WWE 1999 PPVs From Worst To Best

The Austin Era or the Year of the B Shows?

By Lewis Howse /

1999 was a big year for the WWF. They finally overtook WCW, who were rapidly heading towards self-destruction, and business was booming. The company were selling out their shows everywhere and had no shortage of talent, most of whom were over. The main events were being carried by The Rock, Steve Austin, Triple H, Kane, The Undertaker, Mankind and Vince McMahon. That's a damn impressive roster, whichever way you chose to look at it. The WWF product was changing in many different ways. Some were for the better, such as the rise of talented midcarders like D-Lo Brown, Val Venis and the incoming Chris Jericho. The production and all-round presentation of the product was arguably the best it had ever been. The company was a well-oiled machine and a merchandise phenomenon. Ratings, buy rates and attendances were all up. Creatively, meanwhile, there were still a few hickups, with dodgy and often nonsensical storylines, usually penned by the polarising Vince Russo (who really didn't care about the actual wrestling). The company might have been doing big numbers, but how were the PPVs overall? 1998 was not a particularly great year for the company, with many of their big shows failing to hit their mark. Would 1999 prove to be any different or was it a case of more of the same? Join us (and switch on the WWE Network) as we rank the promotion's 1999 PPVs from worst to best.

14. King Of The Ring

The Good: Very, very little. The emerging Hardy's and The Brood (Edge and Christian) had a really good five minute match on the undercard, which was probably the best thing on the show from an in-ring perspective. These two teams would regularly steal the show later in the year. The Rock and The Undertaker had a typical Attitude Era brawl where they went all over the arena in lieu of actual, y'know, wrestling. 'Taker was really hurting at this point and would have to take a hiatus later in the year to recover from his injuries. The Bad: Oh God, where to start? Perhaps with one of the show's main selling points, the King of the Ring itself. The quarter and semi final matches were pure filler, each lasting only a few minutes. The final was a total washout, too. Billy Gunn beat former stablemate X-Pac in an epic five minutes to clinch the crown. WWE consistently tried to push Gunn and it never worked. He was one of the worst KOTR winners ever, second only to Mabel. The Steve Austin versus Shane and Vince McMahon ladder match main event has not aged well but is admittedly fun, in a goofy way. The Rest: The writing in the promotion at this point was very convolute and hard-to-follow and the in-ring action wasn't nearly the standard it would become in 2000. Amazingly, The insanely over Road Dogg and Chyna managed to have a decent match which featured the hilarious 'We can all say we saw Chyna get it doggie-style tonight' like from JR. And you thought you had to wait until One Night in Chyna to see that.

13. No Mercy (UK)

The Good: Again, there wasn't a lot to shout about at the UK version of No Mercy, but then there usually wasn't when WWE presented a PPV in the UK. It seemed like some kind of cruel rib to give us a poorer show. A lot of the guys were blatantly phoning it in. Shane McMahon and X-Pac had the best match of the night. Although it was very similar to their WrestleMania effort, it was still heated and action-packed. Although it was another typical Austin era main event, Stone Cold versus Triple H versus The Undertaker was good overbooked fun. The Bad: Too many throwaway matches, as usual. Tori was pinned by the feakish Nicole Bass, filling in for Sable, in less than thirty seconds after Sable revealed she had a chest cold and couldn't wrestle. Kane versus Mideon, Tiger Ali Singh versus Gillberg and Droz versus Steve Blackman were all awful and/or boring. The Rest: The company aired a vignette for Harry Beaver Cleavage, one of the most ill-conceived characters in company history, during the show. In a sign that the company was serious about pushing him, Billy Gunn went over Mankind. Incredible.

12. Over The Edge

The Good: It's hard to come up with something 'good' on the show that Owen Hart tragically fell to his death on. For what it's worth, the opening WWF Tag Team Championship match pitting Kane and X-Pac against D-Low Brown and Mark Henry was probably (shockingly) the best of the night. The Bad: Inside the ring, Over The Edge wasn't very good. But that doesn't matter, in the grand scheme of things, because this event featured one of, if not the, worst moments in WWE history. Owen Hart fell from a platform suspended 74 feet above the ring, landing chest first on the top rope/turnbuckle. Owen died as a result of his injuries, despite frantic attempts by medical personnel to save him. Later in the show, Jim Ross had the unfortunate task of informing the world that Owen Hart had died. The WWF continued the broadcast, a decision which drew a mixed from fans, critics and wrestlers. The Rest: Many performers were visibly dejected when they had to perform later in the show, especially Debra and Jeff Jarrett (who had to go on just after Owen fell). And who could blame them? It was a horrible situation and it is really the only thing of note that happened on the show.

