10 Ways Warner Bros. Should've Made The DCEU

We could've done without the big crossover as the first sequel.

By Ewan Paterson /

Warner Bros.

Whatever your opinion of the DCEU, it's fair to say that Warner Bros. big cinematic universe hasn't panned out quite the way we all hoped it would.

Advertisement

Right from the very get-go, it was clear that their attempts to ape Marvel's dynamite venture (which turns ten next year, incidentally), weren't going to go according to plan. The ever divisive Zack Snyder was tapped to lay the foundations of the studio's big multi-year, multi-project release slate, and while Man of Steel certainly illustrated some signs of promise, it was clear that this wasn't going to be a universe every fan could get behind.

And that's not to say that the MCU isn't without its detractors - quite the opposite. The point is that each and every DCEU production - barring Patty Jenkins' Wonder Woman - has been greeted by a toxic gaggle of 'fan vs critic' discourse. That's an awful legacy to leave behind, and one made worse by WB's talents using it as a means of deflecting genuine criticism; "it's for the fans" has become a rallying cry for lacklustre comic book adaptations ever since.

Advertisement

Undoubtedly the most frustrating thing about the DCEU, however, is the fact that there were other, more obvious routes WB could've taken. We could've had an intricate, layered and, more importantly, enjoyable universe to invest in (sans Jared Leto). How should they've gone about it? We've got a few ideas.

10. Make A Different Kind Of Superman Film

Warner Bros.

As far as Superman films go, Man of Steel isn't actually all that bad. Sure, it might be littered with Snyder-isms right across the board, from obtuse Christ-like imagery to bloated, overinflated and computer generated fight scenes, but it's not as soulless as one would think.

Advertisement

The problem with the film, fundamentally, is that it's suffocated by the very obvious intention to mark a severe course correction in Superman's filmography. Each and every last cinematic outing to have featured the Last Son of Krypton had made a point of placing the character's symbology front and centre to their proceedings. Action wasn't so much a priority as it was an addition to the bread and butter of the films' stylistic attempts to echo the Fleischer Studio's shorts of the forties and fifties, and so WB - anxious to avoid criticism that their next Supes film could be considered 'boring' - went all in with a director who could (in theory) make a Superman story with plenty of thrills, spills, and Kryptonian space drills.

The resulting product conjured a bleak and emotionally distant incarnation of the Superman mythos, with Henry Cavill in particular missing the mark as Clark Kent. Further to that was the film's controversial climax, which contradicted any kind of optimism conveyed by Hans Zimmer's wonderful (and overlooked) composition.

Advertisement

WB made the right move in electing to use the Man of Steel as a means of kickstarting their shared superhero ensemble, but it lacked balance. Of course fans want to see Superman duking it out with crazy powerful enemies, but he needs a heart too. Laying the foundations of your universe on the bodies of thousands in Metropolis just wasn't the way to go.

9. Save Batman For Another Phase

Warner Bros.

It was always going to be the case that Warner Bros. would look to bring Batman back as soon as possible. Christopher Nolan's Dark Knight Trilogy had dominated the cultural landscape for close to a decade, and while any successor was always going to have a hard time under the cowl and living up to the vision of that saga, WB didn't make life any easier for their chosen candidate.

Advertisement

While it's equally true that Affleck hasn't done nearly enough to assert his Bat-credentials, introducing him in an overinflated comic crossover just wasn't the way to do it. The Dark Knight Rises was barely four years old, and thrusting the Caped Crusader into the mix so early on felt like a cynical measure by a studio lacking confidence in their own burgeoning franchise.

Batman sells - of course he does - but so does the idea of Batman. Much like The Force Awakens delayed the arrival of Luke Skywalker, Snyder et al. could've quite easily saved Bruce Wayne for another day, placing him centrally to the wider narrative of the DCEU whilst affording these newer heroes space to grow and develop into fan-favourite characters.

Advertisement

Instead, we got Batman v Superman, which managed to aggravate fans on both sides of the Bat/Supes divide for a myriad of different reasons.

8. ...And Portray Him Authentically

Warner Bros.

Although Ben Affleck's adoption of the cape and cowl is considered to be one of the few redeeming features of Batman v Superman, there's no getting away from the fact that Snyder fundamentally misreads the character in that film.

