Pro wrestling is an odd beast, indeed. While John Cena, the 14-time world champion, continues to be the face of the WWE, he is not without his detractors. Much like many past "faces of the company", there's the feeling among a large group of fans that he has perhaps overstayed his welcome. Cena is not the first to have this happen, and he likely won't be the last. However, underneath Cena, underneath any face of the WWE, he is supported by an undercard of gifted talent. These are men that inlcude multiple time Intercontinental Champions, United States Champions and even men who have yet to be given their big break. It's fair to say, then, that many of these talents have been ready to carry the torch of the WWE, but for whatever reason, have been playing back up to the man on top. He may not be the current champion, but the man who is clearly identified as the face of the company rarely needs it. Fans believe in these wrestlers, they want these wrestlers at the top. And while a couple of them have been promoted to a status that they probably could have never even dreamed of, at the end of the day, they still aren't labeled as "the man". While one can argue that some of them may haven't been ready, or proved to not be able to draw legitimate money, that much is completely different when it comes to the fans. They often get chants when they're not on the card, or even in the building. By now, all of these men and women should have been top stars, but have either been forgotten or depushed so much, it's a wonder they aren't forgotten.
7. Cody Rhodes
There was a time when Cody Rhodes was the most compelling and fascinating character in the entire WWE. After suffering an injury in a match with Rey Mysterio, his entertaining, yet somewhat flat character, "Dashing" Cody Rhodes, underwent a massive shift. He returned wearing a clear, protective face mask and got a brand new theme and attitude. Spurned from the psychological drama of what he believed to be his hideously scarred face, Cody became "Un-Dashing", and sought to ruin everything beautiful in the WWE. This change in gimmick was exactly what Cody needed. The Dashing element was fun, but it lacked depth. Once Cody became the deeply disturbed and calculating upgrade of his former self, he gained a true sense of confidence that a main event player needs. He had an added bonus in that he was able to physically interact with the audience, which was always a plus. As Cody came out to the ring, he brought paper bags with him that he would use to cover up the "lying eyes" he saw staring at him from the crowd. It was a riveting time for Cody, and the prospect for how high he could soar with this character was very exciting. Fast forward to 2014, and Cody is working the tag division with his older brother Dustin, as Goldust. Granted, it's better than being relegated to Superstars duty, but the Un-Dashing character was one of the most brilliant WWE persona in the last decade. He was scary and haunting, with one of the most eerie entrance themes to date. He also possessed the ring presence of an old-school veteran, despite having only been in the business for 5 years. I believe that Cody will one day become a top star, but I will also fear that the best time to pull the trigger on Cody has already passed.
6. Beth Phoenix
Beth Phoenix exploded into the WWE in 2007, brandishing a new gimmick, the Glamazon. She was strong, powerful and dominated the entire roster of WWE Diva's. In a Diva's division that sorely needed its own version of "the woman", Beth was the tops. She captured the WWE Women's Championship in October of 2007, and held it for six months. By the time she left the company for personal reasons, the division had slowly deteriorated. Beth's rise was just as quick as her seemingly instant fall. She was massively over, and the crowd was into her, despite the crushing villain that she played. Her multiple reigns with the WWE Women's Championship were impressive, and she carried the title with so much legitimate power, that she was always credible. She was so credible, in fact, that you could always buy her with the title, and it made beating her a big deal. It's one of the things that is missing in the division, a Diva that you believe in. Whether she's a babyface or a heel, you do need that one dominant Diva who bulldozes the competition. And with Beth, you had that. She made the division exciting, and it immediately made every other Diva an underdog. As her push slowly died, so did the WWE's faith in her. She was lumped into a terrible romance angle with Santino, and drafted to SmackDown. While a switch to the blue brand can sometimes be helpful to a wrestler, it ultimately hurt Beth's character. And while it seemed as though she was being prepared to reclaim her former throne, holding the Diva's Championship for 204 days, her reign was somewhat uneventful. She should have been the next Trish Stratus, but was never fully appreciated by management for what they had. But she's currently a new mom with former WWE Champion Edge, so perhaps she was the biggest winner of all.
