WWE 2006 PPVs From Worst To Best

Two very different ECW PPVs, the return of DX and some great wrestling from Smackdown.

By Lewis Howse /

2005 was a great year for WWE, with the company creating a bunch of new stars and really delivering consistently when it came to PPV. 2006 was very different from 2005. Fewer stars were made, although the ones that did break through (such as Edge) managed to cement themselves at the top of the card. The two major storylines from 2006 were DX's long dispute with the McMahons and their associates and the return of ECW as a fully-fledged brand. Speaking of returns, the ultra popular Jeff Hardy came home to WWE after two years in TNA. Ostensibly over his drug issues, Jeff was given a big push on Raw. While there were returns, there were also departures. Trish Stratus and Lita, two of the most influential female performers of all-time, left the company within two months of each other. The way they were written out of the storylines was markedly different, however. And JBL transitioned from 'Wrestling God' and main eventer to Smackdown's best play-by-play man. It was a memorable year, both on-screen and off, but how did the company do where it really matters, on PPV? Here are 2006's 16 PPVs ranked from worst to best...

16. December To Dismember

The Good: At least it was short? In all seriousness, the opener between The Hardys and MNM was pretty damn good. Not a classic or anything, but a great way to kick off a PPV. Oh how it all went wrong... The Bad: Balls Mahoney vs. Matt Striker? Daivari vs. Tommy Dreamer? Kevin Thorn/Ariel vs. Mike Knox/Kelly Kelly? That's a pretty awful line-up by house show standards, but PPV? Those who ordered the event (not many) were insulted with the lack of star power and the by-the-numbers action. Only two matches had been announced beforehand - The Hardys vs. MNM and the Extreme Elimination Chamber. The Chamber match was a huge disappointment for a number of reasons. Firstly, Sabu was taken out of the match mid-show and replaced by Hardcore Holly. Secondly, the combatants barely used the weapons that had been supplied to them (and hyped throughout). Then there was the booking. Nobody wanted Bobby Lashley as ECW Champion, least of all Paul Heyman, who had originally suggested CM Punk going over strongly (nixed by Vince McMahon). The Rest: Heyman and Vince had a falling out over the failure of the show - in short, Heyman was upset with Vince's meddling and let his feelings be known. Vince, in response, sent Heyman home to sit out his contract. He wouldn't be seen again in WWE until 2012.

15. New Year's Revolution

The Good: This was the night that Edge became a bona fide WWE superstar. Indeed, while the in-ring content might not have been much to shout about, the event certainly provided a major histortical moment. Edge's Money in the Bank cash-in on John Cena (the first in history), following Cena's successful WWE Title defence inside the Elimination Chamber, ended the event on a high. Further down the card, Triple H and Big Show had a slow but heated match, which told a great story. And Mickie James and Trish Stratus clashed in their first major singles match in their long and celebrated rivalry. The Bad: Freshly heel-turned Gregory Helms and Jerry Lawler had an interminable ten minute match, which King inexplicably won cleanly. Shelton Benjamin (with his 'Momma') was given the pleasure of wrestling Viscera. Their match sucked. And the Elimination Chamber failed to sparkle as brightly as previous instalments. The Rest: Kurt Angle, whose attempts to play heel were being thwarted by a crowd who had nothing but admiration for him, cut a hilarious over-the-top promo where he claimed to not like black people and would love to make Jesus Christ tap out. The fans cheered him, natch.

