When the Fertitta brothers parted with $2 million at the start of the century, they got little more than the UFC name which at the time stood for controversial cage fighting which had little business success. At the same time, Vince McMahon's WWF was breaking pay per view box office records for pro wrestling, enjoying a wave of popularity off of characters like The Rock and Stonecold Steve Austin. A savvy young promoter named Dana White looked at the WWF and realised something vital, as much as people paid to see a fight, they paid to see an emotional narrative. Taking a small stake in the UFC and the presidency, White set about to apply McMahon's business model on to a real sports setting. He encouraged characters such as Ken Shamrock and Tito Ortiz, implemented pro wrestling style feuds and documented them as narratives to sell fights. He also borrowed much of the same WWF production standards, taking note of how Kevin Dunn had made slick presentation work. Business took off. The UFC was transformed from unsophisticated cage fighting into the elite sport of Mixed Martial Arts. Pro Wrestling styled feuds helped to sell the contests, best demonstrated by the Sonnen vs Silva storied feud which popped a reported 1 million buys at UFC 148. White has made no qualms in admitting he copied Vince's promotion and pay per view model. It would have seemed unbelievable in 2000, but by the end of the decade, Vince was scraping PPV buys at 200k as White enjoyed months in the region of 700k. UFC had started doing sports entertainment better than its inventor. The matches were real, but everything around the UFC in its hottest period was pure McMahon levels of building characters and promoting feuds to sell a monthly card. I'm all for enjoying MMA from a purist sporting point, but there's no denying the mainstream popularity emerged from the more superficial storytelling point. MMA enthusiasts scoff at the relation, but there are more shared values of sports entertainment, 10 of which this feature will detail to illustrate UFC and WWE are operating sales in the same industry...
10. Success Of Ultimate Fighter Off The Back Of Raw
The ignition of UFC's hottest period of business started off of the back of WWE's Monday Night Raw. Literally. In 2005 Spike TV and UFC launched 'The Ultimate Fighter' reality show in the time slot immediately after Raw, gaining a 57% retention rate of Vince's audience. The ratings for TUF grew and grew, proving a catalyst for the boom in UFC interest over 2006 and onward. In The Ultimate Fighter Tv show, White had finally found the story telling device he needed to apply meaningfulness to the UFC. It wasn't just about fights, it was about human stories. This is what Vince has been doing for two decades, and all of a sudden, sports entertainment fans found themselves preferring UFC's version of conflict narratives. The reason? Pretty clearly because UFC was real human stories against McMahon's increasingly far fetched narratives that involved boogeymen and lepreachauns. The new 2014 WWE Tv deal could see this shared evening scenario yet again. Why would the Network schedule them together? Because they're both sports entertainment with a shared fanbase.
9. Both Are Cyclical Businesses Who Rely On Creating New Stars
What has emerged in the UFC in the last few years is a drop in fortunes. It isn't anything horrificly bad, but Ultimate Fighter tv ratings are nowhere near what they used to be. Pay per view is also down. The big characters of the peak MMA era such as Liddell, Ortiz, Lesnar and Couture are gone. Anderson Silva and Geoge St Pierre look pretty much done too. The impressive buy numbers and tv ratings have cooled off for the most part although still hot for specific stars like Silva. Dana White has found this problem because he copied Vince's way of doing business and this is exactly what Vince found after his stars such as Austin and Rock left. One of the biggest problems of the last decade for WWE has proved to be reversing the decline in PPV buys, which has ultimately led them to launching their own network. White's way of addressing his business decline is different, he's desperately trying to create new stars. The problem is, the likes of Chris Weidman are never going to replace an Anderson Silva. Jon Jones continues to emerge as the new face of UFC, as does Ronda Rousey. However, they are simply Cena and Batista to WWF's Rock and Austin. The fact is sports entertainment is cyclical and coming off a hot era it's almost impossible to have another big period. Fan perceptions are locked on to the past stars, the new generation are unfairly compared which diminishes their ability to emerge in their own right. As for Rousey, a few years ago White declared women would NEVER fight in his octagon. He's having to change all of his values as he looks for his next face of the company.