Advertisement

Taking inspiration from Frank Miller's dour depiction of the detective, the DCEU's Batman is a shadow of his former self, having lived through a lifetime of muggings, deaths and sidekick departures. It's very much in the Dark Knight Returns mould, except with the bizarre caveat that this newer, older Batman, is partial to the odd gun or two.

Not only does this Batman willingly use firearms as and when he pleases (already a big no no), he kills indiscriminately too. People he 'brands' are killed in prison (for reasons that are never fully explained), he ploughs through people in the Batmobile, and one particularly unfortunate thug dies in an explosion, courtesy of a machine gun bullet to an explosive tank.

Advertisement

It's just not Batman, and while previous cinematic features did depict the occasional death or two, the body count in BVS was beyond the pale. Those two tenets (not using a gun and not killing anyone), are a fundamental component of the character, so it stands to reason that any Bat-film would've fared far better if they'd been implemented authentically.

7. Change Literally Nothing About Wonder Woman

Warner Bros.

Wonder Woman really is the DCEU's one saving grace.

Advertisement

Gal Gadot was already a clear highlight of Batman v Superman, but Patty Jenkins' film deserves praise for taking that element and putting it into a truly compelling superhero adventure. Women-led, historically salient and jam-packed with plenty of wit and warmth, Wonder Woman stands out not only as the best film DC have made this decade, but also for its cultural significance. For years, Marvel have 'ummed' and 'ahhed' when faced with the topic of making a female-led superhero feature, and DC - barely three years into their universe - just set out to get it done.

Talk of an overinflated third act might dog the film slightly, but there's no denying its quality, and there's little that could've been done to change it for the better. If anything, WB might've been wise to kick off proceedings with Wonder Woman, eschewing Bats and Supes for the time being and allowing Diana to herald a new age of heroes thematically and tonally distant to anything that we'd seen before.

Advertisement

With Justice League again reverting the DCEU to type, the torch once more falls to Wonder Woman. Maybe things would've been better if it had been the film to launch everything in the first place?

6. Read More Than One Comic For Inspiration

Warner Bros.

Someone should've probably told the folks at WB that The Dark Knight Returns isn't the only book in DC's library, seeing as how pretty much every release has paid homage to it in one way or another.

Advertisement

That particular comic, first published in 1986, might be one of the most influential in the medium, but there's only so much Miller one can take before things start to feel stale. That, and the DCEU's continued use of New 52 iconography - a comics reboot left behind in 2015 - is pretty jarring, owing to the fact that there are literally dozens of better books out there that WB could be taking inspiration from (a whole ruck of them can be found here).

Even though the MCU gets stereotyped for its ostensibly formulaic nature, there's no denying that dozens of different comics, storylines, writers and artists have factored into the finished product. Captain America: The Winter Soldier takes major inspiration from Ed Brubaker's run on the character from the late 2000s, while Thor: Ragnarok unashamedly embraces Jack Kirby's comics from the bullpen era of the sixties.

Advertisement

This has given the MCU a heterogenous feel, in that it can play to multiple genres and comics whenever it wants. With the DCEU, everything is very much of the Miller mould: dourer, cynical and totally unconventional.

5. Get The Casting Right For Villains

Warner Bros.

A comic book film can only be as good as its villains, so it's no surprise that the DCEU has fallen at that hurdle on the two occasions where it mattered the most.

Advertisement

Jesse Eisenberg was an unconventional casting pick for Lex right off the bat, and audiences were largely rewarded for their scepticism come BVS's release, with the actor spouting some variation of "God, man, night, day, Bat, God, power, man" sequentially right on through to the film's final act. It was dead embarrassing, to be frank, and while other comic book capers have succeeded in spite of a weak villain on plenty of occasions, DC are letting themselves down in this department.

The publisher have some of the finest villains in the medium, and yet they're repeatedly failed by their on-screen counterparts. Jared Leto's Joker was genuinely appalling (that 'Damaged' tattoo says hi), but even he looks to be staying on in the role with a planned Joker/Harley rom-com spin-off. Yuck.

Advertisement

Shifting from the likes of Aaron Eckhart, Liam Neeson and Heath Ledger to... whatever this has been, speaks more to a lack of direction than anything else. DC have Marvel well and truly beat when it comes to their villains, and seeing as how it is - theoretically - the easiest punch to land, it's pretty dire to see the universe falter.

4. Hire Literally Anyone Else To Make Suicide Squad

Warner Bros.