14. Cyber Sunday

The Good: Those interactive PPVs weren't very good, were they? By 2006, the concept had lost a lot of its lustre (thanks to overall poor events in 2004 and 05). 2006 wasn't much better, boasting only one really good match (Rated RKO vs. DX) and a lot of filler. Saying that, the triple threat main event pitting the three World Champion (ECW, World Heavyweight and WWE) against each other wasn't so bad, and was going along fine until the stupid Kevin Federline interference. Almost a decade later, is there anyone on the planet who cares about Kevin Federline (except Kevin Federline)? This whole angle was a washout. The Bad: The tone was set in the very first match, when fans voted in Kane to be Umaga's opponent, instead of Chris Benoit. Jeff Hardy and Carlito had a terribly disappointing Intercontinental Title match, considering the talent of both. And Lita and Mickie James had an incompetent, overly-long match. Despite what WWE may try to tell you, no, Lita was not very good in the ring. The Rest: Although derided at the time, Roddy Piper and Ric Flair's World Tag Team Title win is a sweet moment in retrospect. Shawn Michaels stole the show in the backstage segment where he walked down the corridor kicking random people in an attempt to prove that he was 'controversial'.

13. Royal Rumble

The Good: Rey Mysterio's Royal Rumble win was a genuine feel-good moment. The references to the late Eddie Guerrero may have been a little much (did Rey really need to come out in a low rider?), but Rey deserved it and it was better than a Triple H win, which many feared/expected. Edge and John Cena had their usual decent match. While the action was good, the finish was horrible. WWE really dropped the ball hot-shottiing the title from Edge back to Cena so quickly, especially considering the ratings were improving with Edge as champ. The opening Cruiserweight Title Open got the show off to an energetic start. The Bad: Nobody wanted to see JBL take on The Boogeyman, did they? At least it was short. The Kurt Angle/Mark Henry main event was a joke and ended the show on a sour note. The post-match Undertaker pyrotechnics show was lame, too. The Rest: Matt Hardy was violated with Viscera's 'Walrus' move in the Rumble match. Yes, WWE were still punishing Matt for dodging 'Taker's Survivor Series chokeslam (amongst other things).

12. Survivor Series

The Good: Another wildly uneven offering from WWE, the 2006 Survivor Series was notable for one particularly nasty send-off... Some of the action was good, however. Chris Benoit and Chavo Guerrero had a decent wrestling match, as you'd probably expect. Still, it was clear watching it that Benoit's career was winding down. Triple H, Shawn Michaels, The Hardys and CM Punk easily disposed of Rated RKO, Gregory Helms, Johnny Nitro and Mike Knox in a traditional Survivor Series tag match. It was a glorified burial, sure, but at least it was fun and didn't drag on longer than it needed to. Undertaker and Mr. Kennedy had a compelling (if rushed) First Blood match. Performances like this helped convince people that Kennedy was a main event player. The Bad: The way WWE chose to send Lita off, in her last appearance, was tasteless. Okay, so Lita had been portraying the, for lack of a better term, 'promiscuous woman' on Raw for the last year-and-a-half, but did WWE really need to send Cryme Tyme out there to auction off her 'personal belongings'? Lita did a lot for WWE. Hell, she even broke her neck for them, but WWE chose to take one last shot at her and her character as she was on her way out of the door. A shame, really, considering the red carpet treatment that Trish Stratus had received just a couple of months prior. As far as the sucky matches, Batista vs. Booker T was laborious. Those two never clicked. The Rest: The Spirit Squad were ran over by Sgt. Slaughter, Ric Flair, Dusty Rhodes and Ron Simmons. As they should have been.

11. Armageddon

The Good: WWE decided to reward those who had bothered to order the PPV by changing the London/Kendrick vs. Regal/Taylor Tag Team Title match to a four way ladder match, also including The Hardys and a reformed MNM. Although a little cluttered at times, this was easily the match of the night (shame about Joey Mercury's face, mind). Elsewhere, Benoit and Chavo had their standard good wrestling match and Mr. Kennedy and The Undertaker had another strong outing in their underrated series (this time fought under Last Ride rules). The Bad: The Inferno Match between Kane and MVP wasn't very good. MVP hadn't yet blossomed into a decent worker. That would come after a few months on the road and in matches with Chris Benoit. The main event was a let down. The dream team of Batista and John Cena easily defeated Booker and Finlay in a match that felt more like a house show main event, rather than a PPV one. The Rest: Do not try this at home.

