Dave Batista is scheduled to return home to the WWE on Raw this week, where he will no doubt get the chance to pick up his awesomeness from where he last left it. Granted, it would be tough to top his last run, where he was pretty much the worst human being on the face of the Earth for months, but thats part of the challenge of our so-called sport. I certainly have made no secret of my love of Batistas run as a heel in 2010, including an exit from the promotion where he was fired by Bret Hart and wheeled out with a cast on several parts of his body while crying like a baby. So theres a lot to live up to there.
However, in the spirit of positive thinking, Id like to present five other returns after long absences where the returns far exceeded the investment and made everyone take notice for a little while. And in the interest of fairness, five returns where wed just like to forget about them. These are in no particular order, by the way, aside from whatever I thought about off the top of my head that seemed like a good idea at the time.
5 Returns That Rocked...
5. Brock Lesnar (2012)
When Brock left WWE to pursue his dream of making millions of dollars doing anything else but pro wrestling while hunting deer and living in a cave in Minnesota, few gave him a chance. Heck, I think that living out life as a mega-rich Viking Space Lord while running your own farm in a cold wasteland and occasionally clubbing grizzly bears to death with your own hands is pretty much the American Dream. But when going from wrestling to pro football turned out to be unattainable for poor Brock and contract entanglements threatened to keep him from working at doing anything else with his life that would earn him the hundreds of millions that he was clearly entitled to, he simply sued the pants off of WWE and won his freedom. And to celebrate, he went to UFC and beat up dudes for money, some of whom were significantly smaller than grizzly bears and thus easy prey for him. And there was a lot of money to be earned from trolling hardcore fight fans who didnt want to see the fake pro rassler dominating their sport. Sadly, while no wild animal (boar, bear, giant squid, whatever) could best Brock in a fair fight, a rare intestinal disorder could, and he was forced into retirement from MMA and back to WWE again, where wrestling a bear for money was a right and honorable pastime. And then he lost to John Cena in his first match back, but my lord that return was so tremendous that GROWN MEN were jumping up and down in excitement like pre-teens at a Justin Bieber concert, losing their minds. And ever since then, Brocks appearances have been like a force of nature unleashed on the show, sweeping in and kicking hats, throwing couches, slamming dudes onto tables, whatever. You can say that he should be more selective about the jobs he does and who he works with, but would you argue with the guy that probably plows his own fields with a yoke tied around his neck like Babe the Blue Ox? I wouldnt.
4. X-Pac (1998)
All things considered, this was quite the promotion for the former 1-2-3 Kid. After spending his final months in the WWF as the guy that Shawn Michaels and the Clique kept around because they liked to laugh at him while he puked on himself (according to Jim Cornette), Sean Waltman drastically reinvented himself in WCW. Going from high flyer to weasel smart-mouthed heel boosted his stock immensely and dramatically lengthened his career path, and after getting fired due to neck injury in late 97 he made his return back to the WWF in 1998 the night after Wrestlemania 14. You may have heard Vince McMahon brag about the ratings win that this led to on a few different documentaries, and Im not saying it was entirely Waltmans doing, but Im not NOT saying that either. OK, Im not actually saying that, that would be pretty stupid. But X-Pac had a pretty good run as a key member of D-X and won some titles before annoying everyone later on and winding up with personal adventures in sex tapes and rehab. But man, that one return promo, so awesome.
3. Rick Rude (1991)
Heres some carny nonsense at its finest: Rick Rude was feuding with Big Bossman in 1990 over contentious remarks made about the Bossmans mother. Rude got injured, but the WWF kept advertising him as the headliner for house shows for months afterwards anyways. Rude, quite reasonably, told Vince McMahon that if he was going to be advertised as being there, then he should also collect his share of the money taken in for that show. This didnt go over with the office very well, and Rude told them where to go before quitting in the fall of 1990. And then they continued to advertise him for house shows anyway, because VINCE MCMAHON. Revenge proved sweet for Rude, however, as he reappeared a year later in WCW after healing his injuries, debuting as the mysterious WCW Halloween Phantom at Halloween Havoc 91, thus immediately kickstarting a new chapter of his career as a main event heel. Not to mention leading the Dangerous Alliance into one of the best periods for a heel stable ever, beating Sting to win the US title, and eventually winning the NWA World title from Ric Flair to cap his career. Sadly, a neck injury in 1994 would end his career for good, but it was a heck of a reinvention and a grand loogie spit in the face of the WWF.
