WWE Extreme Rules: 5 Greatest Ever Matches

By Joshua Foster /

It is that time of year again. Wrestlemania season is over and it's time for the WWE to get extreme. Many fans look forward to this event each year as we are currently still stuck in the PG era meaning we don't normally get this type of excitement often enough. Ladder matches, Tables matches, Cage matches are all in play and all on the same pay per view. Extreme Rules is an event that raises the bar for a superstar's reputation. This yearly pay per view has the potential to take a wrestler who may be thought of as soft and toughen him up by giving him the chance to show he can hang in the land of hardcore. Now being a long time fan I am well aware that the origin of Extreme Rules came from the idea of the ECW One Night Stand pay per views. The ECW One Night Stand pay per view was then later rebranded as just One Night Stand. With that all being said this article will only cover matches under the WWE branded Extreme Rules event. Some of my favorite matches of all time happened on the two ECW One Night Stand but pay per views but that is subject matter for a different article at some point. Now that we have cleared that up let's take a look at the 5 greatest matches from WWE Extreme Rules...

5. Daniel Bryan Vs. Sheamus - 2 Out Of 3 Falls Match

On the road to Wrestlemania 27 Sheamus and Daniel Bryan were involved in a feud over the United States championship. Fans were excited to get to see these two fresh superstars face off against each other on the grandest stage of them all. Then their U.S. title match was moved to the preshow and somehow ended up becoming a huge battle royal including many other superstars that had nothing to do with their feud. Does that sound horrible to you? Don't worry it was but another reason not to worry is because barely anyone saw it. WWE creative was given a shot at redemption for their bad booking of these two superstars in the form of a Wrestlemania match a year later which saw Daniel Bryan defending his World Heavyweight Championship against Sheamus. This match had the fans pretty damn excited as both wrestlers had picked up alot of steam over the past year so it was easy to pick this match as an instant classic. Then we all came face to face with another epic failure on behalf of WWE creative which saw Daniel Bryan lose his World Heavyweight Championship to Sheamus in a mere 18 seconds. This terrible decision by WWE left a bad taste in the mouths of many causing many fans to turn on Sheamus who was supposed to be the face and cheer Daniel Bryan who was supposed to be the heel. Daniel Bryan caught fire with his "YES!" chants becoming the most infamous thing in WWE at the time. It was because of this WWE had to take notice and decided that at Extreme Rules they would finally give Daniel Bryan the chance to show the world what he can do and he took the ball and ran with it. Daniel Bryan can get a good match out of anyone and Sheamus has a reputation of giving it his all everytime he steps in the ring. Most people would assume they could put on a good match together but no one could have expected it to be this good. The two completely different styles of both men meshed very well in this match as it showcased technical wrestling, brawling, and grappling. The 2 out of 3 falls stipulation proved to be a great choice for these two superstars as it gave them an adequate amount of time to show off their skills. Sheamus has a very hard hitting style but Daniel Bryan seemed to have a counter for everything. Daniel Bryan made Sheamus use every move in his arsenal in order to retain his World Heavyweight Championship and in the end Sheamus managed to gain some respect back from the fans by putting on a great match. This is the match that these two should have had at Wrestlemania as it would have no doubt provided both men with a much needed "Wrestlemania moment". Sheamus went on to have a mediocre World Heavyweight Championship run (to no fault of his own, creative just never managed to get him in an interesting feud) and Daniel Bryan spent the summer embroiled in one of the most memorable feuds of the last few years fighting CM Punk for the WWE championship. This match was the match that showed both of these superstars can hang in the main event and will be two guys the company can count on for years to come.