8. Athleticism
Let's get one thing straight, WWE stars in 99% of cases could never make it in UFC. The world of MMA is infinitely tougher than WWE and the majority of UFC prerequisites are either completely lacking in pro-wrestlers or would take a year of training to instil. Brock Lesnar is a physical freak, he achieved UFC success, but who else in WWE could conceivably do what he did? Who has the athletic background and attributes of elite strength, speed, power and stamina? No one. CM Punk has teased a turn in MMA but with no formal jiu jitsu belt he would need at least a year of elite training first. Even then, Dana White would most likely only use him as an Ultimate Fighter tv ratings gimmick like he did with Kimbo Slice. MMA at the PPV level is so elite now that Punk could never catch the top ten contenders up. Still, although transitions are highly unlikely, you can't deny that both WWE and UFC have shared values of athleticism. Take a look at a Daniel Bryan match, he's enjoyable because he shows off a range of agility, pace and strength. As fans we enjoy both WWE and MMA because they have athletic events at their core.
7. The Cult Of Personality
One of the most interesting shared values of WWE and UFC is they're both headed by cults of personality. It's hard to imagine WWE without Vince McMahon, likewise it's difficult to imagine UFC without Dana White. They are the embodiment of what their business stands for, powerful and creative figures who lead with forceful personality. What we can learn from this is that a sports entertainment business needs a cult leader. Even WCW had it with Bischoff. By having a man who will put his neck on the line as the promoter, who will live his business, the company benefits greatly. The ambition of McMahon and White has dragged their business to success. McMahon did it in the 80's when he took a regional company and put it on a global scale via closed circuit broadcasting. White did it in the 2000's when he took a close to extinct cage fight concept and transformed it into a sport. The confidence and unwavering belief made both men multi-millionaires. By the end of 2010 however it was White who was by far the better promoter. More aware and in touch with his audience (literally on twitter) White has been able to promote a product that regularly answers fan expectations. McMahon meanwhile has been lost, but could be set to re-emerge and show White the way with the implementation of the WWE Network.
6. A Shared Digital Future
When Dana White branded the WWE Network "ridiculous" he was basically admitting that he was in the same industry as Vince. He was peeved that Vince was shaking the PPV model they both worked on. White then went on the attack, stating that Vince had de-valued the WWE product by giving away everything for ten dollars a month. White sounded almost frustrated. Why did he care? Because he knows that his own business is essentially the same industry, he knows his own PPV model now looks expensive and outdated. If the WWE Network is success, White knows he will have to follow suit. For the first time in a long time, WWE are showing the UFC what will be the future. Granted UFC already offers the Fight Pass, but the Network is a wholly different concept. As a complete package it locks WWE fans into the sports entertainment world. Pay per view suddenly looks antiquated, the digital mode is the future and even the wider TV industry is taking notice. White said he wouldn't follow suit, but he also said a woman would never fight in UFC. If WWE Network is a success there'll be talks in Zuffa for sure about the future of PPV to digital.
5. Long Term Future
In addition to digital media, the long term future of both WWE and UFC is tied in other ways. If they end up on the same Network which they could do with the WWE TV rights discussions ongoing, then there'll inadvertently be cross promotion and audience sharing just like 2005. The fact is that both UFC and WWE are still locked on the same target market, 18 to 35 year old males. The future is built around who best engages that audience. WWE might target PG but their ratings reflect they're still an adult audience. As both companies look to the long term future they'll continue to learn and adapt from each other. We've already seen this happening with UFC learning the power of feuds from WWE. Likewise McMahon is learning from UFC the importance of fans wanting a more hard hitting product - which if you take a look at WWE ring style from the last few years it's increasingly the 'in' thing to use MMA influenced move sets with stars like Punk, Bryan, Lesnar and Undertaker. Going after the same fanbase, UFC and WWE constantly have their eyes on each other whether they want to admit it or not. The future of WWE will involve more MMA style realism, meanwhile the UFC will try to recreate WrestleMania when they eventually book a supershow at Cowboys Stadium or Madison Square Garden when New York finally allows MMA.
