Billed as the biggest rematch in WWE history, Brock Lesnar vs. The Undertaker is undeniably a worthy main event for this year's SummerSlam. Whether it ends up being as great as it's being hyped up to be remains to be seen, but seeing The Undertaker finally get his revenge on Lesnar's ass in Brooklyn is going to be great, right? Wrong. When The Beast conquered The Streak at WrestleMania and become the one in twenty one and one, the foundation of the WWE Universe was forever altered. A controversial and very divisive moment, Lesnar's victory sent shockwaves across the world, received mainstream media attention, and even caused Jon Stewart to embark on a passionate rant much to the surprise of his bemused Daily Show audience. It was a once in a lifetime moment which the WWE are now inevitably looking to repeat, but with no Streak on the line, the Deadman emerging the victor in order to make up for his devastating loss on the grandest stage of them all feels like a given. However, it's essential that the man who has already conquered him once does so again. While it probably won't be a popular decision, Lesnar leaving the Barclays Arena as the victor is essential and losing isn't an option for him. The Undertaker meanwhile shouldn't even come close to winning. Why? Well, here are the eight biggest reasons why there's only one way this epic rematch should end less than one week from now...
Advertisement
8. The Undertaker Gains Nothing From Winning
The Streak is dead, and The Undertaker has only made three televised appearances since it came to an end. Those were WrestleMania 31, Battleground, and Raw a few weeks back. There's really no reason to suspect his TV time is going to dramatically increase after SummerSlam, and if the plan is for the Deadman to continue making sporadic appearances over the next few years and engage in these seemingly random rivalries (what did that match with Bray Wyatt accomplish again?), then a victory here isn't going to change anything. If he defeats Lesnar, is it really going to redeem his loss at WrestleMania? It's that shocking and unbelievable moment which is going to go down in history, not the rematch from nearly a year and a half later. The Undertaker simply isn't around enough to gain anything from beating Lesnar. A victory at SummerSlam is something the commentary team is likely to mention when he returns for WrestleMania 32 and might be a talking point the Phenom brings up in a future promo, but a loss for Lesnar feels like little more than a bid by the WWE to appease fans who were left outraged by the fact that The Beast conquered the Streak in 2014. As impressive as The Streak was, it lost its meaning when it became apparent that it was never going to end. That fact that it did is what made Lesnar's victory in New Orleans so shocking, and he's benefited from it in a major way since. Had The Undertaker won yet again, no one would even remember that match by now, and a victory at SummerSlam for him would also no doubt be soon forgotten.
7. It Will Ruin Brock Lesnar's Mystique
When Brock Lesnar emerged victorious from WrestleMania 30, he was transformed from the guy who came back and spent a year being beaten by Triple H into an unstoppable Beast on a vicious path of destruction. Brock was always worth watching, but seeing if anyone could put an end to him as an almost unstoppable force made his matches even more compelling, and as he dominated everyone from John Cena to Roman Reigns and Seth Rollins in convincing fashion, it was almost as if he had inherited The Undertaker's supernatural powers! WWE Creative has already made some mistakes with Lesnar in recent months by ending a Raw with Brock being easily beaten down by Rollins and The Authority, a fate which nearly every Superstar on the roster has seemingly suffered at one point or another (and as we're supposed to view him as being on another level to everyone else, that's a problem). Even so, the way Lesnar took Rollins to Suplex City and shook off nearly all his offence proved that The Beast was still very much alive at Battleground. Could his apparent indestructibility get old? it's possible, but not if he's continuously pitted against only those with a chance of taking him down. The Undertaker is certainly one of those people, but a victory for the Deadman here would likely rob Lesnar of the mystique he's built up since WrestleMania 30. He'll become the guy who defeated The Undertaker by chance and someone who was unable to do so a second time. After all, if a 50 year old part-timer can come back out of the blue and take down the so-called Beast, why should any of us buy into him as a meaningful threat moving forwards?
