WWE Extreme Rules - Ranked From Worst To Best
Does anything come close to the 2012 edition?
After all the excitement and hoopla that surrounds WrestleMania season, May can often seem a little bit mundane in comparison. World Wrestling Entertainment's attempt to spice up this lull comes in the shape of Extreme Rules, a night where WWE harks somewhat back to the long-lost years of gimmick matches and violence.
The first edition of the show came in 2009, and every year since WWE has indeed gone extreme. Stipulations are the name of the day, and in the seven editions of the event a total of 21 different stipulation matches have taken place, not including those standard matches of course. Variations of the cage have featured the most, with a total of six cage matches happening over the years.
The quality of WWE Extreme Rules has varied from 'Show Of The Year' to 'Oh Yeah, That Show Happened'. Following WrestleMania is either the hardest or easiest task, If the big show hits the right notes, whatever follows it is going to be tough. If Mania disappoints, Extreme Rules has the chance to be the perfect pick-me-up.
So if you're watching the show live this Sunday and are thinking of watching a past Extreme Rules to warm up, let me do the work for you in choosing which one. Here are the seven Extreme Rules events ranked from worst to best.
7. 2015 - A Kiss My What Match?!
Last year's edition of WWE Extreme Rules wasn't a bad show in truth. The card looked interesting enough, with a number of developments post-WrestleMania being moved to the next level. Dean Ambrose and Luke Harper opened the show with a brawl that took to the streets of Chicago, Ambrose eventually picking up the win some 56 minutes after the opening bell sounded.
The New Day clambered to the top of the tag team mountain for the first time, defeating the duo of Tyson Kidd and Cesaro (K-Swiss? Swisskers?) for the WWE Tag Team Championship, and Roman Reigns managed to drag a more than enjoyable match out of the Big Show of all people, a match contested under Last Man Standing rules.
Even so, the show failed to rise to anything above underwhelming. John Cena continued his destruction of Rusev by besting the previously unbeatable Bulgarian in a Russian Chain match, and Seth Rollins defended his newly won WWE World Heavyweight Championship in a steel cage against Randy Orton with 100% of the stipulations on his side.
The biggest crime of the night came in the shape of the Dolph Ziggler/Sheamus bout, a match that was billed as a 'Kiss Me A*se' match. What this mean, in theory, was that the loser was to kiss the bottom of the winner, a stipulation that most likely amused Vince McMahon and no one else. Ziggler won the match, yet a post-match attack by Sheamus left the Show-Off's lips in close proximity to the buttocks of the Celtic Warrior. That is a sentence I never wanted to type.
6. 2013 - The Shield Cometh
Emanating from St. Louis, Missouri, the 2013 edition of WWE Extreme Rules served one function and one function only. It was the night that The Shield showed that they were a force to be reckoned with outside of six-man tags, as all three members ended the night with a newly-won championship belt slung over their shoulder.
Dean Ambrose bested Kofi Kingston early in the night for the WWE United States Championship, a title he would hold for longer than anyone else in the WWE era of the title despite defending it less than Aston Villa defend their own goal, and Roman Reigns and Seth Rollins combined to end the 245-day reign of Team Hell No at the top of the tag team pile.
In the main event of the night Brock Lesnar defeated Triple H inside a steel cage in a match the audience were already bored of, John Cena and Ryback fought to a no contest in a Last Man Standing match (a booking cop out if ever there was one), and Alberto Del Rio defeated Jack Swagger in an 'I Quit' match that was the end of Swagger's mini mega push in 2013.
Much like the 2015 edition of the show, this isn't exactly a bad show. The problem with it is that it is just there. It was a show of little intrigue, little interest, little excitement.
5. 2010 - CM Punk Saves His Hair, Saves The Show
A cursory glance at the 2010 WWE Extreme Rules card doesn't make pretty reading; the show featured John Cena taking on Batista, Sheamus battling Triple H and Jack Swagger going one-on-one with Randy Orton. It is an immensely WWE card. It was also something of a WrestleMania re-run, with no less than four matches being re-matches from the big event.
Of those that weren't re-matches, JTG and Shad Gaspard collided in a hugely anticipated (by nobody) match between the former Cryme Tyme members, one of three strap matches to take place at Extreme Rules. Beth Phoenix defeated Michelle McCool in an 'Extreme Makeover' match, a bout where the weapons dotted around the ring were home appliances. The Hart Dynasty also earned a future tag title shot in the laziest way possible, by entering a gauntlet match last and winning it.
Despite all of this, two matches on this show really stood out. They were also WrestleMania re-matches, but pretty fantastic ones at that. Chris Jericho and Edge continued their beef, no longer over the World Heavyweight Championship, in side a steel cage, with Edge coming out on top to even their series up.
The match of the night (by some distance) saw CM Punk avenge his WrestleMania defeat to Rey Mysterio, in a match that would have seen him lose his hair if he was the man defeated. The two got almost 10 minutes more between the ropes here, and put on the match that many felt they were robbed off putting on at WrestleMania. It makes the show well-worth watching.
4. 2014 - Beware The Scary Children
I don't know how I feel about WWE Extreme Rules 2014. On one hand, it is a strangely fun show. Hornswoggle and El Torito put on a blinder of a pre-show in the first (and only) WeeLC match, a bout that took the inherent offensiveness of the joke and pretty much blew everyone away. Cesaro continued building on his WrestleMania momentum by defeating Jack Swagger and Rob Van Dam in a three-way elimination match.
