So TLC 2015 is in the bag and it looks like the general consensus is that it was the same as it is every year. I.e. the booking was sometimes baffling and it was clearly a placeholder show before next month's Royal Rumble, but that there was enough weapons-based carnage to make up for the questionable creative. TLC has been a WWE institution since 2009, when the company felt that, gee, wouldn't it be great to take an impactful stipulation bout, dilute it and string it out over the length of an entire PPV? (see also: Hell in a Cell). Before TLC, however, there was Armageddon, which was WWE's December PPV from 1999 onwards (aside from in 2001 when it was renamed Vengeance, because WWE felt 'Armageddon' was too harsh following 9/11 and God bless America etc.). Far from being predictable or, heaven forbid, consistent, the quality of Armageddon varied wildly from year to year. In its history it was a tri-branded PPV, and both a Raw and Smackdown exclusive show, meaning that no singular show was ever quite the same. Armageddon played host to several major gimmick matches and one or two important angles (and also featured some absolute dreck) but how were the shows overall? I've looked back at the history of WWE Armageddon and ranked them from worst to best, pointing out the good, the bad and the rest...
Advertisement
9. 2003
The Good: EricBischoff's Battle of the Sexes was arguably the best, most entertaining match on the show. Although it was a little uncomfortable watching Christian willingly manhandle Trish and Lita, the match was well worked and the crowd were with them. At just under seven minutes in length it didn't outstay its welcome, either. Randy Orton and RVD had a so-so IC Title match. The Legend Killer prevailed after eighteen minutes of action to raise the strap. This was a big moment for Orton. The pair would have better matches in later years, but this had its moments. The Bad: Too many filler or disappointing matches here. Booker T versus Mark Henry was a waste of the former five time WCW Champion. Molly Holly versus Ivory was a thing that existed just because. Tag Team Turmoil was just an excuse to get a bunch of guys on the card and eat up some time. Shawn Michaels and Batista's clash wasn't terrible, but Batista was still very green and clearly had to be led by the experienced HBK. Then there was the Triple H/Goldberg/Kane main event was just twenty minutes of drawn-out power moves. It wasn't great but it was certainly watchable. The match and night ended with every member of Evolution holding gold as Triple H reclaimed his precious World Heavyweight Title (Flair and Batista had won the World Tag Titles earlier in the night). The Rest: This PPV wasn't available to UK viewers, as a contract dispute meant that neither Sky Sports nor Sky Box Office had the rights to broadcast it. We didn't miss much, really.
8. 2004
The Good: Armageddon 2004 was host to two pretty damn good matches, the opener and the main event, which bookended a show that was, on the whole, very mediocre. Rey Mysterio & Rob Van Dam's Tag Team Title defence against the long-forgotten duo of Kenzo Suzuki and Rene Dupree was a spirited affair. These two duos had surprising amounts of chemistry between them. The main event saw Eddie Guerrero, Booker T and The Undertaker - three men who had been screwed over by JBL within the last six months - take on the WWE Champion in a fatal four way. The match was exciting, if not a little disjointed at times. The highlights were undoubtedly whenever Latino Heat and The Deadman interacted with each other. It's a damn shame we never got a feud between those two. Based on the evidence here, it would have been great stuff. The Bad: The boxing match between Tough Enough finalists Daniel Puder and Mike Mizanin had no place being on a wrestling PPV. The contest wasn't very good, although The Miz surprisingly managed to hold his own and not get knocked the f*** out by the vastly more experience Puder. Hardcore Holly & Charlie Haas vs. The Bashamas and Funaki vs. Spike Dudley were both Velocity-calibre bouts. No one in the arena cared, even if the work itself wasn't terrible or anything. Big Show's 3-on-1 handicap match against Mark Jindrak, Luther Reigns and Kurt Angle was...yeah. It was just yeah, yeah? Show finished off Jindrak with an F5, a direct shot at Brock Lesnar (who had recently been shown sitting ringside at a New Japan Pro Wrestling event). The Rest: The knackered Angle actually pulled doubly duty at the show - earlier in the night he caused Santa Claus to tap out to an Angle Lock. What a heel.
7. 2005
The Good: There was some really solid wrestling on the Armageddon 2005 undercard. The Mexicools (Super Crazy & Psicosis) versus MNM (one of the hottest new acts in the company) was a breezy, high-flying ten minute match. Chris Benoit and Booker T, meanwhile, had their usual solid, hard-nosed scrap over the US Championship. The Undertaker and Randy Orton's Hell in a Cell clash was considered a disappointment at the time but, looking back, it was actually very engaging. Orton's goofy facial expressions were a delight and 'Taker was game. Juventud versus Kid Kash was good, even if it did play out before near silence and 'boring' chants. The Bad: The Friendly Tap. Yup, that time where WWE thought it would be a good idea to film ex-referee Tim White's attempts at killing himself (because his life has supposedly been ruined due to an injury sustained inside the Cell). This wasn't funny, it didn't get anyone over and, coming so soon after the death of Eddie Guerrero, came across as insensitive. Matt Hardy was pounded like a jobber in the opener with JBL, who blasted Hardy over the house mic for 'crying to the internet' over the Edge/Lita affair. Hardy lost in just over six minutes. WWE were sending a message to him after he managed to politic his way out of taking a chokeslam from The Undertaker at Survivor Series. The Rest: The Undertaker went mental when he found out that Bob Orton had tested positive for hepatitis - Randy's dad had bladed during the match and his blood had come in contact with The Deadman. President of Talent Relations John Laurinaitis got an earful from WWE's locker room leader ('Taker didn't contract the virus himself).