11. Survivor Series

The Good: Chyna and Chris Jericho had a really good Intercontinental Championship match. Behind-the-scenes, however, the two were at odds with each other and Jericho had been reprimanded for being too rough with the Ninth Wonder of the World. The Hardy Boys looked really good in their Survivor Series elimination match. The Bad: WWE should have been ashamed of themselves for advertising Stone Cold Steve Austin for the main event up until the final minute when the company knew full well, days in advance, that Austin would not be performing on the show. Austin needed spinal fusion surgery and was replaced by The Big Show, who shockingly beat Triple H and The Rock in a poor match to win the WWF Championship. The New Age Outlaws versus Mankind and Al Snow was not very good, at all. Foley was so broken-down at this point that he couldn't really do a lot in the ring, besides comedy. The Rest: How could WWE have not added Test to the main event? He was the logical choice, given his feud with Triple H, but the gig went to The Big Show instead. Survivor Series 1999 was not a great show, by any means. That it wasn't the worst of 1999 shows just how bad a year it was for the WWF.

10. Royal Rumble

The Good: Royal Rumble 1999 was pretty rotten overall, but it was saved from being a total dud thanks to the superhuman efforts of The Rock and Mankind in their WWF Championship I Quit match. Watching the match with 2015 eyes, it's hard to enjoy it as much due to the number of vicious unprotected chairshots that a handcuffed Foley takes. In a post-Benoit world and knowing the physical state of Foley these days, it really is difficult to watch. Although the other matches weren't the best, the wrestlers themselves were hugely over. The Bad: After the success of the 1998 Survivor Series, Vince decided to give Russo more booking power. The results were incredibly hit-and-miss. The Rumble was dominated by the Austin/Vince feud. Vince winning was supposed to be a shocking moment but it was rendered pointless when Austin main evented 'Mania anyway. The undercard matches were tame. The Big Bossman versus Road Dogg and Sable versus Luna were never going to set the world on fire, but there's really not much entertainment value to be had at all. The Rest: Billy Gunn was supposed to go over Ken Shamrock in their Intercontinental Championship match, but arrived late and hungover after a night of heavy partying and the result was changed. Still, WWE went ahead with his push a few months later.

9. WrestleMania 15

The Good: What's WrestleMania, the biggest and most important how of the year, doing so far down the list? Well, it wasn't very good and, like the Rumble, was basically saved thanks to one really good match. The Rock was once again involved, finally clashing with Stone Cold Steve Austin. Wrestling took a back seat to the angles in 1999 and so the in-ring action wasn't really the focus. Shane McMahon versus X-Pac in a European Title match was the second best match on the show. The Bad: Oh, there was a lot of it (again). Michael Cole was atrocious on commentary and was mercifully replaced by Jim Ross for the main event. It was not like Cole had a lot to work with, mind: most of the matches were poor and the angles ludicrous. Worst of all was the Hell in a Cell debacle between The Big Bossman and The Undertaker, which ended with 'Taker and The Brood 'hanging' The Bossman from the Cell. Kane and Triple H are two very good workers, but they had an absolute clanger here. The match was basically a backdrop for the DX shenanigans. The Rest: Michael Cole gave away the result of the WWF Championship match before it happened. What a muppet. After foiling the company's Brawl for All Plans by knocking out expected winner Steve Williams, Bart Gunn was 'rewarded' with a boxing match with Butterbean, who flattened him in thirty seconds. How vindictive.

