WWE 1998 PPVs From Worst To Best

Fans still rave about the Attitude Era, but are the PPVs from that time actually any good?

By Lewis Howse /

1998 was a huge year for the WWF. Having trailed WCW in terms of television ratings and pay-per-view buys for some, the company was finally starting to get its act together. Although top star Bret Hart had exited the company at the 1997 Survivor Series on the very worst of terms, it turned out to be a blessing in disguise, for a number of reasons. WWE was able to push their tyrannical owner Vince as the evil Mr. McMahon based off the fact that he had screwed Hart. It was money. In Hart's absence people like Stone Cold Steve Austin, The Rock and Triple H were able to step up and fight for the top spots, too. Hart, who had publicly objected to the increasing sexuality of WWF programming, couldn't stand in the way of the Attitude Era any longer. The company laid down the gauntlet in January when they announced that they had signed boxing bad boy Mike Tyson to appear at several events, including WrestleMania. It was a huge deal and, coupled with the meteoric rise of Austin, helped make the company seem cool and relevant to a whole new audience of, predominantly, young males. There were a lot of things going in WWF's favour at the time but just how good were the company's big events that year? The roster was stacked with superstars but that's not to say everything measured up when customers had to part with their hard-earned cash.

Advertisement

13. Rock Bottom

The Good: There wasn't much to shout about at Rock Bottom. When Steve Blackman is in the best match of the card, you know you're in trouble. Rock Bottom was an apt name for this show. The Bad: Michael Cole's commentary, for a start. If you think Cole is bad today, check out Rock Bottom to see how much he used to suck. It was woeful. Cole took over announce duties from Jim Ross after JR suffered a severe Bell's Palsy attack. The current voice of the WWE didn't even know half of the names of wrestler's moves. The main event Buried Alive match between Steve Austin and The Undertaker, which sounds great on paper, was a total washout. These two had some absolute stunners (pun intended) earlier in the year but this gimmicked mess was far from their finest hour. The Rock and Mankind also under-performed in The Rock's first defence of the WWF Championship. On the undercard there were too many short or just plain bad matches. Al Snow, Bob Holly and Too Cold Scorpio versus The Brood sounds like a lot of fun but it really wasn't. Kurgan and Golga versus The Headbangers was worse. The Rest: Goldust and Jeff Jarrett had a match where the stipulation was if Goldust wins then Debra had to strip and if Jarrett wins then Goldust had to strip. Goldust lost meaning he had to strip but commissioner Shawn Michaels came out and reversed the decision meaning Debra had to strip. Because the Attitude Era.

12. Unforgiven

The Good: Dude Love and Steve Austin had a great main event. As was the case with a lot of 1998's PPV output, the main events were carrying the shows while the undercard generally stunk the joint out. The Dude and Stone Cold would have a better match the next month at Over the Edge but this was a lot fun nonetheless. Other decent matches included Triple H versus Owen Hart for the European Title and, erm, nothing else, really. The Bad: There was a lot of Russo crap at Unforgiven 1998. One of the biggest offenders was the Inferno Match between Kane and The Undertaker. While a cool concept in theory, in reality the stipulation really hindered their performance. The terms 'slow' and 'methodical' come to mind. The New Age Outlaws and the Legion of Doom may be two of the most famous tag teams ever but their matches together routinely sucked, and this one was no different. Speaking of tag teams, the legendary Rock and Roll Express looked awful against The New Midnight Express. The whole NWA revival angle had no place in the WWF in 1998. The Rest: In April 1998 The Rock was getting over but he was still jerking the curtain. Sable paraded around in her underwear, as was customary. Also, a sign in the crowd during the Triple H/Owen match read 'PLAYBOY NEEDS CHYNA'. Be careful what you wish for, 1998 Chyna fan!

11. Over The Edge

The Good: Proving that they were no one-hit-wonders, Steve Austin and Dude Love had an absolutely sensational match in the main event of Over the Edge. It was a truly wonderful, inventive and entertaining brawl. This time it had added stipulations: Vince McMahon was the guest referee, Pat Patterson was guest ring announcer and Gerald Brisco guest timekeeper. The Undertaker was ringside enforcer. Everyone in the match, including the stooges, were so over. It really is something else to see the reactions that Austin was getting at the height of his powers. The Bad: Again, just about everything else. DX against Owen Hart, The Godfather and D-Lo Brown was a boring letdown although it did have Owen finally getting a pin on Triple (with the pedigree no less) so it wasn't completely useless.The LOD versus DOA (battle of the acronyms) open was, to quote Jim Ross, 'bowling shoe ugly'. The Rest: Marc Mero and Sable had a non-match to set up a rematch further down the road. After his Masker Versus Mask loss to Kane, Vader referred to himself as a 'fat piece of s***' in a bizarre post-match interview. He would leave the company soon after.

