WWE: 9 Unforgivably Stupid Gimmicks That Ruined Great Characters

Or how to completely wreck a wrestling talent...

By Andrew Soucek /

It's hard to create a great wrestling character: for every Rock, there's 10 Man Mountain Rocks, and for every Kane, there's 10 Isaac Yankems. But with the right talent, and the right push, a star can be made. Sometimes that star begins to fade, though, and sometimes WWE likes to get cute, which is invariably a bad combination. The company then tweaks a formula that was once working too far, and fans end up now rejecting a former favourite. Every once in a while, a drastic turn for a character works. After all, when The Rock first began talking in the third person, it seemed a bit out there. But fans adjusted quickly, and that change to his act paid off tremendously. More often, though, big gimmick changes fall flat and are painful to watch. WWE would have been better off not tweaking something that was already working. Worst of all, some of the talent whose gimmick was "enhanced" never recovered at all. Here are 10 unforgivably stupid gimmicks that ruined otherwise great characters.

9. Kane The Murderer

Kane is one of the most enduring characters in all of wrestling, and incredibly, this is despite the fact that he's had some of the dumbest storylines in the sport's history. He's been involved in anger management classes, battled an imposter and put on a suit to become part of The Authority, but most infamously, we saw WWE retcon all of Kane's back story and expose him as a killer. Back in 2003, WWE was going through a bit of an identity crisis: the popularity of the Attitude era had ended, The WCW Invasion had flopped and Steve Austin and The Rock were no longer full-time stars. WWE began scripting more ridiculous storylines that were at times offensive (HLA anyone?), but more often, just downright awful. The worst victim of this was Kane, who was asked to star in the amazingly stupid storyline that revolved around a deceased former lover named Katie Vick. For years, we had all known Kane as Undertaker's evil half-brother who was basically raised in a basement. Then WWE decided to throw that all away so they could say he "murdered" a past girlfriend on his way to a wrestling show. Apparently Kane wasn't a very good driver and got into an accident in which Katie was killed, but the monster himself survived. Years later, this was all good fun for Triple H, who called out Kane publicly for being a murderer. The two engaged in a feud that resorted to Hunter simulating sex with a mannequin in a funeral home and pretending it was Vick. Not only was this a lowlight in Kane's career, but it remains one of the worst moments in wrestling history. Thankfully, the feud only lasted a few weeks, but it felt like years. Kane did eventually recover from the colossally stupid storyline, as he always does, but only until his next idiotic one, which is always right around the corner.

8. Steve The Hugger

Steve Austin had the hottest run in wrestling history in the late 90s, but he reached heights that were unsustainable, and his character had to change at least a little to stay fresh. In a controversial move, Austin turned heel against the The Rock at WrestleMania 17, and joined his longtime nemesis Vince McMahon. Sure, Austin start doing bad things to get fans to hate him, but he quickly did a complete 180 that made his character virtually unrecognizable.

Advertisement
Austin went from being a total badass to a man who needed constant attention and love from his boss. He showered McMahon with presents, and started giving him routine hugs. These two men made each other's lives a living hell for the past couple years, but here they were now just sharing a friendly hug. The hugs, though, weren't quite mutual: McMahon didn't seem to be so into them. He was creeped out, while Austin always held an almost perverse look on his face during the drawn out holding. Things became even weirder when Kurt Angle joined the fold as another McMahon lackey - the two competed for Vince's attention, and even sang (horribly) to him. Was it funny? Absolutely. But did it draw actual good crowd heat and make you hate Austin? Not at all. Austin's heel run was an absolute flop, and only served to damage his legendary character.

7. Shelton's Momma

Shelton Benjamin is a fantastic athlete: in college, he was a two time All-American heavyweight wrestler, and he had some of the flashiest moves in the WWE during his time there. After his tag team with Charlie Haas ran its course, he was given a big singles push and almost broke out as a star. After being drafted to Raw in 2004, Shelton was booked in a one-on-one match with Triple H. It seemed obvious that Hunter would go over, but he was upset by the new arrival. After that, Shelton took on the rest of Evolution, until he came up short against Randy Orton in an Intercontinental title match. An injury took him out of action for a few months, and upon his return fans remained hopeful that he could get his momentum back. Instead, he went to a new low when WWE must have decided that he needed show more of his personality. He was first booked in a losing streak, which never seem to work out. This was all part of a story, as Benjamin's frustration and losing ways led him to be paired with his "Momma." Of course, this wasn't his actual mom, but it was actress Thea Vidale who had her own ABC sitcom years earlier. Right from the get-go, it was clear this wasn't going to work. Momma was an overbearing, obnoxious character who proved that her son was nothing more than a momma's boy. Why would fans cheer for him? Since this failed horribly in making Benjamin more popular as a face, he was turned heel and had Momma interfere in his matches. Again, this also sucked, and Momma was given storyline heart problems and never returned. Unfortunately for Benjamin, the damage was already done, and he never got close to regaining his former popularity again.

