20 Movies Destroyed By Their Plot Holes

With The Village, Shyamalan totally lost the plot.

By Robin Baxter /

Since the dawn of cinema, movies have been built on the suspension of disbelief. They offer us heightened and fantastical stories that don't unfold in realistic ways, and few, if any, films are totally devoid of logic gaps, no matter how great they are. For example, Citizen Kane - often touted as the best features ever made - is built around a huge one: journalists try to work out the meaning of the titular character's last word... but no-one was in the room when he said it!

Advertisement

Most stories don't make perfect sense when you look at them in a literal way, and that's OK. Nonetheless, there is a limit. Some plot holes are just too big to ignore and actually destroy the entire movie - just ask the following 20 films. 

Some are broken by a poorly-crafted inciting incident, others feature villainous plans that are constructed from one implausibility after another, and a particular one suffers from a story world that is conceptually broken. What they all have in common is that their plot holes completely destroyed them. As they show, disbelief can only be suspended so far.

20. Law Abiding Citizen - Clyde's Ridiculous Scheming

With its gory violence and angry, steely vibe, Law Abiding Citizen is a movie that you can enjoy... if you switch your brain off completely. If you think about anything that occurs in this story for longer than a minute, you're going to give yourself a splitting headache. It's so darn ludicrous. 

Advertisement

This vigilante thriller sees Clyde Shelton (Gerard Butler), a former government assassin, embark on the most insane campaign of revenge against his family's killers and the justice department, who gave those killers overly short sentences. Around halfway through, Clyde is locked up in jail, yet various murders continue - how can his crimes still be happening?

It eventually turns out that Clyde deliberately got himself locked up in solitary confinement because he actually dug tunnels between the prison and his lair. All along, he's been sneaking in and out of jail and carrying out his killings that way. So, how were these tunnels not discovered? What if he'd been put in a different prison or different section of it? Clyde is meant to be this genius assassin, but he actually left an awful lot to chance. 

That's not even addressing the increasing silliness of his acts, which includes somehow sneaking a big-ass rocket launcher into a cemetery. It's a shame, because this flick does have some noteworthy positives, and it is something of a cult classic, but for many, it will be too ridiculous to view as anything more than a guilty pleasure at the most. 

19. Ready Player One - Why Did No One Ever Drive Backwards Before?

Sometimes, just one question can destroy a story on its own, which is kind of a scary thought.

Advertisement

In Ready Player One, a soulless and overrated slice of nostalgia porn which could basically be called Member Berries: The Movie, most of humanity has become addicted to using the OASIS, a virtual reality simulation that helps the population to escape the world's problems. The deceased owner has left behind a contest that promises control of OASIS to the winner, and three keys must be discovered in order to win the prize. 

Protagonist Wade Watts (Tye Sheridan) is the one to find the first key here. He does so by beating an apparently unbeatable race by driving backwards at the start line instead of forwards, which allows him to win and discover the first MacGuffin, and he figures out that he should go backwards from clues left behind by OASIS' founder. 

While this is a cool trick on the initial viewing, many quickly realized just how bizarre this actually is. Over five years, all of these devoted gamers who were trying to win the competition couldn't figure out this clue, and yet this one, supremely boring kid could? Surely someone else would've driven backwards before? 

Because it is set off in such an illogical way, Ready Player One's story is immediately undermined, and the rest of the plot is also very weak, so the overall movie never recovers. 

18. Gone Girl - The Idiotic Police Investigation

Looking back on it over a decade later. Gone Girl is very silly indeed. A good watch, sure, but it should not be accused of being as clever as it so often has been. Gone Girl is one of those films that falls apart whenever you look closely at its plot, and after so much discussion and analysis over the years, its plot holes have only become harder to ignore with time.

Advertisement

Most notably, the investigating authorities are so damn incompetent. Had they investigated the clues properly, they would've known that Amy Dunne (Rosamund Pike) had faked her death and framed her husband, and they totally failed to check her subsequent cover story. 

Later in the film, she goes to stay with Desi (Neil Patrick Harris), a creepy ex-boyfriend, and she eventually kills him and claims that he kidnapped her. But here's the thing: her mobile phone data would've told a different story, and there would've been CCTV showing her arriving as a guest. 

For the record, these questionable plot points are present in the book, too, but they felt more forgivable there. In prose, writer Gillian Flynn was able to really explore the psychology of the two main characters in a gripping way. The film adaptation, on the other hand, leans more heavily on its twists, few of which feel entirely earned, least of all its famously downbeat ending. 

