10 Comic Writers Who Need To Stop

It's for everybody's sake, guys

By Tom Baker /

Dark HorseThe life of a comics writer is not an easy one. Even if the financial, personal and professional strains don't totally crush your will to live, you've got to contend with the crippling expectations of fans who have been reading characters for years if not decades, who will be intimately familiar with the history of comics and possibly your own track record. Anything you do will be judged against an endless stream of irrational metrics, and chances are you won't come up trumps. Us comics readers are notoriously fickle, and boy do we love to complain about stuff nobody else cares about. Sometimes though, we're right on the money. Whilst we can't necessarily expect monthly masterpieces from writers who are probably spinning a half dozen different yarns every couple of weeks just to stay afloat, we can expect them to write stuff that isn't utter garbage. We don't think it's unrealistic to expect writers to produce work that isn't offensive, lazy, nonsensical, or terrible. We also don't think writers should rest on the laurels of either their past material or the character they're working on. There's a heck of a lot of people penning funnybook scripts, and not all of them are good. From plain terrible writers to former stalwarts who have fallen on hard times, here are ten comic writers who just need to stop. Please, guys.

10. Rick Remender

Marvel ComicsThe inspiration for this article came originally from the #firerickremender campaign that has been setting the social media multiverse into a bit of a tizzy these past couple of days. The contention over the current Captain America writer turned out to be completely unfounded, based on a misreading of the most recent issue of the title - wherein The Falcon gets drunk and sleeps with Jet Black Zola, who people were claiming is 14 when she's actually - has since been widely discredited by industry professionals and other fans alike. Which is kind of a shame, because it means a lot of the crappy things that Remender has written are going to be fobbed off as similar Tumblr-born moral panics. Formerly an animator who worked on the likes of the Iron Giant, Rememender made his break into comic books on indie titles like Fear Agent and, um, XXXombies (how do you even pronounce that?) before getting talent scouted by Marvel. Since then he's become the lead writer on the Captain America book and headlined Uncanny Avengers, a team with a 50/50 X-Men and Avengers split which has been its own source of contention. Besides the hacky, unnecessarily violent "twists" Remender is so found of, both Cap and Uncanny Avengers have also seen some inherently problematic parts. Like in Avengers when he preached racial assimilation in the form of Havok rejecting the designation of "mutant", all the more dodgy when you consider the X-Men's use as a Civil Rights analogue. The fun, jaunty Captain America has meanwhile been bogged down with misogyny, racism, and just plain bad writing. For these crimes, Rememnder, we banish you. May god have mercy on your soul.

9. Tony Daniel

DC ComicsThat one was pretty tough going - a bad writer and totally offensive! - so for number nine on our list we're just gonna go with a plain terrible writer. Tony Daniel, as an artist, isn't anything too terrible. Pretty unremarkable, sure, but not terrible. It's when he's allowed to not only draw but write comics that he really shows himself up as an awful excuse for a storyteller. Following his feted collaborations with Grant Morrison on the title, Daniel was handed complete control over the Batman-starring Detective Comics. To disastrous results. It's clear where Daniel's talents lie, and it's not with writing. He does try, bless him, but we're just not sure he has it in him. His structuring was incredibly sloppy, to the degree that an issue which switched between flashbacks and the "current day" was totally incomprehensible because of the way it was written. When he wasn't been totally obtuse he was being way too obvious, signposting character arcs and "twists" from a mile off, and it seemed at times like he thought the audience were stupid enough not to catch on. Everything got explained over and over again, slowing the pace and being a might condescending. He earned some leeway by following a truly execrable run by Judd Winick but, really, Daniel's Batman wasn't all that much better. Daniel really surpassed Winick by having basically no ability as a writer, being seemingly unable to write any of his characters consistent throughout his time on the book, tossing in blood and guts to compensate for any real depth or maturity. We're not saying you should quit comics completely, Mr Daniel, just perhaps to consider sticking to the drawing board.