6. A Rubber Match Wouldn't Have The Same Level Of Excitement
If The Undertaker wins at SummerSlam, there's no way the WWE will be able to resist the temptation to have a rubber match between him and Lesnar in order to decide who between them really is the best. This is after all the company that billed The Rock vs. John Cena as being "Once In A Lifetime" and followed it up with a rematch a year later! The Undertaker and Brock Lesnar's rubber match could take place during one of this Autumn's PPV's when it comes time to try and boost WWE Network subscription numbers or at next year's WrestleMania, but a third bout between them would be a big mistake regardless of the venue. The WWE has done a good job of making everyone forget that these two clashed many times during Lesnar's original WWE run, and while this upcoming rematch definitely feels like a big deal, it's hard to imagine there being a huge deal of excitement around a third. The rubber match aspect would certainly add something to it, but other than that, what exactly would the stakes be? Brock has already conquered The Streak (something which can never be undone), and if The Undertaker emerges victorious at SummerSlam, he'll have had his revenge. There's simply nothing to be gained by these two going at it for a third time. The Undertaker winning is near enough a guarantee that it will happen though, and that's why it would be in everyone's best interest for Lesnar to remain the victor in this particular feud.
5. It Would Have No Lasting Impact
As I mentioned in a previous slide, there's really nothing to be gained from The Undertaker winning at SummerSlam next Sunday. Him managing to take down Lesnar would no doubt make a lot of fans happy (that low blow appeared to be an indication that the Deadman would return as a heel, but WWE Creative may have underestimated just how much fans love him), but what does that accomplish in the long run? After SummerSlam, The Undertaker will no doubt once again disappear until next year's WrestleMania season, and even if Brock takes a few months off, you can bet he'll be back before the Phenom. He'll no doubt be engaged in an entirely different feud by that point and Paul Heyman will have absolutely no reason to try and talk his client's way out of this loss if enough time has passed. It's also hard to imagine whoever Brock's future opponents might be throwing the Beast's defeat at SummerSlam in his face either as chances are that they won't have ever beaten The Undertaker anyway! The Undertaker meanwhile rarely utilises promo time in his current Deadman persona, so him kicking off Raw with a fifteen minute soliloquy about beating Brock also seems unlikely. A victory for Lesnar on the other hand would be huge. It would serve to not only make him even more indestructible, but gives Heyman a new talking point for years to come; his client becomes not only the man who conquered The Streak, but also the guy who put The Undertaker down when he returned for revenge! If The Undertaker wins, chances are it will be as quickly forgotten as his match with Bray Wyatt earlier this year.
4. Now Is The Right Time For The Undertaker To Pass The Torch
When Brock Lesnar defeated The Undertaker at WrestleMania 30, a large portion of the audience assumed that that was it for the Deadman. He had passed the torch to Lesnar in his defeat, giving The Beast the chance to use his newfound mystique to put over younger Superstars on the roster (something he's since done with both Roman Reigns and Seth Rollins). Of course, The Undertaker's concussion soured that match somewhat as he clearly wasn't at 100% for the vast majority of it. He no doubt now wants to make up for that by proving he's still got it - which was perhaps the only take away from his recent match with Wyatt - and that's more than fair enough. Even so, now still feels like the right time for The Undertaker to pass the torch to the next generation, and doing so by taking another defeat at the hands of Lesnar seems like the best way to accomplish that. Even if he plans to continue making sporadic appearances for the next few years (for that long rumoured match with Sting for example), this SummerSlam rematch could still accomplish a lot if it's used for The Undertaker to almost open the door to Lesnar taking his position as the WWE's most dominant force and persona. At 50 years old and on an extremely limited schedule, it's apparent that The Undertaker can't or isn't willing to spend time appearing regularly to help get younger talents over. Lesnar on the other hand has a contract on which the ink is still barely dry and plenty of time to help the likes of Cesaro, Finn Balor, and Kevin Owens shine. Should The Undertaker win, the Beast just takes once step closer to becoming just another Superstar.
