WWE Royal Rumble 2019 - 10 Most Likely Winners

We're apparently getting a repeat winner this coming Rumble. Who could it be?

By Jack Robert /

As we march forward to the end of the calendar year, the gossip is coming hot and heavy in the wrestling world. We're now getting to the point where we're hearing serious rumor and innuendo about WWE's most important season that stretches from the Royal Rumble to WrestleMania.

Advertisement

This past week, WrestleVotes, a usually reliable insider, hinted that WWE was planning to have the winner of the 2019 Men's Rumble match to be a "repeat winner." So immediately, this dashed the hopes of anyone hoping Daniel Bryan would finally win one of these darn matches. Oh well.

Of the past Rumble winners who aren't dead, retired, or massive bell-ends that there's no way in hell people would stand their presence (looking at you, Alberto), there are plenty of options when it comes to a repeat winner.

That said, some of these options are so unrealistic, we'll table them right here. Brock Lesnar will probably be too busy prepping for UFC in early 2019, and Sheamus is a midcard tag wrestler at this point.

Other than that, though, there's plenty of past Royal Rumble winners who could win the match next year and main-event WrestleMania (or go on in the midcard if they're challenging for the WWE title).

10. Roman Reigns

Can you imagine? The absolute audacity of those madmen if this were to happen.

Advertisement

Right now, what's preventing the possibility of Roman Reigns from winning his second Royal Rumble is the fact that he's currently Universal Champion. He was forced to defend his world title in the Rumble match in 2016, so if WWE embody the definition of insanity, then they very well might do the same thing over again.

Still, WWE are always going to contrive a way to have Reigns chase after another coronation, so you can never fully count out the idea that WWE will be cheeky enough to contrive a way for THE BIG DAWWWWWG to lose his title, and then win the Royal Rumble to earn his shot to get back the title.

If that scenario were to occur, it would be likely that Roman loses his title to Braun Strowman at TLC in some manner that doesn't involve Roman getting pinned. Keep in mind, what I've just charted out for you comes from the most cynical and defeatist part of my WWE-loving brain.

But hey... WWE have been known to be way worse than your imagination.

9. Triple H

I'll take "really unappealing and uninspired" for 400, Alex.

Advertisement

Only one man has ever won three Royal Rumbles, and that's Stone Cold Steve Austin. There are many on this list who could join him if WWE plans to have a repeat winner, and one of them is the King of Kings.

Triple H first won the Royal Rumble back in 2002, when he was a triumphant returning babyface. He then won it in 2016 for the WWE Championship, again as a triumphant returning babyface (at least to the Orlando crowd who really didn't want Roman Reigns to win).

There's really no appealing way to picture Triple H winning the Rumble. It would only be three years after his last win, and with all this nonsense with The Undertaker going on, it would seem weird to put him in a title picture. And it would kill everyone's enthusiasm if they had him go after Roman Reigns and the Universal Championship. Because that's exactly what we need: a rematch from WrestleMania 32.

However, if WWE were smart, they would book a dream match people might actually want to see. Given Triple H always likes to have the longest match at WrestleMania, why not book him against someone who can go long? Triple H-AJ Styles does sound appealing, but otherwise, I don't think fans would be clamoring to see Hunter win his third Rumble.

8. Batista

Big Banter Dave Batista's two Rumble wins couldn't be more different. In 2005, The Animal won his first Rumble to major fanfare as the company's hottest rising star. In 2014, Big Mouth Season 2 on Netflix Dave returned to the company to promote Guardians of the Galaxy, and won the Rumble to a chorus of boos due to his unfortunate affliction of "Not Being Daniel Bryan." From there, Bootista happened, then Bluetista, and then Dave left the company once again.

Advertisement

With Big Butts And I Cannot Lie Dave returning to the company as part of SmackDown 1000, talk is naturally going to spring up about a possible in-ring return. Batista has gone on record for a while now expressing his interest to wrestle again, although WWE have been cold about the idea. Perhaps they're keeping their plans close to their chest, and if said plan is to have a repeat Rumble winner, then Dave is almost certainly one of the people on their mind.