8. Armageddon

The Good: Russo left the company in October and, hey, wouldn't you know it, the quality of the shows began to improve. Funny, that. Armageddon had the right mix of storyline and in-ring action. Top of the list was the surprisingly good No Holds Barred main event between Triple H and Vince McMahon, which saw Stephanie turn heel and join the dastardly Helmsley. It was a killer angle, even if it did spell the beginning of Steph and Triple H's TV dominance. Also decent was the Chris Jericho versus Chyna IC Title match (the fans were really starting to get into Y2J), the cage match between Kane and X-Pac and the opening tag team battle royal, which proved that The Hardys were clearly stars-in-the-making. The Bad: The Big Show versus The Big Bossman (which came off the back of one of the most ludicrous angles of the year) lasted only 3.13 but that was still about two and a half minutes too long. The New Age Outlaws versus The Rock 'n Sock Connection, while decent enough, was formulaic and a little disappointing. The Rest: This was also the show were The Kat flashed her breasts to the crowd following her Evening Gown Swimming Pool match victory. WWE got into trouble with the PPV companies (and The Kat apparently got into trouble with management) for that one.

7. St. Valentine's Day Massacre

The Good: A rare bright spark during the Russo era, St Valentine's Day Massacre had several in-ring highlights, not least of which was the crazy cage match main event between Austin and Vince McMahon, which saw Vince take an incredible bump off the side of the cage and through the announce table. This match also featured the WWF debut of The Big Show, who attacked Austin. Triple H and X-Pac versus Chyna and Kane, a battle of DX versus The Corporation, was shockingly good stuff. Even better was the Last Man Standing match between The Rock and Mankind, who stole the show for the second consecutive PPV. The Bad: You can skip matches like Bluedust (The Blue Meanie) versus Goldust and The Big Bossman versus Mideon without feeling too bad about it. Owen Hart and Jeff Jarrett versus D-Low Brown and Mark Henry was surprisingly poor, given who was involved. Ken Shamrock and Val Venis were also noticeably off in their grudge/IC Title match. The Rest: Al Snow and Hardcore Holly ended up in the Mississippi River, a first in a professional wrestling match.

6. Rebellion

The Good: Now this was an improvement over the dire UK version of No Mercy. The show got off to a good start with a fast-paced opener between D-Lo Brown and a wonderfully obnoxious Jeff Jarrett, who made a plant hoover up some debris in the ring before slapping the figure four on her. Chris Jericho started showing signs of improvement (after a seriously rocky start to his WWF career) in his match with the Road Dogg. Big Show and Kane, who are astonishingly still fixtures on WWE TV today, had a decent match with each other, too. The headlining WWF Championship cage match between The Rock and Triple H made sure everyone got their money's worth from this one. They'd have better matches with each other in 2000, but this was a very encouraging sign. The Bad: Lots of short matches. X-Pac/British Bulldog, Ivory/Tori/Luna, Val Venis/Mark Henry and The Godfather/Gangrel all lasted all but a few minutes each. The action in them wasn't great, either. The Rest: The heels spent much of their promo time running down England and English fans. The term 'cheap heat' comes to mind.

5. Unforgiven

The Good: The six pack challenge main event was all sorts of fun and the best match of the card (as it should have been). On the undercard, Chris Jericho had a really good match with X-Pac (who was instructed to help Jericho learn the WWF style), Chyna had another good match, this time against Jeff Jarrett, and Edge and Christian worked well with The New Age Outlaws. The Bad: Three words: Kennel From Hell. The Big Bossman (who must be a candidate for worst wrestler of 1999) and Al Snow had a match inside a cage, inside Hell in a Cell, with vicious dogs surrounding the ring. The match sucked and, hilariously, the dogs would not behave and kept urinating and disobeying their trainers. The Dudleys had their first WWF match, against The Acolytes. Neither team was really over and they didn't have an ounce of chemistry together. The hardcore match between Ivory and Luna was a good concept, but it was too short to mean anything. The Rest: Conspicuous by his absence was The Undertaker, who began a lengthy lay-off to recover from injuries. Although, at the time, it was rumoured that he was WCW-bound. There was an interesting storyline/in-joke taking place throughout the show with the WWF referees 'on strike' because they were sick of being beaten up all of the time.

