10 Star Trek Episodes That Seriously Deserve A Second Chance

They may not be universally loved, but these episodes aren't anywhere near as bad their reputations.

By Sean Ferrick /

In a franchise spanning almost sixty years, there are bound to be a few episodes that simply slip through the radar. Now, there can be any number of reasons for this - perhaps they simply came out at the wrong time. Maybe the budget didn't do the idea justice. Maybe they were simply in bad need of a second pass through the editing room?

Advertisement

For whatever reason, there are those entries in Star Trek's canon that tend to be thrown to the side. They may be skipped on a rewatch, or even ignored altogether. Perfectly inoffensive, one might describe some of them as.

This list is aimed at those entries. There will be another list for defending the so-called worst episodes of Star Trek (Spock's Brain, I will see that you get your place in heaven), but this list is for the castaways, the forgettable, and the ignored.

There are over eight hundred hours of Star Trek to consume, so not every hour is going to get the recognition that it deserves. For this list, let's see what we can do for some of these poor stories of Trekdom.

10. Resistance

Resistance is an oft-forgotten episode of early Star Trek: Voyager, guest starring Oscar-winning actor Joel Grey. It was also the first story that Michael Jan Friedman and Kevin J. Ryan sold to the franchise, both of whom going on to produce tonnes of content from that point.

Advertisement

The story was described by all involved as a 'Don Quixote' type episode. Grey's Caylem, an older man with trouble accepting reality as it is, mistakes Janeway for his long-deceased daughter. He struggles to fight for a resistance that has been crushed, unable to do anything else.

The episode hangs on the performances, with both Grey and Mulgrew delivering on all fronts. Lisa Klink, who was given the task of writing the teleplay - only a month into her tenure with Star Trek - was asked by the production staff how she felt about Janeway pretending to be a prostitute in one scene. She argued that Janeway was the kind of person who would think nothing of doing whatever it took to safeguard her people.

The episode, which had begun life as a B'Elanna story, features a strong b-plot that sees both she and Tuvok kidnapped and tortured, with them beginning to understand each other much better.

9. 11:59

11:59 tends to get a little bit of a bad rep, owing to its lack of any hard science-fiction. Writer Joe Menosky felt that the premise of the episode simply didn't work, then recalled Rick Berman calling him to tell him how much he loved it. As Menosky said - you just never know.

Advertisement

The episode stands out largely thanks to Kate Mulgrew's performance as Janeway's ancestor, Shannon O'Donnel. This was both an echo of the strong and confident person that Kathryn Janeway is, yet a completely different, somewhat smaller character too. She walks with her head bowed and with her hands in her pockets, though is still well able to verbally spar with Henry Janeway.

Though hardly the most important episode for continuity, it nevertheless is a snapshot of the history of the time. The episode was set in the run-up to New Year's Eve, 2001, although much of the dialogue makes reference to the then-fear of the Y2K bug. Memories of watching this episode on release swim to the surface easily as they discuss the much-hyped non-global catastrophe, while sipping on a beer.

Though the original idea, developed by John de Lancie of all people, could have seen Q and Guinan in the year 2000, this story actually works as it is - a low-stakes example of some great acting, some great old-age make-up, and a car that looks lifted directly from an Alanis Morrissette video.

8. The Empath

There are several third-season episodes of the Original Series that are overlooked as that season as a whole displayed a sharp drop in quality for the show. The Empath was an example of taking a minimalist approach to the story of the week, largely thanks to Robert Justman and director John Erman.

Advertisement

The pair had previously worked on an episode of The Outer Limits called Nightmare. This dealt with a very similar theme to the Empath, so Justman felt confident that Erman could handle it. The director did such a good job with a minimal budget that the BBC refused to air it until the 90s, owing to its themes of torture.

For Star Trek, and particularly early Trek, the scenes are fairly brutal. McCoy's condition, in fact, is perhaps the most difficult part of the episode to watch. The grumbling Doctor is one of the most popular characters in the series, so to see him selflessly put himself in harm's way to protect the captain, and Spock, was a powerful moment.

The episode could easily be transformed into a stage play - the script is solid, the set is easily reproduced, and the story doesn't require any external shots. One is left to wonder that, had there been more episodes like this in the third season, would the Original Series have made it to a fourth year?

7. The Reckoning

The entire Prophets storyline of Deep Space Nine is a bit marmite - people tend to get deeply invested, or feel their eyelids grow heavy, whenever Sisko opens up one of those Orb boxes. But The Reckoning was an example of including the Prophets, introducing the Kost Amojen, and dialling the action up to eleven.

Advertisement

The events of this episode set up the finale of the sixth season, but also much of the final run of the seventh season. Louise Fletcher's pitch-perfect Kai Winn, maddeningly sure of herself, is guaranteed to set your teeth on edge. However, it's her self-righteous indignation that Sisko failed to thank her after her actions that is enough to drive most fans over the edge. There's barely a person alive who wasn't hoping Major Kira would flush her out of the airlock at that moment.

The episode would gain a little more notoriety when the tablet that features so heavily here appeared in the teaser for Star Trek: Picard's second season. Alas, it was simply set dressing! The hearts of so many Trekkies broke when that realisation was made - but there is still this episode to enjoy, along with - it almost goes without saying - a superb performance from Avery Brooks.

6. Hippocratic Oath

This episode falls into the 'O'Brien Must Suffer' camp, but perhaps only tangentially. Really, it is another example of why Bashir and O'Brien do so well together - they are the perfect foil for each other. It's also quite heartbreaking in moments, though that's often not a word one would assign an episode about the Jem'hadar.