17. The Boy In The Striped Pyjamas - Shmuel Wouldn't Have Been There

Here's a case of a movie inheriting its source material's problems.

Advertisement

John A. Boyne's novel The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas has been incredibly successful and has frequently been used in schools for Holocaust education, but it's also been divisive over the years, with criticism aimed at its messages and especially its many plot holes and historical inaccuracies. Perhaps the most damaging one of all is that the main premise is built on something that's implausible for an extremely tragic reason.

2008's The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas, which faithfully adapts the book, depicts a most unlikely friendship between Shmuel (Jack Scanlon), a Jewish boy in a concentration camp, and Bruno (Asa Butterfield), the son of the Nazi who runs it. As many commentators have accurately pointed out, this friendship would never have occurred because, in the most sensitive way it can be put, Shmuel wouldn't have been there for Bruno to befriend. The heartbreaking truth is that children were nearly always killed as soon as they arrived at the camps, and it seems unlikely that Bruno would've been there on his own for so long. 

Essentially, this entire, divisive story is facilitated by a glaringly inaccurate set-up, and this gives the narrative at large an unfortunate air of inauthenticity. 

16. Wonder Woman 1984 - Steve Trevor's Reappearance

Plot holes and superhero flicks go hand in hand, but this one from Wonder Woman 1984 cut far deeper.

Advertisement

The key conflict in WW84 revolves around the Dream Stone, which grants wishes but does damage to the wisher in the process. Wonder Woman/Diana (Gal Gadot) uses it to wish for her deceased boyfriend Steve Trevor (Chris Pine) to return, and he does, but the stone begins to drain her powers. 

The stone was a generally ill-conceived MacGuffin with wildly inconsistent powers and rules, and nowhere was this more troublesome than with Steve. So many things that are wished for appear out of nowhere, but Steve, for some reason, reappears in an unnamed man's body rather than just appearing out of thin air like everything else did. 

Alongside the confusing mechanics, this entire storyline is one of the distasteful things in the history of the superhero genre. That poor man had his body hijacked and put in many dangerous situations, while it's implied that Steve and Diana sleep together in one scene, making this icky and problematic in the extreme. It was also so out-of-character for Diana and Steve, two immensely decent people, to never once worry about the man Steve had possessed. 

As such, what should've been the heart of the film became disturbing as all hell, and it was perhaps the main thing that made WW84 such a disaster. There was no need for Steve to possess someone like this, so it was frustratingly avoidable, too. 

15. A Quiet Place - None Of It Makes Any Sense

A Quiet Place was the little film that could. It was a dead-average, borderline nonsensical creature feature that somehow became a global critical and commercial hit and has even, to date, spawned two mediocre follow-ups.

Advertisement

Much like with Gone Girl, it's a movie that makes less sense the more you think about it. It unfolds in a post-apocalyptic world where aliens who hunt via sound have somehow overrun the entire planet. So, the might of the world's military couldn't destroy them? Also, at the end, it turns out that high-pitched frequencies can weaken the aliens - did none of the other seven or eight billion humans on Earth discover this when the aliens arrived? 

So, the initial setup is implausible, and the main story isn't any better. The aliens' ability to hear sound fluctuates depending on how convenient it is to the plot, and also, there's the main couple deciding to have another child in this scenario. That's the most infamous plot hole, but really, it was just one of many, and A Quiet Place's characters and plot just aren't interesting enough to distract from the total absence of any kind of logic. 

A Quiet Place's critical standing seems to have fallen a little in the years since, and that isn't surprising, for all of those questionable plot elements will have become more and more blatant on rewatches. 

14. Last Night In Soho - Why Did The Visions Lie?

This one takes a little while to kick in. At first, you might really like Last Night in Soho's twist ending, but then, once you reflect on it a bit more, you realize that the twist fatally undermines the rules of the story world, not to mention its core themes. 

Advertisement

In Last Night in Soho, Ellie (Thomasin McKenzie) is a fashion student who keeps having visions of 1960s London, specifically of a young model called Sandy (Anya Taylor-Joy) who, as the visions show, was abused by a series of men and then murdered by her pimp, Jack (Matt Smith). Ellie becomes determined to get justice for Sandy and find Jack, but there's a big twist lying in wait. Sandy isn't dead at all; she's Ellie's landlady, Miss Collins (Diana Rigg), and the vision she saw was a lie. Sandy killed Jack, not the other way around, and she's been killing abusive men for decades. 

