WWE: Ranking The 16 Elimination Chamber Matches

By Chad Matthews /

WWE presents Elimination Chamber on Sunday and has a more intriguing than usual card on deck. The event's signature match will be the focal point, with all eyes on the WWE World Heavyweight Championship and whether or not the WWE might pull a swerve and change up the rumored WrestleMania plans that have, thus far, underwhelmed in creating substantial buzz on the internet. The main-event this weekend should surely be a great edition of the gimmick, no matter the outcome. It is full of elite workers; arguably as impressive a line-up of in-ring ability as we have seen since the stipulation debuted in November 2002. Where will the 2014 Chamber rank amongst its peers? Time will tell. Before we get to Sunday's event, though, let us look back at the Elimination Chamber, match by match, and see what Cesaro, Daniel Bryan, John Cena, Christian, Sheamus, and Randy Orton are up against, historically.

16. The Extreme Elimination Chamber (December to Dismember 2006)

The first several months of the ECW Reboot were actually quite good. Rob Van Dam was on fire with a series of Hardcore matches against the likes of two of his Extreme Chamber opponents, Bob Holly and Test. The envelope-pushing ECW in-ring style was maintained during that time, aiding in the careers of Attitude Era holdovers who needed the gimmicks and the garbage (and the Paul Heyman booking) to stay relevant and have entertaining matches. Big Show thrived in that environment, as well. As ECW Champion, he previewed the better part of his career that largely came about after he returned from hiatus that he actually began after December to Dismember concluded. Sabu was given a new lease on life and became a surprise hit of 2006. Then, of course, CM Punk made a splash in what was unquestionably the most significant debut in the brand return's four year history. The five aforementioned stars, along with Bobby Lashley €“ seemingly the WWE's answer to Brock Lesnar's departure what with his similar build and amateur background €“ combined for what is largely regarded as a lousy Elimination Chamber match. On paper, it seemed pretty intriguing. Take a popular gimmick match and add weapons to each pod? Sounded good. Unfortunately, the execution was lacking. The most popular star in the match, CM Punk, was eliminated early in a situation reminiscent of the current WWE predicament involving Daniel Bryan failing to get the push that the people want in favor of someone more "WWE friendly."

15. The "Smackdown!/ECW" Chamber (No Way Out 2008)

Chambers are most compelling when there is star power. From the first one onward, that was part of the draw. When Eric Bischoff first publicly announced the concept on Raw in 2002, he made it clear that the gimmick borrowed from the aspects that made both the Royal Rumble and Survivor Series matches popular €“ unpredictability of entrants and eliminations. One of the underlying themes was that it placed six major stars in one match with something significant at stake. Well, Undertaker and Batista were major stars in the Smackdown/ECW version in 2008, but MVP, Great Khali, Big Daddy V(iscera), and Finlay were not the caliber of supporting cast expected. Subsequently, while it was not a bad match, it was never worth a second viewing. The result was obvious and there was not enough talent to make up for the predictability of a gimmick that seemed to suggest unpredictability. Credit goes to the big names in the match, plus workhorses Finlay and MVP, for ensuring that it did wind up garnering a favorable rating from most critics.

14. The "Edge Cashes In Post-Match" Chamber (New Year's Revolution '06)

This was not your traditional, loaded with star power version of the gimmick, either. WWE Champion John Cena was the obvious winner. However, the match itself maintained a level of unpredictability through the first twenty minutes by ousting the remainder of the established stars involved in favor of two young, hungry upstarts looking to make a big impression in their first main-event stints. Going into the match, Kane, Kurt Angle, and Shawn Michaels seemed predictable locks to join Cena in the latter stages of the climax. To everyone's surprise, Carlito and Chris Masters formed a tag team that nearly overcame Super Cena and eventually challenged for the Tag Championships at WrestleMania. They developed a trend of mid-carders playing integral roles and taking advantage of their opportunities to shine in a bright Chamber spotlight. Cena overcoming the odds was not what made this memorable, though. Rather, it was the post-match Money in the Bank cash-in by Edge €“ the very first of its kind €“ that put the historical stamp on the proceedings. That was one of the greatest moments of Edge's career and arguably one of the most significant happenings of the last decade.