8. Scott Lobdell

DC ComicsLike Daniel, Scott Lobdell hasn't particularly done anything outright insulting in his comics work, but he has done a lot of terrible writing and when faced with criticism has admitted he couldn't "find it in heart to apologize." He has also, admittedly, done some good for the constantly under-fire New 52 DC Comics reboot, introducing characters of different races, genders and sexualities to the Teen Titans book. At the same time, however, he was the jerk behind the totally terrible Red Hood And The Outlaws which, besides just being an incredibly mediocre superhero comic, reintroduced Starfire to the world. Previously Starfire had been one of the strongest, most complex female characters DC had going. She was interesting, fierce, conflicted, and had a neat power set. Under Lobdell's rule, she became a brainless, sex-crazed bimbo of the sort that exist only in the imaginations (and web browsers) of similar total creeps. We'll also note here that we're not calling Scott Lobdell a creep because of something he wrote in a comic, but because of the time he sexually harassed a female comics professional on stage at a convention. And admitted to it. What a guy! Even doing the whole separating-art-from-artist thing, the stuff that Lobdell writes simply isn't any good. It's of a piece with the last big downswing the industry had, the mid-nineties slump where nobody was buying comic books and so the people writing them felt no compunction to make them any good. Everything he's been behind has been thoroughly mediocre and for that, along with the aforementioned creepiness, we cast thee out.

7. Chris Claremont

Marvel ComicsLook, we all love the X-Men*. Of course we do! What kind of geeks would be if we didn't have a soft spot for Marvel's merry band of mutants, especially in a year when the comics have reached a new high and Bryan Singer reminded us that the movie adaptations don't all have to be hot garbage? It wasn't always so, however, as nary a decade after their creation the X-Men comic was on the verge of being cancelled. It was the work of one team that single-handedly rescued them from obscurity, produced some of the most iconic stories ever and hurtled them back into the collective consciousness however: they were artists John Byrne and Dave Cockrum, and writer Chris Claremont. Days Of Future Past and The Dark Phoenix Saga both came from the mind of Claremont, the British-born and American-raised writer who has since become synonymous with the mutants. There's no denying his legacy, or the fact that he made the X-Men who they are today. There's not a lot said about what a truly awful writer he is, however. Not in terms of his plotting or ideas (mostly), but in what he actually chooses to put down on paper. At times it seems Claremont actively hates his artist, as he endeavours to cover up as much of the page with dialogue and text boxes. Oh, the text boxes. Never have you seen such exercises in florid hyperbole, as Claremont shirks the "show don't tell" rule that's even more true for a narrative form that relies as much on images as text, perhaps best illustrated by a page in a seventies X-Men book where the omniscient narrator actually has a go at Cyclops and works him up into a right tantrum. Claremont had a lot of good ideas, but nowadays his writing style is pretty embarrassing to behold. *Except Gambit.

6. Garth Ennis

DC ComicsPreacher is one of those stalwarts of the comic book canon, one of the most popular titles put out by DC's mature readers Vertigo line and, for many, the first "grown up" title that many fanboys read. It's still remembered fondly today for its gonzo blend of bad taste humour, violence, and heresy, along with the grotesque artwork of Steve Dillon. The real mastermind behind Preacher, however, was Garth Ennis, and it's amazing to see how little he has developed as a writer since his mid-nineties masterpiece. Let's put it this way: Garth Ennis is like the buddy you had at school that you thought was the sharpest, funniest and coolest guy around. He told you great jokes that you recall fondly to this day, he introduced you to new ways of thinking about the world, and for a while there you aspired to be everything he was. A few years down the line you bump into him, maybe when you're back in your hometown for a school reunion or something, and at first you're relieved to see he hasn't changed a bit. Then you realise that it's kinda sad than, in the intervening years, he has remained exactly the same - especially when you begin to realise his jokes are pretty homophobic, his "insight" is absolute nonsense, and maybe he's actually kind of a douche? That's where we are with Garth Ennis now. He's still peddling the exact same trite, "woah comics are for kids but these ones have boobs and swears in!!!" malarkey that he made his career on, and it's really starting to get old. Especially when the more uncomfortable aspects of his mature themes start getting pushed more to the forefront, and you realise that for all the puerile fun and games, this is actually really not okay. Also The Boys is awful and we're not fond of Crossing, either.