10. Backlash

The Good: Backlash is usually a huge comedown after WrestleMania, but that wasn't necessarily the case in 2006, since the event boasted several entertaining matches. The show kicked off with a decent match between former partners Carlito and Chris Masters. The fans were really, really into Carlito here. Rob Van Dam and Shelton Benjamin, two of the most athletically gifted wrestlers in WWE history, had a damn fine match. Even if it wasn't the classic that many purists hoped it would be, it was still the best pure wrestling match on the card. What was not a pure wrestling match was Shane and Vince McMahon's epic showdown with Shawn Michaels and 'God'. Typical OTT brilliance from Vince, excessive interference from the Spirit Squad and the typically great HBK performance ensured that this one was never less than entertaining. The Cena/HHH/Edge triple threat main event was inventive, bloody and utterly compelling. Exactly what you want in a big time PPV main event. The Bad: Trish Stratus unfortunately suffered a shoulder injury just minutes into her anticipated rematch with Mickie James, meaning they had to go home early and improvise a finish, which was a shame. Kane versus Big Show and Umaga versus Ric Flair were not very good but served their purpose. The Rest: 'Matt Striker loves poop'.

9. SummerSlam

The Good: Sabu and Big Show had an odd, yet engrossing spotfest. This was Sabu's forte, but Show did his best to adapt and looked like a real killer in the process. Hulk Hogan and Randy Orton had the typical Hogan match. It was basic, and short, but the crowd were with them every step of the way. Ric Flair and Mick Foley's feud was not a highlight of either man's careers, but they definitely produced the goods here in a brutal I Quit match. Both men deserve credit for absorbing a tonne of punishment and putting it all on the line, especially when you consider their physical condition (Foley) and age (Flair). Overbooked to the hilt and featuring more run-ins than an Attitude Era main event, DX versus The McMahons was entertaining nonetheless. As stupid as a lot of the DX summer of 06 stuff was, some of it was pretty damn entertaining, too. John Cena and Edge produced a worthy main event. The Bad: Rey Mysterio and Chavo Guerrero had a deeply disappointing opener. Their storyline (based on the death of Eddie Guerrero) was risible, too. And Batista and Booker T had yet another dud on PPV. They just never clicked at all. The Rest: Hogan was advised to pull out of his match due to his knee injury but declined. He couldn't well pass up the opportunity to go over clean on one of WWE's biggest stars, could he?

8. No Way Out

The Good: Kurt Angle and The Undertaker delivered a sterling main event. This was the best the Dead Man had looked for years, totally hanging with the world-class Olympic gold medalist. The 'controversial' ending didn't necessarily need to be tacked on, but at least it gave them an excuse to have a rematch on Smackdown. Randy Orton momentarily robbed Rey Mysterio of his WrestleMania main event when he defeated him in the semi-main event. Not that it mattered, since Teddy Long just gave it back to Rey Rey a few days later because he felt sorry for him. Still, at least the two had a decent match. Booker T and Chris Benoit was good, even if their series was past the point of played-out. The Cruiserweight Title scramble match was decent and JBL did his best to get something out of the still green Bobby Lashley. The Bad: How disappointing was the reveal of Tatanka as Matt Hardy's mystery tag team partner? You could practically feel the apathy seeping through your TV screen! But really, this was a three match show and all three matches delivered. The Rest: The Boogeyman beat Simon Dean in the dark match.