While the fans likely wouldn't boo Bigger, Faster, And Stronger Too Dave like they did last time, he wouldn't exactly be anyone's ideal choice. Even though we're coming on five years since Batista last won a Rumble, it still feels so recent. And really, aside from Triple H or Randy Orton, none of the members of roster seem like logical WrestleMania opponents. The idea of Dave-AJ is unlikely, and certainly nobody's clamoring to see The Big Dog get a pin on Big Brother UK Dave.

7. The Undertaker

Age is just a number... unless you're the Undertaker, in which case, the age of 53 is a sign that he does not know how to retire. A year-and-a-half removed from his supposed last match with Roman Reigns at WrestleMania 33, the Deadman has defied our expectations in 2018 and has kept coming back for more. First squashing John Cena at WrestleMania, then burying Rusev softly (brother) in a casket match, things started to get serious when a match with Triple H was announced for Super Show-Down. With Kane and Shawn Michaels now involved, all roads are leading to a DX/Brothers of Destruction encounter at Crown Jewel. And now, the rumor and innuendo is hinting at HBK vs. The Deadman at Survivor Series.

Advertisement

That's all well and good, but what's next for The Undertaker? While another title program is unlikely given 'Taker's age, you never know just what this company will do for nostalgia.

Should The Undertaker win his first Royal Rumble since 2007, fans would most likely dread the prospect of him once again going up against Roman Reigns (assuming he still has the title by that point). Of course, they could always go for AJ Styles, given SmackDown was always The Undertaker's yard back in the day, but that seems less likely.

6. Rey Mysterio

After all these years, come SmackDown 1000, Rey Mysterio will be back in WWE for good (or at least the next 18 months, either/or). With the roster so different from the one Rey left behind, there're so many options as to who he can be programmed with that would provide new, exciting matches (at least in WWE proper).

Advertisement

And of course, being a returning legend, and having won the Royal Rumble back in 2006, Rey is naturally a possible winner for this coming Rumble. It would be an interesting contrast from 13 years ago, as then, Rey was the plucky underdog avenging the death of his best friend Eddie Guerrero. It remains to be seen, but it stands to reason that WWE will portray Rey as more of a grizzled veteran. Him winning the Rumble would be done as a feel-good nostalgia pop, much like Batista in 2014.

Of course, unlike Big Bang Theory Dave, Rey has never been treated as one of "the chosen ones" in the WWE hierarchy. Despite being a legend in his 40s, Rey winning wouldn't come off as a legend taking the spotlight away from the young guys, since he's so naturally lovable. And of course, if he's gonna be on SmackDown, the idea of him going up against AJ Styles or Daniel Bryan for the title at WrestleMania? How could you pass that up?

5. Braun Strowman

You might be quick to point out that Braun Strowman isn't an option to win the Rumble because he hasn't won one of the January matches. However, given that this past April, he won the Greatest Royal Rumble in Saudi Arabia, I'd say that makes him the greatest shoe-in.

Advertisement

Okay, maybe not, but still, given Strowman's ever-protected status as a main-eventer, it's safe to say that he'll be a speculated pick to win these kinds of matches for years to come. WWE love themselves their monster characters, especially the Monster Among Men these days.

Of course, Strowman winning the Royal Rumble might ruffle feathers. Not because people dislike him, far from that. It would just come off as predictable, and prolong this never-ending feud with Roman Reigns. Given how there are talent on RAW like Finn Bálor or Kevin Owens that have been kept away from the main event scene in favor of guys like Strowman, Reigns, and Lesnar, having Braun win the Rumble would just be another reminder to fans that there is a glass ceiling that guys like Bálor can't coup de grâce through.

Still, if Braun can win a 50-man Royal Rumble match, then he's got a chance in January.

4. The Rock

I can't think of a choice that would be any more controversial than this one.

Advertisement

The Rock won the Royal Rumble all the way back in 2000 (except he didn't, The Big Show got robbed. It should be him making a movie with Jason Statham while The Rock stars in Knucklehead). Since his last in-ring run in 2013, Rock has made infrequent appearances in the company and has not wrestled, bar his showstealer with Erick Rowan at WrestleMania 32.

