WWE Payback takes place this weekend, with the key sell being a rematch of The Shield vs Evolution. That's proving a point of derision for some fans, who view the pay per view as a lazy and contrived effort. That assertion is backed up with the fact that we have yet another rematch as the co-main event, John Cena vs Bray Wyatt going into battle once again. The problem for WWE is that the Cena / Wyatt bout has passed it's sell by date, the feud started in January, it's now June and the initial enthusiasm has been drained. The main event of Evolution vs The Shield is also problematic, we already seen the Shield dispatch of Evolution at Extreme Rules, so there's really no need for another match. Despite these criticisms, current WhatCulture research illustrates that fans still have an interest in watching Payback: in a sample of 344 people, 37% of you told us that you'll be watching on the Network, with 26% more of you tuning in on pay per view. The reason fans are intrigued is perhaps down to the potential of the gimmicks. The Shield match will be 'no holds barred' elimination rules, with the Cena match being a 'last man standing' battle. To be fair to WWE, they couldn't have booked much better, with the untimely Daniel Bryan neck injury leaving them without a WWE title match. Although there are some low expectations, that can sometimes mean the show ends up a pleasantly surprising great night. Here we look at the results predictions for what we expect to go down at Payback.
8. Daniel Bryan's Title Decision
WWE are actually marketing Daniel Bryan's title decision as a reason to buy the show, so it's only right we make a prediction about what will happen. The tease is that Stephanie McMahon has blackmailed Bryan, laying the ultimatum down that Bryan must do the right thing and resign the WWE title. If he doesn't do this, Stephanie says she will fire Brie Bella, calling her recent behaviour a sackable offence. It's a pretty silly angle and an example of WWE really scratching the barrel to create interest in the show. Another point to make is that the whole angle kind of makes it all about Stephane and Brie. Is this really the best storyline WWE could come up with for Daniel Bryan as WWE Champion? The title and Bryan are both being weakened from all of this. The expected outcome this Sunday is that there'll be some sort of swerve, Bryan will find a way to keep Brie's job as well as his title. Despite the time out with his neck injury, it simply isn't imaginable that WWE could take the title off of Bryan at this early stage in his reign. He isn't going to be out of action much longer, so there's really no point in doing an angle to remove the belt. He will finish the night still as WWE Champion.
7. El Torito Vs Hornswoggle, Hair Vs Mask Match
The 'kickoff' match for Payback is El Torito vs Hornswoggle, with the little bull's mask being on the line against his opponent's hair. It's as daft as it gets and won't be everyone's cup of tea, but if you enjoy it for what it's worth, you might find it a bit of a laugh. The WeeLC match as the Extreme Rules 'kickoff' was similar in nature, and that ended be up being a guilty pleasure for some viewers. Maybe the midgets can do it again, or just as likely it will be horrible, it really depends on your WWE outlook. It's at least interesting in that there's actually something of importance on the line, Torito's mask or Hornswoggle's hair. At least the result matters, unlike some other matches on the main card! It seems a safe bet to suggest that Hornswoggle will lose and get his head shaved. It would kill Torito's gimmick if he lost his mask, so that's got to be an unthinkable move from WWE's point of view. The little bull scores the pin in a short and sweet contest. Winner: El Torito
6. Big E Vs Rusev
The build for Big E vs Rusev has been shockingly poor, nothing more than a USA flag waving Big E standing up to the proud Russian heel. It's a classic concept of the patriot against the hated foreigner, but the story has been so underdeveloped that fans who actually care will be at a minimum. Not to say it will be a bad match, Big E is one of the most improved grapplers on the roster and Rusev is slowly finding his niche. Hopefully it gets a bit of a time and they can work out some good big man spots, we know that both have solid athleticism for their size, so we hope they get to put that on show. Then again, WWE may just want Big E to be another quick squash for Rusev's monster heel push. If that's the case then why even bother? This match could easily have been done on Raw in that context. It's hard to see past Rusev for the winner, he's the man headed toward bigger things right now. Big E gets a chance of some attack, but Rusev stops him possibly with the distraction from Lana. Winner: Rusev
5. Divas Title: Paige (C) Vs Alicia Fox
This Divas Title match is a tricky one to predict, with Alicia Fox breaking out in recent weeks as the most interesting diva on the roster. Fox's crazy freakouts at ringside have really turned some heads, to the point that she was actually voted the best performer on Raw last Monday in one Wrestling Observer poll. WWE will be high on the fact that someone has got so over on their 'freakout' angle, so you could see them running with it and putting the title on Fox this weekend. Conversely, maybe she loses, to provoke her biggest tantrum yet. The problem with Paige is that she started with bang and quickly turned into a whimper. She has became a side show in recent weeks to Fox. Paige almost certainly wasn't ready to be thrusted into the main diva role, and a temporary relegation of status would make her far more comfortable. This match will be pretty poor, Paige will get her chance to prove her ring work, but ultimately we could see Fox winning after a crazy tantrum which blind sides the Champion. Winner and new Champion: Alicia Fox