At first, this is quite the shocking twist... but hang on. Why did the visions lie to Ellie? That's never explained, and it was a jarring case of a movie lying to the viewer in order to set up a twist without any in-world justification. In addition to this, Last Night in Soho's critique of misogyny was undermined by Sandy suddenly being revealed as a serial killer who tries to murder the completely innocent Ellie, so this entire final act needed a massive rethink. 

13. Spider-Man 3 - The Butler

What the hell was this?

Advertisement

Throughout Sam Raimi's Spider-Man Trilogy, Harry Osborn (James Franco) is seeking revenge on Spider-Man for supposedly killing his father, and yet, this whole villainous arc could've been avoided had someone else simply had a quick conversation with him. 

That is Harry's butler, Bernard Houseman (John Paxton). When the plot needs Harry to go and help Spider-Man, Bernard suddenly explains to him that his father was killed by his own glider, not by Spider-Man. He then says, "I loved your father as I have loved you, Harry." Did he really? Why didn't he tell this to Harry before? Why did he allow Harry to suffer for so long? 

Furthermore, it's jarring the way that this random background character suddenly becomes so important, and it also felt strange that he'd been the one to deal with Norman's body after his death. This character never appeared in the first Spider-Man, after all. 

Essentially, most of Spider-Man 3's story could've been avoided had Bernard actually done right by Harry. There's been an attempt to reclaim Spider-Man 3 in recent years, but no, it's actually even worse than you remember. Moments as dumb as Bernard's jarring exposition dump would not have come from a good film. 

12. Cars - Who Built The World?

From 1995 to 2010, Pixar was untouchable. Merging breathtaking visuals with masterful, Oscar-worthy writing, they delivered a ludicrous run of outstanding animations, with just one exception. That exception was Cars. 

Advertisement

Cars might look stunning, but compared to virtually everything else Pixar did in the 2000s, it is a notably mediocre venture, and a big reason for this (alongside its forgettable story and characters) is the poor world-building that just raises far too many unanswered questions. 

In a word populated entirely by cars, who built this vast world? If there are no humans, why do the cars have door handles and stuff? Oh wait... is this secretly a post-apocalyptic world where cars overthrew humanity?! 

Well, almost certainly not, but people's minds have often wandered in that direction, and with a clearer story world, it'd be a lot easier to get invested and such questions wouldn't have been asked. Additionally, the lack of humans or animals makes the entire thing feel kinda soulless, in all honesty. 

In stark contrast to the beautifully constructed worlds of other Pixar films like Monsters Inc. and Coco, the Cars franchise is burdened by a poorly designed world, which just raises far too many unanswered questions. That is one of the main reasons why this generally forgettable (or outright terrible in the case of Cars 2) series has been such an albatross around Pixar's neck for the past 20 years. 

11. Mindhunters - No-One Has This Level Of Foresight!

Mindhunters is a movie so plot hole-ridden that it might just have you howling with laughter. An And Then There Were None-style thriller, this sees a group of trainees in the FBI's Behavioral Science Unit being picked off one by one during a training exercise. 

Advertisement

Fellow trainee Lucas (Jonny Lee Miller) turned out to be the killer, and he's used his profiling skills to set up each of their deaths. Well, that's what he says. In fact, each death is the result of a never-ending series of coincidences that he could never possibly have predicted, no matter how clever he was. 

For example, the first death is that of JD (Christian Slater). While the group is exploring a room, a clock starts playing an annoying tune and JD goes to turn it off, which sets off a Rube Goldberg machine that activates a tank of liquid nitrogen that freezes him to death. Anyone else could've stopped the clock, and JD might've just taken one step to the side, which would've saved him. 

Sure, Lucas later says that he knew JD would stop the clock because he's a natural leader, but that's just dumb. Turning off an annoying bit of music is something any of them would've wanted to do. The rest of it continues in this vein, confirming Mindhunters is one of the silliest horror-thrillers in existence. Thanks to its countless logic gaps, any enjoyment of this one is likely to be ironic, at best. 

10. 28 Weeks Later - The World's Most Unsafe Safe Zone

In order for a tragic story to work, it needs to feel earned and logical, or else it'll be excessively cruel. Unfortunately, 28 Weeks Later didn't get the memo.

