WWE: 4 Format Shake Ups That Would Benefit NXT

By Matthew J. Douglas /

The WWE is an interesting and unique brand of entertainment. Part circus, part sport, part sitcom, part variety show and part drama. Nearly every aspect of any kind of TV show that is available for consumption, from Saturday Night Live to the riveting action of an NBA game, is part of what goes into Monday Night Raw, Friday Night Smackdown, and the monthly WWE Pay Per Views (or "Special Events" as the WWE wishes them to be called now). It€™s always been fascinating to see how the WWE views its own product, because they can skew in so many different directions. They (and by they I mean Vince) likes to think that they are in the business of telling stories and views the WWE€™s weekly programming like a network drama or sitcom. His public statements on the subject also seem to suggest that he would rather his product not be viewed as resembling a sport in any shape or fashion, unless it is convenient (like when touting the fact that their DVD/Blu-Ray sales are tops in the sports category). The truth is that most of their programming more resembles a sketch comedy show, with a bunch of unrelated segments getting mashed together, some working and some not working, but when a segment hits, it makes the whole show seem worthwhile, not unlike SNL in recent years. It seems that the WWE could stand to try introducing more of the elements of sport into their programming, by having clearly defined rules and regulations, and a stronger structural foundation for their shows. The drama of sport is so conducive to they type of storytelling the WWE should be in the business of focusing on. You€™d need to test out such sweeping changes of course, and where better to do so than on NXT. While NXT might be the most enjoyable hour of WWE TV each week, it suffers somewhat from coming across as Raw-Lite, with more outlandish characters, but similar structure. NXT is filmed at Full Sail University and it would behoove the program to install a narrative structure that more resembles college athletics than a night at the improv. These changes would not only bring about a more sporting atmosphere on NXT, but will make the NXT brand feel different from that of Raw or Smackdown. This week we€™ll look into what the narrative structure could be like if you made NXT more like college sports and how they should go about implementing it. As always your thought and comments are welcomed and much appreciated, so feel encouraged to share in the comment section below. Now let€™s revamp NXT!

4. Implement A Ranking System

One of the staples of the NCAA in both their Basketball and Football programs is their ranking of the schools€™ teams based on performance. Unlike most sport leagues where a team€™s record speaks for itself, in the NCAA not every team is facing the same competition. Thus the need for a ranking system where the strength of the opponents along with your record are taken into account, among other criteria like strength of the victory, etc. The NXT ranking system could work in a similar fashion, where the NXT Title Holder is #1 as long as he holds that title. Everybody else is ranked according to their record in matches, the way that they win their matches, the strength of their opponent, and possibly how much trouble they have in defeating their opponents (like how long the match is or how many near falls they are on the receiving end of or something like that). All this information can be part of a fictional algorithm that provides the rankings. This allows you to provide reasonable rankings without really needing to pay absolute attention to the science behind it, because at the end of the day it€™s all part of a narrative. The question then becomes how do you implement it on the show? The easy answer is to have a new authority figure placed in charge of NXT (preferably somebody young like a Byron Saxton) and have him champion the idea of a ranking system. Build up its implementation as a huge innovation that will shape the future of the WWE. He will set up a huge battle royal featuring every member of the NXT roster, and the order in which eliminations occur will determine where the superstars rank, meaning if you are eliminated first, you are ranked last, and so on and so forth. Going forward from this initial ranking, on a weekly basis the positions will be updated based on the activity of the week prior.

