WWE SummerSlam 2015: 12 Biggest Takeaways
The most important ramifications stemming from the biggest party of the summer.
SummerSlam 2015 has come and gone, and over the course of the event, we saw some truly historic moments. Ten matches took place on the card, and the show was hosted by none other than former Daily Show host Jon Stewart. Four titles were on the line in three matches, the 'Divas Revolution' was in full swing, and two of the biggest legends squared off in a main event match that will be remembered for years to come.
So what were the ramifications of this show?
To begin, there were high expectations for SummerSlam, the least of all because, a) it was the first time the show went four hours long, and b) it was on the heels of yet another outstanding NXT TakeOver event that took place the night before. As such, WWE's decision-makers decided to make this show as 'memorable' as possible, partly by having its two most important matches end via controversial means. At the same time, the matches were exciting by WWE standards, with a lot of emphasis on high-flying maneuvers being shown (seriously, there were over-the-top-rope diving moves in at least five matches on a ten-match card...and that's a good thing).
This article will highlight the 12 most important things we've learned from SummerSlam 2015, in terms of storylines, match results, and overall show presentation.
12. Randy Orton Vs. Sheamus Was A Poor Choice For Opener
The combination of Randy Orton and Sheamus in singles competition has the dubious distinction of being one of the most repetitive feuds in recent memory...even more so than Randy Orton vs. John Cena. This was the match that took place on the night after WrestleMania XXIX, and on that night, the crowd didn't care about it whatsoever. They chanted random things, for legends, and even for the commentators...anything other than investing into the match between Orton and Sheamus.
While those actions might not have been malicious in nature, they highlighted a problem that was very prominent back then: Sheamus/Orton is a boring match prospect.
And yet, not only did WWE resurrect this feud without giving fans a new reason to like the match-ups, but they decided to make this the opening match for a four-hour event.
The match itself was nothing special, and felt very much like a regular main event of a televised program. Although the effort was there, it was just a boring combination that failed to excite the fans enough to make them loud enough to make SummerSlam even more memorable.
11. The Tag Team Title Match Should've Been the Opener Instead
When WWE books a match with so many participants, it's normal for those matches to descend rather quickly into chaos, with moves being executed seemingly at random, and one person being sent out of the ring after another, until there are 'bodies lying everywhere'. That's what happened in this case, and it actually ended up being an exciting match. So much so that it's very strange that this wasn't the opener.
All four teams had some impressive offense (especially by Big E, Darren Young and the Lucha Dragons), and there were so many risky moments in the match that the fans were on their feet chanting 'this is awesome' by the time it ended.
Had that been the opener, it's guaranteed that fan reaction for the rest of the match would've been more positive and noticeable.
10. Dolph Ziggler And Rusev's Feud Must End
Rusev and Dolph Ziggler have been thrown together in a strange romance storyline for months now. What started off as a relationship issue between Rusev and Lana has transformed into a prototypical 'new boyfriend versus jealous ex' storyline that has been seen many times before. Nevertheless, both men tried to make the best out of this storyline direction, but sadly it wouldn't work out.
Despite both men having great athletic skills, the crowd was apathetic for the most part. Maybe they were tired from the match that preceded it, or maybe they found this storyline (and its participating wrestlers) uninteresting. Whatever the reason may be, the audience didn't care for this match at all, not even for Ziggler's great selling or his special high-spots. In fact, the loudest reaction during this match and after it ended was for Lana, who was standing outside doing nothing for the most part.
The crowd booed when the match ended in a double count-out, and the subsequent multi-person brawl spoke volumes of nonsensical booking that didn't yield any kind of greater benefit to any of the participants.
Rusev and Ziggler need better feuds. Maybe new ones can start on the RAW after SummerSlam, and both of them can move onto something bigger and better.
9. Stardust And King Barrett Deserve So Much Better
If there was ever a duo of WWE Superstars who were constantly being presented with unnecessarily-humiliating storylines and ridiculous match-ups, it would be Stardust and King Barrett. Though they did their jobs in this match (literally and metaphorically), they were both once again presented as weaklings, losing to a team of which one member isn't even a wrestler.
Under normal circumstances, any match involving a celebrity as an actual in-ring participant should be reserved for someone like Santino Marella or a full-time jobber, and not for two wrestlers who, not too long ago, were believed to be major stars that would become fresh challengers for the WWE Championship. But no; WWE took the 2015 King of the Ring winner and the son of Dusty Rhodes and sent them out as fodder to Stephen Amell in a match that seemed to be put together without a clear payoff.
Though Amell looked very impressive during this match (this might very well have been the best match involving a celebrity in recent memory), what does this do for either Neville, Barrett or Stardust long-term? While Neville's career might still be safe, for his opponents in this match, any positive momentum or legitimacy they might've had before this match is gone.
Hopefully they can bounce back, but such hopes have been raised in the past, and with little success so far...