Advertisement

This sequel is set seven months after the outbreak of the Rage Virus, when the US army has set up a new safe zone in London and is trying to repopulate the country. Of course, everything needed to go wrong, but they could've found a remotely believable way to set things off. Instead, the zombie outbreak in 28 Weeks Later is the most avoidable one ever put to film, and its gory carnage comes off as unearned and staggeringly cruel.

Despite being the foremost military power in the world, it appears that the US military was incapable of setting up a proper safe zone. First up, two stupid kids make the bafflingly selfish decision to sneak into the unsafe London in order to get a photograph of their apparently deceased mother, and somehow, they are able to sneak off without any of the soldiers catching them. 

It gets worse, though. The kids find their mother, who's an asymptomatic carrier of the Rage Virus, and she's brought back to the safe zone. No-one guards her room, and her husband Don (Robert Carlyle) is allowed to visit her unsupervised, during which he kisses her and becomes infected, triggering a new outbreak. What a load of hogwash. 

9. Non-Stop - The Nonsensical Evil Plan

First things first: no-one goes to watch a Liam Neeson action film for a realistic plot. To do so would be an exercise in futility. Nonetheless, even with those expectations in place, there is no getting around Non-Stop. It makes works like the Taken films seem like British Kitchen Sink Realism by comparison.

Advertisement

Non-Stop presents its audience with a tantalizing setup. Air Marshal Bill Marks (Neeson) is on a flight from New York to London, and he gets texts informing him that a passenger will be killed every 20 minutes unless certain financial demands are met. What unfolds from this great premise is one of the dumbest action flicks of the 2010s, maybe even ever. 

Nothing about this film makes the slightest bit of sense, with the villains somehow getting around this tiny closed space and committing numerous murders without anyone seeing them doing it. An awful lot of things, such as how they killed one of the pilots, are never explained in any way, and there's a reason for that: there was no way the two hijackers could've pulled all of this off. 

8. Double Jeopardy - The Misunderstanding Of Law

Double Jeopardy is a perfectly fine legal thriller that happens to have one of the most flagrantly inaccurate premises in Hollywood history - at least, in the context of movies that are set in a realistic world.

Advertisement

In this one, Libby (Ashley Judd) is sent to prison for killing her husband Nick (Bruce Greenwood) during a boat trip, and while locked up, she discovers the horrifying truth: Nick is very much alive. He faked his death and framed her for murder in order to collect some insurance money. 

One day, Libby hears from a fellow inmate that there's a way she can get revenge without being convicted. There's the double jeopardy law, which means that no person can be tried for the same crime twice. She could shoot Nick in the middle of Times Square, and they couldn't even touch her. Err... no. Not at all.

This movie completely misunderstands Double Jeopardy. What it actually means is that an accused person can't be tried again for the same charge unless serious new evidence comes to light. So, she wouldn't be tried again for the murder she was wrongly convicted of but if she just went and killed Nick then, of course, she'd be tried for this new crime. 

When Libby does kill Nick, it is self-defence, so she's fine anyhow, but her quest throughout much of the story was preposterous in the extreme. This goes a long way towards explaining why so many viewers struggled to engage with it. 

7. Frozen - The Worst Ski Resort Ever

No, not that Frozen. This one is a fairly weak horror film from 2010, where three skiers are left trapped on a ski lift after it is switched off for the weekend. They face freezing to death if they do not make their escape, which is hampered by the presence of dangerous wolves down below. 

Advertisement

Much like with 28 Weeks Later, this is a horror tragedy that couldn't have felt less earned. The three main characters persuade the chair lift operator to let them up for one last run late at night, but the operator hands this over to a second staff member, and this staff member immediately shuts the lift off once he sees three other skiers arrive back at ground level. 

Simply put, this scenario is a load of rubbish. In real life, whenever a ski resort shuts down, the lift is checked on to make sure no-one is still on it, and even without that knowledge, it immediately seemed ridiculous that any well-established ski resort would be so careless. 

If the rest of the movie had been better, this could've been forgiven, but even then, Frozen would've had to do a lot of work to win audiences back after such an idiotic inciting incident. 

6. The Village - M. Night Shyamalan's Most Illogical Twist

For better or for worse, M. Night Shyamalan is known as the twist guy, and much like his output at large, these are a mixed bag. The twist that concludes The Village is easily his stupidest rug-pull to date. 

Advertisement

While this story appears to be set in a monster-infested village in 19th-century Pennsylvania, the twist is that it's actually in present-day America. The village elders set this up as an escape from the modern world, and they dress up as monsters to keep the residents from leaving. It was a great idea, but the execution was maddeningly silly. 

