10 More Most Inappropriate Marvel Comics Storylines Ever

Those bewildering and offensive Marvel story arcs that unbelievably happened.

By Andrew Pollard /

Created by Martin Goodman back in 1939 as Timely Comics, Marvel Comics is a true powerhouse of the industry and beyond. Formally changed to the Marvel name in 1961 - following a stint as Atlas Comics - this world of superheroes and supervillains has forever caught the attention and interest of generation after generation.

Advertisement

While the pages of the Marvel books over the decades have largely seen those heroes fighting the good fight, doing what's right, overcoming insurmountable odds, and being role models for youngsters around the globe, there have been those other times where the creative powers at this comic book juggernaut have delivered stories that are distasteful, disrespectful or downright stomach-turning in how unsuitable they are.

Given the title of this piece, this list serves as a sequel to 10 Most Inappropriate Marvel Comics Storylines Ever. As such that means that *deep breath* Shang-Chi's original backstory, Hank Pym's abuse of Janet van Dyne, Moon Knight's homophobic slurs, that infamous Spider-Woman cover, the incestuous Ultimate Maximoffs, the incestuous Hulks of Old Man Logan, Hulk's orgy, the sexual assault of Carol Danvers, Gwen Stacy and Norman Osborn's children, and the radioactive sperm of Peter Parker (yes, really) are all off the table.

With all of that in mind, then, here are ten other times that Marvel Comics left readers in bewilderment at what they'd just read.

10. How Angel And Husk Consummate Their Relationship

Chuck Austen's 2000s run on Uncanny X-Men is one that firmly split opinion amongst long-time fans of Charles Xavier's band of merry mutants. To make matters worse for Austen, his ham-fisted time on that title happened whilst Grant Morrison was wowing over on the New X-Men book.

Advertisement

Amongst the many, many questionable moments of Austin's run, was the relationship between Angel and Husk.

There are so many weird elements to this situation, which came to a head in Uncanny X-Men #440. There, when original X-Men member Warren Worthington III and the much younger Paige Guthrie become romantically entwined, Warren sits down to have a heart-to-heart with Paige's mother. Not just does Angel explain how he's afraid of having something horrible happen to yet another love interest, he also reveals how Husk had already died whilst under his supervision, and he managed to revive her.

Despite the age gap between Angel and 19-year-old Paige, her ma is all for Warren becoming an official item with her daughter. Not just that, but Husk berates Warren about how she is of "legal age to make my own mistakes in most states".

If all of that wasn't questionable enough, Angel and Husk fly up into the air and have sex above the head of Paige's mother - complete with one of her daughter's shoes falling onto the startled Lucinda Guthrie.

9. Invisible Woman Becomes A Supervillain After Suffering A Miscarriage

When looking at the Fantastic Four, the beating heart and moral compass of the team is so often Sue Storm.

Advertisement

Whilst Reed Richards' arrogance and obsession with work often gets the better of him, Johnny Storm's hot-headedness can cause him to make rash decisions, and Ben Grimm's inner turmoil and insecurity can rise to the surface, it usually comes down to Sue to steady the FF ship.

Back in 1984, though - in Fantastic Four #267's A Small Loss - Marvel Comics completely bungled the Invisible Woman becoming pregnant with her and Reed's second child. Tragically, the radiation damage previously done to Sue's cells caused her to suffer a miscarriage.

In terms of how this extremely sensitive matter was bungled, Storm and her loss played second fiddle to other parts of this story. Firstly, so much of the focus was on whether or not Reed and Doctor Octopus could co-exist to help save the unborn child. Secondly, once tragedy does indeed strike, everybody just gets on with their business as usual while leaving Sue with her grief..

To only do further injustice to the Sue Storm character, Marvel Comics then had Sue don a bondage-style outfit and become the supervillain known as Malice. Sure, this was due to a scheme from Psycho-Man, but still, this was all so misguided from Marvel.

As for the child Sue lost, thankfully it would later be revealed that young Franklin Richards had managed to save the kiddo, who would become Valeria Richards. Well, until that was all retconned.

8. Cyclops And Emma Frost Hooking Up On Jean Grey's Grave

When the X-Men books are great, they're the best in the medium. However, when the X-titles of the day have been bad, they've been a proper rough, questionable, confusing ride for readers.

Advertisement

Of Charles Xavier's famed team of mutants, one particular person who has made some boneheaded decisions over the decades, is Cyclops.

