For me, 2005 was one of my favourite years as a wrestling fan. It had the perfect mix of exciting to watch up-and-coming superstars like Shelton Benjamin and Rey Mysterio, along with larger-than-life characters like Batista, Triple H and the returning Hulk Hogan. Everyone seemed to know their role and WWE was preparing for the future. 2004 hadn't been great, with WWE really failing to create any proper new stars. 2005 was the year when John Cena, Batista and, to some extent, Randy Orton really began to break through and establish themselves. Of course they were going to be guided by the likes of The Undertaker, Shawn Michaels, Kurt Angle and, erm, JBL. These were the names that were headlining PPVs and, on the whole, they were increasing business from the previous year. The product had an air of excitement around it and that was reflected in their PPV output. While not every push or feud was a major success, there was certainly more bad than good and we were treated to some rather extraordinary matches. Off-screen, things were shaped further by some major events, such as the return of Hogan, the departures of Chris Jericho and Christian and the death of Eddie Guerrero. Things looked a lot different by the end of the year than they had at the beginning, but there were fourteen PPV events in-between. Here's how they rank, from worst to best.
14. The Great American Bash
The Good: Not a lot to write home about with this one. The WWE version of the Bash had a reputation for sucking something fierce and this card was no exception. The one real bright spark was the Rey Mysterio versus Eddie Guerrero grudge match, which was the best bout on the show by a mile. Even then, it was probably the weakest match of their lengthy series. The Bad: Where to start? How about with the murder of Muhammad Hassan? Well, it was never explicitly stated that Undertaker killed him but he did give him a last ride through the stage after squashing him like a jobber with the camera showing a motionless Hassan lying on the concrete below. He was never seen in a WWE ring again. The tag title scene was set back several years when WWE decided to switch the belts from the new and hot team of MNM to the really weird 'New LOD' pairing of Animal and Heidenreich, for the sole purpose of promoting the forthcoming Road Warriors DVD. Shameless. JBL and Batista had a plodding, disjointed main event (which ended with a cheap finish to boot). The Rest: The show featured a bunch of standard midcard matches in the form of Booker T versus Christian (both of whom should have been main events by then) and Chris Benoit versus Orlando Jordan.
13. No Mercy
The Good: Not a terrible PPV, by any means, but just a totally unmemorable one. The best match of the night was, fittingly, the main event. Batista and Eddie Guerrero had a hell of a match, different from most PPV main events you will see due to both guys' face status and the 'will he or won't he?' Eddie storyline going in. Eddie gave his all during the match, despite being in obvious pain at the time. He really was a superstar worker, right until the end. Other good, if unspectacular matches were the U.S. Title 4-Way between Benoit/Booker T/Jordan/Christian, JBL/Mysterio and Orton/Undertaker (casket match). This event also marked Bobby Lashley's WWE PPV debut. He looked like a beast in his destruction job of comedy fitness guru Simon Dean. A green beast, but a beast nonetheless. The Bad: The fans could not have cared less about Nunzio and Juventud Guerrera's Cruiserweight Championship match. Total crickets. The Rest: William Regal and Paul Burchill beat Paul London and Brian Kendrick in the dark match.
12. Taboo Tuesday
The Good: Coming a couple of weeks after No Mercy was Taboo Tuesday, WWE's second crack at the interactive PPV format. Overall, it must be said that this was a better effort than 2004's version. The show kicked off with a surprisingly entertaining tag match between Raw's Chris Masters and Snitsky and Smackdown's Matt Hardy and Rey Mysterio. WWE really wanted JBL to get the nod for the Smackdown crew but, unfortunately for them, voting was legit and fans spoke with their votes. They wanted Hardy. After a glut of poor or worthless matches came Triple H and Ric Flair's Intercontinental Championship steel cage match, which was all sorts of 1980s style NWA awesomeness. Flair rolled back the years and The Game must have been loving working this match with his idol and mentor. The Cena/Michaels/Angle main event was good but, come on, Cena was clearly out of his league here and everyone knew it. Cena overcame the odds and won, which would become a recurring theme over the next decade. The Bad: The feeble pop that Mick Foley (as Mankind) got was depressing to witness. It was almost as if his Backlash 2004 war with Randy Orton hadn't happened and the fans were watching Al Snow or Test (the butt of Mick's jokes) in there. Vader's performance in the handicap match against Batista was a complete shambles. The Rest: Steve Austin was supposed to square off against Jonathan Coachman on the show but he walked when WWE made it known that they wanted Stone Cold to do the J-O-B to the former announcer. Also supposed to be on the show was Edge, but he suffered a legitimate partial pectoral tear and was replaced by Snitsky.