4. Fully Loaded

The Good: Fully Loaded featured no single outstanding or classic match but the quality of the matches was consistently high throughout the show, which is more than can be said for a lot of 1999's output. Match of the night honours probably went to either The Rock and Triple H for their overbooked but fun strap match or The Hardy's against The Acolytes. Also worth watching were Edge and Jeff Jarrett's Intercontinental opener and Austin and Undertaker's First Blood brawl, which was one of their better efforts around this time. The biggest miracle of the show, though, was the fact that The Big Bossman actually managed to have a decent match! His Hardcore Title scrap with Al Snow was inventive and a lot of fun. The Bad: Some dross on the undercard, as expected. D-Lo Brown was getting very over but he couldn't drag anything decent out of the awful Mideon. The 'Iron Circle' parking lot match between Steve Blackman and Ken Shamrock really should have been better. The Rest: Not much else to this one. To try and make sense of and explain the storylines during this period is something only Vince Russo would be able to do and, even then, odds are they wouldn't make a lick of sense. This show was miles better than the previous month's King of the Ring.

3. Backlash

The Good: Now we're getting to the really good stuff. Backlash was a proper supershow, the show that WrestleMania could and should have been. Highlights from the undercard were Owen Hart and Jeff Jarrett's match with the ridiculously over New Age Outlaws, the stunt-filled Boiler Room Brawl match between Mankind and The Big Show and the fine X-Pac versus Triple H tussle. The show, however, was stolen once again by Messrs Austin and The Rock. Their arena-wide, McMahon-filled brawl was a different match to their 'Mania one but it was every bit as good. The Bad: The Undertaker and Ken Shamrock had a very weird match. Although it sounds good on paper, their styles just didn't mix at all. Their match, which lasted an interminable eighteen minutes, was a lot of Shamrock working The Dead Man's leg and not a lot else. Shamrock wasn't going to the main event any time soon, after this performance, and was gone a in the autumn. The Rest: Just a bunch of matches featuring the usual suspects. The match is really all about the main event and the endearingly stupid Attitude Era booking.

2. No Mercy (US)

The Good: No Mercy took a little while to get going but once it did, boy was it a great show. Not only was match quality consistently high, but the event featured the best WWF match of the year. The Hardys and Edge and Christian tore it up and (literally) set new heights for tag team wrestling in their blistering tag team ladder match. Val Venis and Mankind was probably Val's last big match, which is a shame, because he looked great during it. The New Age Outlaws against The Holly's was good, old-school fun. The show closer between Austin and Triple H, who had an interesting backstage political rivalry in 1999, was decent (even if it couldn't really follow the earlier ladder match). The Bad: The Rock's six minute victory over a totally broken-down and past it British Bulldog was a waste of The Great One's time. Did anyone want to see The Fabulous Moolah wrestle Ivory? No, they did not. The crowd were into The Godfather versus Mideon opener (mainly because of the hoes) but the match demonstrates just how weak the WWF undercard could be at times. The Rest: One of the biggest stories coming out of the show was that Jeff Jarrett, whose contract had quietly expired, demanded a hefty six-figure sum to drop the IC Title to Chyna in their (very enjoyable) Good Housekeeping match. This was Jarrett's last WWF appearance and he is, for all intents and purposes, blackballed from the company for life.

1. SummerSlam

The Good: Shane McMahon had one of the best in-ring years out of anyone in the company, and he was a non-wrestler. His Lover Her or Leave Her street fight with Test was staggeringly good. Shane would prove himself to be a street fight specialist in later years. The D-Lo Brown versus Jeff Jarrett opener was good. These guys were two of the unsung heroes of 1999. Also good were the tag team turmoil match (particularly the Hardys versus Edge and Christian section) and The Undertaker looked motivated in his and The Big Show's Tag Title defence against Kane and X-Pac. The Bad: The Lion's Den Weapons Match between Blackman and Shamrock as another weak outing in their series. Both guys may have had great looks and been legitimate bada**es but their matches together were never good. The 'Kiss My A**' storyline for The Rock and Billy Gunn's not-so-epic showdown was risible. This was the end of the Billy Gunn singles push experiment, at least for a little while. The Rest: The main event triple threat WWF Championship match between Austin/Triple H/Mankind is a funny one. Foley was supposed to take time off to recover from his many injuries but was inserted into the match when Austin refused to job to Triple H. Another theory is that The Game didn't win here because special referee and Governor of Minnesota Jesse Ventura didn't want to raise the hand of a heel in his home town. Triple H won the title the next night on Raw, anyway.