20. John Cena vs. Shawn Michaels - WrestleMania 23
This one probably gets more respect from its peers than it does from the fans. From the moment it became apparent that HBK would be taking Triple Hs spot in the WWE Championship match (after Hunter got injured in early January), the anticipation for Michaels vs. Cena began to build. Cena had rounded the corner and started to become a great worker during his late summer work against Edge in 2006 and Umaga in early 2007. HBK being the ultimate big match performer, Mania 23 was as much about seeing what Cena could do with Michaels than anything else. To this day, HBK vs. Cena at Mania has arguably the second greatest pre-match hype video of all-time (behind Austin-Rock II featuring My Way). It perfectly set the stage for a title match. 28-minutes was how long these two were given to work that night. For HBK, this was no big deal. For Cena, it was entering uncharted territory. He had worked matches close to that length with Last Man Standing or TLC gimmicks attached to help kill some of the dead time, but never before had he been asked to go for so long in a standard match. It was an old school kind of match, bringing forth memories of the 90s style main-events featuring HBK and Bret Hart. In many ways, it was a game of cat and mouse between the cunning veteran and the over-anxious young champion. There was one stretch of the match where HBK worked over Cenas knee that dragged a tad and at one point it seemed like HBK was noticeably frustrated with Cena. Other than that, though, the match built to a great finish. HBK pulled out a rare pile driver and Cena sold it accordingly before making his comeback and ultimately finding a way to make Michaels tap out to retain the WWE title for the second straight Mania. Their rematch on Raw a few weeks later has always been more universally praised, but the Mania match was only just a notch below it. It is supremely underrated, historically.
19. Edge vs. The Undertaker - WrestleMania XXIV
Edge was a classic case of a superstar working his way up the ladder (pun-intended) as a mid-card act to ultimately achieve great singles success. By the time he began the (nearly) yearlong build to his match with Undertaker at Mania 24, he was ready to step up to the main-event of the years biggest show and steal the show in the process. In an excellent interview backstage just hours before his World Championship defense, Edge told the story of how he was a teenager at Mania 6 in Toronto watching his hero lose the title and how he, subsequently, lost his innocence. He said that he would try to recreate his youth by causing the current hero, Taker, to lose his Streak. As fans, you know that being in the main-event at Mania means everything. Edge was one of those guys and his pre-match promo well set the stage for the most important night of his professional life. The outdoor setting made the introductions to this match three times as visually stunning. It was pitch dark when Edges pyro lit up the sky and Taker came out with his dazzling entrance. It was just a very unique experience. The match itself was very well paced and told a thorough story that detailed the history of their feud dating back to Survivor Series 07, when Edge used a TV camera to screw Taker out of the World title. Edge was booked like a dominant force that could hang with Taker to the bitter end. In fact, there were a couple of times that you legitimately had to wonder, for a second, if Edge might be the guy to end the Streak. Hells Gate was still coming along as a primary finisher for Taker, so there was some doubt as to the finish even when Edge got stuck in the hold. The lasting impression left by the match was the sheer number of counters that they pulled off. They did too many reversals of each others top moves to count. Taker was in match 2 of his awesome streak of 4-star or better matches that just ended a few weeks back. Having been on last at one Mania put the stamp on Edges legacy as an all-time great.
18. The Dudley Boyz vs. The Hardy Boyz vs. Edge & Christian - WrestleMania 2000
Tag Team wrestling had seen a bit of resurgence in the fall of 1999, in large part thanks to the Tag Team Ladder match at No Mercy between Edge and Christian and The Hardy Boys. Matt and Jeff had come into the WWE that year as a high flying duo, while Edge and Christian had been part of The Brood together. The Dudleys debuted soon after as maniacal partners who put all that stood before them through tables, culminating in a Tag Team Tables match at Royal Rumble 2000 with the Hardys, with whom they tore the house down with their creative blend of false finishes within the confines of such a unique and challenging match. Edge and Christian were reinserted into the fold for Mania. The Tag Team titles were put on the line in a special Triangle Ladder match to determine the best in a popular new period for tag team wrestling. If you ever wanted to show a person who constantly called wrestling fake a match that would make them rethink their stance and/or gain a little bit of respect for what some guys are willing to put their body through to make it in the business of sports entertainment, then this might very well be the match that you should offer up. Six men that were hungry to make their mark on the WWE spent nearly twenty-five minutes beating the living hell out of each other in what was the first, yet unofficial TLC match. If people thought that the No Mercy Ladder match was extreme, then the introduction of many a broken table off of a ladder took things to a new level. By the end, the six men that had walked into the match as Mania rookies walked out as the leaders of a new golden era that would eventually be called TLC. It was one of the craziest stunt brawls ever witnessed in the WWE. ECW had truly displayed its influence on the WWE with a match of this magnitude. It stole the show at that years WrestleMania and sparked the main-event careers of Jeff Hardy and Edge. Of course, it also gave birth to a classic new match type in TLC. It was groundbreaking.