11. Armageddon
The Good: Armageddon was never a valued WWE PPV. It was almost as if WWE came to the end of the calendar year and just put out a card that was passable. The 2003 and 2004 events were certainly nothing special. Fortunately, the 2005 event was pretty decent, thanks to a motivated Smackdown roster. MNM had a worthwhile match with the Mexicools pairing of Psicosis and Super Crazy. Even better was Chris Benoit and Booker T's entry into their Best of Seven series. This was a long affair and, despite a fair cagey moments, they had the fans totally invested by the end. The main event Hell in a Cell match between Randy Orton and The Undertaker, whilst perhaps not up to the standards of previous epic Cell outings was still a pretty damn good effort and showed that Orton still possessed all of the qualities to make it as a headliner in the company. The Bad: Once again, the crowd could not care less about the Cruiserweight Title match. This time it was Juventud and Kid Kash out there soaking up the apathy. Apparently WWE were disappointed with both men backstage, feeling they should have used their experience and initiative to quell the 'boring' chants. Big Show and Kane versus Rey Mysterio and (a very injured) Batista was disappointing (but that can be forgiven considering the circumstances). The Rest: JBL pounded Matt Hardy like a jobber in the opener. Throwing his blows with undue force, Bradshaw was sending Hardy a message via WWE management, who were upset that Matt politicked his way out of taking a chokeslam at the end of Survivor Series (as well as still being bitter over the whole Edge/Lita reveal in March).
10. No Way Out
The Good: Two standout matches elevate this one above some of the other B-level PPVs from 2005. The first outstanding match was Rey Mysterio and Eddie Guerrero's WWE Tag Team Championship victory over the Bashams. Although nothing particularly fancy, this was still some high-calibre tag team wrestling. Eddie and Rey's win got the pop of the night, too. The second great match was the No.1 contender's match between Kurt Angle and John Cena. Angle and Cena usually delivered the goods when in the ring together, but this was probably their best singles match ever. This one came so close to being a genuine classic (before the ref bump). The Bad: Undertaker had one of his most useless PPV outings ever against the worthless Luther Reigns. What the hell did WWE management see in the bland, awkward Reigns, anyway? Oh yeah, I forgot he had a massive physique. Booker T was similarly handcuffed with John Heidenreich, who was genuinely one of the worst WWE wrestlers ever. Poor Booker. The Cruiserweights had their typical gauntlet match where the work was fine but the crowd was uninterested and JBL and Big Show had a heavily-hyped barbed wire cage match...where the barded wire barely came into play. Oh well. The Rest: Some utterly pointless diva stuff (bikini contest, talent show etc.) was littered throughout the show. Remember Joy Giovanni and Rochelle Loewen? Nope, didn't think so.
9. Unforgiven
The Good: After months of seeing his career mismanaged, Matt Hardy momentarily got on the right track with a win against Edge in a steel cage match, the best of their 2005 feud. Matt took the win after dropping a seriously crazy legdrop from the very top. Given the circumstances, Edge was a brave man to lie there and take that. Another pleasant surprise was Chris Master's match with Shawn Michaels. Masters had been written off by many due to his uncoordinated and clumsy performances. It was assumed that he was just a rock hard body and little else. Well, against one of the best ever he showed that he could actually go in the ring. This wasn't your typical HBK carries the big lug job, no sir. Although not as good as their No Way Out show-stealer, Kurt Angle and John Cena had a perfectly decent main event. The Bad: Nothing really terrible, just a bunch of filler. The divas tag match was alright, Big Show versus Snitsky wasn't as bad as you'd imagine (but wasn't good either) and Ric Flair's IC Title win over Carlito was ordinary, aside from the massive pop. The Rest: I think it was clear around this time that WWE were being motivated by the good shows that TNA were churning out. They might not have been proper competition, but the AJ Styles' and Samoa Joe's of the world were definitely motivating the WWE guys.