7. WrestleMania 22

The Good: WrestleMania 22 was marketed with the tagline 'Big Time!' and, whilst it certainly isn't one of the biggest 'Manias of all-time, it is a damn fine supershow. The MITB Ladder Match was a damn entertaining train wreck, which saw Ric Flair take an insane superplex off the top of the ladder. Chris Benoit and JBL's US Title match was fine, but most would expect more out of a Benoit WrestleMania match. Edge and Mick Foley stole the show with their engrossing hardcore match. Edge was determined to become a singles star in 2006 and Foley was determined to help get him there. Selfless. Trish Stratus and Mickie James had a great Women's Title match. The heat was off the charts and the action was good, until the bungled finish, at least. The No Holds Barred match between Shawn Michaels and Vince McMahon was the best McMahon match of the year (and there were a lot of them...). And finally, Triple H and John Cena had a suitably epic main event, which was as much fun to watch for the in-ring action as it was for the crowd response to it (this was in the early days of the Cena hate). The Bad: The Orton/Mysterio/Angle WHC match should have been given a lot more time. That these three were only given nine minutes, the same amount of time as Benoit/JBL and Trish/Mickie (and less than other matches), was an insult. The match was good, considering the time they had. Undertaker and Mark Henry's casket match ranks amongst the most boring Streak matches ever...Booker T & Sharmell vs. The Boogeyman was useless....as was Candice Michelle and Torrie Wilson's pillow fight. The Rest: CM Punk famously made an appearance as a Tommy Gun-toting gangster for John Cena's prohibition-inspired entrance.

6. The Great American Bash

The Good: Smackdown was on good form in 2006, churning out several high quality PPVs. The Great American Bash, typically one of the worst WWE shows of the year, was rather good that year thanks to the efforts of a motivated Smackdown roster. The opening tag match between London/Kendrick and The Pitbulls (Kid Kash and Jamie Noble) was good formula fun. London and Kendrick were one of the true highlights of the year, and their matches were usually on-point. Ditto Gregory Helms and Matt Hardy, who had a competitive Cruiserweight Title match in the midcard. Although not a particularly great match, Ken Kennedy and Batista's bout was a spectacle nonetheless, thanks to Kennedy's excessive blade job. I think he might have hit 0.8 on the Muta Scale, there. Finally, King Booker dethroned Rey Mysterio in a very good main event when Chavo Guerrero predictably turned on the masked man. The Bad: The card had to be reshuffled when Mark Henry (Batista's original opponent) went down with a torn patella, and several other members of the roster were said to have had elevated liver enzymes. Bobby Lashley, Super Crazy and The Great Khali were all taken off the show to safeguard their health. Big Show replaced Khali in the first ever Punjabi Prison match with The Undertaker. It was not very good. Lashley/Regal/Finlay was turned into a singles match, and suffered as a result. Finlay, who was supposed to play babyface, did not do so convincingly leaving the audience confused. The Rest: Not a classic show, but mostly entertaining form start to finish. Watch this one on the Network if you get a chance to!

5. Unforgiven

The Good: Trish Stratus was given one of the most dignified exits in WWE history, defeating long-time rival Lita clean in her home town with the famed Sharpshooter. Trish was then given a Stratusfying standing ovation and left the arena with the Women's Title. The match was pretty damn good, too. Johnny Nitro and the recently returned Jeff Hardy kicked things off in style. Vince, Shane and Big Show once again unsuccessfully attempted to vanquish DX, this time in Hell in a Cell. A cartoony, silly match, one of the 'highlights' was Vince getting his face shoved up Big Show's bare backside. At least the feud was over... The finish to Randy Orton versus Carlito was stunning... Cena and Edge continued their rivalry in a blistering TLC match. Say what you want about Cena during this period, but he had good to great matches on a regular basis. The Bad: Anyone remember The Highlanders? No? They received a WWE Tag Title shot against the Spirit Squad here. It was as average as you can get. Kane versus Umaga was poor, too. The Rest: The event did 307,000 buys, a really solid number.

4. Vengeance

The Good: The summer of 06 was a weird time in WWE. That weirdness is reflected at Vengeance a show that, while weird, was still a really good watch. Best match of the night went to RVD and Edge's WWE Title match. Other choice matches were the Shelton Benjamin/Carlito/Johnny Nitro three way match, Sabu and John Cena's lumberjack match and Randy Orton vs. Kurt Angle. Finally, DX versus the entire Spirit Squad was a totally self-indulgent demolition job but, again, at least it was entertaining. Poor Mitch had his face shoved in HHH's ass afterwards, just for kicks. The Bad: Kane versus Doppelgänger Kane was not very good, although fake Kane (Doc Gallows/Festus) did a great job portraying early Kane. Mick Foley promised to stink out the joint in his 2/3 falls match with Flair (a novel way of promoting a PPV) and he did just that. Well done, Mick! The Rest: What was with WWE's obsession with male ass during 2006? Answers on a postcard.