4. CM Punk Vs. Chris Jericho - Chicago Street Fight

Wrestlemania 28 was a defining moment for both of these superstars. Punk was trying to claim his spot amongst a long list of legends by carrying the WWE championship into the big event and Chris Jericho was trying to do everything within his power to make CM Punk look like the best in the world. At Wrestlemania 28 these two put on a great match but it was somewhat lost in the shuffle between a few other main events and the added stipulation that if CM Punk got disqualifed he would lose his title did nothing but hurt the match itself. Punk and Jericho put on a great match at Wrestlemania 28 but it wasn't quite the match we wanted from them. Their feud had been very bitter and built on alot of hatred from Jericho towards Punk and deserved something a lot more brutal. Fast forward to their Extreme Rules rematch and it was time to see that brutality. Punk and Jericho pulled out all the stops here giving us the match that made the most sense given the nature of their feud. Jericho hated Punk because he thought he was a copycat and Punk hated Jericho bcause he was making his life a living hell. Weapons of all sorts were integrated into this match and it was exactly what this feud needed. Seeing these two beat each other senseless was very convincing as each played their part well. The top rope elbow drop from Punk to Jericho to the outside through the announce table sums it up perfectly. There is nothing these two wouldn't do to hurt each other no matter how much of their own health that had to sacrifice. CM Punk went on to have a historic WWE Championship reign and Jericho went on to work with other young stars in an attempt to build them up. This match will be remembered for years to come thanks to Jericho unselfishly giving his all to make Punk look like a fighting champion and for Punk seizing the opportunity to do so with a true legend.

3. John Cena Vs. Brock Lesnar - Extreme Rules Match

John Cena is very stale nowadays. There is nothing he hasn't done and no one he hasn't beaten. Cena definitely has a great match when paired with the right superstar from time to time but lack of character progression has forced much of the WWE fanbase to turn on him. When Cena lost to The Rock at Wrestlemania 28 it was a breath of fresh air for the fans. For a long time Cena looked unbeatable so to see someone finally score a legit pinfall over him was a rare and welcoming experience. The night after Wrestlemania 28 Brock Lesnar shocked the world by doing something no one ever thought he would do and returning to the WWE. A shockwave was sent all over the WWE fanbase (I refuse to say WWE universe) when Lesnar's music hit and he returned sending Cena straight to hell with an F5. This completely changed the landscape of WWE at the time. The weeks leading up to Cena Vs Lesnar at Extreme Rules really got people talking. During a brawl between Cena and Lesnar on an episode of Raw Cena got busted open the hard way and we saw blood make a rare appearance on Raw. People started to wonder "Is this real?" which is a question that pretty much never gets asked in the world of WWE. Lesnar's UFC reputation carried over to WWE with him making him even scarier than he was during his first run with the company. No doubt kids who were new to the product that may not have seen his first run feared Brock Lesnar and it was unlike anything we had seen in a very long time. When Extreme Rules finally came around and the match got under way Lesnar wasted no time living up to his reputation as a destroyer. After years of looking invincible John Cena was made to look vulnerable as soon as the match started. The punches that were thrown in this match were thrown perfectly and made it look more like a legit MMA fight rather than your typical WWE match. Where John Cena seemed liked an even match for The Rock he seemed like absolutely no match for Lesnar. Brock for most of the match absolutely destroyed Cena and Cena sold it perfectly. This was a dream match that completely lived up to all expectations. This match was extremely unorthodox and the image of Lesnar throwing his body over the top ropes and using it as a weapon with complete disregard for his own well being is burned in my memory. Like I said earlier when paired with the right guy Cena can have a great match and this was one of his best. In yet another baffling decision by WWE creative they booked John Cena to comeback out of nowhere and win the match. This finish made little sense and just furthered the animosity from the fans towards Super Cena. Brock Lesnar was booked to look like a monster but he should have been booked to win on this night. Regardless of the winner this match gave us all something special that we won't soon forget.

2. Edge Vs. Jeff Hardy - Ladder Match

The career of Jeff Hardy throughout the years has been rocky at best. Through numerous wellness policy violations it had been made very public that quite often Jeff just couldn't get it together. The ability of Jeff Hardy is something that had never gone unnoticed by the WWE fans and everyone held their breath waiting for him to finally make his way to the main event. Hardy was over at this time period and almost as over if not arguably more so than Cena. After scoring his first WWE championship win back in December of 2008 Hardy proved to the world that he could hang in the main event and look legit doing it. Fast forward to Extreme rules 2009 where Hardy was paired with Edge in a ladder match for the World Heavyweight Championship. Edge and Jeff Hardy have both been intertwined in the careers of one another ever since the beginning. The Hardy Boyz and Edge and Christian are arguably what made the ladder match famous in 1999. When we arrived in 2009 and saw that we would be getting a one on one match involving both Edge and Hardy for a major championship we just knew that something special was about to happen. Neither Edge or Jeff Hardy had any problems putting their bodies on the line when it came to giving the fans a show and this night was no exception. In a match where you would think you've seen all there is to see from these two superstars they kept pulling off spots that wowed everyone in attendance and everyone watching at home. These two fearless men managed to pull off stunts that would have killed any normal man many times over and somehow kept going. It's one thing to fall off of a ladder but it's a whole other thing to fall through a ladder. Jeff Hardy managed to pull out the win in this one by trapping Edge within the ladder and climbing to the top clamining the World Heavyweight Championship as his own. While a bruised and battered Jeff Hardy was celebrating with his newly won title CM Punk thickened the plot by cashing in his money in the bank briefcase. In a heartbreaking twist of fate Jeff Hardy lost his World Heavyweight Championship to CM Punk. This event set these two on a collision course all summer which gave Jeff Hardy arguably his best feud to date. This match is a classic because it tells a story on so many different levels and without a doubt is not just one of the best ladder matches in Extreme Rules history it is one of the best matches in WWE history.