17. Daniel Bryan vs. Triple H - WrestleMania XXX
You know how the story goes. Daniel Bryan won the WWE Championship at Summerslam 2013, only for Triple H to immediately turn heel and cost him the title, beginning the Authority storyline that continues on to present day. It was an emotional roller coaster of a saga, featuring times when it seemed that the WWE would never fully get on board with Bryan as a top level, main-event player. The investment that fans made in Bryan proved to be the game-changer, as the people refused to allow their guy to be left out of the Mania main-event when it seemed that there was no more compelling a tale to tell. B+ player he could no longer be considered after rising to the occasion and proving himself in the last eight months, culminating in one magical night in April 2014. What an incredible match between Trips and Bryan to kick start Mania XXX! They delivered in spades and told a story that will be difficult to rival, historically. WrestleMania is all about such stories. Psychologically and technically, it was the best match that Mania had seen in quite a number of years. It was reminiscent of The Games bouts with Chris Benoit from a decade ago. When working against wrestlers of smaller statures, it allows Hunter to open up his playbook and do some things that most people have forgotten that hes capable of doing. The Tiger Suplex, for instance, was an awesome move to target Bryans injured shoulder, which Trips did well to attack throughout the match. The intensity of the execution was top notch and the crowd, predictably, was more invested in this bout (and the main-event later on) than any other. It was Bryans night from beginning to end and, though the finish was an incredible moment that no one who had been on this journey with him will ever forget, what will stand out most, one might suspect, about WrestleMania XXX will be its opening match. The climax was outstanding, the near falls incredibly dramatic, the intangible qualities brought to the table by Stephanie McMahon enhanced the presentation, and the pure elements were flawless. This was one of the greatest matches in Mania history. In all likelihood, time will be very kind to this match. It may very well move up the list.
16. Shawn Michaels vs. The Undertaker - WrestleMania XXVI
HBK challenged Taker to a rematch from their heralded Mania 25 clash. The Deadman respectfully declined. Michaels tried to win the Rumble to challenge him for the World title, but he failed to get it done. He magnificently told the story of a man that had one thing left to do in his storied career and that was beat Taker at Mania. He finally cost Taker the World title at the Elimination Chamber, prompting one of those memorable TV segments that usually happen during WrestleMania season when the wrestlers are oozing excitement about their biggest show of the year. Taker told Michaels he had to put his career on the line to get another shot at the Streak. If I cant beat you; I have no career. Youre on. The only bad part about the awesome TV moment was that it immediately threw in your face that HBKs career was about to end and that this would be our last chance to see Mr. WrestleMania do what had made him famous. The night he retired was a bittersweet moment for a fan. He certainly delivered, perhaps not topping the Mania 25 match but certainly having a match for the ages that no one will ever forget. The story was different, with the use of finishers galore putting over the desperation to win. For some, that has prompted a ranking for The Streak vs. Career match ahead of the original simply. Style preference aside, the closing moment when HBK was crying on the stage to raucous applause was one of the most emotional in recent memory. The reception was great. The match was everything that an HBK final curtain call should have been. He showed off his athleticism, performing a move that nobody else in the WWE can do that being the moonsault from the turnbuckle to the announce table. He also did another excellent job of actually making people believe he had a chance. Perhaps that is the enduring legacy of HBK he was so good that you could overcome his considerable size differential against guys like Taker and buy him as a threat to actually win the match. The bout also had stamina and fluidity of the other classic HBK bouts. He was still just young enough to be able to do most of what he had always been able to do.
