WWE ECW December To Dismember – Where Are They Now?

Reflecting back on the worst PPV in WWE history.

By Andrew Pollard /

When thinking about the worst PPVs in WWE history, one that instantly brings a shudder to your spine is the 2006 December to Dismember event that ran under WWE's relaunched ECW banner.

Advertisement

Previously, December to Dismember was a 1995 event put on by the original ECW, and WWE decided to revisit that name to serve up a timely festive pay-per-view for the second coming of ECW. But much like said coming coming of ECW, the second coming of December to Dismember was an absolute disaster and is actually the lowest-selling WWE PPV of the pre-WWE Network era.

On the card that December 3, 2006 night we had:

- The Hardy Boyz defeating MNM

- Balls Mahoney defeating Matt Striker

- Elijah Burke & Sylvester Terkay defeating The F.B.I.

- Daivari defeating Tommy Dreamer

- Ariel & Kevin Thorn defeating Kelly Kelly & Mike Knox

- Bobby Lashley becoming ECW World Champion after winning an Elimination Chamber contest featuring Big Show, Rob Van Dam, CM Punk, Test and Hardcore Holly

Reflecting back on this most awful of PPVs, then, let's take a look at what the stars of the 2006 December to Dismember are up to here in 2020.

26. Joey Mercury

By the time of December to Dismember, MNM had recently reunited after breaking up earlier in the year. That reunion didn't last long, with Joey Mercury released by WWE in March 2007.

Advertisement

Mercury would return to WWE in 2010 as a producer and briefly a member of CM Punk's Straight Edge Society, before a more regular on-screen role followed several years later as part of the Authority.

2017 saw Mercury released by WWE once more, and he was last seen working as a trainer, producer and writer for Ring of Honor - until a dispute there saw Mercury depart ROH towards the end of last year.

25. Johnny Nitro

Johnny Nitro would soon become John Morrison in early 2007, and the years since then have seen the former MNM member take on the mantles of Johnny Mundo, Johnny Impact, and even wrestle under his real name of John Hennigan at times.

Advertisement

Having left WWE in 2011, Morrison made his return to the company earlier this year. And annoyingly, he looks even better now than he did 14 years ago.

24. Melina

At December to Dismember, Melina was in her usual position alongside the MNM tag team. She would remain with WWE until 2011, becoming a three-time Women's Champion and two-time Divas Champion during that time.

Advertisement

Still active, Melina became a key part of NWA Powerrr as 2019 rolled into 2020. Her most recent match was for New York Wrestling Connection this past February, and rumours of a WWE return have rumbled on throughout this year following her one-off appearance on July 2019's Raw Reunion special.

23. Matt Hardy

Much like MNM, the Hardy Boyz were also in the midst of their first proper reunion by the time of 2006's December to Dismember PPV.

Advertisement

Subsequent singles runs and reunions would follow over the ensuing years, with Matt nowadays in All Elite Wrestling - where he is seemingly in the middle of a heel turn.

22. Jeff Hardy

Having battled Johnny Nitro over the title in the months prior, Jeff Hardy went into December to Dismember as the reigning Intercontinental Champion.

Advertisement

Like his brother, Jeff would have several WWE departures and returns over the years, and the Charismatic Enigma was moved to the Raw brand earlier this year - after Matt and Jeff made an explosive WWE return in 2017 at WrestleMania 33.

21. Matt Striker

Matt Striker's WWE in-ring career was a brief one, but December to Dismember was one PPV where he got to wrestle - that night losing to ECW favourite Balls Mahoney in a Striker's Rules Match which called for no eye gouging, no hair pulling, and no foul language.

Advertisement

Striker would eventually take up a place at the commentary booth in 2008, and that is something he's continued to do since leaving WWE in 2011.

Having commentated for Lucha Underground and New Japan Pro Wrestling - in addition to wrestling independent dates - Striker has branched into sports broadcasting, is a go-to fantasy sports analyst, and wrote and appeared in the Labor of Love dating game earlier this year.

20. Balls Mahoney

At December to Dismember, Balls Mahoney nailed a Spinebuster to get the win over Matt Striker. Balls would remain with WWE until 2008, before then hitting the independent scene up until his death.

Advertisement

Jonathan 'Balls Mahoney' Rechner passed away from a heart attack on April 12, 2016. He had turned 44 years of age the day prior.

19. Little Guido

The Full Blooded Italians found themselves on the losing side of things at December to Dismember.

Advertisement

For Little Guido, he'd remain with WWE until 2008 and has spent the years since then still active on the independent scene. Clearly enjoying life, his social media shows that Nunzio had a recent catch-up with 'Wildfire' Tommy Rich.

18. Tony Mamaluke

December to Dismember was the last big show for Tony Mamaluke under the WWE umbrella, with the F.B.I. member released by WWE in January 2007.

Advertisement

Details on what Mamaluke has been up to since a brief stint in TNA in 2010 are extremely scarce, although it looks as if the wrestler formally hung up the boots for good in 2018.

17. Trinity

Trinity was only in WWE for a cup of coffee - initially as a valet for the Full Blooded Italians - and she'd actually retire from the wrestling business upon being released by the company in June 2007.

Advertisement

In the years since then, Stephanie Finochio has carved a career for herself as a stunt performer in TV and movie projects.

Advertisement