8. The Intercontinental Title Needs More Attention
The WWE Intercontiental Championship was defended in a Triple Threat match that saw the defending champion Ryback claim victory, despite a series of very believable near-falls. While this match was interesting, Ryback's victory highlights a problem that still persists with the Intercontinental Championship: the belt isn't given enough major attention on the main shows.
So much attention is put on literally every single other championship that the IC title appears to be presented as 'that belt that everyone who doesn't have a long-term storyline gets to fight for'. This is a sad state of affairs for the belt that was once held by the likes of 'Macho Man' Randy Savage, 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin, Chris Jericho, and so many other legends.
A persistent problem in WWE shows is that sometimes, matches are presented in such a way that they limit the degree to which fans invest into them. Look at this match for example: Ryback was going in to the match as champion, yet no one seemed concerned about his chances of losing. Furthermore, no one really saw the Miz as a serious threat, and more people were interested in seeing if Big Show would turn again than if he could actually win the belt.
If this belt is to ever become as prestigious as it once was, there needs to be more effort put in to presenting it as a worthwhile championship to pursue and acquire.
7. Wyatt, Harper And Ambrose All Need Better Feuds
The tam team match that pitted Dean Ambrose and Roman Reigns against Bray Wyatt and Luke Harper was an exciting one. It featured some really impressive maneuvers by all of the men involved, including a series of out-of-the-ring maneuvers that really got the crowd excited. After a lot of back-and-forth momentum shifts, the ending saw Reigns his the Spear on Wyatt, presumably to bring an end to their feud.
This, of course begs the question, 'what's next for Ambrose, Harper and Wyatt?'
While Reigns' creative direction is more or less set in stone at this point, the remaining participants in this match have nothing left to do. Ambrose and Wyatt took part in a lengthy feud in late 2014 and early 2015, and after that, Ambrose feuded with Harper in a storyline that went nowhere. All three of these men are some of the most consistently popular athletes on the regular roster, and all of them have demonstrated that they can put on fantastic performances when it is demanded of them.
However, an important requirement in putting on good matches on a regular basis à la John-Cena-US-Title-Open-Challenge is consistent creative support. All three of these men have suffered through periods of creative indecision and purgatory, and as 2015 rolls along and we move ever closer to WrestleMania 32, all three of these men need better storylines that will give them more opportunities to connect more with the audience and grow ever further as stars.
6. Reigns Still Has Problems Connecting With The Audience As A Face
Out of the four performers in that ring during the tag team match, Roman Reigns had the biggest problem when it came to crowd reaction. Bray Wyatt was still getting his typical loud reaction during his time in the ring and some respectful silence during his entrance. Luke Harper was cheered as a workhorse who can move around well in the ring. Dean Ambrose got the best reaction out of all four of them.
But Reigns was only cheered audibly enough during his entrance and immediately following his win. Between the bells, he was getting booed...loudly.
Whenever Reigns was tagged in, the audience would turn on him vociferously. For example when Ambrose hit his Dirty Deeds finisher on Wyatt, the crowd erupted in cheers. But as soon as Reigns was tagged in and prepared to his his Spear, the crowd's reaction took a decidedly negative turn.
This is a major problem for Reigns going forward. If this were a singles match without Dean Ambrose on his side, Reigns would've been booed out of the building. Despite WWE's attempt to salvage his main event push and take a longer time with him, the fans in the Barclays Center must've still had the 2015 Royal Rumble match fresh on their minds.
If Reigns wants to be successful in WWE, he cannot be presented as a new John Cena; he needs a different creative direction, and he needs it soon.
5. The Divas Match Was Underwhelming
Fresh off the heels of an outstanding NXT Women's Championship at NXT TakeOver: Brooklyn, you'd think that the women on the 'main' roster would be motivated to step up a gear. Sadly, you'd be wrong; while the Bayley/Sasha Banks match managed to be full of excitement in a 19-minute match, this 9-woman match went 15 and was far less exciting.
A major reason for that was because the stipulation had it so that when someone was pinned or made submit, the entire team would be eliminated, instead of, you know, only that one person. All of a sudden a trio's entire success was dependent on one woman's skills. So instead of doing an actual elimination match, where members of each team are eliminated one by one, you have Tamina Snuka getting pinned, leading to all of Team B.A.D. being out of the match.
Despite the heavy emphasis of this storyline in recent weeks, the match felt rushed and overbooked. There were few moments to push particular combinations between two people, and so the only thing that made this match stand out as a women's match was it's length.
Although some of the women managed to show off some cool moves (including some exciting over-the-top-rope maneuvers), the match just fell flat. However, given the positive reaction for the NXT women (and the negative one for the Bellas), maybe some more substantial change might be coming soon.
4. Kevin Owens Finally Gets A Win
After spending months losing important matches and being presented as a cowardly heel, Kevin Owens had to leave SummerSlam 2015 as the winner...and that he did.