One would think Dwayne would value his movie career too much to put his 46-year-old body back in the ring. However, this is The Rock, and The Rock does what he wants, so if he wants to wrestle at 'Mania 35, there's little anyone can do to stop him. Therefore, he should be considered a possibility.

The Rock winning the Rumble would ruffle a lot of feathers. Firstly: it would be yet another ageing legend winning an accolade they don't need for the sake of nostalgia. Secondly: there's no way in heck we're getting Rock-AJ Styles, meaning if things go the way there are now, we're looking at The Rock vs. Roman Reigns.

That idea is can't-miss and irresistible... if your name is Vince McMahon. If not, you're already groaning.

3. John Cena

John Cena is no stranger to success at the Royal Rumble. Although he's usually in title match situations at the PPV, his rate of success in the Rumble match itself is pretty darn good. In 2008, Big Match John shocked the world by coming back incredibly early from injury to win the match at #30. In 2013, Cena once again punched a ticket to WrestleMania by winning the Rumble, but this one was met with less enthusiasm from fans, as it telegraphed a Rock-Cena rematch that nobody asked for.

Advertisement

We're coming on six years since Cena's last won a Rumble, and the company have clearly moved on from him as the top guy. With Hollywood now his primary calling, Cena shows up fairly infrequently, and in the process, he's become less and less of a priority as far as big-time programs go.

If Cena were to win the Rumble, there's a natural story of the former top guy coming back to reclaim his spot one last time. It's the exact story New Japan is telling with Hiroshi Tanahashi. While a match against Roman Reigns for the Universal Championship has more dollar signs on it (at least to Vince), most fans would tell you they'd want to see Cena revisit his rivalry with AJ Styles. A match between those two at WrestleMania? That's hard to pass up.

2. Randy Orton

Randy Orton hasn't had a great history with Royal Rumbles, which is weird, considering he's won two of them. However, they're not looked upon with fondness. In 2009, when he was the company's top heel, he won his first Rumble and went on to have one of the worst WrestleMania main events ever with Triple H. Eight years later, Orton won his second in a move that was mostly met with bemusement and apathy from the fans.

Advertisement

However, Orton's luck might be different this coming Rumble season. Since returning in July, the Viper has reinvigorated himself, once again donning the persona of a vicious heel, twisting ear lobes and just generally being a bit of a knob.

People have really responded to Orton's change in attitude after years of babyface mediocrity. However, Randy has conspicuously been kept far away from WWE Champion AJ Styles. With how much traction this heel turn has gained, it's not out of the realm of possibility to have Orton win the Rumble and finally go one on one with Styles (this time on PPV and with the proper heel/face alignment).

If you ask my brain, this is who will win the 2019 Royal Rumble. But if you ask my heart...

1. Shawn Michaels

On a surface level, with how WWE has over-promoted part-timers and legends over current full-time talent over the years, the idea of Shawn Michaels, who at the time of this article's writing isn't even out of retirement, is insulting and disgusting.

Advertisement

But on an emotional level... c'mon. You've read this list. You've seen the options that might be if WWE really go with a repeat winner. Most of them are painfully predictable. Meanwhile, Shawn Michaels, who last won a Royal Rumble match in 1996, would be a completely out-of-nowhere winner (unless he announces his participation ahead of time, in which case, forget I said that).

But just to squeeze into the comfy cushion of smarky armchair booking, think about who HBK could reasonably face in his second comeback. What's the one match you would want to see at WrestleMania 35? If your answer was anything other than Shawn vs. AJ for the WWE Championship, unless it's a match with Daniel Bryan, I don't know what to tell you.

Obviously, HBK is a long-shot, especially at the time of writing this article, but if we're going on the premise that a repeat-winner will happen this year, HBK offers the most opportunity for excitement.

-

But forget the gossip. Who do you want to win the 2019 Royal Rumble? Let us know in the comments below!

Advertisement