3. It Would Make WrestleMania Meaningless
As angry as it made both fans and those in the wrestling business, there's no denying the fact that Brock Lesnar conquering The Streak is a moment which is going to go down in WWE history as one of the all-time greatest. It was a ballsy decision by Vince McMahon, but on a show with a fan pleasing ending to Daniel Bryan's story, he could afford to take a chance by ensuring WrestleMania 30 was a show no one would forget. For twenty one years, The Streak remained undefeated. Lesnar changing that to 21-1 (well, 22-1 now I guess) is a huge deal, but should he lose at SummerSlam, does that WrestleMania victory still mean as much? No. It becomes a fluke. Fans will start viewing Brock as someone who got lucky, and the fact that he's responsible for bringing The Streak to an end will be overshadowed by a loss when it really mattered. After all, the feud between Lesnar and The Undertaker going into WrestleMania 30 wasn't that great and actually ended up being rather forgettable (the fact that Brock being stabbed in the hand by a pen was a highlight says it all really). As a result, going into WrestleMania, everyone was convinced that while the two would no doubt have a good match, The Streak would remain in tact. It just didn't feel all that important. SummerSlam on the other hand is being billed as the biggest rematch ever by the hyperbole loving WWE. If Lesnar loses that, it matters just as much as The Streak coming to an end - if not more so - and makes that historic WrestleMania moment a footnote in the story between these two titans.
2. A Non-Finish Of Some Sort Would Be More Exciting
So, if The Undertaker winning is the wrong move and the WWE doesn't want to have Lesnar gain a second victory over the Phenom, how else could this match end? How about with the ever unpopular no-contest ruling? While those are often the worst way possible to bring a PPV to an end, there's a lot of potential here for one of those. For starters, it will give the WWE the choice to redo this rematch somewhere down the line. With no definitive victor at SummerSlam, fans would no doubt be excited to see these two once again clash. More importantly, a non-finish caused by interference could set the stage for an even bigger match in the not so distant future. Picture this: The Undertaker is about to deliver the final blow to Lesnar only for the arena to go dark and the sound of crows to blast through the Titantron. Just like that, you'd have that long rumoured match with Sting ready to go at next years' WrestleMania. How about The Rock returning to take vengeance on Lesnar for what his did to his cousin and for Heyman's comments about his family? Those are just a couple of random possibilities which would be better than The Undertaker emerging victorious. While Brock winning would ultimately be Best for Business, I would happily sacrifice that for an open ending which sets up something even more exciting than this much hyped rematch!
1. It's The Predictable Outcome
Whether it was the fault of a concussion or not, the match between The Undertaker and Brock Lesnar at WrestleMania 30 really wasn't that great. While it was far from bad, it's nowhere near one of their best encounters and wasn't close to even being the best bout on the card that night. What makes it memorable and special is the way it ended. No one saw that coming from a mile off; Daniel Bryan in comparison ending the the night as the WWE World Heavyweight Champion was always a given. The Undertaker winning at SummerSlam really does feel like the most likely and predictable outcome as of right now. After all, surely they're not going to have Lesnar beat him for a second time in a row? Well, for the points I've outlined throughout this feature, that's exactly what they should be planning to have happen. You have to believe that both the crowd in Brooklyn and those watching at home are going to be going in with the belief that The Undertaker is going to get his redemption next Sunday, so Brock once again getting a definitive victory over the Deadman is guaranteed to have jaws on the floor. Brock winning doesn't feel like a given at this point; it feels like something which could happen, but probably won't. While it's sure to p*ss off a lot of fans, having The Undertaker lose yet again helps to keep Lesnar as WWE's top dog and ensures that this is a SummerSlam which easily has an impact as big as that of any WrestleMania either in the past or future...