5. Kofi Kingston
A mere two years after his debut, Kofi Kingston was already working high-profile matches in the WWE. He won the Intercontinental Championship at Night of Champions, defeating Chris Jericho. Since then, he has become a 4-time Intercontinental Champion, a 3-time United States Champion and former Tag Team Champion with CM Punk. He was seemingly the top rising star in the company, and was massively over with the WWE Universe. He has an explosive, fun style in the ring. The crowd was lit up when Kofi came to the ring. Starting in 2009, Kofi began a fued with the then white hot Randy Orton. While it should have been designed as a program to elevate Kofi, it was clear that we were very wrong. Kofi had excellent chemistry with Orton, and it seemed clear that he would get a very nice boost from Orton and be on his way to a world title run. Five years later, and Kofi is a mainstay on Superstars and Main Event. This isn't necessarily a bad thing for someone like Kofi, who is still early enough in his career that he can still be built to a main event star at a later date. But the problem is that 2009 was the best time to do it. The WWE is constantly in fear that they won't have a top star to replace John Cena as the face of the company. I would be more sympathetic to this if they didn't squander numerous opportunities to make a new star. The WWE has no issue with packaging a star in the right way, and putting them over the right people to get the crowd to start supporting them. The issue is that they never pull the trigger, fearing that they won't captivate the same way Cena, or any other past top star did. But while it's still questionable whether Kofi would have been the next guy or not, what isn't questionable is how the fans believed in Kofi during this time. They wanted him. We may never know if that would have worked, but we may get the chance to know in the near future. And that part is exciting.
4. Zack Ryder
In true professional wrestling style, you're either a Broski or you aren't. While Zack Ryder's meteoric surge to the tippy-top of the uppder midcard was fascinating to watch, it wasn't without its critics. But even so, you can't deny the power of the WWE Universe, when they literally forced Ryder into the spotlight. In 2011, Ryder had become somewhat disgruntled with his position in WWE. Despite getting some impressive crowd reactions, Ryder was continuously shafted by creative. Barely promoted, yet the crowds knew enough to chant "We Want Ryder", despite him not appearing anywhere near these shows. The Ryder Revolution had begun. Throughout the year, Ryder was put into storylines featuring John Cena, and was given ample time for the spotlight to shine on him. And he did it well, even inadvertently teaming with Hugh Jackman to gain a pinfall victory over Dolph Ziggler. It seemed as though WWE was listening, even putting the coveted United States Championship on Ryder at TLC 2011. And even though he ended up dropping the title to Jack Swagger a mere 29 days later, it was at least a sign that the company may be prepping Ryder for something more. After all, he managed to become one of the top merchandise movers among the likes of John Cena and CM Punk. Eventually, though, as all good things do, it came to an end. Ryder was put into a romance storyline with Eve, jobbed out like crazy and overall made to look like a weak and ineffectual nothing. He still gained some nice reactions, but the push was slammed on so hard by WWE, it would be difficult to give any credibility to another try at Ryder. But you can look back at Ryder's rise in 2011, and be proud of him. He got himself over, despite the obvious fact that no one in the company ever believed he could do it. Zack Ryder should be an upper midcard guy, and even be given a token World Title run during some of the quiet months in the company, just as a show of support for working so hard. But it's highly unlikely that the company sees anything more than a solid utility worker, which is a shame, but it's the nature of the beast.
3. Wade Barrett
When Wade Barrett led the Nexus into the Viewer's Choice edition of Monday Night Raw in 2010, he was shot straight to the moon by creative. It was the first time in a long time that the company had took a chance on doing something different. Instead of just sporadically debuting the rookies of the first season of NXT on Raw and SmackDown, they put them together in one of the greatest stables the WWE has ever seen. Lead by the charismatic and entertaining Barrett, Nexus targeted John Cena and the entire WWE roster. Though they were similar to the group that inspired it, the NWO, the Nexus were a different breed. They weren't just a group of outsiders, they were WWE bread. And they wanted one thing. John Cena's head on a platter. But much like the NWO before it, they were eventually watered down into a shell of what they used to represent. And despite my love for CM Punk, the New Nexus was, and still is, a terrible idea. Ultimately, the Nexus should have been the springboard to create a new top heel in Wade Barrett. And he was on the cusp of that, when he worked a WWE Championship match with Randy Orton at Survivor Series. In a perfect world, Barrett would be booked to win the title and capitalize on the enormous momentum he had. But it was not to be, as Orton retained. Shortly thereafter, the inevitable destruction of the Nexus sent Barrett packing to SmackDown. Despite forming a new stable in the Corre, Barrett failed to catch fire like he did on Raw. He's a gifted entertainer in the ring, and his booming voice makes for some intimidating promos, but creative has saddled him with less than spectacular angles to work with. Since 2013, he has been working a new gimmick in Bad News Barrett. It's an odd one, and reeks of WWE keeping him around because he's well-liked, but it's doubtful he will ever reach his the height of heat he had during the original Nexus run. It's a shame, because the WWE is going to need a new top heel once Orton starts to slow down, and you may have missed your chance at one in Wade Barrett.