3. NXT Title Shots Awarded According To Ranking

Now that the ranking system is in place, the question becomes is how will it effect weekly television and the awarding of NXT Title shots. Firstly superstars can only challenge for the NXT Title if they are ranked in the Top 5. It would stand to reason that people would go about trying to improve their ranking so that they can be eligible for these title shots. Now people would think that you€™d be sacrificing personal feuds, but if you are being honest with yourself you will see that you are only adding more drama to them. Now there is something tangible on the line in every feud, you ranking stands to improve or worsen based on the result of any match, which will lead to grudges being forged and rivalries being sparked. Every sport has its great rivalries and NXT with this ranking system will be no different. To add to the drama and allow for last minute switch ups and more narrative maneuverability, the bylaws of the ranking system will allow for special matches that will feature rapid re-seeding. That means if a party feels compelled either by hubris or blood boiling vitriol, they can put their ranking on the line. That means the #2 superstars could wrestle the #10 superstar, and if the #10 superstar wins, they will switch spots. These kinds of matches would be done sparingly, but the option will always be available. Otherwise, the rankings will be updated based of the algorithm discussed earlier, based of a plethora of wrestling criteria (and obviously creative direction).

2. Bring On The Madness!

Now this is where things get really fun. We have the ranking system in place, and we€™ve figured out how it plays into the week-to-week narrative of NXT, but what else to we need to put this idea over the top, and bring prestige and theatre to this system? It€™s simple really, March Madness! March Madness is one of the top 3 North American sporting events year in and year out because it embodies everything that we love about sports. High stakes, high emotions, and wild, unpredictable finishes. This 64 team, single elimination college basketball tournament is some of the best sports theatre every year, giving us Cinderallas to root for, powerhouses to root against, and nail biting, knockdown drag em€™ out games that often come down to the final shot. Every year before Wrestlemania, NXT should hold its own March Madness Tournament, featuring the top 16 (or more) NXT superstars, all vying for the NXT National Championship Cup. The brackets will be based on the rankings that have been cultivated throughout the year, and the final match will be held at Wrestlemania, giving NXT a presence at the biggest WWE event of the year. The NXT Championship is important because it gives you top ranking and top billing, but you win the NXT National Championship Cup, and you own that for the entire year, and nobody can take that away from you until the next tournament. It will feel special, it will be exciting, and it will be something completely new and exciting to look forward to every year for NXT at Wrestlemania. Wrestling fans and sports fans love prestigious events that we can look forward to because they happen annually. We love looking forward to the Royal Rumble and when it comes we€™re always excited. Same with Wrestlemania, Money In The Bank, the NBA, NHL & NFL Playoffs and of course the Olympics and the World Cup. The annual NXT National Championship Cup Chase can become one of those staples of the WWE that we look forward to from NXT for years to come. Plus who doesn't love a good Tourney?

1. I Do Declare!

If you thought this was over, think again. Now that we€™ve come up with the ranking system, the way that it effects weekly TV and an exciting and prestigious Tournament to go along with it, it€™s time to bring one of the most interesting elements of college sports to the WWE€™s developmental system narrative. That element is of course declaring for the draft and going pro. Every year after the big National Title Tournament, the winner will have the option to decide whether or not he wants to declare for the main roster or stay on NXT another year and make a run at another NXT National Championship the following year. Building up the drama behind this decision would be paramount, having him truly wrestle with what is best for his career. Sometimes the superstar will be told he€™s not ready and decide to go to the main roster anyway, sometimes he€™ll stay for another run at the National Title. Regardless what they choose, the WWE will need to craft compelling narratives going forward for them, but having this annual ritual in place gives you a consistent and fruitful starting point at the beginning of each new cycle after Wrestlemania This doesn€™t mean that superstars can€™t be called up during the course of the year, but it just brings another fun element to the entire college athletic atmosphere that NXT could have broadcasting from Full Sail University. Usually getting called up onto Raw or Smackdown is at the discretion of the executives in the WWE, but winning the NXT National Championship Cup gives the superstar control over his own destiny. It is the only way to put the decision of debuting on Raw or Smackdown in your own hands (narratively speaking of course). It would be a spectacularly fun addition to the structure of NXT, and will give us the drama and excitement of annually having a new superstar possibly declare and debut on the Raw right after Wrestlemania. These changes only add intrigue to NXT, and the sooner the WWE sees this and considers these format changes, the better.