WWE Battleground 2017: Best Booking Scenarios For Each Match

Is it too late to deconstruct the Punjabi Prison?

By Jackson Osterhout /

The only way WWE could possibly have a PPV worse than Money in the Bank this year is if they decided to put a Punjabi Prison and a Flag Match on the same night. Evidently the company read that statement and thought to themselves: "Challenge Accepted!"

Advertisement

There was once a time when SmackDown Live was handily besting its Raw counterpart in PPVs. That time is no longer, with WWE Great Balls of Fire (ugh, that name is still terrible) effectively becoming one of the best shows of the year.

Still, just because a card has low potential doesn't mean it can't turn out great with the proper booking. Then again, "WWE" and "proper booking" don't often go hand in hand.

The build-up for Battleground has not been kind to viewers. Sure, The New Day and The Usos can both cut world class promos in their sleep, but the incredibly one-sided Mahal vs. Orton just refuses to die. Cena and Rusev are having a grudge match over a single promo, only two years removed from the latter's utter burial. And we still haven't figured out the man formerly known as Mike Bennett.

It might not be the most desirable line-up in history, but even WWE could salvage this with the correct booking. What's the ideal result for each match?

8. Dillinger Vanquishes English

A quick glance at WWE's YouTube page reveals that Tye Dillinger has already defeated Aiden English three times on live TV. Twice on SmackDown, and once on the WWE Backlash pre-show.

Advertisement

Does this technically count as a feud?

Perfect 10 is incredibly over with the fans, so it's nice to see he has a spot on the card at all. But is squashing perennial jobber Aiden English for the fourth consecutive match really the only thing WWE has for Dillinger?

Yes, that is the best case scenario here. Dillinger's true peak is in the upper midcard, while English is pretty much doomed to be "that one guy who used to team with a circus strongman" for the rest of his career. If it looks as though Tye is having too much trouble putting down a former member of the Vaudevillains, he can pretty much kiss his future goodbye.

If there was ever a match that shouldn't go longer than five minutes, here it is.

After this, both should permanently go their separate ways. Dillinger can remain on the fringes of the United States Championship scene, participating in side feuds until a spot opens up for him. English can job for more than one person. Because every brand needs their jobbers. An obnoxious singer just makes a better one than most.

7. Kanellis Cheats His Way Past Zayn

Wow, SmackDown Live is really missing Miz and Maryse, aren't they?

Advertisement

The Kanellises have largely been dead on arrival, and only picked up recently by smashing a glass across the back of the head of Sami Zayn.

Speaking of Zayn, one year ago, the Underdog of the Underground (enough of the terrible nicknames, WWE) defeated long time enemy Kevin Owens in a horrible case of short-sighted booking. Owens would go on to become WWE Universal Champion, while Zayn became the most annoying person currently on WWE television (and jobbed to Owens approximately 48 times in the process).

Such a booking result absolutely cannot be repeated here.

Yes, Kanellis just defeated Zayn on SmackDown Live, and we all know how much the company loves their 50/50 feuds. But if they're truly trying to recreate Miz's magic, then they need to remember one crucial part:

Miz and Maryse won. A lot.

Sure, they almost always cheated to get there, but that was a part of what made Miz so ridiculously successful in 2016. The most hated villains are the ones that constantly achieve victory through any means necessary. Mike and Maria are charismatic and obnoxious enough to quickly rise up the card in the company.

Losing to someone that is well known for always losing is not going to do the Kanellises any favors.

6. The New Day Takes The Gold

... or silver, technically. This feud has been a rare bright spot in the mostly dismal build-up to Battleground.

Advertisement

SmackDown Live doesn't have the best tag team division at the moment, largely due to WWE's decision to let both brands have their own separate championships. So the best thing for everyone involved is for The New Day to win the championships.

Why? Because this is one rivalry that definitely deserves to be prolonged. The Usos have already held on to their titles once before against The New Day, losing via count-out at Money in the Bank. If Jimmy and Jey get a clean win here, there's not as much of a reason to keep this feud going.

The Usos have shown that they are their best as delusional, cocky heels. Taking away the thing that they hold most dear may take the twins out of their comfort zone, but imagine how frighteningly unhinged it could make them become. Not only would it make for incredibly compelling television, but the championships being the lynch pin behind all of this would seriously elevate the belts.

Some may argue that Woods, Kingston, and E winning the straps would delay their inevitable break-up. Which is definitely a good thing. WWE has gone particularly overboard with splitting up tag teams lately.

5. Cena Beats Rusev?

What's the best booking for this match? Cancel it, and give John Cena and Rusev new opponents.

Advertisement

Seriously, there is no good outcome here. Cena just returned, and looks to keep his promise to beat everyone before his inevitable and looming retirement. Rusev, meanwhile, made a bunch of empty threats regarding a WWE Championship match at Money in the Bank, and has only recently returned to live television. This, of course, is after his burial at the hands of Roman Reigns, a bizarre feud with Enzo and Cass, and a pairing with then-jobber Jinder Mahal.

Both men desperately need a win here.

Also, it's a Flag Match. Has anyone ever looked good in a Flag Match? Why didn't this just take place on America's Independence Day, when it was much easier to forget about?