1. Alberto Del Rio Vs. Christian - Ladder Match

Now this one is a bit of a sentimental favorite for me and it may be causing quite a few of you to go "Huh?" so hang in there. The number one thing lacking in the PG era of modern WWE is storytelling. Storytelling has always been the heart of professional wrestling and this is something that seems to be missing nowadays. This match could not have unfolded in a more perfect way. We were all heartbroken to see Edge retire. The man had given us as fans so much and we hoped upon hope that he still had so much more to give but at the end of the day his body just couldn't do it anymore. When Edge vacated the title it left an open spot in the World Heavyweight Championship match at Extreme Rules. Enter Christian the once "brother" of Edge who was now billed as his "best friend" (yea we noticed you guys tried to pull that one on us) who found himself in the right spot at the right time. Christian had always had what it took to be a big player in WWE and in 2005 was arguably the best heel in the company. If you don't believe me go back and watch his Wrestlemania 20 match with Chris Jericho. It's some great heel work right there. After getting frustrated with lack of attention from WWE creative Christian made the jump to TNA and became the biggest fish in a much smaller pond. Christian's run as "The Instant Classic Christian Cage" in TNA is some of the best work of his career and he finally proved that he could carry a brand on his shoulders. A few years passed and with main event experience under his belt Christian decided to make his way back to WWE for another shot. We all assumed he would be immediately paired with Edge. With Edge being a bonafide superstar now and Christian showing that he has everything it takes to do the same thing it made perfect sense. I'm not sure if they thought it was a good idea or if they were trying to punish Christian but they brought him back and stuck him on the C show in the form of their ECW brand and it was months before Edge and Christian ever came face to face. Regardless Christian sucked it up became ECW champion and made an otherwise lackluster show worth watching. He slowly worked his way up the WWE ladder once again and seemed like a sure pick for money in the bank but was passed over year after year. In the months leading up to Wrestlemania 27 the WWE slowly seemed to be building toward a Edge Vs. Christian feud which is something we had all been dying for. Unfortunately it never happened but something great still happened even though it wasn't what we all hoped for. Finally at Extreme Rules Christian was getting his chance to show the world that he belonged in the main event. You could tell just by looking at his face as he made his entrance that it was his time and he was going to seize this opportunity. Alberto Del Rio had been shoved down our throats for months and no one was really buying it. Although at first he seemed pretty reluctant to take bumps this match gave Del Rio some much needed credibility. Del Rio was "soft" so to speak and seemed unwilling to pull out all the stops, so to see him go extreme helped up his stock with the WWE fanbase. Admittedly the bumps in this match aren't on the same level as the Jeff Hardy Vs. Edge match but this bout had people on the edge of their seats for an entirely different reason. Everyone watching hung on every move wondering "will he do it? will Christian finally win the big one?" which made for one of the most interesting ladder matches ever. It's rare to see someone win their first world title nowadays without the assistance of money in the bank and even more rare to see a much deserved WWE veteran get something they worked so hard for. When Christian finally climbed to the top of the ladder and unhooked the World Heavyweight Championship the crowd went wild. This was the feel good moment that had not been seen in WWE in a very long time. This is something that was much needed in WWE after a very lackluster Wrestlemania 27 it gave us fans something to be thankful for. We finally got to see someone we wanted to win the World Heavyweight Championship win it. It wasn't the guy WWE told us to like it was the guy we had stuck with for well over a decade and always hoped would win the big one and he finally did and although Christian's World Heavyweight Championship run was cut short by another questionable decision on behalf of WWE creative, no one can ever take this moment away from us. This is my list! Let me know what you think and give some examples of matches you might have included in there!