13. The "Goldberg" Chamber (Summerslam '03)

Expectations were high when Goldberg's vignette aired during WrestleMania 19, but the execution never matched the hype. By and large, his run in the WWE was forgettable. He might very well have viewed the experience as an opportunity to cash in what name value he still had in wrestling before too much time had passed from his dominating WCW days. The second Elimination Chamber was the exception to the general rule that Goldberg and WWE did not mix. At least for that one night, he was used in the perfect way and came across as the star that he was brought in to be. The match had some serious obstacles to overcome. It was thrown together at the last minute when Triple H got injured and could not provide a healthy other half of a World Championship defense against Goldberg in a one-on-one scenario. So, Randy Orton vs. Shawn Michaels and Chris Jericho vs. Kevin Nash were recast into the Chamber, where the WWE could hide Goldberg's apparent weaknesses and the injured World titleholder. Luckily, the booking was superb, Michaels and Jericho carried the way, Orton gave an inspired performance, and the WWE found just the right roles for Nash, Trips, and Goldberg. It wound up being a well paced match that further built heat on Triple H for his eventual title loss. Not a great match, but a fun one...

12. The "Daniel Bryan Finds A Way" Chamber (Elimination Chamber '12)

The first 20-minutes of this match were rather ho-hum. It was a lot like the Smackdown/ECW version in the star power department and it was rather predictable to boot. However, when Big Show eliminated Great Khali, it sparked a greater attention to detail and the match picked up. Bryan had stolen the title from Show in December 2011. Show had a frustrating run of failures in attempting to regain the strap. So, after Show broke into Bryan's pod from its top, the crowd came alive and the emotional investment in the match increased. With the star power not there, they did well to maximize the Show vs. Bryan interaction from previous weeks. It was the one true source of drama in this match before the finish. The elimination of Show was handled well and planted the seeds that something crazy and unpredictable might happen. With Show out of the match, it was basically an exhibition in "let me show you what I can do" amongst Bryan, Cody Rhodes, Wade Barrett, and the star of the match, Santino Marella. When it came down to Bryan and Santino as the final two, the wrestling world rolled its eyes at the predictability of what was to follow...until Santino nearly beat Bryan again and again and again. In a thrilling final few minutes, Bryan showed his ability as a lead heel, making Santino look incredibly threatening in a phenomenal underdog tale that came up just short.

11. The "Cena Wins, Then Loses" Chamber (Elimination Chamber '10)

By 2010, the WWE had found a nice formula of mixing major names with talents that they wanted to test. This bout was a good example. John Cena, Triple H, and Randy Orton were the alphas attempting to capture the WWE Championship on the Road to Mania 26 from Sheamus. As an upstart champ, the Celtic Warrior was turning heads already with his in-ring ability and tendency not to look out of place when battling his more accomplished peers. Thrown into the mix to see what they could do were Ted Dibiase, Jr. and Kofi Kingston. The biggest thing that the match had going for it was unpredictability. It was not so much that the Mania card was up in the air, as we had seen in years past with the Chamber's presence in February, but the placement of the title into one of the matches that was becoming a clearer addition to the "Show of Shows" by the week. Sheamus vs. Triple H, Cena vs. Batista, and Orton vs. Dibiase were all heavily rumored and/or obviously in the making. Which would be for the title? That was the major question at EC '10. When Sheamus was eliminated, it made it obvious that Cena would win...and he did. The surprise came after the match, when Batista got a random title shot and won it. It set up a fantastic championship feud for WrestleMania, with Bats doing the best character work of his career.

