WWE Backlash 2017: Every Match Ranked From Worst To Best
Living down to expectations.
This year's Backlash was hardly a much-anticipated spectacle to most fans, and though there wasn't a single outright dud on the card, it was still a thoroughly mediocre and forgettable night for the most part.
There was only one must-see match, a ton of glorified TV bouts and couple of fights that just barely rose to "good" or "decent" status. The real embarrassment here, of course, is that NXT once again showed WWE how it's done, with their TakeOver: Chicago event decisively "winning" the weekend, all while the core product mostly floundered in mediocrity.
The main event at least has people talking, and it'll be interesting to see how WWE follows through with it moving forward, though expecting anything more than a bungled title run for Jinder Mahal is probably wishful thinking.
8. WWE Title: Randy Orton (c) Vs. Jinder Mahal
Result: Mahal kills Orton with the Cobra Clutch Slam to win the title (15:45).
Rating: A lot of fans were justifiably nervous about what shenanigans WWE might pull here, especially given the cynical reasons Mahal is even in the main event picture.
You just have to try and accept the match on its own terms, and hey, maybe Jinder might surprise us all, right? But he didn't. This was an incredibly bland "main event" for the most part, overloaded with rest holds and basically uninspired ring work from both men.
The only memorable moment was Orton's absolutely hellacious table suplex botch on one of the Singh brothers, and the hilarious face he pulled after. Mahal winning is naturally divisive but it just doesn't feel earned either by Mahal's performance tonight or his character work so far. There's room to do something with him, sure, but he really needs to prove himself ASAP.
Either way, the best thing about this match was the pained crowd reactions after Mahal won. Otherwise, a total non-event of a title match. 5/10
7. Luke Harper Vs. Erick Rowan
Result: Harper lands a Discus Clothesline for the victory (9:00).
Rating: How hilarious is it that Erick Rowan is in the penultimate match on a PPV? Few fans were jazzed about this match going in, but it was basically a fine, passable cool-down match ahead of the main event.
Harper did rock solid work as usual, and Rowan gets a lot of flack but he put in a decent performance here too. The match didn't belong on a PPV, but such is the price we pay for brand-specific shows.
The ending was laughably mild, though: Harper's Discus Clothesline totally lacked impact and just looked like a "normal" clothesline. 5/10
6. Smackdown Tag Titles: The Usos (c) Vs. Breezango
Result: Jey Uso lays out Fandango with a superkick to retain the titles (9:15).
Rating: It would've been foolish to expect a genuinely serious, competitive match here, but the comedy stuff played out surprisingly well, particularly the mop and "grandma". The commentary also added a lot to the fun factor, and say what you want about JBL, but he did some great work calling the mayhem ("Last time that happened to me, I paid for it!")
In terms of actual wrestling, it was totally forgettable, sure, but it had the good sense to wrap itself up just when it was about to outstay its welcome. It was more fun than an actual, decent match, but it did what it set out to, and sometimes that's enough 5/10
5. Tye Dillinger Vs. Aiden English
Result: Dillinger smashes English with the Tye Breaker for the win (8:20).
Rating: This was a quintessential kickoff show match as expected, but the crowd being so into Dillinger helped it have a little more energy. English's chinlock went on way, way too long considering the length of the match, but overall this was acceptable for what it was and absolutely didn't drag on too long.
Hopefully WWE will do more with Dillinger in the long run rather than relegate him to permanent warmup act status, considering he's a strong worker and ridiculously over with fans. Also, English got to have actual offense, which was nice. 5/10
4. The Welcoming Committee Vs. Becky Lynch, Charlotte Flair & Naomi
Result: Becky taps out to Natalya's Sharpshooter (10:05).
Rating: It's a pretty baffling proposition to have the Women's champ wrestle on a PPV and not even have her defend her title, but it still makes more sense than Charlotte being a face, at least.
This was uninspired but fine, basically. Everyone had a moment to do their thing, it hit the usual TV match beats and didn't do anything wrong, so it ended up a decent if forgettable sprint.
The underwhelming finish was a shame, as the crowd didn't seem to believe that Natalya would actually make Becky tap going by their totally flat response to it (that or they just didn't care), and seeing Becky eat another loss was predictable but disappointing all the same. 5/10
3. Dolph Ziggler Vs. Shinsuke Nakamura
Result: Nakamura kills Ziggler with the Kinshasa (15:50).
Rating: This was a Hell of a way to kick the main show off...on paper. Sadly it started pretty slow and struggled to find a solid rhythm throughout, as their styles didn't mesh all that well and the crowd were surprisingly dead with just a few brief exceptions.
The first half in particular had a glacial pace, and though it picked up a little more after that, it was still ultimately an uninspired and underwhelming main roster debut for Nakamura, if an acceptable match by any usual metric.
It's surprising how much offense Ziggler actually got in, and this probably should've been more of a squash considering the gulf of talent between the two. To that end, it also should've been about 5 minutes shorter. 6/10
2. Sami Zayn Vs. Baron Corbin
Result: Zayn lands the Helluva Kick for the win (14:35).
Rating: This was a totally solid match, which was pretty much enough to put it ahead of the rest of the show, even if it was ultimately just above-average TV fare. It worked from the standard hoss vs. underdog formula and was fun to that end.
It seemed pretty clear that Corbin would win, so Sami emerging victorious was a welcome surprise, and it paid off without making Corbin look weak or stupid. Zayn's great in the courageous scrapper role, and the crowd loved it, even if the match probably ran slightly too long for what it was.
Still, considering WWE's habit of contrarian booking just for the sake of it, this is one shock win that actually worked well. 6/10
1. United States Title: Kevin Owens (c) Vs. AJ Styles
Result: Owens traps AJ's leg inside the monitor compartment of the announcer's table for the countout win (21:10).
Rating: This started slow but picked up soon enough, though there were definitely too many rest holds throughout. It wasn't the classic these two are capable of, but compared to most of the show's other matches, how could they not steal the night away?
It went long and pretty much got better as it went along, getting increasingly more desperate and physical. Plus, either man could've won so it actually felt like something was at stake. AJ's knee selling was fantastic here, especially with the "botch" when he went for the Phenomenal Forearm, and Owens' top-rope superplex looked spectacularly brutal.
Yes, the ending was weird and goofy, but it made sense for Owens' character and was at least an inventive way to end a match via judgement call. 7/10
What did you think of Backlash? Shout it out in the comments!