Remember, the event is about honoring Andre properly, along with displaying today's talent. While there is is something to be said for finding an unknown or a fresh face to try and put over by having them win this Battle Royale, it would make more sense for Big Show to emerge victorious. In the first place, wrestlers Big Show and Andre's size are exceedingly rare, and secondly among wrestlers that large, few command such longevity, success, and dedicated fan followings as the Big Show does. And when you're talking about Andre, longevity, success, and dedicated fan followings are the name of the game as he remains clearly relevant, even 21 years after his death.