If any DC project could be singled out for being the most disappointing, it would be Suicide Squad.

Advertisement

Directed by End of Watch, Fury and Sabotage alum David Ayer, the cinematic adaptation of DC's very own Dirty Dozen should have been a surefire success. Will Smith was in the lead, Margot Robbie was perfectly cast as Harley Quinn and the team as a whole were shaping up to be an interesting cast of characters.

Advertisement

One thing that undoubtedly exacerbated the Squad's eventual disappointment, however, was the film's marketing, which was pretty spectacular. The trailers seemed to promise this irreverent, sinister action film that had a whole array of top talent at its command, and yet when it released, neither of those elements were able to shine through.

With the benefit of hindsight, it's clear that Suicide Squad was plagued by issues right from the very start of production - a tragedy that was made complete by the decision to bring in a trailer-editing group to chop and change the finished product. If Ayer hadn't been involved, and WB had followed through on the idea with a different creative team at the helm (and someone else to change Joker's design), then it could've been a fine reply to Guardians of the Galaxy.

Advertisement

Instead, fans have to settle for a glorified music video for a superhero film. Bummer.

3. Craft It With Multiple Formats In Mind

The CW

Although it took some time for Marvel to spread the MCU onto different formats, the rise of Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. and the company's Netflix Originals has served them well.

Advertisement

Daredevil, Jessica Jones, Luke Cage and now the Punisher have all debuted to remarkable success over the years, and while DC haven't experienced comparable success in that medium, they do have a formidable small-screen presence to boast. The Arrowverse, for its faults and shortcomings, is still very popular, and yet there's little sign that the DCEU will be venturing to TV anytime soon.

That's a major problem, and although it's true that the majority of people who go out and watch the MCU on the big-screen will rarely checkout their small-screen counterparts, it's another revenue stream DC are neglecting. If they were to turn their attention to Netflix, what with Disney shifting their wears to their own streaming service, their universe would be so much better.

Advertisement

Plus, there are a whole bunch of candidates well suited for that particular medium. Ignoring it the way WB have just doesn't make any sense at all.

2. Take Things Slowly

Warner Bros.

Despite there being a great many DC fans out there who've praised WB's decision to launch straight into Justice League just four films into their universe, the reality remains that it wasn't the best course of action.

Advertisement

Comparisons to the MCU were always going to be inevitable, and while there's cause to argue that WB needed to catch up ASAP - simply because no one knows when the cinematic universe bubble is going to burst - it would've been smarter for them carefully plan just how, exactly, things were going to progress. It doesn't matter if it would take an extra year or two for it to happen, or even if those MCU comparisons were thrown their way, because at the end of the day, things would feel more organic, more compelling, and probably a whole lot less convoluted too.

Batman v Superman exemplifies Warner's failure better than any other film does. It's littered with forced cameos, aimless references and nods to a history that, to the general audience, just doesn't exist. Fans haven't been given a reason to invest in anything because, by making Batman an older bloke, their window into the character's most compelling years has been shut.

Advertisement

A DCEU without the exposition, contrivances and convolution of the one we now currently have would've been so much better to sit through and experience, even if it would've taken a little longer.

1. Have Someone Else Lay Its Foundations

Warner Bros

Zack Snyder is one of the most stylistic directors of our time, but, in the DCEU's case, his involvement just wasn't meant to be.

Advertisement

WB's decision to appoint Snyder in 2011 certainly made sense. Both 300 and Watchmen were, while undoubtedly flawed in their own way, visually impressive. Apart from the fact that both were comic book adaptations, it was clear that Snyder had the nous to make a comic book look good on the big-screen. The problem, which became increasingly apparent in the wake of Man of Steel's 2013 premiere, was that there was little substance to match the style, and for a medium that prides itself upon having something to say, that's a major problem.

On the surface, it's clear what Snyder et al. have aimed to achieve with the DCEU; the whole world's meant to be this mythic pantheon of gods, monsters and mortals, fighting in an abstract reality where personal struggle and melodrama are left squarely at the door. That might be someone's cup of tea, but it's not mine, or doubtless other DC fans who've been left shortchanged by their repeated attempts to love a world that simply does not work.

Advertisement

It's a veritable tragedy of the superhero genre, and while the MCU continues to wow and entertain true believers everywhere, the DC faithful have been well and truly left behind.

What would you have done differently to change the DCEU? Be sure to let us know in the comments below!

Advertisement