In what can only be described as a dream match-up, Owens and Cesaro were neck-and-neck throughout this exciting match. Despite the lack of an enthusiastic crowd audience, both men put on a stellar performance together. Though Cesaro was obviously the stronger and more agile of the two during this match, Owens had the more devastating offense, which went well with his current heel gimmick.
Some of Owens' best moments in this match include: a somersault plancha onto Cesaro within the first 40 seconds of the match, a devastating-looking Argentine Neckbreaker onto Cesaro, and how he almost hit a picture-perfect Moonsault from the top rope. Then, of course, there was the ending, that saw Owens hit a cradle suplex from the top rope, and then a pop-up Powerbomb for the pin.
A win like this is just when Kevin Owens needed. He looked like he belonged in this match and that he could hang with someone as strong and tough as Cesaro. Moreover, after losing in such a high-profile match to Finn Balor the night before, Owens has some important momentum going forward. Whether his feud with Cesaro continues or not, expect to see more good Owens matches in the near future.
3. John Cena And Seth Rollins Put On The Best Match Of The Night
With NXT: TakeOver Brooklyn still fresh in fans' minds going into SummerSlam, expectations for match quality was high. Unfortunately, most of the matches were above-average at best, with one or two of them more akin to a RAW-level match than something you'd see on a marquis show like SummerSlam. However, the match between John Cena and Seth Rollins not only managed to meet fans' expectations for match quality, but it was hands down the best match of the show in terms of quality.
Both Rollins demonstrated some unbelievable athleticism during this match, and told a great story in the ring. Though Cena did perform to his usual high standard, he managed to bust out some interesting moves, including a rare Figure-4 Leg Lock, which was an awesome reference to Ric Flair's legacy that hung ominously throughout the match.
But it was Rollins who delivered the goods in this match more than Cena. Rollins simply out-performed Cena in every way: his aerial maneuvers were more crisp and well-timed (Cena botched hid diving leg drop badly, missing Rollins' head entirely), he showed unusual strength (which is usually Cena's selling point), and used a rare variety of moves (a Superplex immediately transitioned into a Falcon Arrow).
Though the ending wasn't clean, the end result was the best one possible: Rollins won, demonstrating why Triple H and other power-brokers in WWE are behind him so much. His athleticism, character, and overall presentation make him the perfect person to carry WWE into the future.
2. Jon Stewart Put On An Historic Performance As Host Of SummerSlam
Normally when you think 'guest host' of a show, your mind conjured up images of known failures in that endeavor's history. The Rock was a decent host at best for WrestleMania XXVII, and many of these similar guests have shown up on RAW recently, with their involvements being generally disappointing.
However, one person who managed to make full use of his involvement with the show was John Stewart.
Not only was his status as 'host' put to good use throughout the show (with a bit of an exception for that opening segment), Stewart took part in one of the most historic moments in WWE history as he aided Seth Rollins in defeating John Cena to become the first simultaneous holder of both the WWEWHC and the United States Championship.
While some have derided the decision as bizarre and nonsensical, it did a great job of adding a moment of genuine shock to an otherwise predictable show. There were many theories abound on the ultimate outcome of the Cena-Rollins match, with most people suggesting interference from Sheamus, the Authority, Kevin Owens, or some other unclean finish that would in all likelihood have both men retain their respective championships.
With Jon Stewart, not only does his involvement further elevate Rollins as the ideal 'chickens**t heel', but it adds an entire new dynamic for the WWE's storyline directions going forward. Stewart's involvement will certainly be one of the most hotly-discussed moments for a long time to come.
1. The Feud Between Undertaker And Brock Lesnar Isn't Over
The main event of the evening featured Brock Lesnar and the Undertaker put on a classic 18-minute long match that eclipsed their WrestleMania encounter from 16 months ago. Both men showed impressive athleticism (especially Undertaker, who looked way better during this match), there were exciting high spots (including one of the best Undertaker Chokeslams ever), and it even featured some never-before-seen moments as well (Undertaker laughing at Lesnar, Lesnar attacking 'Taker before his coat was even off).
But what will be remembered most of all was the controversial ending to this match. Lesnar had Undertaker in the kimura lock, and as Taker tried to lift Lesnar into a pinning position, the Deadman tapped, the timekeeper noticed buy the referee didn't. The referee argued with the timekeeper, and Undertaker low-blowed Lesnar, who then passed out to the Hell's Gate submission hold.
It was a strange series of circumstances. Logic would dictate that the referee would review the footage and make a more definitive ruling on such an ending. Instead, the referee recognized Undertaker as the winner, even though everyone, from the commentators to the fans saw Undertaker tap out (which is an historic occurrence in itself).
As a result, expect to see this feud continue. Paul Heyman will probably show up on RAW on the 24th of August to make more noise, and this legendary feud will continue, with another match between them possibly at the next major PPV.