5. Geoff Johns

DC ComicsGeoff Johns is one of the most successful writers working in comics today. We don't think there's a DC character he hasn't written at this point, and he's been such a big draw for the company that he was one of the key architects working on the New 52 reboot that sent all of their properties back to square one. Since then he's helmed the big Forever Evil crossover event and been the lead writer on both Justice League and Superman. 50,000,000 fanboys can't be wrong, can they? Well, yeah, they probably can. And are. They are definitely wrong in this instance, because Johns is an irredeemably terrible writer. The first issue of his Superman run, which came out last month, included some terrific artwork by John Romita Jr and Klaus Johnson, and a career-worst script by Johns. Where everything the art team was doing was fresh and new, Johns was trotting out some tired tropes of genre storytelling - namely the doppelganger of the main character who's probably gonna turn out to be evil - and writing some of the most on-the-nose expositional dialogue this side of a Final Fantasy game. His basic technique stinks, and it's just as bad if you take in the whole view. The biggest crime you could accuse Johns of is being stuck in the past, something which he can actively try and resurrect with his vaunted position of Chief Creative Officer at DC. Nostalgia is a dangerous thing, and simply returning the good old days will often result in creative stagnation - which is something Johns is all about, consistently retconning character developments and the like out of existence in favour of making stuff stay the same. Forever. Which is really boring. And badly written. And that's why we don't like cricket. Sorry, Geoff Johns.

4. Mark Millar

IconAllow us to recycle something we wrote previously about the universally acclaimed writer of Kick-Ass, Wanted and Ultimates: Mark Millar is a sad, small man. Mark Millar is The Narrator from Fight Club, a man who has bought into the idea of the emasculated modern male, who has to reassert his dominance by indulging in crass violence, language and treatment of women. Mark Millar is also fantastically rich, and doesn't care what we write about him, which means we can keep calling his manhood and/or sanity €“ certainly his good taste €“ into question as much as we want and it doesn't matter. Just so you don't think we're being totally lazy, that's actually an incredibly post-modern and meta criticism of Mark Millar in and of itself. Because along with writing comic books that are incredibly cynical in their use of violence, sex and misogyny in place of actual maturity (this is all sounding a lot like Ennis...) Millar's writing is also incredibly cynical in that pretty much every creator-owned work he's produced in the past ten years has been done explicitly to try and get a movie adaptation made. That's where the real money is these days, after all. We truly believe that Mark Millar doesn't care about comic books. He cares only about how much he can make from the film rights, which is why ever since Wanted and Kick-Ass became box office gold he has focussed on creating new series after new series, with self-contained plots that would just be perfect for a ninety minute run time. Plus there's the fact that his stories are frequently totally tedious and include lashings of sexism, racism and homophobia. Still, see you all at the premiere of Kingsman: The Secret Service, eh?

3. Frank Miller

Dark HorseNow this one is a doozy. Frank Miller is one of, if not the most famous and beloved artists working in comics. He is known not only amongst fanboys but also in the mainstream, as his deconstructions of superheroes in the eighties allowed his work to crossover to more discerning literary types and his Sin City film adaptation with Robert Rodriguez got his work out to film fans who otherwise would have remained unaware of him. That reputation isn't totally unfounded, either, since his run on Daredevil in the eighties certainly did a lot for the medium both in the themes it addressed and in terms of what could be done with art and layouts in superhero books, The Dark Knight Returns and Year One remain high water marks for Batman stories, and the Martha Washington graphic novels are often-overlooked gems. What's he done for us lately, though? Not a whole lot, as it goes. Besides outing himself as the right-wing reactionary we'd always expected with his comments on the Occupy movement, Miller's recent comics have been both politically incorrect and just plain terrible. The Dark Knight Strikes Again, his long-awaited follow up to the Dark Knight Returns, was a complete mess narratively and with its horribly congested art style, suggesting somebody who'd just gotten Photoshop and was much too enthused with the gradient tool. His most recent graphic novel, Holy Terror, is just as illegible, with some casual Islamophobia thrown in for good measure. The thing is, Miller might always have been this terrible. His Daredevil run is hilarious in its humorlessness, something that even the stony-faced Alan Moore pointed out, The Dark Knight is a cynically "gritty" remake of Batman in the style of Mark Millar, and Sin City is a pretty rubbish do-over of pulp and noir tropes which weren't particularly interesting in the first place. He also has a rather unfortunate preoccupation with Nazis and swastikas, which somehow even made its way into his big-budget film version of the Spirit. Like the opposite of a fine wine, Frank Miller is only getting worse with age - and he wasn't great to begin with - so we could do without him ever making another comic ever, thanks.