10. Survivor Series

The Good: If you're looking for good wrestling, do not watch Survivor Series 1998. Featuring mostly short matches (The Rock versus The Big Boss Man lasted all but four seconds), this was not a wrestling fans' wrestling show. In terms of storyline development and entertainment, however, it ticked all of the right boxes. Survivor Series 1998 did not feature the traditional Survivor Series matches but was instead focused around a one-night tournament to crown a new WWF Champion. The best of the tournament matches was the semi-final match between Steve Austin and Mankind. The Bad: Did the world really need a rehash of the 1997 Survivor Series finish? Sure, it was 'fresh' back in 1998, but it was also unnecessary. Watching it now, given how many times WWE have done the finish, the importance of it is lost. The tag team title match between The New Age Outlaws, Headbangers and the team of Mark Henry & D-Lo Brown sucked so much that even JR had to acknowledge it on commentary. The Rest: Sable won the Women's Championship from Jacqueline in an actual match, not a bikini contest/evening gown stripper fight, which was as rare as an eclipse in those days.

9. Capital Carnage

The Good: The main event between Steve Austin, The Undertaker, Mankind and Kane was a lot of fun. WWE wishes they could put four stars of this level in a PPV top-liner these days. This match headlined a lot of house show events at the time and drew monster business. The UK fans went wild for it at Capital Carnage. Even better, from a wrestling standpoint, was The Rock's WWF Championship defence against X-Pac. These two pros had everyone in the building that X-Pac might pull it off at the end. The Bad: How many times did Tiger Ali Singh bore UK fans senseless? The company seemed to only wheel Singh out for the British pay-per-views. Was it some sort of rib on us? Anyways, his match (against Edge) was the worst of the night. There were more short, house show style matches in the form of Gangrel versus Al Snow and Goldust versus Val Vanis. The Rest: After the Marc Mero & Jacqueline versus Sable & Christian match Sable ripped Jacqueline's top off, exposing her naked knockers to the world. The WWF really didn't care about offending anyone back then.

8. Breakdown

The Good: Edge and Owen Hart had a great opener, which featured the first appearance of Edge's future tag team partner Christian. Better than that was the triple threat cage match between The Rock, Mankind and Ken Shamrock. When you watch matches like this, it's no wonder that Foley became a physical wreck later in life. The Rock was insanely over during the match. His star was clearly rising, so much so that Vince had to put the belt on him a couple of months later. The Bad: Steve Austin versus Kane versus The Udnertaker might have a lot of star power but, as a match, it wasn't very good at all. A major disappointed, the three had a pretty standard, slow brawl. All three men were capable of greatness but could be very hit-or-miss at times. The burial of Vader continued. Here he was jobbed out to Bradshaw (who definitely threw a few potato shots Vader's way). Val Venis and Dustin Rhodes (during his 'I'm not Goldust anymore phase') had a shocker. Not only did they not have great chemistry, but there was a major screwup during a nearfall at the end of the match. The Rest: This show had a lot of filler. Many of the matches seemed more suitable for your average Raw rather than PPV. The Raw after this PPV featured the infamous Austin/Zamboni angle, which was about as entertaining as anything you'll see here.

7. Judgement Day

The Good: There were some sterling matches on the undercard. Val Venis and Goldust finally clicked and delivered the goods. TAKA Michinoku (one of the unsung heroes of the WWF's midcard division back then) had a really enjoyable Light Heavyweight Championship match with Christian and D-Low Brown and X-Pac had something of a minor classic over the European Championship. The Bad: As fondly as a lot of fans might look back on the rivalry between The Undertaker and Kane, it must be said that they had some God-awful matches together. This one was pretty awful, too. Austin was wasted in the guest referee role and the finish was typical Russo bulls*** - with both Kane and Undertaker out cold, Austin declared himself the winner. What? In 1998 the PPVs seemed to be used as a set-up for the TV shows, which is the reverse of what you'd expect the logic to be. The Rest: Mark Henry versus The Rock and Mankind versus Ken Shamrock were both underwhelming. Although their match with The New Age Outlaws was alright here, can anyone believe how strongly The Headbangers were pushed in 1998? Madness.

6. Fully Loaded

The Good: Val Venis continued to show why he was one of the best workers in the company during his opening match victory over Jeff Jarrett. The crowd were on fire for Venis and Venis entered a red-hot performance as a result. Ken Shamrock and Owen Hart had the first ever 'Dungeon Match' which took place in Stu Hart's infamous basement. What a novel concept. The Rock and Triple H had a good 2/3 falls match, albeit one which was inferior to the bonafide classics they'd have later. The Kane and Mankind versus Austin and Undertaker headliner set up SummerSlam wonderfully. The Bad: The company tried to make Bradshaw a monster heel by having him turn on bizarrely loveable Terry Funk. It didn't really work and the calamitous Brawl for All tournament would seriously hurt his momentum later in the year. LOD versus The DOA was awful, as usual. How could the WWF not see that the LOD were completely past-it? The Rest: Sable and Jacqueline continued their flesh-flaunting tour of the United States. This time Sable came out, er, on top by pulling off her t-shirt and revealing a set of handprints covering her breasts. Jerry Lawler's reaction was priceless.