6. 2002
The Good: Eddie Guerrero and Chris Benoit stole the show with a mat-based minor classic. One for the pure wrestling fans, the two talented Smackdown men contested a tight match with the No.1 contendership for the WWE Title on the line. A great deal of the fans sat on their hands until the nearfalls, but the match itself was great. Well worth seeking out, this one. The opening four team elimination World Tag Team Title match was good, but the action was overshadowed by Goldust and Booker T's victory. It was a genuine feel good moment and richly deserved, considering how entertaining they had been for most of the year. The two World Title matches were alright, but nothing exceptional. Big Show and Kurt Angle, who had great chemistry with each other, put on a decent match for the WWE Title. It was overbooked, sure, but it was the right kind of overbooking. It added to the match, rather than took away from it. Triple H and Shawn Michaels' Three Stages of Hell (Street Fight, Ladder and Cage) match was overly long but it had its moments. The Bad: A-Train versus Edge was a snoozefest that did nothing to progress Edge's burgeoning singles career. The Trish/Jacqueline/Victoria triple threat was pretty bad. Kane versus Batista was somehow worse. As bad as those matches were, they were still better than the pathetic segment where Dawn Marie and Torrie Wilson engaging in some softcore foreplay in a hotel room. WWE hyped this up so much, and the commentators sold it so hard, that it came across even more exploitative and lame than it probably should have. Just awful. The Rest: Matt Hardy was supposed to be the man to injure Rey Mysterio and face Edge here, but John Laurinaitis (him again) lobbied for A-Train instead. Because A-Train is bigger and therefore better and more entertaining, you see.
5. 2006
The Good: Christmas came early for fans who ordered the event, as Smackdown General Manager Teddy Long changed the Paul London & Brian Kendrick versus William Regal & Dave Taylor Tag Title match into a ladder match, also featuring MNM and The Hardys. What a pleasant surprise. Chock full of exciting action and dangerous stunts, fans got their money's worth with this one. A clear match of the night. Chris Benoit and Chavo Guerrero's US Title match was good, but not much different from the 300 other matches they had around this time. Ditto Jimmy Yang and Gregory Helms' Cruiserweight Title collision. Ken Kennedy continued to show main event potential in his Last Ride match with The Undertaker. It was clear watching this that 'Taker was motivated and Kennedy was bound for main event stardom. The Bad: The opening Inferno Match between MVP and Kane was poor. Has there ever been a good Inferno Match? Worse than that was The Miz vs. The Boogeyman. Nobody was expecting a technical masterpiece here, but it was still a really hard watch. The Batista & John Cena versus King Booker & Finlay main event was a typical house show match, i.e. completely by-the-numbers. The Rest: This is the show where Joey Mercury's face exploded. Watching it back, he's very lucky that he didn't lose his eye.
4. 2008
The Good: The main event was, fittingly, the best match of the show. Triple H, Edge and Jeff Hardy had a wonderfully inventive triple threat match with the World Heavyweight Title on the line. After many false dawns, Jeff finally won the big one, much to the delight of the fans in attendance. Chris Jericho (who had a sensational 2008) and John Cena had their usual good match, as did Rey Mysterio and CM Punk. All four men involved worked hard here. Batista vs. Randy Orton wasn't the epic match you'd think it would be but it was still pretty damn good. Odd to see it placed firmly in the midcard, mind. And Rey Mysterio and CM Punk had a good match in the Intercontinental Championship contender tournament finals. They'd have better matches a couple of years down the line, but this was decent. Both men were babyfaces and had to really graft in order to get fans invested, which they were (especially for the near falls). Clumsy Punk probably didn't want to bloody Rey's nose with the GTS, though. The Bad: It wasn't terrible, but Vladimir Kozlov versus Matt Hardy is not something I'd ever want to watch again. It was just so dull, and the clean heel finish did nothing to help Hardy. Mark Henry and Fit Finlay's Belfast Brawl was similar in that it wasn't awful or anything and worked as an acceptable time-waster, but didn't really belong on PPV. Ditto the eight diva tag match (yawn). The Rest: This is the PPV where Khali and Mae Young finally (and I use that term as sarcastically as possible) made out. I'm sure some of you are into that kind of thing...