2. Shawn Michaels (2002)
Back in 1998, things were looking grim for Shawns career and continued livelihood. After dropping the WWF title to Steve Austin, he seemed to be permanently retired thanks to spinal fusion surgery and a spiraling drug habit. Even as late as 2001 there were attempts made to get him back into the mix again in a program with BFF HHH, but his demons resulted in getting sent home to sober up and HHH getting punished by losing to Undertaker at Wrestlemania X-7. And then, in 2002, he found Jesus, and more importantly discovered that his back might not be in as bad of shape as previously thought. The combination of spiritual peace and sobriety (along with a successful marriage) suddenly opened the door for a comeback, and he never looked back. In fact, his second run in the main event was so spectacularly successful that most fans today only know him as the legendary guy who delivered Wrestlemania classics year after year from 2002 until his second retirement against Undertaker in 2010. From the guy who screwed Bret Hart in Montreal to Mr. Wrestlemania and a beloved legend is not a bad career trajectory.
1. Hulk Hogan (1983)
After an initial heel run in the WWF as a rookie, young Hulk Hogan set out for greener pastures via the AWA and improbably became a movie star. Using his natural heel charisma, he scored the plum role of THUNDERLIPS the Ultimate Male in Rocky III (and as a sidenote, whoever creates character names in those movies is an unsung genius) and suddenly found himself the hottest property in wrestling. Unfortunately for Verne Gagne, that meant he was suddenly out of the AWAs budget, despite Vernes best efforts to convince him to take the World title. Versions of the story depend on whos telling it, but in 1983 Hulk left the AWA and turned down the belt, choosing to sign with the rising WWF instead. And just like that, Hogan ran out on TV and saved Bob Backlund from a Samoan beating, suddenly finding himself on top of the promotion. With Backlund on the way out of the promotion and Vince needing a new face of the company, Hogan won the World title for the first time in January of 1984, and things were never the same again. For better or worse, I guess. However, Hogans returns were not always this glorious
5 Returns That Fizzled...
5. Hulk Hogan (1993)
Stop me if youve heard this one before. Hulk Hogan returns from retirement in 1993 (ie, his failed movie career and ducking the steroid trials), now toting Jimmy Hart as his manager, and immediately wants the World title back, which kind of undermines the experiment of having Bret Hart on top of the promotion. Vince tells Bret that hell get the title back at Summerslam (he was lying), and Hogan ends up walking out of Wrestlemania IX as the champion. Not coincidentally thats considered by far the worst Wrestlemania in history. Business dies with Hogan on top again, Hogan decides to get out before any further blame can be thrown his way, and he leaves the business until resurfacing in WCW in 1994. That at least went better for him, but I think wed all like to forget Hulks ill-fated fourth WWF title run. But it wasnt to be his LAST run
4. Hulk Hogan (2002)I suppose Im of two minds about this one. When Hogan and the Outsiders returned to the WWF in early 2002, Hogan himself popped a big number for Wrestlemania against the Rock, and fans in Montreal gave him the legendary ovation that seemingly never ended. So it seemed like good business sense to strike while the iron was hot and get the World title back on him one last time. In fact, if I was the guy in charge at that time, I would have done the same thing. I guess we all just didnt realize how fast Hulkamania would burn out that time, because almost literally the day after he beat HHH for the title at Backlash, fans had seemingly had enough Hogan for one lifetime, and attendance plummeted for shows with Hulk on top. Clearly the trigger just wasnt pulled fast enough, which is kind of a shame because there was a real nostalgia factor with Hulk at that point which probably could have been milked for a while. But as it was, the title reign was such a disaster that it was switched to Undertaker at the very next PPV, which was also the first show under the new WWE name. Yes, Hulk Hogans 2002 run was so bad that HE KILLED THE WWF. Admittedly thats a bit of a stretch, but its my article.