6. Saturn Loves Mop

Brain damage is always funny! Right? Well, at least in WWE it was humorous enough to build an entire gimmick out of. Perry Saturn is a true badass. He was an Army Airborne Ranger before he was in wrestling, and post wrestling he was shot in the neck while saving a woman from being raped. For some reason, though, wrestling promoters just wanted to make him look foolish. In WCW, the man had to wear a leather dress for awhile after losing a match to Chris Jericho. When he jumped ship to WWE, he must have thought was as bad as it could get. Oh boy was he wrong. After The Radicalz stable ran its course, Chris Benoit and Eddie Guerrero were being groomed for bigger things while Dean Malenko and Perry Saturn were left by the wayside. While Malenko was given a comedic James Bond like character, Saturn was left to date a mop. Yes, a mop. After getting knocked around by the APA and Raven, Saturn was having some issues with his brain. He started cutting promos that didn't make a lot of sense, and then fell in love with a mop that he lovingly referred to as "Moppy." His employers apparently weren't too concerned, and marched him out there every week for another beating. They didn't seem to concerned over his mop love. Too bad for Saturn, though, his storyline girlfriend Terri Runnels couldn't put up with it anymore, and left him when Saturn chose the mop over her. But really, when you fall in love with a mop, there's no coming back from it. No one is going to take you seriously again. Not even John Cena could recover from that. Tragically, Moppy was murdered by Raven after being thrown in a wood chipper. This left Saturn without a gimmick at all, and he was soon relegated to the B-shows and later released. Saturn never returned to the WWE, but hopefully he got the care he needs, and has at least found love again with another inanimate object.

5. Mark Henry The World's Largest Incest Machine

At one point, Mark Henry was legitimately one of the strongest men in the world - that should be a gimmick in, and of itself, right? But no, that wasn't interesting enough for WWE's taste. Someone in charge thought having him play the role of a guy that has sex with his sister was somehow a better gimmick. In the midst of the Attitude Era, Henry was fresh from his run in The Nation. He needed some new direction, and it was decided that he'd play a sex addict, which was clearly an interesting decision to make. Well, at least he must have dated a boatload of beautiful women right? That way fans could still hate him because they'd be jealous... Nope - he instead had sex with old women, a transvestite and worst of all, his own sister. Henry couldn't keep his addiction under control, so he visited a series of therapists to talk about his problems. For some reason, Henry thought it was ok to record and air these personal sessions to millions of people. Anyway, one of the therapists was a beautiful woman, whom Henry confided in that he had sex with his sister when they were young. For some reason, this really upset the therapist, and she harshly judged him. She then asked him when the last time they had sex was, and he admitted that it was just a couple days prior. Yuck. Ick. What? What was the point of that? Are we supposed to hate him for his incest ways? Are we supposed to cheer someone to beat up the huge pervert? Who thought that was a good idea? Not surprisingly, it didn't lead to any big matches, and was just downright disgusting. Is it really any surprise that it took over a decade for Henry to finally rid himself of the stink of this angle and for fans to finally take him seriously?

4. Hulk Becomes Too American

Whether you love him or hate him, you'd at least have to admit that Hulk Hogan is one of the most successful wrestlers of all time, and after being out of the WWF for nine years, he finally came back home. His initial NWO run there didn't live up to it's potential, but that was due in part to fans wanting to rabidly cheer Hogan. The company soon caved, and gave the fans the classic red and yellow version they remembered from their youth. At first it was a lot of fun, but you can't sustain a character's popularity off of nostalgia alone. WWE sure tried, though. Instead of being the "Babe Ruth" of the company that WWE wanted him to be, they were rushing him out there every week, which made his appearances feel less special. After Hogan vanquished Vince McMahon at WrestleMania XIX, the company seemed to run out of ideas. Or at least good ones. Instead of occasionally bringing Hogan back as a legend for big matches, they slapped a mask on him and called him Mr. America. The company didn't even try to hide that it was Hogan, as you could clearly tell it was him. He would do all of Hogan's poses, had the same limited move set and would still say "brother" ad nauseum. The entire act was ridiculous, and was far beneath Hogan for that time in his career. The gimmick was just too cheesy, and not funny like WWE must have hoped for. The company went so far as to even book a lie detector test for Mr. America to take to prove he wasn't Hogan. He passed, but this entire gimmick failed.