5. No Way Out Of Texas

The Good: The main event, a chaotic no disqualification eight man tag match pitting Cactus Jack/Terry Funk/Steve Austin/Owen Hart against Triple H/The New Age Outlaw/Savior Vega, was ridiculously fun. Watching Mick Foley take full-on unprotected chair shots to the head is not easy to watch in 2015, however. On the undercard TAKA Michinoku and luchador Pantera had a great match for the Light-Heavyweight Championship. Unfortunately the crowd couldn't care less and the match played before long periods of silence. Technically, however, it was really good. Kane and Vader had a decent big-man match. Vader lost (again) and was beaten down after the match. The Bad: Not too much, this time. While matches like Bradshaw versus Jeff Jarrett didn't set the world alight, they weren't terrible or anything. The Rest: Goldust came out dressed as something resembling Marily Manson for his match tag match with Marc Mero against The Headbangers. TAFKA Goldust was not Dustin Runnels' best-remembered period of his career. Savio Vega replaced Shawn Michaels in the main event. HBK could not compete because of a serious back injury (more on that later).

4. King of the Ring

The Good: The 1998 King of the Ring will live in infamy thanks to one match - the Hell in a Cell bout between Mankind and The Undertaker. Foley was never one to shy away from taking horrific punishment but he outdid himself in this environment. His two major bumps have lost none of their impact seventeen years later. Steve Austin and Kane couldn't hope to follow the HIAC match but they tried admirably in their First Blood encounter. Once again, this match was used to set up Raw the next night. The Rock and Ken Shamrock's King of the Ring final match was the best match of the tournament (although that wasn't saying match). X-Pac and Owen Hart also had a good match. The Bad: The tournament semis were rushed. The fact that Al Snow & Head (seriously) versus Too Much received more time than them was an insult. The Rest: Foley suffered a shopping list of injuries in his suicidal stunt show. Vince McMahon was so shocked that he warned Foley that he never wanted to see him put himself in jeapordy like that ever again. Hey, when Vince is telling you to tone it down you know you've probably went too far.

3. Royal Rumble

The Good: The Royal Rumble was another show that was in danger of being a huge letdown but was saved by two excellent matches: the Rumble itself and Shawn Michaels and The Undertaker's casket match. Austin won a heated Rumble match. You could tell by the reaction of the fans that Austin was the guy going forward. HBK and The Dead Man had the best casket match ever, which was only marred by the serious injury Shawn suffered when he took an awkward backdrop on the casket. Michaels didn't wrestle again until WrestleMania in March and then took another four years off. Many thought he was finished but we all know how that story turned out... The Bad: The New Age Outlaws and the LOD had a shocker. The LOD's 1998 run is one of the most baffling in company history: they weren't anywhere near as over as they had been in the past and they sucked in the ring, yet Vince persisted with them. TAFKA Goldust and Vader had an awful match. The Rest: Mick Foley entered the Rumble three times, as alter-egos Dude Love, Cactus Jack and Mankind. The WWF presented a Minis match with midget luchadors from Mexico. It was memorable only for Jerry Lawler's insufferable short jokes and the fact that Sunny botched a leapfrog on the 3ft7in Max Mini.

2. WrestleMania XIV

The Good: Shawn Michaels fought through considerable pain to put Stone Cold Steve Austin proper in the main event. Passing the torch and doing what was right on his way out, Michaels even took a (worked) punch from Mike Tyson afterwards. He wasn't happy about it, but he did it. Kudos to him. Triple H and Owen Hart had a good, solid match, as they always did. Cactus Jack and Chainsaw Charlie's (Terry Funk) wild dumpster match with The New Age Outlaws was unlike anything you will see in the WWE today. Taka Michinoku and Aguila (the future Essa Rios) had a high-flying spectacular which is worth checking out, if you want to see something different. The Bad: The tag team battle royal was a dud (although Sunny's LOD-inspired outfit somewhat made up for that). The Rock and Ken Shamrock's Intercontinental Title match was only allocated a disappointing four and a half minutes. Two talents of their caliber deserved more. The Rest: The Undertaker and Kane's first meeting divided fans and critics at the time. Some thought it was a slow, boring match with a ridiculous finish (it took three whole tombstone piledrivers to put Kane down) but it undoubtedly had a big match feel to it. The company built this one for months.

1. SummerSlam

The Good: There was a lot more good than bad at SummerSlam, which might have had something to do with the MSG setting (Vince takes shows at The Garden very seriously). Match of the night honours had to go to Triple H and The Rock for their superlative ladder match. You could tell watching this that both guys would go on to greatness. Another great stip match was the Lion's Dean outing between Ken Shamrock and Owen Hart. Taking place inside a makeshift Octagon, this was so ahead-of-its-time. Jeff Jarrett against X-Pac (Hair versus Hair) and Val Venis versus D-Lo Brown (European Title) were all good, too. SummerSlam 1998 really had the feeling that it was an important show which you had to see. The Bad: Steve Austin got his bell run early into his main event with The Undertaker, meaning he wasn't all there and the match wasn't as good as it could have been (it was still decent). Mankind's handicap Falls Count Anywhere match against The Outlaws was disappointing, but Mick can be forgiven for taking it easy after Hell in a Cell. The Rest: The Insane Clown Posse, who would actually wrestle for WCW the next year, did a mini-concert before the awful Kaientai versus The Oddities match.