4. The Implementation Of MMA In WWE
In further developing the last point, the slow subtle change of WWE ring style is actually hugely owing to MMA. Whereas UFC borrowed storyline inspiration from WWE, the pro wrestling outfit has borrowed move inspiration from Ultimate Fighting. Undertaker was one of the first to adapt his ring style to be built around MMA holds and attacks, stating in 2003's 'Unscripted' book that he believed the WWE product would end up like Ultimate Fighting. In some ways his prediction came true. While still entirely fake obviously, WWE matches now have several aspects of jiu jitsu and MMA strikes built into their spots. In 2012 we witnessed CM Punk and Daniel Bryan dominate the ring with MMA inspired kicks and holds. Brock Lesnar is another man who has made WWE more like MMA, having came back to WWE as a successful UFC Champion he has helped to get over the idea of Ultimate Fighting being used in WWE - something we first witnessed on a smaller scale with Ken Shamrock back in 90's. This time around it's a bigger influence and the style is throughout the pro wrestling product. As WWE evolves alongside UFC its ring style is undoubtedly more MMA influenced than it was ten years ago.
3. Both Sell Their Product As Sports
As WWE look to make a big money return on their up for grabs TV rights, they've marketed their product as 'sports' to potential broadcasters. This will no doubt infuriate purist MMA fans where the competition really is a sporting contest of ability. Admittedly, there's nothing about WWE that could be considered sport. It's fixed. It has more in common with a rehearsed performing arts routine than it does a fight. It flat out isn't combat, if a pro wrestler lands a punch then they are not doing their job properly. Still, WWE are now declaring themselves a sport in order to attract a Network, with the belief that live sport concepts are more attractive due to the need to watch instantly as opposed to DVR. I guess that the broadcasters might be convinced that WWE is a sport in the context of it being 'acted sport'. It's also worth noting that rehearsed performances are Olympic sports in some cases. So WWE's athletic brand of performance really isn't a million miles away from being sport. Keep your eyes peeled on Raw as they make some subtle changes of their product to make it more like sport, probably taking it closer to the presentation of UFC than it ever has been.
2. Narratives
The biggest thing WWE and UFC have in common is that they both tell stories in order to sell cards. Take a look at this video of Brock Lesnar, it could easily have been a WWE production. Lesnar talks about how he is going to beat Frank Mir up and then kicks a door down. It's almost like the way he said he was going to beat John Cena up or the way he gets aggravated in the ring in WWE promos. UFC applies these sort of vignettes for all their top stars. It builds anticipation and makes a fight seem even more compelling, a conflict between two guys who hate each other is way more dramatic than a fight between two guys who get along. Essentially UFC applies the exact same face / heel formula WWE made popular, casting their fights in this way whenever they can. If UFC want to re-ignite their hot period of business, more than ever they need to cast their fighters as defined characters who are fighting in a personally charged feud. Take a look at UFC's history of top drawing matches , characters and story fuelled the success as much as the sporting context did ... a pro wrestler in fact being MMA's top ever draw.
1. The Choice Of What To Buy
UFC and WWE can be seen as a shared industry when they land on the same weekend. When it comes down to it, UFC on a Saturday night or WWE on Sunday night, some fans can only afford one event. I myself have been in this situation in the past. For fans like myself, UFC and WWE are absolutely in competition for my money. That can be applied to a much broader stroke, the 18-35 male dynamic is something I'm part of. UFC and WWE are going after people from that representative for a $50 dollar pay per view buy in a time when money is tight. From a business standpoint and the fact that both UFC and WWE are on the same pay per view platform, it absolutely makes them competitors. The extent to which WWE and MMA fans crossover is also demonstrated by sites like F4Wonline, the leading pro wrestling website is now as much an MMA site as it is WWE. As fans we like storied conflict, we find this entertainment in both UFC and WWE. One is a shoot and the other a work, but both are sports entertainment.