3. Judgement Day

The Good: Rey Mysterio finally looked like a proper World Champion after weeks of being jobbed out to the likes of Mark Henry, Finlay and Regal. He and JBL worked a great big man vs. little man match. Although the references to Eddie Guerrero could have been cut, it was a damn fine effort. London and Kendrick won the Tag Titles from MNM. Although a shock at the time, the reasons for the switch would become clear soon after. The action was good, as you'd imagine. Gregory Helms versus Super Crazy was fine and Mark Henry and Kurt Angle's match was about fifty times better than their Royal Rumble clanger. Best of all was the slow burning Chris Benoit versus Finlay match. A modern masterpiece, both men wrestled a slow, deliberate style and the fans were glued from the start until the finish twenty minutes later. Oh, and Booker T became King Booker with a well-received victory over Bobby Lashley. The Bad: The Great Khali squashed The Undertaker and pinned him with one foot on his chest. Yes, that really did happen. Bonkers. The Rest: Regarding the MNM split: Nitro and Melina needed to be moved to Raw since they had alienated most of the Smackdown locker room with their prima donna behaviour. Mercury, meanwhile, needed a trip to rehab to sort some substance abuse problems.

2. No Mercy

The Good: What a pleasant surprise this turned out to be. Considering how thin the Smackdown roster was at the time, they managed to cobble together a really entertaining PPV, one for the real wrestling fan. In top matches, a returning Chris Benoit defeated William Regal in a hard hitting war. Real-life friends Gregory Helms and Matt Hardy had a spirited opener. Paul London and Brian Kendrick worked a miracle with the inexperienced and, frankly, colourless KC James and Idol Stevens (Damien Sandow). The Undertaker and Ken Kennedy had their usual solid match. Looking back, it's a damn shame that injuries (and his big mouth) kept Kennedy from becoming a true headliner. Rey Mysterio and Chavo Guerrero continued the Eddiesploitation tour with a decent Falls Count Anywhere match. Finish was weak, mind. Finally, in the main event, King Booker thwarted Bobby Lashley, Batista and Finlay. Veteran Finlay carried the action. The Bad: A truly awful skit between Layla, The Miz and Big Dick Johnson was the only real blemish. I'll leave you to guess the punchline to that one... The Rest: William Regal's, erm, member was momentarily exposed during a backstage segment. Like, the whole thing. Unbelievable...

1. One Night Stand

The Good: Once again, the ECW guys and gals (with a little help from WWE) produced the goods. While not as good as the original, the 2006 One Night Stand was nevertheless the best show of the year. It wasn't a perfect show, but there was a lot more bad than good. Rob Van Dam finally climbed to the top of the WWE mountain with a victory over John Cena. This match is legendary for its insane crowd heat. No hollow threat, the ECW faithful probably would have rioted, had Cena left with the gold. Edge/Foley/Lita took on Dreamer/Funk/Beulah in a wild brawl. Poor old Funker, still rolling around in barb wire in his late 50s... Rey Mysterio and Sabu was something of a dream match for a lot of fans and they met expectations - right up until the cop-out finish. A referee stoppage in ECW? Really? Randy Orton and Kurt Angle had a great opener (the first proper match, after the thirty second Tazz/Lawler macth/angle). The Bad: Balls Mahoney vs. Masato Tanaka was a let-down, considering how awesome Tanaka's match with Awesome the year before was. As mentioned before, the finish to Rey/Sabu was a huge disappointment and really should have been changed. The Rest: How did WWE manage to get it so right here and so wrong a few months later at December to Dismember? The answer: Paul Heyman.