2. Alan Moore

DC ComicsLook, we know that Alan Moore is the preeminent comic book sacred cow. And not just because he's a bit of a dopey thing that lives in a field in Northampton, as Moore has written some of the most well-regarded comics the medium has ever produced, including (but by no means limited to) Watchmen, The League Of Extraordinary Gentlemen, V For Vendetta, and turns on Swamp Thing and Batman - his Killing Joke often topping lists of the best funnybooks ever to feature the Dark Knight. He's also a writer we could do with never reading anything by again. Like Miller, it's been a diminishing returns type of deal with Moore. In recent years each new stories connected with the famously eccentric scribe have grown to be met with sighs and snorts of derision, rather than the palpable excitement that used the herald each announcement of an Alan Moore comic, as if he was Moses come down from the mountain with stone tablets telling us where sequential art will go in the future. These days you're more likely to see Moore slagging off the state of superhero comics, which he has suddenly become incredibly superior to, or bad mouthing innocent journalists, or simply stating that he's going to do another series about a beloved childhood character having sex. Little Nemo In Slumberland is his next target. We're also just getting a bit tired of Alan Moore's shtick. When you thumb through his greatest hits, as we did at the top of this entry, it implies a sort of impressive eclecticism, a hopping from genre to genre that would've made Stanley Kubrick jealous. In reality, Moore's stories are all pretty much the same - at least his famous ones are. In each one he "deconstructs" a well known genre or facet of popular culture, whether it be superheroes or Victorian literature, and then expects you to be impressed by how clever he is. He actually is pretty clever, but that's not really enough to make a good story. So often the actual content of an Alan Moore comic is lost to the sands of time, because not a lot actually happens in them. And you have to put up with that smug feeling without, as if he's sat in the room with you eagerly awaiting your fawning praise. For being a broken record and making us all feel like idiots for reading comic in the first place, we are done with you, Mr Moore.

1. Stan Lee

Marvel ComicsWe know what you're thinking - Smilin' Stan Lee? Stan The Man? That charming old dude who turns up in all of the Marvel movies, a small tribute to the lives he has improved through his many comic book creations, from Spider-Man to the Avengers? That's a writer you're sick of? WhatCulture, go home. You are drunk. Well first of all, we've only had like two beers, and second of all, we'd've been saying this even if there wasn't any booze involved. Stan Lee may have played a considerable part in bringing superhero comics to their current status, but that doesn't make him a good writer. He definitely isn't. It was Lee's name on all of those early Iron Man, Hulk and Fantastic Four stories, but how much writing he actually did...well, we don't know. Actually we do, and it wasn't all that much - the bulk of the storytelling was handled by the artists, working off of a rough outline by Lee, who then went in and added all the dialogue and narration boxes. Which are overwhelmingly the worst part of any sixties Marvel comics, full of terrible attempts at being "hip", jokes that don't land and speech patterns that we can't believe made sense even back then. Still, didn't stop him from taking all the credit and money, did it? Stan Lee's real strength has always been as an ideas man, and really he was much more comfortable in the role of Marvel's editor-in-chief, where he made business decisions rather than creative ones. It's that same acumen that has made him into the quasi-celebrity he is today, as he shamelessly crops up in all the most visible places saying all the right things so you buy him as the kindly old man who made your childhood magical. Which is good, because his actual creative ideas over the past twenty years have been nothing to write home about. Yeah, Stan Lee is still writing comics and by no means should you seek them out. One of them's called Striperella, for glob's sake. And another is a manga called Heroman. In the early noughties he even defected to DC for a series called Just Imagine... where he put his own spin on the distinguished competition's flagship characters. All of which were terrible. For the love of your legacy, your fans, and the poor misguided fools who keep buying anything with your name on it...please, Stan, stop. Excelsior!