When Marvel announced their plans for a cinematic universe it sounded crazy - people thought it could never work. Nearly eight years later they've proved the naysayers wrong many times over. They hired the best actors and directors they could get their hands on; they patiently established the universe by making solo movies leading up to the big Avengers blowout and maybe the most important thing of all they clearly cared about making entertaining movies. DC, on the other hand, seemed completely lost for years with how to build their own; they had the Christopher Nolan's The Dark Knight Trilogy, but he made it clear his Batman could never exist in a world with other superheroes. Their attempt to turn Green Lantern into a franchise was DOA, with plans for their other properties often languishing in development hell. They finally got moving with Man Of Steel, which was a success but met with harsh criticism by fans and critics. With Batman V Superman and Suicide Squad on the horizon theyre finally stumbling towards their goal of a cinematic universe to rival Marvels, but can they overcome some of the big mistakes theyve already made?
11. They Got Off To A Weak Start With Man Of Steel
Marvel launched their cinematic universe with Iron Man; a blockbuster that felt refreshing thanks to a great cast and solid direction. It wasn't faultless, yet it managed to take the story seriously and have some fun, as well as laying a small trail of breadcrumbs that could lead to future movies. DC launched their universe with Man Of Steel; a noisy, overlong blockbuster that featured a lead character with little in the way of charisma. The movie had seriously confused morals (did his Dad really think he should have left a bunch of school kids to drown?) and thought that spectacle was a good substitute for emotion; and when the big set pieces happened most people were checking their watches waiting for it to end. It was a lacklustre way to kick off a potential franchise, and the response to the film has coloured people's perception of DCs plans ever since. Iron Man is still a well-regarded blockbuster, while people only look to Man Of Steel as an example of what not to do.
10. The Characterisation Of Superman
One of the reasons Christopher Reeve became the most iconic actor to play Superman is that he managed to embody the character in both look and personality without making him boring. Superman is a tricky character to pull off; he lacks any real edge and as hes practically invincible its hard to worry about his safety. Yet Reeve managed to make a likeable, relatable character out of an all-powerful super being; something that Man Of Steel failed to do. Besides the fact that Henry Cavill doesnt have the same level of charm, his version of Superman is just kind dull. He has no personality or depth; hes just a square-jawed dude in a cape with a severe Jesus complex. He is brave and selfless seen when he hands himself over to Zod and stops the World Engine yet the film felt he needed more edginess. And thus hes reckless with his powers, as seen with the fights in Smallville and Metropolis, and the film felt the need to give an origin story for his no killing rule when hes forced to break Zods neck. This should come from his innate sense of right and wrong, and not from contrived storytelling.
9. Firing Michelle McLaren From Wonder Woman
DC made a big deal out of hiring acclaimed TV director Michelle McLaren (Breaking Bad, Game Of Thrones) for the Wonder Woman movie, stating that it was important to hire a talented female director to take charge of the character. They kind of shot themselves in the foot when they fired her a short time later, as it turns out she thought shed have some kind of creative input into the story. She and the studio had constant arguments about the direction it should go during pre-production, as they didnt like any of her ideas and she didn't like any of theirs. They hired her exactly because she was a talented director who spoke her mind, but when she wouldnt play along they dropped her for the same reason; which is a little embarrassing. They soon replaced her with Monster director Patty Jenkins, which is a risky choice as shes never directed anything with the scope of a summer blockbuster before.
8. Stuffing Too Many Characters Into Batman V Superman
The smartest part of Marvels plan was releasing solo movies before getting to The Avengers, instead of starting with the epic event and letting the solo movies branch off from there. This gave audiences a chance to know each of the characters first, while fuelling anticaption for their eventual team-up. Warners decided not to go this route, opting instead to cram Batman V Superman with as many characters and plotlines as possible. As if the first big screen fight between the two icons wasnt enough of an event, the movie will also introduce Wonder Woman, Lex Luthor, Aquaman, Cyborg and possibly The Flash and Green Lantern (and maybe a Martian Manhunter cameo if theyre feeling really generous). The conflict between the two titans is more than enough to hold people's attention, with the other characters being added simply to quickly set-up the Justice League movies. As a result, theyll all be fighting for screentime in a movie that should be focused on the title event.
7. Miscasting Key Members Of The Suicide Squad
Suicide Squad is positioning itself as the edgy film in the DC universe, as it has a bunch of villains teaming up to stop a group of other evil people. The film is directed by David Ayer, whos only ever directed bloody action flicks and is said to be a madman to work with, so it should be something different. The Dirty Dozen-style premise means it will rely heavily on the chemistry of the cast, but as key members of the group feel miscast that might be an issue. Charisma black hole Jai Courtney is playing Captain Boomerang, seemingly just because hes Australian. Hollywood appears to be desperate to make Courtney a thing, but the audience keeps saying no. They should take the hint by now. Elsewhere Will Smith will be playing Deadshot, who will presumably be the leading character since hes Will Smith. Smiths ego will see him try to dominate the screen as much as he possibly can, which will be distracting in an ensemble film. The jury is still out over Jared Leto, though it sounds like his method acting made him a nightmare to work with (like director like star). Finally theres Joel Kinnaman, who replaced the great Tom Hardy as Rick Flagg; an idea that could only be worse if he was replaced by Jai Courtney.