Best case scenario is that Rusev doesn't get completely buried when he loses to Cena. Nobody loses this type of match in their home country, because apparently nobody has informed WWE that it's no longer cool to hate someone just for being foreign.

Hopefully, after the inevitable Cena win, Rusev can do something to get his heat back. Maybe he could hit The Champ with the Bulgarian flag. Anything to make sure someone comes out of this match not looking terrible.

4. Corbin Topples Nakamura

Miz. Daniel Bryan. Alberto Del Rio. Dolph Ziggler. Damien Sandow. Sheamus.

Advertisement

Since Money in the Bank moved onto its own show and off of WrestleMania, those are the names of the men that lost their next PPV match. In fact, Seth Rollins is the only person to be successful in his follow-up bout (albeit by forfeit), with Kane, John Cena, Randy Orton, and Dean Ambrose all cashing in their briefcase before they got the opportunity.

It's time to buck the trend.

The difference between Baron Corbin and past Money in the Bank recipients (except Damien Sandow) is that all other winners were seen as having clear main event potential in the eyes of the fans. Corbin just isn't at that level yet. He needs to be built up as a credible threat before eventually taking the WWE Championship, lest we have another Jinder Mahal situation.

The Nakamura Experiment may have bombed since Shinsuke first debuted, but he remains a popular staple of SmackDown Live. His bulletproof aura has already worn off, so it wouldn't be too big of a loss if he looked at the lights for Corbin.

Jobbing out the Money in the Bank winner does make some sense, in that it gives legitimacy to their opponent. Considering Corbin is having trouble being taken seriously as it is, he can't really afford that.

3. Owens Regains His Title

Kevin Owens' "Face of America" shtick is excellent, despite the fact that he's lost the WWE United States Championship twice, and only held the belt for 94 days total.

Advertisement

AJ Styles capturing the gold at Madison Square Garden was a great moment, but it's hard not to be cynical of the true reasons here. Styles needed a final highlight for his DVD, and Kenny Omega had just become the inaugural IWGP United States Heavyweight Champion only five days prior.

WWE's secondary titles are in constant danger of being used as props. That's definitely a higher risk with Styles than it is with Owens.

The feud between the two has been great thus far, but there will always be the nagging worry that both deserve better things. Kevin Owens is a smart choice to bring prestige back to both the championship and himself following a lackluster main event run in 2016. Styles, on the other hand, needs to return to the main event where he belongs.

Besides, other legitimate midcard heels that could compete for the title aren't in high supply at the moment. The face side, on the other hand, has Tye Dillinger, Chad Gable, and Sami Zayn.

With Randy Orton a bore and John Cena leaving at the drop of a hat, SmackDown Live needs a new top face to take a crack at the WWE Championship. As he proved in 2016, AJ Styles is the perfect man for the job.

2. Tamina Conquers The Elimination Match

Yes, Tamina Snuka is an odd choice to be involved in a big match at WWE SummerSlam. But hear me out.

Advertisement

First of all, SmackDown Live's women's division has a heel problem. The biggest names (Charlotte Flair, Becky Lynch, and Naomi) are all faces, while the heels come off as second rate as comparison. Something has to change.

Enter Tamina. She has the potential to be SDL's equivalent of Nia Jax, an unstoppable destroyer. She has shown that she's more than capable in the ring, but hasn't really been given much of a chance in her seven years with the company. Any promo issues could be solved by her new, bizarre alliance with Lana, who's so good on the microphone she could probably make Roman Reigns popular.

The feud between Naomi and Tamina has real potential. Lana and Naomi already have a feud going, so it's easy to build off of that. Additionally, Naomi and Tamina are both former faction partners and family members (albeit through Naomi's marriage to Jimmy Uso).

Given that it's an elimination match, multiple women can look strong here. Lana can be taken out almost immediately, while either Lynch or Flair can remove Natalya. From there, Lana returns to help Snuka eliminate both Charlotte and Becky.

It's time to give Tamina a shot.

1. Mahal Finally Puts Down Orton

This match features neither The Great Khali nor The Big Show. So, it will probably be the best Punjabi Prison match in history. Which is pretty much the equivalent of being the valedictorian of a home school. Still, Orton has demonstrated that he can put on a decent-to-good match when he tries.

Advertisement

This feud needs to end as quickly as possible. It would take the award for "Worst Rivalry Of The Year" if Dean Ambrose and The Miz hadn't been competing since Barack Obama was in the White House.

If there is one upside to Jinder Mahal, it's that he actually gets a reaction, so he's the easy pick for the win here. This also means that hanging onto the title for a bit longer can actually build up a new top heel on the brand.

Picture this: either AJ Styles or John Cena finally ends Mahal's reign at SummerSlam. The sigh of relief and excitement for the return of a legitimate world champion is felt throughout the entire arena. For a moment, that wrestler will instantly become the biggest face in the world. Then... BOOM, Baron Corbin cashes in, robbing the title.

If you want to build a mega-heel out of the Lone Wolf, that's definitely one way to do it. This type of reaction just wouldn't be possible if the championship was taken from Randal Keith Orton.

Advertisement