Advertisement
3. The Ultimate Warrior (1996)
Oh man. I cant even. Ive got one word for you: DESTRUCITY. Sure, now he's going into the Hall of Fame, but in 1996, business was not good in WWF-land. Vince was so desperate for a main eventer that he reached out to Ultimate Warrior, the guy who had literally walked out on the promotion twice before and was now more interested in promoting his Warrior University than with being a wrestler. Not to mention the endless litigation over his own name and likeness that was driving the WWFs legal team crazy. But Vince took a chance because it was best for business, and what a flaming trainwreck it turned into. We got Warrior feuding with Jerry Lawler! Warrior feuding with Goldust in a PPV match where Goldust was injured but advertised as being there, resulting in 10 minutes of stalling and a DQ finish! And for the grand finale, after weeks of Vince shamelessly plugging whatever ridiculous merchandise and crackpot teachings that Warrior demandedwell, Im sure you can guess the ending. Warrior flaked out and left them without a PPV main event yet again. Vince was so desperate at that point that he brought Sid back and GAVE HIM THE WORLD TITLE. Thanks a lot, Warrior.
2. The Ultimate Warrior (1998)
Oh, but were not done yet! You might think that the hot topic of conversation in 1998 was Goldberg or Steve Austin, but it was not, and frankly Im a little bit disappointed in you personally for thinking that. Its kind of ignorant on your part, if were laying all cards on the table here. No, as I was walking around airports at the time, people would come up to me and be like Scott, why hasn't Hulk Hogan ever beat Ultimate Warrior after losing to him that one time 8 years ago? As a member of the youth of the 90s, this is a pressing concern to me. And then airport security would escort me out because I was hanging around airports for no reason, but it was a different time and that sort of thing wasnt frowned upon as much. Hulk Hogan is nothing if not hip and a real groovy cat, and he obviously understood that people just couldnt get enough of recycled WWF main events from nearly a decade before, and set about to correct that by bringing in Warrior for an obscene amount of money and then, and this is the best part, letting him have creative control. So we got Warrior creating the one Warrior nation (sic), then brainwashing Brutus Beefcake into being his subservient buddy, not to mention appearing in Hulk Hogans mirror backstage to torment him. Of course, Eric Bischoff was unable to see Warrior in the mirror, but everyone watching at home could, because WCW. And then once they had killed off any interest in the match completely, we got Hogan v. Warrior at Halloween Havoc in a negative-star classic car wreck, complete with Hogan botching a fireball to finally avenge his loss to Warrior and mercifully end the whole stupid thing. Sadly, by that point Yokozuna was unavailable for Hogan to bring back and beat, because we probably would have had to endure that as well.
1. The Rock (2013)
OK, fanboys, put down the flaming pitchforks slowly, where I can see them. Yes, Rock boosted the numbers for Wrestlemania for 27 and 28 and basically saved the show with 27. No ones denying that. However, by 2013, it was pretty obvious that there was little interest in still seeing him in the main event, and even less interest in seeing him end Punks WWE title run in such telegraphed manner. Especially when it was also telegraphed that John Cena would be getting it back instead. Not only that, but any increases for 2013 for PPV buys were more than offset by Rocks astronomical salary. And ratings actually went down in the buildup to Wrestlemania. I love the Rock, you love the Rock, but it was an uninspired storyline (Rock gets a title shot for some reason, never defends it, loses it and then leaves again) with an uninspired payoff (We know we said last year was the only time youd see this match, but we lied.) that left everyone looking like sub-par stars next to him. And for that, I have to declare his 2013 return a flop. Its nothing personal.