2. Daniel Bryan
Believe me, the only reason that Daniel Bryan isn't the number one choice here is because it seems logical that WWE are prepping Bryan to become one of the next torch-bearers. But even with the company putting Bryan on the push of a lifetime, the feeling is that it should have happened sooner. There's something about Bryan that connects with a crowd, and it isn't just the "Yes Movement", either. It's the clarity of who he truly is, and that's what makes people hijack events until they get what they want. They like Bryan because he's them, he's the everyman. He's a very pure, real character. In truth, Bryan has had the most organic character development of just about any wrestler brought up from NXT. He came from the indie scene with a name already in place. People knew who Bryan Danielson was, even if they didn't. Much like CM Punk, there was an aura about this king of the indies, a man who had held the ROH World Championship for 462 days. And when he finally came to the big stage, making his debut on Raw as a part of the Nexus, there was something clear about Daniel Bryan. He was gonna make it. And even though there was a roadblock when he was released for going a bit too far by choking Justin Roberts with his own tie, he eventually made his way back to the company. After winning the World Heavyweight Championship at TLC, he began what is now the most popular chant in the WWE today. The "Yes!" chant sprang out naturally, and was born from his in-ring persona. He wrestled every match like it was the biggest match ever, and fans believed it. And today, the "Yes Movement" is in full swing. But while it seems like Bryan is ready to pop, I still feel like the trigger hasn't been pulled. Perhaps that is coming at WrestleMania 30, or maybe it isn't. Regardless, while Daniel Bryan may be "the man" in the eyes of the WWE Universe, the impression is that the company still doesn't see it that way. I'm happy for Bryan, and I'm one of his biggest fans, but at this point, something has gotta happen for Bryan to truly become the next guy in line. And it's gotta happen soon.
1. Dolph Ziggler
You guys know enough about wrestling to know what a heel is. On paper, he's the villain. The bad guy. He's the one who cheats, and blatantly breaks the rules behind the back of the referee. They are nefarious characters. In the old silent movies, before the talkies, they were the ones you booed and hissed at. But in 2013, when Dolph Ziggler cashed in his Money in the Bank briefcase against Alberto Del Rio, you would never be able to tell he was a heel. The crowd was absolutely bananas when Ziggler's music hit. It was clear. Ziggler was money. In fact, it's difficult to watch a PPV or episode of Raw where the crowd doesn't chant "We Want Ziggler". He has a very natural charisma, and is insanely likable. He's supremely entertaining, almost without even trying. But perhaps more than any of the other wrestlers on this list, Ziggler may be the one that looks the most like a top star. If you could build a main eventer from scratch, he would look like Dolph Ziggler. The crowd is always into him, his matches are the highlight of any card and he is clearly a guy who would be willing to be the guy that has to do tons of media and promotion for the company. His dedication is second to none. But while it seems as though Ziggler is ready for the big promotion, WWE clearly isn't as convinced. At this point, Ziggler is past any silly mid-card thing they'd try to do with him. Putting him in anything that isn't the main event just seems counterproductive to what he does out there, and what he does maybe better than anyone on the roster. I don't truly know why they've been so hesitant to let the sparks fly on Ziggler. Maybe it's all the reasons I've mentioned before, but I'm not so sure. It seems like the WWE knows Ziggler is money waiting to happen, but don't know quite how to make it work in the most effective way. No matter how many times he's jobbed out to someone he has no business going over him, the crowd still loves him. Obviously it's about more than the pops you get in the arena, but I think if Ziggler was given the ball, he'd score you a touchdown every time. But this is the part where I shut up. Do you think I'm crazy for even suggesting Daniel Bryan, or do you think I've missed someone completely? Sound off in the comments!