative points for winning the '99 Royal Rumble.

5. The Montreal Screwjob

By the time all this came about, Bret Hart had been a loyal servant to the then WWF for over 14 years. In late 1997, Bret had agreed a lucrative deal to take him to the WCW, but at the time he was still reigning champion in the WWF but was due to face Shawn Michaels in one of his final few appearances, at Survivor Series with the belt on the line . Due to a series of real life clashes with Michaels, including Shawn stating that he would never job to Hart, Bret refused to drop the title in his home nation of Canada, where Survivor Series was being held, and insisted he would drop it on T.V. before he left to go to WCW. Vince however, feared that Bret would turn up on WCW television with the crown jewel of the WWF. He concocted a plan to have Earl Hebner call the match when Hart was placed in the Sharpshooter, his own finishing manoeuvre , by Michaels, despite Hart not submitting. Again, just a real classless act by Vince towards one of his longest serving members of the roster, which led to a long standing dispute between Hart and McMahon that was only rectified in 2006 when Bret was inducted into the Hall of Fame. The one positive to take from this whole debacle is that without this, there never would have been the dastardly Mr. McMahon character who would go on to be one of the best authority heels of all time.

4. Mocking Jim Ross's Bell's Palsy

I've never understood Vince's obsession with mocking Jim Ross. The man is without a doubt the best commentator that the sport has ever seen, but that still doesn't stop Vince. He's constantly humiliated him (kiss my ass club), done incredibly unfunny bits about him (colon surgery) and the making fun of his Bell's Palsy syndrome is simply one of the most crass things I have ever witnessed. Do you remember how much heat Ed Ferrara got for doing the same thing with his Oklahoma character in WCW? Ric Flair called it a disgrace to wrestling, but that's fine, let's have the owner of a multi-million dollar company do the same thing years later. Just downright insensitive. Good to see Vince taking the Be A Star anti-bullying campaign seriously anyway.

3. The Katie Vick Angle

Possibly the most distasteful angle ever show on WWE television (one which would be used against Linda McMahon in her later senate runs) saw Kane being accused of murder and necrophilia by Triple H. Yes, you read that correctly. It was in 2002, when Kane was feuding with Triple H for his world title, that Trips claimed that years earlier Kane had been in a relationship with a woman called Katie Vick, who had unfortunately perished in a car crash, and that after she was dead, Kane had had sex with her. Hunter would go on to say he had video footage of the aforementioned act, but when it was revealed it was simply Triple H himself in a Kane mask, having sex with a mannequin inside a coffin. Wow. To spare some of the blame on Vince, apparently this was as much Stephanie's idea as his but seriously, how could they not see what a terrible idea this was? There was also an unsubstantiated rumour that Vince was on hand when the angle with the mannequin was shot, and that he was instructing Hunter to "fornicate" with the doll harder, with an actual funeral going on next door. Dear god, I hope that rumour is just a rumour.

2. Continuing Over The Edge After The Owen Hart Accident

In one of the most tragic occurrences to ever happen inside a wrestling ring, during the 1999 pay-per-view Over The Edge, when Owen Hart, in his Blue Blazer persona, fell 78 feet before landing on the top rope and flipping into the ring. It was thought that Owen had accidentally activated his quick release mechanism. He later died from his injuries in the Truman Medical Centre in Kansas City. How can you possibly justify continuing with the show after such a tragic occurrence? It's not like Vince and company didn't know that Owen had passed in hospital, as Jim Ross delivered the heartbreaking news on commentary during the pay-per-view itself. Ultimately, it's just a sport, and a pre-determined one at that, and some things are just a lot more important. The show should never have been allowed to go on, in respect to the memory of Owen Hart, a truly great wrestler and, from what people have to say of Owen, a genuinely nice guy.

1. The Melanie Pillman Interview

Honestly, it was pretty close between this and the Owen Hart incident as to what would earn the number one spot on this list, but I ultimately settled on the interview of Brian Pillman's widow on television, just 24 hours after the death of Brian, due to it's clearly exploitative nature of a grieving widow. On Monday Night Raw, Vince conducted an interview with Melanie, and to watch it now, some of the questioning actually makes me sick. His questions about Brian's pain pill addiction clearly came off as a man in damage control mode, trying to deflect blame away from his company. However, worse was still to come, as Vince asked Melanie, again this is just one day after he had passed, what she planned to do now as a single parent, and how she would support her children. Wow. Tactless and quite disgusting in my opinion. Feel free to sound off in the comments below if you think I've omitted any other times when Vince went way too far.