3. 2000
The Good: Armageddon 2000 was pretty much a one-match show, with all the credible main event talent put into the first ever six-man Hell in a Cell. The star power on display here is simply astounding, with The Rock, Steve Austin, Triple H, The Undertaker, Kurt Angle and, erm, Rikishi, all in the same ring at the same time. This one is great because of spectacle alone, but also managed to weave many interesting story threads during the course of the bout. Featuring some great brawling and a really big bump, this one is a lot better than some give it credit for. Could have done without Angle being made to look like the world's least deserving WWE Champion, but you take what you can get. Bit of a nothing undercard but The Radicalz versus Team Extreme elimination match was good fun and the crowd were way into the closing moments when it came down to Dean Malenko vs. Lita. Chris Benoit positively destroyed Billy Gunn to raise the Intercontinental Title. I mean, the Rabid Wolverine just treated him like a jobber out there. And the four team Tag Title match was alright, too. The Bad: Chyna and Val Venis' feud was a mess. They're match here was a washout, despite the best efforts of the porn star-cum-PC flag-waver (Venis, not Chyna). Kane and Chris Jericho's Last Man Standing Match (the result of Y2J spilling a cup of coffee on the understandably burn-conscious Big Red Machine) was neither man's finest hour, to put it mildly. Those two never really clicked. The Rest: WWE did a great job of building up the Cell throughout the night by showing interviews with each of the combatants talking about how brutal it is. Simple but very effective.
2. 1999
The Good: Watching WWE PPVs and TV shows from 1999, you quickly realise just how insanely over everyone is. From the main eventers to the opening match guys and even the lowly jobbers, everyone was getting big pops by the rabid Attitude Era fans. That was on evident from the first match at Armageddon, with the crowd going positively bonkers for the red-hot Hardy Boyz, who just lost a decent tag team battle royal. After a few disappointing undercard matches, Kane and X-Pac picked things up with a good steel cage match. They did what they could with the eight minutes they were given and the fans were well-invested in their storylines (which centred around Kane's girlfriend Tori). Even better than that was Chris Jericho and Chyna's remarkably good Intercontinental Title match. The double champion storyline may have been silly, but their effort here was positively first class. Fans were going mental for the supposedly heel Jericho and it was clear he'd be a big babyface star in future. The New Age Outlaws Tag Title match with The Rock and Sock Connection was decent, although it was clear Mick didn't have too long left as an active performer. Finally, the main event between Triple H and Vince McMahon might have been far from a scientific classic (Vince is possibly the most unathletic man to ever be associated with athletics), but it was a lot of fun as a spectacle. The Bad: The Big Bossman should have never received a WWF Title shot after the utterly woeful year he'd had in the ring. Needless to say, The Big Show wasn't the man to carry him here. At least it was short? The European Title triple threat between Val Venis, D-Lo Brown and a clearly struggling British Bulldog was, to put it mildly, a complete clusterf***. It would have been a whole lot better without Davey Boy's involvement. Kurt Angle versus Steve Blackman was slightly more exciting than doing your taxes but not nearly as exciting as watching paint dry. The Rest: This is the show where The Kat (Jerry Lawler's wife at the time) took her bra off and exposed her bare breasts to the entire world. WWE would go 'one better' the next month by having Mae Young ape her and unleash her prehistoric (thankfully prosthetic) slobber knockers to the world at the Royal Rumble. No, the Attitude Era wasn't all Stone Cold Steve Austin and TLC matches!
1. 2007
The Good: A wrestling fan's wrestling show, Armageddon 2007 featured several top notch matches and a minimum of nonsense. There were two contenders for best match of the night, one of which was Triple H and Jeff Hardy's No.1 contenders match. Jeff was really starting to get over at this point, but some still doubted as to whether WWE would pull the trigger and let him score a clean win over The Game. But he did, cradling Trips after fifteen minutes of solid action. A more surprising contender for best bout came in the shape of Mr. Kennedy (....Kennedy) versus Shawn Michaels. A psychologically-tight encounter, this proved that Kennedy could hang with the very best in the world. HBK's selling was typically on-point and he really did what he could to put Kennedy over (before he inevitably beat him with the Sweet Chin Music). The Batista/Edge/Undertaker main event perhaps could and should have been a little better, given the talent involved, but it was a fine show-closer nonetheless. Randy Orton's WWE Title defence against recent returnee Chris Jericho was fine, but the finish (JBL interfering after Jericho had crashed into him on the announce table) kind of sucked. And Rey Mysterio and MVP kicked the event off well enough with a solid opener. The Bad: CM Punk was made to look like such a jobber in his and Kane's tag team match with the gruesome twosome of Big Daddy V and Mark Henry. It took WWE ages to really see what they had in Punk. Great Khali versus Finlay wasn't Finlay's best match and, while the action was alright, nobody in the crowd really cared about Beth Phoenix Women's Title match with Mickie James. The Rest: Jesse and Festus beat Miz and Morrison on the pre-show. They probably forgot to shake JBL's hand or something.