15. Shawn Michaels vs. Chris Jericho - WrestleMania XIX
In December 2002, Jericho confronted Michaels and called him the Has-Been Kid, prompting HBK to super kick Y2J right in the face. Then, leading into the Royal Rumble in 2003, Jericho made it known that he intended to win the Rumble from the #1 spot, only to be disappointed when he learned that HBK had already secured the first entry. Jericho jumped Michaels from behind and quickly eliminated him from. Y2Js antics only escalated when Michaels jumped him later on in the Rumble and helped get him eliminated. The story eventually shifted to Jericho having once been HBKs biggest fan. Jericho wanted to prove that he was now better than Michaels and was intent on ending HBKs career. Quietly, fans wondered whether or not HBK would be able to hold up his end of the bargain in a non-gimmicked match, since he had not had a standard, feature length wrestling match since 1998. Michaels quickly answered any questions about his fitness level and health when he engaged in a fast paced game of one-upmanship with Jericho to start the match. In what can best be described as a game of chess between two master players, Jericho and Michaels went back and forth for nearly 23-minutes. There were times during the match where each showed off their wrestling acumen, while there were others where they each put their athleticism on display. Then, they proved why they were two of the best in the history of WrestleMania with the steady build to the climax. Jericho was cocky at times, even going so far as to use Sweet Chin Music on Shawn and mock his signature poses. Michaels did a great job of playing the veteran babyface, outsmarting Jericho on a few occasions and finding ways to counter a lot of Jerichos established offensive repertoire. After Jericho and Michaels had exhausted nearly every move in their playbooks, HBK scored the pin with a unique legs over the shoulders pinning combination. It was a match heralded as a highly successful return for HBK and a great showcase of what Jericho brought to the table, but it was often left out of the conversation for being one of the best WrestleMania matches of all-time. It ages like a fine wine and gets better with each viewing.
14. Triple H vs. The Undertaker - WrestleMania XXVII
The hard sell for Mania 27 got kick started when the WWE began airing mysterious videos hyping 2-21-11. Speculation went wild as to who would be showing up on that date and it turned out to be the Undertaker. Yet, as soon as The Deadman made his entrance on Raw that night, Triple H made his long-awaited return and spoiled Undertakers. In one of those rare moments in wrestling when no talking was needed to tell a story, Triple H and Undertaker simply stared a hole through each other and let the crowd talk for them. They each gazed at the WrestleMania marquee before Taker gave a throat-slashing gesture and Trips countered with a crotch chop. The stage was set: Taker vs. Triple H at WrestleMania 27. Before the match, Triple H came out to Metallicas For Whom the Bell Tolls (followed by his usual theme). It perfectly set the stage for the war that began once the bell rang. This was not your typical wrestling match. It was No Holds Barred and they used the gimmick to their advantage to beat the tar out of each other for the first ten minutes. Triple H gave Taker a spinebuster through the announce table. Taker back dropped Trips off the announce table. Once they returned to the ring, they started with a flurry of finishing moves that culminated with Trips kicking out of the Tombstone and Taker kicking out of the Pedigree. It was the moment when Taker goozled The Game and when Trips subsequently looked down at him and shook his head No - that the match became a classic. Nothing that The Deadman could do from that point forward seemed to be able to stop the Game, but even when Triple H went so far as to give Taker the Tombstone it was not enough. Nothing was enough to save the Game from eventual defeat. Taker had to be carted off from the ringside area. 19-0. While not heralded as being on the level of HBK-Taker 1, many rated it on par with HBK vs. Taker II, for obviously different reasons. The storytelling was praised, as Taker and Triple H overcame their physical shortcomings to put on a marvelous performance that was generally well-received by the majority of the top critics in the wrestling media. Taker continued a streak of five straight Mania classics.