6. Copying Marvel's Formula Exactly
DC were content to just sit back and let Marvel Studios bet the farm on their cinematic universe gamble; probably time they could have used to plan their own approach if it worked out. But they waited and waited, and by the time they figured out it was a good idea Marvel had completely left them in the dust. In order to make up for lost time theyre not introducing any new, innovative ideas to their approach; theyre doing exactly what Marvel did, only faster and sloppier. This includes that slamming about five movies worth of material into Batman V Superman, but also announcing a whole slate of future projects and doing the whole crossover thing that Marvel pioneered. This lack of originality could be their undoing; the Marvel approach only worked because they cared about what they were doing. DC is looking to be caring about how much money they can make, and how fast they can make it, something they really need to combat.
5. Making Aquaman Dark And Gritty
Aquaman isn't considered the coolest character in the DC universe in terms of costume design or superpowers; of a group of kids are going to play Justice League, Aquaman will always be the boy who was too slow to pick someone better. Hes a fun character in his own right though, even if hes not exactly hip thanks to all that mocking, so it feels a bit extreme to give him a dark and gritty makeover for his cinematic translation. Its clear from the brooding teaser poster alone that the film will be an edgier take on the character, which highlights a problem with DCs approach in general. Aquaman is one of the more optimistic characters in their catalogue, so they should try to stay somewhat true to his roots. Batman will be plenty moody for everyone, so having characters that contrast rather than mesh together with his personality would be the smart option.
4. Man Of Steel's Destruction Porn Finale
If theres any one element of Man Of Steel that left a bad taste with people it was the mega destructive ending, where Superman and Zod duke it out on the streets of Metropolis. They smash through buildings, shoot lasers at each other and generally terrify the crap out of people trapped in the middle of it. The major problem with this scene for most people - besides the overdose of CGI - is how Superman is causing as much destruction as his enemy; yes hes trying to stop Zods rampage, but watching him recklessly trash the city to do that results in tonal whiplash. There's also no real drama to the fight; its just two super-powered beings hitting each other endlessly while buildings collapse around them. Instead of being awe-inspiring the sequence is completely tone-deaf - with clumsy 9/11 imagery and a hero who's as much of a menace as the villain. If DC thinks this is what people want to see, then they really need to re-examine their approach.
3. Casting Gal Gadot As Wonder Woman
Before Wonder Woman was cast there were lots of exciting candidates up for the role, including Gina Carano, Alexandra Daddario and Adrianne Palicki (even if her Wonder Woman TV pilot didnt work out for the best). Of all of them Carano appeared to be the obvious choice; she had the right look and if anyone could convincingly kick ass on-screen it was her. It came as big surprise to everyone that Gal Gadot ended up as the character; outside of some modelling and a supporting role in the Fast & Furious movies, shed done nothing to show shed be a strong choice for the role. Shes hardly the most magnetic performer in the world, plus her skinny frame doesnt make her a very imposing fighter. Out of the many casting missteps made so far, this feels like the one that could badly impact DCs plans. The Wonder Woman movie will rest entirely on her shoulders, so if audiences dont warm to her in Batman V Superman theyll have a serious problem to deal with later.
2. The Childish Rivalry With Marvel
Once DC announced their upcoming slate they started taking pot-shots at their biggest rival, which already has people rolling their eyes. Warner Bros. head of creative development said DCs movies will be in the hands of master filmmakers, and their movies will be more grounded and realistic. There was also the suggestion that Marvel makes films by committee in this, with the studio keen to show theyll allow filmmakers to have more creative say in the process. Then Ben Affleck came out and said pretty much the same thing while adding that Marvels output is too lightweight and glib, with his team's movies planned to be more mythic. These early statements and others come across as petty, which DC can't afford to be as they're not in a strong position to start calling Marvel out. The filmmakers comment is way too cocky - does anyone consider David Ayer or Zach Snyder to be master filmmakers? - although is only the tip of it; they also hired Patty Jenkins to take over Wonder Woman, who was famously dropped from Thor: The Dark World after disagreements with Marvel. As for Marvel being too lightweight; DC should realise that not everything has to be gritty to appeal to an audience.
1. Having Zach Snyder As Their Creative Overseer
Why DC decided that Zach Snyder the visionary behind 300 and Sucker Punch was the perfect the man to lead them into the future is a mystery. Its true that he makes visually arresting movies, but he has absolutely no idea how to tell a story. This leaves his film achingly hallow as a result; a criticism that was rightfully aimed at Man Of Steel. Even after those complaints he was handed the sequel, which appears to be more of the same; moody visuals, an avalanche of CGI and everybody looking glum and serious. In addition to that hes directing Justice League Parts One and Two, as well as producing the other DC movies. Hes become their version of Kevin Feige basically, which sounds like a terrible idea all around. If they want a visual consultant hes not a bad choice; but if they want someone with a sense of story or characterisation hes a disaster. Anytime hes even attempted to get deep with characters (Sucker Punch) hes only shown just how poor his skills are. Having him supervise a whole universe - and digging to the core of what makes these characters tick - could be a massive disaster. How do you think DC has handled their cinematic universe so far? Are you really excited for their upcoming films? Share your opinions in the comments below.