8. Backlash
The Good: Backlash 2005 was all about Hulk Hogan, as any PPV with him on it invariably was. Hogan wrestled his first WWE match in almost two years at the show, teaming with Shawn Michaels to vanquish the evil forces of Muhammad Hassan and Daivari. It was a standard Hogan tag match, nothing fancy, but oh my God the reaction to the old man was just incredible. He really was a masterful worker. Somewhat better from an in-ring standpoint was Shelton Benjamin's IC Title defense against Chris Jericho and Chris Benoit and Edge's Last Man Standing match. These four guys, who were all involved in the Money in the Bank match at WrestleMania, should have been doing bigger and better things, though. Triple H and Batista had a pretty good 'Mania rematch, too. Although they'd really find their groove later in the year at Vengeance, they still produced a worthy main event. The Bad: What, no Christian? Captain Charisma was about to go on a serious roll in the company but he wasn't even booked for a match here, instead coming out and cutting a promo on Smackdown's John Cena, likening him to Corey Haim. Burn. Seriously, go back and look at Christian from this period and tell me he wasn't ready to be a main eventer. The Rest: Trish Stratus caused a bit of a stir online when she referred to Viscera as a 'chicken-eating loser'. Choose your words carefully, Trish.
7. Survivor Series
The Good: Flair and Triple H continued their heated rivalry with an engrossing Last Man Standing match. Both men took an incredible amount of punishment and the fans were glued to the action. Booker T and Benoit had a solid match in the opener. These guys could always be depended on to produce a good match. The Smackdown versus Raw traditional Survivor Series elimination tag (Michaels/Masters/Big Show/Kane/Carlito versus JBL/Mysterio/Lashley/Orton/Batista) was certainly star-studded. The action, all thirty minutes of it, was good too. Orton won for Team Smackdown but The Undertaker p***ed on his parade by returning and destroying the Smackdown roster. The Bad: Vince McMahon saying the N word isn't ever good, is it? I bet he regretted that one when TMZ and the like were digging it up in the wake of this year's Hogan scandal. Speaking of scandals, the overbooking of John Cena and Kurt Angle's WWE Championship match completely ruined it. These two had proven they could have great matches together but WWE handcuffed them with all the nonsense they tacked-on to it. Trish Stratus versus Melina was disappointing. The Rest: This was the first WWE PPV since the tragic passing of Eddie Guerrero.
6. Royal Rumble
The Good: A solid undercard and a great Rumble match, what's not to love? Shawn Michaels and Edge squared off in a competitive opener. Although it started slow, it really got going at the end and Edge's win was a pleasant surprise. They'd have better matches later on, but this was still good. Angle versus Show versus JBL suffered from the same problems that a lot of WWE triple threat matches suffer from, but it was still pretty decent and entertaining in parts. A lot of people look back at JBL's original title run as a failure, but he played the cowardly champion to perfection. Orton and Triple H strived to have an epic match for the ages...but came up short. That would be a running theme throughout their long feud. It was still a good match, but not the classic they were probably hoping for. Also, it's a bit unsettling watching the Orton concussion stuff in a post-Benoit world. The Rumble, as previously said, was awesome. The finish may have been spectacularly botched but before that it was a captivating watch. The Bad: Heidenreich and Undertaker's casket match was bad but not as terrible as you might imagine. Still, 'Taker was lucky to get out of that feud alive, considering how dangerously sloppy Heidenreich was. The Rest: Ever wonder how it was to be a rookie in WWE ten years ago? Watch Eddie Guerrero, Chris Benoit and Hardcore Holly just absolutely annihilate Tough Enough IV winner Daniel Puder with chops and stiff blows.
5. SummerSlam
The Good: SummerSlam 2005 had a real big event feel to it, which is as it should be, really. Rey Mysterio and Eddie Guerrero had a damn fine, risky ladder match. Yes, the storyline was stupid, but you cannot fault the action and effort of both men. John Cena and Chris Jericho also had a great match, Y2J's second last before going on a long hiatus in order to focus on his music career. Then there's Hulk Hogan versus Shawn Michaels. We all know the story by now: Michaels, peeved at having to do the job without Hulk returning the favour, decided to completely oversell his offense, turning the match into a spectacle. It wasn't a great match, but it was completely captivating. The Bad: Eugene versus Kurt Angle was a waste of Angle, who was having a sensation year between-the-ropes. JBL's World Heavyweight Championship challenge was a washout. There have been stories of JBL refusing to full cooperate with Batista during their 2005 series and, on the evidence of this match, it's easy to believe they could be true. Matt Hardy must have wondered why he even bothered coming back to the company after being pounded like a jobber inside five minutes. The referee stoppage finish was an insult. The Rest: Why wasn't Triple H involved on the show, huh? Well, believe it or not, The Game voluntarily took himself off of television and missed the PPV in order to freshen up his character.