3. Santino's Cobra Becomes Self-Aware

As a heel, Santino was a great, pesky mid-card character: he was fun to hate, and actually kind of funny. He had a fun gimmick going in the Honk-a-Meter where he tried to break the Honky Tonk Man's 64-week Intercontinental Title run. Ultimately, he came up quite a bit short, but then he turned babyface and quit trying. Santino kept a lot of the traits that made him a heel, but didn't really evolve as a character. Now that he was good, though, he was finally able to connect with his Cobra finisher. In the past, he would miss virtually every time, but now the ridiculous looking throat punch started knocking people out. To make things even worse, Santino pulled a Mick Foley and put a sock over his hand when dishing out the move. Somehow it got even worse. Much worse. The hand sock started to develop a mind of its own. Once the sock was on, Santino could no longer control it. Somehow, it even fell in love with Aksana. It was one of the worst storylines of the year, and seemed to never end. Santino was no longer fun to watch, he was painful. In 2013, the act continued and at one point, The Cobra was snake charmed by flutes that Jinder Mahal and The Great Khali were playing. It was awful and unforgivable. Whatever love Santino had from the hardcore fans is probably gone forever. Hopefully, he's sold enough of those merchandise socks to make up for it.

2. Ultimate Warrior Becomes Batman

The Ultimate Warrior doesn't have to do too much to be cheered. He just has to run to the ring, shake the ropes, flex his muscles and the fans will eat it up. It's a good thing for him, because he couldn't wrestle a good match to save his life (unless he was in the ring with Rick Rude or Randy Savage). After controversially leaving the WWF in 1996, Warrior showed up on WCW Nitro in 1998. He immediately set his sights on his former friend Hulk Hogan, and tried to destroy the NWO. He got a tremendous pop from the crowd upon his arrival, but soon divulged into one of his pseudo-philosophical nonsense promos that only made sense to himself. Even stranger, was that Warrior soon adopted aspects of Batman. Yes, Batman. At the end of his promos, he would finish with the line "tune in next week, same Warrior time, same Warrior channel" just like the voiceover from the 1960s Batman TV show said. Then, Warrior would disappear in a cloud of smoke, and a mysterious Warrior symbol would appear above the arenas. It must have been a lot of work to lug the Warrior signal across the country. Anyway, once again, Warrior's run didn't last long, but this was arguably his worst and most confusing one.

1. Finlay Gets A Leprachaun

There are few men in all of wrestling (or perhaps roaming the earth) tougher than Dave "Fit" Finlay - various wrestlers have said he's one of the men in the locker room that you wouldn't want to mess with. During a match in WCW in 1999, Finlay proved his toughness when he almost lost the use of his leg when he lacerated a nerve in it during a match. That should have been the end of his career, but he was able to return within a year. Amazingly, despite being in his late 40s, he debuted in WWE in 2005. Now simply known as Finlay, he quickly developed into a great mid-card heel who just loved himself a good fight. Imagine Sheamus without the cheesiness, and a bit more toughness and you'd have Finlay. Things were going great for him, until he got a leprechaun. Initially known as Little B*stard, the future Hornswoggle joined Finlay's side by hiding under the ring and attacking his friend's opponents. The gimmick was just ridiculous, horribly stereotypical and hurt Finlay's tough guy persona. Why was he hanging out with a littler person, who could only grunt and would dress as a fictional creature? Little B*stard was a comedic act that the announcers (and Vince McMahon) just loved, but everyone over 10 hated. Eventually, it was revealed that Finlay was the B*stard's father. There was really no way of recovering from that. A demotion to ECW later where Finlay was used to wrestle with more inexperienced wrestlers was the beginning of the end for him. Meanwhile, Hornswoggle has somehow now surpassed his"father's" entire tenure in the WWE. That's magically awful to think about. Which other awful gimmicks ruined great WWE stars? Share your own picks below in the comments thread.