Advertisement

The central theme of the episode - that the Jem'hadar are simply victims of addiction who need to be freed - is approached differently by both characters. Bashir immediately sets about curing them, while O'Brien plots a way to escape the planet they've been trapped on. The climactic argument between them - where O'Brien literally uses a disruptor rifle to save Bashir from himself - is one of the strongest moments from their friendship.

The episode does frame another point of view for the Dominion's footsoldiers, but ultimately it's an excellent example of why Alexander Siddig and Colm Meaney work so well together. They both capture their positions perfectly - that heartbreaking moment mentioned earlier involves Bashir pulling rank on O'Brien, the enlisted man. It is perhaps the lowest dig in their entire relationship - one that stings them both, and makes this episode a must-watch.

5. How Sharper Than A Serpent's Tooth

This is an episode that remained almost the same from pitch to release, with minor notes from Gene Roddenberry. It was actually D.C. Fontana who put writers Russell Bates and David Wise on the task of writing about Native American legends. Bates was a Kiowa Native American, something that interested Fontana greatly.

Advertisement

Kukulkan is a deity from Mayan culture, but the script had deliberate jibes toward revisionist history. Particularly, Bates said, toward Europeans. He noted that the grand claims made by settlers - that there was no way that Native Americans could have made the great cities and pyramids without external help - allowed him to get a dig in in this episode.

Kukulkan is revealed to have visited Earth of the past, spending hundreds of years there, teaching all of the peoples how to build their great marvels. This, Bates joked, was his revenge. If the Native Americans couldn't have done it alone, then no one could have!

The episode is easily one of the strongest stories of the Animated Series, with beautiful designs from Filmation, along with the inclusion of Walking Bear - a Native American officer serving in Starfleet.

4. We'll Always Have Paris

To be very clear, there aren't many first-season episodes of The Next Generation that stand out for any good reason. Where stories like Encounter At Farpoint seemed to be doing everything in their power to get the show cancelled, along came a story that dared to be a little different in the show's debut year.

Advertisement

The title is a direct reference to Casablanca, which is arguably the most romantic movie ever released. Why would Star Trek set itself up beside such a giant, and could it pull it off?

Well, no. But, this episode offers a great performance from Patrick Stewart, and guest star Michelle Phillips of the Mamas and Papas is a great love interest for him, even if their relationship is all meaningful looks and stares.

There are some fun time travel moments to enjoy - who doesn't love three Datas and a shiny space beam? But the strength of the episode is in its longing for the past, while accepting the reality of the future. it was an early example of the heady material that The Next Generation would end up diving into, a little more skillfully, as the years went by.

3. Pen Pals

This second season episode of The Next Generation is one of the stronger offerings from that year, even though it tends to fade beside episodes like The Measure of a Man and Q, Who? The tale of Data breaking the Prime Directive to save the life of one child offers the audience one of the first, great discussion scenes in the show.

Advertisement

Picard invites the senior staff to his quarters to discuss Data's actions, which is then followed by a debate - did Data do the right thing, leading to the Enterprise interfering in the natural evolution of a planet, or, did his actions show a lack of judgement?

There are convincing arguments on both sides - Worf may be the stereotypical hardass in the scene, but his argument that the Prime Directive is clear on such matters is solid. In the end, emotion wins the day - the Enterprise does indeed go to Sarjenka's aid - but in true Trek style, this ending was by no means guaranteed.

The episode also features a good b-plot for Wesley Crusher, who in the second season had developed into a more capable, likable character.

2. Acquisition

Enterprise's first season is often forgotten, even on series rewatches, as it struggled to truly figure out what it was. There were shades of the Next Generation and Voyager thrown in for good measure and, to be fair, this episode is a mix of both of them. However, thanks to the guest stars, and Connor Trinneer running around in his underpants for a good portion of the episode, this episode truly is a fun one to revisit.

Advertisement

Jeffery Combs, Ethan Philips, Clint Howard, and Matt Molloy are frankly brilliant as the Ferengi here. While there is a definite rehash of parts of the Next Generation's Rascals here, these stars manage to rise above the rehash to deliver Enterprise's first truly funny episode.

It's as predictable as anything - there was never a chance they'd get away with their heist - but it's highly entertaining watching them try and fail. Combs displays, yet again, why he should be in every version of Star Trek possible, but props must also be given to Jolene Blalock. She manages to convince the Ferengi that she is a slave aboard the ship - and Blalock seems to have an absolute ball in convincing them.

The episode also manages to skirt around canon by never naming their species - something this writer did not appreciate at the time!

1. A Private Little War

A Private Little War is a directly analogy of the Vietnam War, which was still very much ongoing at the time. It shows one of the biggest violations of the Prime Directive that Kirk ever committed, arming one side of a civil war so that the balance of power will be restored. One could easily say that since the Klingons were first guilty of this, then it negates the actions of Kirk.

Advertisement

This is an episode that deserves far more discussion than it seems to receive. First, the weapons. Providing Tyree's people with Flintlock weapons is against all laws of the Federation, yet it is never revisited in a later episode. This is a choice that is easily on par with Janeway's decision to put Tuvix back through the transporter.

Second, the episode introduces Dr. M'Benga, here played by Booker Bradshaw. He would appear only once more in the Original Series, in the episode That Which Survives, though it introduces his skill at treating Vulcans.

Third, it introduces the Mugato, which means that this episode sets up the joke that some of them just like to watch, almost sixty years earlier.

Oh, Star Trek.

Advertisement