The match of the night saw The Shield defeat a re-united Evolution in an absolute barnstormer of a six-man, with the battle moving from the ring to the crowd and everywhere in between. The finality of The Shield's victory took many by surprise, with the trio looking strong and practically becoming made men in the process. The main event saw Daniel Bryan knee Kane through a flaming table, defending his newly-won WWE World Heavyweight Championship in the process.
On the other hand, Bray Wyatt did beat John Cena in a cage match thanks to a child singing in the door way. I'm big on Wyatt, but this was the first in what would become a worryingly-consistent line in ridiculous horror movie match finishes. Wyatt went from Sister Abigailing Daniel Bryan into the barrier on the outside to relying on singing children and Dean Ambrose's inability to work out electronics.
3. 2009 - A Perfect Finish And The Perfect Finish
2009 was the very first edition of WWE Extreme Rules, and in many ways it was the prototypical Extreme Rules. It had a load of rubbish on the show, matches that were more gimmick that anything else. Some matches got little time, feeling rushed in the process. Batista defeated Randy Orton for the WWE Championship inside a steel cage in just 7 minutes, before forfeiting it the next night due to injury.
John Cena defeated Big Show for the 23753th time in their 'Best of 24001' Series, Santina Marella continued ahead with a joke that wasn't funny to begin with, humiliating the Guerrero family further in the process. CM Punk also defeated Umaga, but it was a strap match, which pretty much guarantees thumbs down in this day and age.
Still, there was a whole lot of excellence on the show. Chris Jericho defeated Rey Mysterio for his 9th Intercontinental Championship in the show opener, with a finish that was absolutely perfect in its creation and execution. Whilst going for the '619' Rey was stopped mid-spin by the hand of Jericho ripping off the luchador's mask. It was enough to distract Rey and allow Jericho to pick up the win. The timing and execution was perfect, to say the least.
The show also ended on an immensely memorable note. Jeff Hardy and Edge put on the ladder match you would expect from two ladder match aficionados, with the Extreme Enigma coming out on top. Before he could celebrate his newly-won World Heavyweight Championship however, CM Punk came out, kneed him twice in the face and took the belt home, via the magic of Money in the Bank.
2. 2011 - The Crowning Of Captain Charisma
WWE Extreme Rules 2011 is something of a forgotten classic show for the company. Coming hot on the heels of a fairly disappointing WrestleMania, (XXVII), Extreme Rules had a great chance to nail its colours to wall and put its hand up as a true return to form for World Wrestling Entertainment. It achieved this, and it managed to do so even with a seven-minute match containing three announcers.
Randy Orton and CM Punk opened the show in a Last Man Standing match, with Orton picking up the victory. The two had good chemistry and with the addition of the plunder put on a great little match to kick things off. Kofi Kingston bested Sheamus for the United States Championship after an epic Boom Drop through a table on the outside. Rey Mysterio and Cody Rhodes put on another fantastic match, with Rey picking up the win this time thanks in no small part to a little bit of mist.
The retirement of Edge just weeks earlier gave this show its most emotional moment though. With Edge vacating the World Heavyweight Championship it seemed that nothing would stop Alberto Del Rio from reaching his destiny. Del Rio didn't reckon on 'Captain Charisma' Christian however, and Edge's storyline brother would win his first World Championship in style, prevailing in a hyper-emotional ladder match between the two. Sure, Christian would lose the strap days later, but seeing him stand atop the ladder with the Big Gold Belt was a sight fans had clamoured for for years.
In the main event of the show, John Cena finally defeated The Miz for the WWE Championship in a triple threat cage match that also included John Morrison. Morrison was the star of the match, putting in a frankly incredible performance that should have seen him to greater heights in the company. He would be out of the company by the end of the year.
1. 2012 - The Beast Is Back
What else did you expect? Extreme Rules 2012 is not only the finest WWE Extreme Rules event to date, it is also one of the best shows the company has put on in recent memory. The event once again contained four WrestleMania re-matches, but with the possible exception of the Cody Rhodes/Big Show tables match these all exceeded the meeting at the Show of Shows.
CM Punk and Chris Jericho finally clicked in their Chicago Street Fight, putting on the classic that many assumed they would at WrestleMania. The extra element of added brawling certainly helped, with the addition of more violence really upping the emotional ante of what was an obviously emotional storyline.
After their 18-second debacle at WrestleMania XXVIII, Sheamus and Daniel Bryan put on what was up until that point the WWE Match of the Year, Sheamus besting Bryan two to one in their two-out-of-three falls match. This was the match that truly announced Bryan onto the WWE stage, with him regaining all of the credibility lost in his all-too-quick defeat at Mania. Sheamus looked like a beast in winning, and the physicality between the two was as impressive as it was jarring.
But, and we all know this, the 2012 edition of WWE Extreme Rules was about the return of one man, and what a man. Brock Lesnar returned to WWE after eight years, and it was John Cena who stood in his way. Sure, complaints still ring round about Cena winning, but Lesnar's presence alone was enough to add a whole new atmosphere to the product. Their fight (let's be clear, it wasn't a match was it), was the stiffest bout WWE had seen in years. For the first time in however long, violence in professional wrestling was compelling.
If you're thinking of which Extreme Rules show to watch before the big event on Sunday, think no longer. 2012 is the best option, by some distance.