So often the leader of the X-Men, Scott Summers is a sucker for romance. And by sucker, that means he does some outright disgusting stuff in the name of love. Whilst knowingly shacking up with a Jean Grey clone once Jean died was ridiculous enough, even more baffling from Scott was his decision to use the gravesite of his fallen beau to hook up with his latest squeeze, Emma Frost.

This came back in 2004's Here Comes Tomorrow arc - one of Grant Morrison's few minor missteps of his excellent New X-Men run - and found Cyclops once again battling with his feelings. With Jean very much dead by this point, Scott is unsure whether to follow his urges to move on from Jean and make a move on Frost.

Given how Jean Grey is Jean Grey, she's actually able to 'visit' Ckye from beyond the grave, giving her blessing to seek new love. While that absolutely gives Scott free reign to pursue the White Queen... could the fella not have made the classless move of sharing a kiss with Frost on Jean's resting place? Not cool, Summers. So, so not cool.

7. Leather Boy Commits "Unnatural Acts" On Monkey Joe Before Murdering Him

Monkey Joe had been at the side of Squirrel Girl since her first appearance back in 1991's Marvel Super-Heroes Vol. 2 #8. So, when the furry sidekick was killed off in G.L.A. #3 in 2005, it was a jarring moment for readers.

Advertisement

That death obviously left Squirrel Girl devastated, but even more troubling was the manner in which Doreen's long-standing BFF was offed.

As is explained to the audience, rejected Great Lakes Avengers (and perennial D-list rogue) Leather Boy carried out "unnatural acts" on Monkey Joe before stamping on the poor squirrel's brain.

Death in comics is always a rough, emotional subject, and likewise the death of an animal is a doubly rough, emotional subject. But to have it insinuated that Leather Boy had his wicked way with little Monkey Joe before the creature was murdered, that makes matters all kinds of disturbing.

To add to the 'performance' element of this sadistic act, Leather Boy also carried out this assault while dressed up in a replica Doctor Doom outfit, merely for his own personal amusement and to further get his kicks.

6. X-23's Teenage Prostitute Origin

What some may not know, is X-23 was first introduced in the X-Men: Evolution animated series in 2003. There, she was shown as a Wolverine clone engineered to wipe out Logan. By the time of her comic book bow the following year, a murkier, more questionable element was added to the formative days of young Laura Kinney.

Advertisement

That first comic book appearance came in NYX, where rather than going straight from a Weapon X lab to meeting and eventually trusting the X-Men, X-23 was first seen working as a teenage prostitute who specialised in dealing with clients with all kinds of creepy, torturous tastes.

Working for a sinister pimp named Zebra Daddy, the decision to bring Laura into the comics in such a way was at best questionable, at worst outright ridiculous. In fact, it's a testament to the X-23 character and writers Craig Kyle, Kyle Yost and Marjorie Liu for getting Laura back on track in the comics and making her such a beloved figure - a million miles away from that NYX debut penned by Joe Quesada.

In particular, it was Kyle and Yost's excellent six-part Innocence Lost series of 2005 that showcased X-23's true origin that saw Laura's creation and subsequent struggles as she became an established part of the main 616 canon.

5. Tony Stark's Creepy, Possessive Iron Man Armour

Back in 2000, the My Own Worst Enemy and Blood Brothers tales saw Tony Stark tormented by an extremely possessive suit of Iron Man armour that was deeply in love with Stark.

Advertisement

Due to a mixture of the Y2K bug, an attack from the nefarious Whiplash, and the installation of Jocasta's consciousness, Tony awakens from a heart attack to find that one of his suits has become fully sentient. In addition to this, said suit has had full access to all of Stark's memories and feelings - and thus it compares its own feelings for Tony to the feelings that Tony has for then-love interest Ru Fujikawa.

Still, ol' Shell-head decides to take this suit out for a spin as he looks to track down the aforementioned Whiplash. Upon finding the rogue, though, the armour takes control and brutally beats the villain to death, regardless of Stark's pleas to stop. By the next issue, the sentient Iron Man is threatening Fujikawa's life and soon engages in an all-out fight with Tony Stark.

Easily besting his creator, the armour kidnaps Tony and takes him to an island in the Pacific where the pair later do battle once more. In a twist ending, this battle causes Stark to have another heart attack - a fatal one, for that matter - and this results in the smitten, obsessive Iron Man suit removing its own heart and placing it in Tony's chest in order to save the Armoured Avenger's life.

4. Nightcrawler Becomes The Pope

Much like hearing the words One More Day puts a cold shiver down the spine of Spider-Man fans, the mutter of Holy War amongst X-Men readers will generate a similar such uncomfortable reaction.