10. The "CM Punk Knocks Out Jericho" Chamber (Elimination Chamber '12)

This was a great match and truly the first on this countdown worthy of that distinction. R-Truth was eliminated early in a nice moment in which someone actually took the fall to CM Punk's flying elbow drop. Future matches benefited from the greater near falls created by it. Chris Jericho came in and was arguably the star of the match from then-on. Many expected that he'd win the match given his impending program with Punk for Mania 28. He eliminated Dolph Ziggler, who up to that point had shared in some of the better moments of the match with his superior bumping skills. The Miz was also in the match, probably wondering how he'd managed to go from main-event at Mania 27 to virtually irrelevant one year later. He had perhaps the near fall of the night when he hit Punk with the Skull Crushing Finale, only for Punk to kick out. Jericho and Punk had a nice exchange before the focus turned elsewhere. Jericho's elimination and subsequent thrashing of Kingston answered the question of how to eliminate Y2J without losing to Punk or winning the title. Creatively well played, it was. Having Jericho win the title, only to drop it back to Punk a few weeks later seemed unnecessary. They made the right call, giving Jericho the excuse that he never lost the match.

9. The Original Chamber (Survivor Series '02)

When Eric Bischoff announced plans for the original Elimination Chamber in the fall of 2002, it brought about the excitement of the unknown. What would it look like? How would it play out at match time? With a star-studded line-up, there was little doubt that they would pull it off. On the night of, few would have stated that they failed to do so. Yet, in a decade plus of reflection and numerous other versions of the gimmick, the original has lost much of its luster in the quality department. An early injury to Triple H stunted the progression of the early proceedings. Rob Van Dam connected with a Five Star Frog Splash from the top of one of the pods in one of the first "Wow" moments in the stipulation's history, but he inadvertently landed much of his weight on Triple H's throat. The Game spent the rest of the match gasping for breath and merely trying to get through it. Instead of being a ring general, he was reduced to having to be helped. Then, there was a malfunction in the pod opening sequence, interfering with the flow of the plan. Booker T, Kane, and Chris Jericho did their best to carry the way, but what should have been the best match in Survivor Series history fell a bit short, historically. Perhaps it was an omen when, earlier in the day, Shawn Michaels checked on the exciting new ring gear that a WWE seamstress had designed for him, only to find that it had turned out to be a dark brown color reminiscent of feces.

8. The "Jack Swagger Shocks The World" Chamber (Elimination Chamber 2013)

Jack Swagger's reign as World Champion in 2010 apparently did not go over well with WWE management, as he was significantly depushed to near irrelevance when he disappeared in late 2012 citing on-air frustrations with himself and his career. When he reappeared in early 2013, quickly joined by the man now known as Zeb Coulter, he surprised many by winning the 2013 Elimination Chamber match to set up a World Heavyweight Championship bout with Alberto Del Rio at WrestleMania 29. His new gimmick pushed the buttons of a lot of different people. The WWE tried very hard to make Del Rio the next great Latin star by placing him against the angry Caucasian All-American whose manager was never short on the "border jumping" insults. The Elimination Chamber match, itself, was very good. Randy Orton, Chris Jericho, Daniel Bryan, and Kane all performed well in their roles, though Jericho and Bryan displayed an eye-brow raising lack of chemistry in their one-on-one exchanges to open the match. The final participant, Mark Henry, was a beast whose work in the Chamber set the tone for his very solid run through the first seven months of the year.

7. The "HBK Costs Taker" Chamber (Elimination Chamber '10)

Both in kayfabe and reality, Taker got burned at Elimination Chamber 2010. First, the almost universally flawless electronic and pyrotechnic wizards employed by the WWE messed up The Phenom's entrance flames, causing a burst right into Taker's path and literally searing The Deadman's chest. Ouch. Though he then proceeded to work a great match alongside John Morrison, CM Punk (who nearly stole the show with his performance), Rey Mysterio, and Chris Jericho, Shawn Michaels came in from underneath the ring and blasted Taker with Sweet Chin Music. A three count later and Jericho was the new World Heavyweight Champion, setting up the awesome Streak vs. Career match that ended HBK's 25 year WWE wrestling tenure. This one flies under the radar, historically. Five of the guys involved had standout performances (R-Truth was the six participant and added little of value to the match). Punk added a unique touch of flair to the bout by finishing the promo that he had started on the way to the ring before Truth's music interrupted him. He quickly eliminated Truth and completed his thought while waiting for the next entrant. The entire match was booked a little differently from its peers, with two eliminations before the ten minute mark of the match signaled the second addition from the two starting wrestlers. It also marked the first and only time that a non-participating star has entered the Chamber from underneath the structure.

