10 Reasons Why Star Trek: First Contact Ruined the Borg

By Adam Borders /

6. Bloodbath

Picard was rescued from the Borg and the implants removed. In Voyager, Seven of Nine was rescued from the Borg and had her implants removed. In €œI, Borg€, Third of Five achieved individuality, even taking on the name €œHugh.€ There would be none of this wanton humanity displayed in First Contact, however. No, in this film Picard, upon seeing an assimilated crew member---shoots him. That€™s right, kill shot right to the chest. Later, another assimilated crew member is gunned down by Jean "Rambo" Picard on the holodeck---a man Picard coldly refers to as Ensign Lynch. Ignoring established canon again---First Contact seems to have forgotten that human beings can be rescued after having been assimilated. They also seem to have forgotten the stun setting. This is beyond a plot hole or discontinuity---this is the flat out rape of what made Star Trek so special to begin with. Gene Roddenberry envisioned a society that would solve problems with peaceful intellect rather than brute force. Now, I€™ll grant you that Gene himself isn€™t likely to have had the Borg in mind, but the fact remains that Star Trek at its core has always been about peace and a utopian society. What we€™re given in First Contact has none of this intact. It has become a sad imitation of a Star Trek film with only a small portion of the original ideas and vision intact. I€™m sure Gene spun in his grave at this offering.