13. Bret Hart vs. Owen Hart - WrestleMania X
In the fall of 1993, Bret Hart was trying to find his way back to the top after losing the title to Yokozuna and never having gotten a rematch. During that time, an idea was pitched that Bret do an angle with his brother, Bruce. The Hitman suggested that a different brother be used. He had a Survivor Series match where he tagged with his brothers, including his brother Owen who was the only Hart to be eliminated. Owen blamed Bret for his taking a pinfall and later challenged Bret to a fight. The Hitman wanted no part in a match with his own brother, but Owen was steadfast in his desire to find out who the better man was, eventually getting Bret to agree to a match at WrestleMania. This was the classic example of two brothers trying to outsmart each other. The wrestling was tip top, as they channeled their past experiences with each other as two kids that grew up in the business with youthful expertise and talent. Owen showed that he was perfectly capable of hanging with Bret. The younger Hart proceeded to dazzle the live crowd with spectacularly efficient moves. He was a very fluid wrestler really getting his first chance to have a showcase match. He made the most of it. The Hitman nearly had his comeback complete when Owen blocked his Victory Roll and scored the pin. The critics were acclaiming this match from the get-go, but while it is unquestionably considered a wrestling clinic that young superstars learning their craft should thoroughly study, it may always be overshadowed by the HBK vs. Razor Ramon Ladder match on the same show. Yet, it is undoubtedly a classic. It stands the test of time and harkens back to a time when things were simpler when telling a story. Brother vs. Brother was simply enough and no further bells and whistles were required. It was one of the finest displays of in-ring performance in Mania lore. I subsequently feel it was the better match at WrestleMania X. While the original Ladder match has been topped, Bret-Owen stands the test of time and may have the greater staying power as the years continue to pass. It could fluctuate, from year-to-year, but it will always be right up near the top.
12. Shawn Michaels vs. Razor Ramon - WrestleMania X
Time has not necessarily done this match justice. A big new chunk of the current viewing audience may not understand how important this match was and how influential it has been to the last fifteen or so years of wrestling history. Think of all the Ladder matches that we see today and about how there are even two PPVs named after two variations of the original. All of that began with WrestleMania X at Madison Square Garden, where two men ascended the ladder of immortality. The storyline was great. HBK never lost the Intercontinental title. Ramon had won the so-called vacant title. When Michaels returned, he naturally wanted to be known as the rightful champ. Ramon had a legitimate claim, too. So, they hung the belts high above the air and prepared to make history. Someone has to do it first in a huge setting and Michaels and Scott Hall will always hold that distinction. Unknowns and unpredictability carry a gimmick match the first time that you see it. Most of the WWE fans had not seen a Ladder match before, so Hall and HBK entered uncharted territory along with the rest of us. People have always said that HBK had a match with a ladder, but Michaels will readily admit that the best part about their ladder match was that they were telling an already personal story and that the ladder was just a nice prop to further it. A lot of Ladder matches nowadays get criticized for making the story about the ladder and less about the storytelling. So, in many ways, the original was the best pure Ladder match. Definitively, this was the match that took bumping to another level. The stuff they did looks fairly routine by todays standards, but back then it was very unusual to see guys putting themselves at risk to that degree. While future generations of stars were able to top this match with the crazy bumping going to a level never thought possible, HBK vs. Razor remains the top dog when it comes to storytelling and historical context. HBKs ladder match with Chris Jericho six years ago might have been a better match with a superior story told, but it will never be able to touch the original for what it came to mean for the wrestling business.
11. Shawn Michaels vs. Bret Hart - WrestleMania XII
Shawn Michaels was very passionate about becoming the top guy in the WWE during the mid-90s and as he became a more tenured superstar, he surrounded himself with the kinds of guys that could help him find a cozy spot with the company while he used his vastly superior in-ring skills to propel himself to championship status and money. Bret Hart was the veteran presence in the locker room and not the type to take kindly to HBKs questionable backstage happenings. Hart had been given the ball and asked to carry the WWE as its champion during some dark days when business was tanking out amidst rumors of scandal and steroids. He developed a reputation during those days as an honorable champion and a very hard worker; not to mention the best in-ring technician in the business. Mostly, the two had coexisted just fine, but HBK was being given Brets spot. Right from the get go, it was built as a spectacle match for Shawn Michaels to get over huge and become the next guy to carry the WWE. HBK famously descended from the rafters on a bungee cord. When the match started, the men cut a deliberate pace. Some would call it too deliberate, but it was the dominant theme of the majority of the match. HBK and Hart worked flawlessly, but the crowd sat on their hands for the most part. The occasional flurries of high spots were not enough to engage an audience that had not been prepped for such a match. Quiet fans politely applauded a technical masterpiece, but the lack of what they were accustomed to seeing kept them from getting very invested in it emotionally. Though it often has, the lack of crowd heat should not overshadow the incredible work that Hart and Michaels performed. Michaels won with Sweet Chin Music to capture his first WWF Championship just a few minutes into the surprising overtime period. The boyhood dream came true There might not be a more polarizing match in the history of WrestleMania. For much of the first 20 years of the event, people often called it the greatest match of all-time. It was named the #1 match in Mania history by the wrestlers prior to WrestleMania XX in 2004. Since then, its critics have grown in number.