4. Judgement Day
The Good: Judgement Day was a very entertaining PPV featuring two stellar but very different matches. My personal favourite was Rey Mysterio versus Eddie Guerrero, which came about as a result of Eddie's stunning heel turn a few weeks prior. These guys had some amazing chemistry and fully embraced the opportunity to have a top-line feud. After their shoddy WM encounter, it's doubtful that many people would have had high expectations for JBL and John Cena's I Quit match. But they did have a phenomenal brawl. Cena excelled in gimmick matches like this one and JBL was game, too. MNM versus Holly/Haas, Chavo Guerrero versus Paul London and Booker T versus Kurt Angle were all fine, although the Angle/Booker feud with 'rapist Kurt Angle' made for seriously uncomfortable viewing. The Bad: Carlito versus Big Show and Orlando Jordan versus Heidenreich were pure filler. The Rest: Matt Morgan used an F5 on Big Show in the closing stages of Show's match with Carlito. Yes, that was a shot at Brock Lesnar (who was in the process of suing the company).
3. Vengeance
The Good: Batista had one of his best matches ever against Triple H inside Hell in a Cell. This was just all kinds of brutal and it was awesome to watch. The best part about it was that Triple H never looked overly dominant, with both men instead trading huge moves and heavy bombs, rather than The Animal taking an extended beating. Further down the card, Shawn Michaels and Kurt Angle had a typically excellent wrestling match, one which came close to rivalling their WrestleMania classic in terms of quality. Michaels got his win back here but Angle did not look weak in defeat. John Cena defended his WWE Title in a triple threat match also involving Christian and Chris Jericho. This was, sadly, Christian's only real shot at the main event scene in 2005. He would be moved to Smackdown in the summer draft. He'd flounder there for a while. The Bad: Nothing outwardly awful, but Christy Hemme versus Victoria wasn't good. The women's scene really missed the injured Trish Stratus. The Rest: The show was brought down somewhat by a segment involving Lillian Garcia, Viscera and The Godfather. What was the point?
2. ECW One Night Stand
The Good: There were PPVs in 2005 that boasted more great matches or significant angle developments, but One Night Stand was just a lot of nostalgia-fuelled fun. Hence why it ranks so high in this list. The event kicked off with a good back-and-forth match between Lance Storm and Chris Jericho, Storm's last in WWE. Super Crazy versus Tajiri versus Little Guido and Rey Mysterio versus Psicosis were both short and WWE-ish, but they were energetic and the crowd were into them, which was good. Things got more EXTREME with Sabu versus Rhino which, while also short, seemed to satisfy the fans' appetite for table destruction. People online ragged on Chris Benoit versus Eddie Guerrero at the time but technically it was fine and the two brought a certain level of intensity other matches lacked. Not lacking in anything was Masato Tanaka versus Mike Awesome, which was a breathtaking stunt show. Both men took an uncomfortable amount of abuse to their heads, mind. The Dudley Boys versus Sandman/Tommy Dreamer main event wasn't great as a match but all the run-ins and the flaming table made it a lot of fun to watch. The Bad: JBL and Blue Meanie. You know the story... The Rest: Conspicuous by his absence in the show-closing melee was Eddie Guerrero, who almost got into a fight with Chris Benoit after their match when the Rabid Wolverine accused him of phoning his performance in (Eddie was upset that he was being asked to do a clean job so quickly after his hot heel turn).
1. WrestleMania 21
The Good: What a wrestling show WrestleMania 21 was (at least for the first three hours). Kicking off with Eddie Guerrero versus Rey Mysterio is never a bad idea. The two had a very exciting match filled with moves and sequences you never see out of anyone else. Unfortunately, Mysterio's mask became detached early on and he kept trying to adjust it mid-match, leading to some awkward moments. Following that was the first ever Money in the Bank ladder match, featuring Edge, Kane, Christian, Benjamin, Benoit and Jericho. What a lineup of talent that is. Unsurprisingly, the match ruled, featuring not only awe-inspiring spots (particularly from Benoit) but good psychology, too (particularly from Benoit). Orton/Undertaker was good and included a few moments where it genuinely looked like Orton would break the streak (which wasn't such a highly-publicised thing then). Trish carried Christy Hemme to a watchable match and Hogan brought the house down with his surprise appearance. Then it was time for Kurt Angle versus Shawn Michaels. What else can you say? This was two of the greatest of all-time, with practically no experience wrestling one another, going out and producing a genuine, show-stealing classic. Finally, Triple H carried Batista to big Dave's first World Heavyweight Championship. The Bad: Big Show. Akebono. Sumo match. Why? JBL and John Cena's match was an anti-climax, especially when you look at what they pulled off at Judgement Day. The Rest: The Hollywood film-inspired trailers for WrestleMania 21 were so much fun. And who could forget...