6. The "Edge Turns WWE into World Heavyweight Gold" Chamber (No Way Out '09)

For much of its modern existence, the February PPV in the WWE €“ no matter its name €“ was an afterthought placeholder to earn a little bit of extra PPV revenue between Royal Rumble and WrestleMania. That was definitely not the case, however, in 2009. It was as if the WWE higher ups woke up one morning in late January 2009 and discovered that which had been so obvious for so long: that fewer people were caring about the February PPV because the WWE rarely offered anything of consequence at the February PPV. Sure, there were some great matches and a noteworthy debut or two, but pro wrestling is as its best when something important is at stake. The Elimination Chamber was a step in the right direction (well, depending on your point-of-view) in 2008, but the results could be seen from a mile away. 2009 changed the expectation. Edge lost the WWE title in the opening match, but took out Kofi Kingston before the main-event could begin, ultimately sealing his reputation as an "Opportunist" by winning the World Heavyweight Championship from John Cena in a match also featuring Rey Mysterio, Chris Jericho, Mike Knox, and Kane. Edge and Mysterio nearly stole the show in a thrilling final few minutes, but this Chamber match may always be overshadowed by the one that preceded it earlier on the card. It was an exciting night in '09, as the title change to start the show and the title change to end the show were fascinating to watch and upped future fan interest in the February PPV.

5. The "Purple Shirt Cena" Chamber (Elimination Chamber '11)

Much like the previous match, the Raw Chamber from 2011 was outstanding, but not quite on the level of the Smackdown version from earlier in the show. John Morrison, in particular, did some phenomenal work. His career hit its crescendo from late 2010 to May 2011 and he, perhaps, never looked better than he did while using the chains of the Chamber as Spiderman would the walls of New York City buildings. The athleticism on display from Jo Mo was equaled on the storytelling side by CM Punk during the heart of his feud with Randy Orton. Punk worked the system as best he could, using the old "Anonymous Raw General Manager" to the fullest extent of its frustrating abuse of power to be the last man eliminated by John Cena (during his purple shirt wearing days that helped make him such an easy target for the returning Rock a week earlier). Sheamus and R-Truth merely provided fodder for the others. At stake that night was a shot at The Miz's WWE Championship at WrestleMania XXVII. There was little doubt that Cena would emerge victorious, which made it all the more impressive that the combination of the match's general layout and the execution by those involved created for such a great match. It might just have been this writer's perspective, but it felt a little more important than the average Chamber match with a predictable result.

4. The "Jeff Hardy Nearly Grabbed The Brass Ring" Chamber (No Way Out '08)

As the WWE transitioned from 2007 to 2008, no wrestler had greater momentum than Jeff Hardy. It could be argued that no one in the last decade built up as much momentum as Hardy did in the build-up to the 2008 Royal Rumble, at which he unsuccessfully challenged for the WWE Championship. The situation leading to WrestleMania XXIV might resonate with fans today. Hardy was on fire in a manner similar to but not quite as substantial as Daniel Bryan is right now. The audience said one thing, but the WWE said another. Triple H and John Cena were clearly being positioned as the top contenders to Randy Orton's title. The last hope for Hardy fans was for Jeff to win the Raw Elimination Chamber. Hardy joined a stacked cast of characters inside the Chamber. Shawn Michaels, Chris Jericho, JBL, Umaga, and Triple H rounded out the field, with The Game winning the match by last eliminating Hardy. The match was stylistically different from its peers. It was the shortest Chamber to date at just under 24-minutes in length, so it had more of a rapid fire feel to it. All of the eliminations came within the last ten minutes. It was a nice change of pace, though the story of Hardy attempting to grab the brass ring being put on hold for several months (he won the title in December 2008) was a bit disappointing at the time. Many in the current fanbase will be hoping that the WWE does not repeat history this weekend with Bryan.