Advertisement

Again from Chuck Austen's run on Uncanny X-Men - 2003's Uncanny X-Men #423 and #424, to be precise - this tale finds Kurt Wagner corrupted by a villainous group of the Catholic Church who seek to erase any and all mutants. As part of this scheme, these sinister sorts have Kurt shapeshift into the form of the Pope.

In a loose sense, it's not the central plot of Holy War that's particularly inappropriate, but more in how poorly handled all of this is. What could've been a nuanced, thought-provoking delve into the extremes of Catholicism when it comes to those who are 'different', is instead delivered in a ham-fisted, cartoonish, zany way that makes it impossible to take seriously.

Far too bonkers to be cited as an exploration of problems with the Catholic Church, Holy War is just an all-round clusterf**k of the highest order. There's a small semblance of a point to this story, but any points of validity are lost in a sea of cartoonish slapstick.

3. Hulk Cannibalism And Sh*t Analysis

While the Ultimate Universe has provided some brilliant moments and characters, there have been plentiful times when this corner of Marvel Comics left fans in puzzled bemusement or disappointed disbelief at what they'd just seen.

Advertisement

Step forward, The Ultimates.

Launching in 2002, this was a title that saw Mark Millar and Bryan Hitch provide a modern-day update on the famed Avengers. Set in the confines of Earth-1610, the Earth's Mightiest Heroes - initially consisting of Nick Fury, Captain American, Iron Man, Wasp, Giant-Man and Thor - of this realm went by the name of the Ultimates.

While several takes on beloved characters very much split opinion in The Ultimates, likely none irked long-time fans as much as this depiction of the Hulk. In particularly, the events of The Ultimate #13 left readers flabbergasted at the antics of the Green Goliath.

Here, with the nefarious Herr Kleiser having got the better of the Fury, Cap and co., Hulk was sent into battle. As part of this, a bunch of S.H.I.E.L.D. personnel beat the utter piss out of poor Bruce Banner in order for him to transform into his alter-ego.

Thrown from a helicopter, Banner transforms just in enough time to tackle Klesier, beat him into literal mush... then eat him.

Yep, Ultimate Hulk is a cannibal. Taking this to an even stranger level, the Ultimates later wait for Hulk to sh*t Herr Kleiser out so they can analyse and fully destroy the rogue's remains.

2. Wolverine Tries To Seduce 15-Year-Old Mary Jane Watson

Back in 2004's Ultimate Spider-Man #66 and #67, readers got a story that took a familiar trope and spun quite the fun tale. That trope? Why, it's the classic 'body swap'.

Advertisement

Here, Spider-Man and Wolverine wake up one morning to find themselves in the other person's body. What follows are some genuine chuckles as Peter Parker struggles to not cut off his own fingers, whilst Logan is pissed off at having to go to school and is startled at every turn by his Spider-Sense.

Where things take a dark turn, is when these two heroes are eventually back in their own bodies. There, Peter is aghast when Mary Jane asks, "That thing you tried to do this morning, can we not do that till we're older?" - with the insinuation being that Wolverine, in Parker's body, tried to have sex with MJ.

It's worth stating that Mary Jane Watson is 15 years of age here. To add another layer of creepiness to matters, it's revealed that the teenage Jean Grey was behind the entire body swap experience, with her doing this as punishment to Wolverine for constantly hitting on her.

1. The Punisher Changes Race

It was hugely insensitive when DC Comics made Lois Lane black for one day back in 1970 - the Daily Planet reporter wanting to experience the life of a black woman - and it was just as baffling when Marvel Comics decided to follow suit a whole 21 years later with the Punisher.

Advertisement

For Frank Castle, this change of race came during 1991's The Final Days arc.

Finding himself holed up in prison, Frank is brutally attacked by Jigsaw and his goons, to the point that Castle's face is a complete mess. The Punisher being the Punisher, he manages to escape his confines and make a break for freedom, but the hunt is on - from both the police and from criminals - to find the vigilante.

In order to hide himself from those after him, Frank turns to a junkie doctor who agrees to do facial surgery on him. Once the Punisher awakens, the doc has somehow managed to change Castle's skin colour, his bone structure, his features, his physique, and even given him a haircut "to go with the look".

Realising what a downright awful idea this all was, Marvel would reverse all of this just seven issues later, with the plastic surgery 'wearing off' mid-fight as Frank's longer hair miraculously grew back immediately.

Advertisement