4. US Title: Sheamus Vs Cesaro
Sheamus and Cesaro has been building slowly in the last few weeks, following a series of physical matches and confrontations. It's been more of a simmering storyline as opposed to a hot storyline, no one really cares about Sheamus, no one really cares about the US title, and fans are unsure whether to cheer or boo Cesaro. As a result we have a match which WWE are trying to pass off as meaningful, when in fact it comes across as just another bout. Both men are reliable talent, so expect the action to be good. A solid brawl is going to make for an enjoyable ten minutes or so, but it's hardly something you'll even remember by the end of the night. The decision on winner is tricky, as WWE want both men to be having momentum going forward. What will perhaps happen is Sheamus will steal the victory in a slightly heelish manner (forwarding his slow burn turn), with Cesaro then going on to get his heat back by winning Money In The Bank later in June. The US title just wouldn't be a good prop on Cesaro right now, he doesn't need it, it's much better left on Sheamus. Winner: Sheamus
3. Intercontinental Title: Bad News Barrett Vs Rob Van Dam
Rob Van Dam won the right to face Bad News Barrett by getting the fastest time in a 'beat the clock' challenge. That's a storyline WWE like to roll out now and again, but it's hardly the best way to build interest, it basically says that RVD is a default challenger based on a match time. Proper feuds are built on personal clashes, not the amount of time someone won a match in. It's yet another match on the Payback card which seems underdeveloped and weakens the overall interest in the event. Again though, it'll probably be a decent watch for what it's worth. Van Dam is timelessly good and Barrett is a great brawler, they can put on a nice mixture of spots, one the one hand you have the high flyer, on the other hand the hard hitter. That could prove an entertaining dynamic for proceedings, with a major finish spot in which Barrett hits the Bullhammer elbow on a mid-frogsplashing Van Dam. That'd be a cool visual and contribute further to Barrett's progression as a genuine star. Winner: Bad News Barrett
2. Last Man Standing Match: Bray Wyatt Vs John Cena
With this feud having started in January, this June match feels long passed its sell by date. They kind of need to do it, Cena won the Mania 30 battle, Wyatt the Extreme Rules match, now we'll hopefully get a definitive winner and end the feud. This match being Bray Wyatt, you know it's going to be fairly interesting to watch. Both men are excellent in-ring workers when they are on form, but have rarely clicked in the feud so far. Hopefully this Sunday will be different, hopefully we finally get the thrilling match you would have expected from these two men. A plethora of weapon spots and ten count drama should help proceedings somewhat. The winner is a hard one to pick. Cena has been so under Bray's oppression on TV, you almost think to yourself that he has to come back and conquer the evil. From the storytelling perspective you can't really have the bad guy built up so much and then walking away the victor. Could you really imagine The Joker in 'The Dark Knight' killing off Batman at the end? No, of course not, we all found The Joker more interesting and liked him better as a character, but ultimately the hero has to beat his nemesis. Cena and Wyatt are a bit like that, Cena's integrity has been under attack, it would be a damaging blow if he was to now lose this feud. On the flip side we have to say that Bray could really benefit from the win, which would maybe elevate him into a very hot title challenge to Daniel Bryan in the summer. Then again, he's already over, win or lose Wyatt is going to be fine. In fact we could see the 'Bryan 2013 effect' in which a loss actually makes Wyatt stronger than a win would have. It'll be your standard Last Man Standing war, with Cena eventually triumphing in some sort of inventive spot which holds Wyatt down for the ten count. Winner: John Cena
1. No Holds Barres 6 Man Elimination Match: Evolution Vs The Shield
It seems likely that The Shield should win Payback's main event, they are the young up and comers, and Evolution are disbanding anyway (Batista is due to take off to promote Guardians of the Galaxy this summer). On further reflection however, given the match stipulation, maybe we could see a result in which WWE lay the groundwork for Reigns vs Triple H at SummerSlam. It could work out that everyone is eliminated but for the Shield leader and Hunter, resulting in a brawl before The Game steals the victory with a sledgehammer shot. That opens up a whole new singles feud for the next few months: Roman Reigns vs Triple H. The other reason to believe The Shield won't win is that they won last month. What purpose would it serve to see them victors again? It would simply be a rehash of Extreme Rules. One thing for certain, this is going to be the match of the night. You have elite level talent in the ring, all six of these men made up the top 10 wrestlers of 2014 list here. That's not bad value for money at all, 60% of WWE's finest are in this contest. Just like Extreme Rules, we are in store for a stunt filled battle which is sure to excite. Winners: Evolution (Sole Survivor Triple H)