3. The "Evolution Implodes" Chamber (New Year's Revolution '05)

The most underrated of all the Chamber matches, the Raw brand PPV main-event from January 2005 was most famous for its advancement of the plot points in Evolution's complete dismemberment. It deserves to be mentioned in the same breath as the two ranked first and second. The storyline was executed flawlessly. Batista was coming up through the ranks in a hurry. A month prior, he was an afterthought; simply the muscle for Triple H and Ric Flair. A mere glance at The Game's World Heavyweight Championship changed everything. Suddenly, the fans were completely behind him. There has been, perhaps, no greater turnaround from irrelevance to such relevance in a short time frame. Meanwhile, Randy Orton had already been feuding with his former stablemates for several months and was trying to regain the belt that had so unceremoniously been taken away from him. Triple H was the cunning 9-time champion attempting to reclaim what he felt was his. He had vacated the title a month earlier in a triple threat match also involving Chris Benoit and Edge, who occupied the fourth and fifth spots in the Chamber. The vacant title added a layer of intrigue to the match. Chris Jericho was the final participant and Shawn Michaels served as the guest referee. The early parts of the match were dominated by the trio of Jericho, Benoit, and Edge before the focus shifted toward Evolution in the final minutes. The climax was quite compelling, with Triple H and Batista building further tension for their eventual WrestleMania 21 main-event, Orton eliminating Batista, and then Triple H regaining the title by pinning Orton with Batista's aid.

2. The "Shocking" Chamber (No Way Out '09)

Going into the match, it seemed like a reasonable conclusion to draw that Edge, the defending WWE Champion who had just won the title three weeks prior at the Royal Rumble from Jeff Hardy, would retain the belt. However, just under four minutes into the Chamber match, Hardy pinned Edge in the fastest elimination in the gimmick's history. Edge, a favorite to win, lost shortly after the proceedings go under way. As described in #6, it was a shock tactic to improve the reputation of the February PPV...and it worked. "Anything can happen" was characterized well that night. The clunky, green wrestling of Vladimir Kozlov notwithstanding, the rest of the match built on the heightened emotions built from the surprise decision to make clear the imminent title change. Hardy was on such a roll, having won the title in December 2008, that he could have conceivably gone on to win. Big Show was on a similar roll throughout the previous year that made him a viable option, too. Undertaker was always a threat after two consecutive title matches in the two years prior, in addition to his glowing reputation and Mania resume. Triple H was, well, Triple H. Four realistic options remained after Edge lost the title. It all came down to a thrilling final sequence featuring Triple H and Undertaker in a preview of their back-to-back WrestleMania classics (with Trips winning). Yet, it also featured so much excitement and drama before it. What sets it apart was Edge unexpectedly losing the title. That little touch makes this the penultimate Chamber match on this list. Not only did it have the spectacle of Taker vs. Trips to close it out, but a shocking moment in the first few minutes to set the tone.

1. The "Awesome Smackdown!" Chamber (Elimination Chamber '11)

What makes this such an odd choice for the #1 Elimination Chamber match of all-time is that, on paper, it looks like the weakest Elimination Chamber of all-time. Three years of history have done little to refute that. Yet, that night, every single participant had a standout performance. Drew McIntyre, he of 3MB infamy today, looked like a superstar ready to breakout back then. He took his opportunity and made the most of it, displaying an intensity and desire to be one of the top stars in the business that should have taken him much further than his current position. He was arguably the star of the match. Then again, most of the field could make an argument. Wade Barrett impressed in the early stages of his career, attempting to stay over after the conclusion of his debut feud as leader of the Nexus against John Cena. His cowardly act played out very well. Big Show had a great two year stretch in 2011 and 2012, beginning with his work in this match and extending through his matches with Sheamus for the World Heavyweight Championship. Kane excelled, as well. The match was already great through the eliminations of the aforementioned four wrestlers, but the incredible climactic sequence between Rey Mysterio and the defending World Champion, Edge, was seven of the most dramatic minutes of modern pro wrestling that seemingly no one ever talks about. Back and forth, near fall after near fall they went before Edge finally Speared Mysterio in mid-air to retain the title. Awesome match.