Over the years, viewers have had a field day breaking down all the different ways in which this doesn't work. Somehow, these people cannot hear the big road that is quite close to the village, and somehow a plane has never flown overhead. 

Fine, there's some vague explanation given that, to the outside world, the village's area is a protected wildlife reserve that's been made a no-fly zone to avoid disturbing the animals, but this is nonsense, too. Wildlife reserves are taxpayer-funded and cannot be bought by one rich family, as in the movie, while no-fly zones don't work in that way. It is damn-near impossible that no plane would ever have gone overhead. 

The Village wasn't doing too well before this, but it was this twist that truly destroyed it beyond repair. 

5. Alien: Covenant - One Stupid Choice After Another

2012's Prometheus was widely criticized for how stupid its plot and characters were, so hopefully the sequel would do better? "Hold my whisky," Alien: Covenant replied.

Advertisement

This sequel is even sillier, and everything about it is driven by bad decision-making. These supposedly clever scientists go to investigate a creepy planet with no helmets or proper precautions, one of them leans into a dangerous, hatching egg when the clearly dangerous main antagonist David the Android (Michael Fassbender) tells him to, and none of the infected crew members are ever properly quarantined. 

Alien: Covenant also contains one of the worst plot twists in recent memory. It turns out that David has escaped the planet by disguising himself as Walter, a much nicer android who is identical to David. Surely the crew-mates would've done something to check it wasn't David? They should've been able to guess that something like this could happen. This is a movie where many viewers will be too busy marvelling at all these bad decisions to actually get invested in anything that's going on. 

The movie ends on a bleak note, with David in charge of the whole ship and about to experiment on the thousands of sleeping colonists; a ballsy ending, but one which felt frustratingly unearned. If people like this crew were actually put in charge of important missions in space, humanity would be doomed. 

4. Oldboy (2013) - Leaving Everything To Chance

Spike Lee's ill-judged Oldboy remake retells the story of a man held captive for decades before embarking on a journey of revenge, but it throws out nearly everything that made it so great before. The emotion, the complexity, and worst of all, the logic. This is especially true in regards to the villain's big plan, which was demented genius in the original, but a load of plot hole-ridden bilge in the remake. 

Advertisement

In both versions, the antagonist locks the protagonist up for years without explanation, then sets them free just as suddenly. Both incarnations are trying to trick the protagonist into committing incest with their own daughter in order to get revenge for exposing an incestuous relationship they themselves had as a young man, but while Oldboy 2003's Lee Woo-jin used hypnosis to facilitate his sick scheme, Oldboy 2013's Adrian Pryce (Sharlto Copley) left everything to chance. 

There was no hypnosis, and when Adrian's ally led protagonist Joe (John Brolin) to his daughter, Marie (Elizabeth Olsen), there was no guarantee that the pair would hit it off. They wouldn't have even met again had Joe's friend not found Marie's card in Joe's pocket and called her, and that was wildly coincidental at best. 

To be fair to Oldboy 2013, it's not awful at first, and though it's noticeably less emotional, it could've been a perfectly watchable thriller had it told a remotely logical story. Alas, it wasn't to be, and it's no surprise Spike Lee has disowned it since. 

3. Angels & Demons - Father Patrick's Ludicrous Plan

The bats**t-crazy Angels & Demons unfolds during a turbulent papal conclave. Four cardinals have been kidnapped by an Illuminati assassin, who is threatening to destroy the Vatican with an antimatter bomb. Eventually, symbologist Robert Langdon (Tom Hanks) saves one of the cardinals and finds the bomb, which is flown away by the priest Patrick McKenna (Ewan McGregor). As McKenna parachutes down from the helicopter, he hits several things on the way down yet improbably survives.

Advertisement

Impressively, that isn't even the tenth dumbest thing in this one. 

As it turns out, McKenna is behind everything. As he felt the late Pope (who he was Camerlengo to) was too open to science, he killed him and invented this plot to turn the Church away from science. Furthermore, he hoped his heroic actions would get him elected as the new Pope. There are so many things wrong with this. 

McKenna's entire plan revolved around so many improbable timings and coincidences; he hid the antimatter bomb behind a labyrinthine treasure hunt instead of making it easy to find for his big moment, and regardless of what he'd done, it's extremely unlikely that the Church would elect some random young priest as pope and break centuries of tradition. 

Simply put, this is one of the stupidest evil plans in Hollywood history, and the fact that it almost works makes it even more incredulous. This is another one that's so ludicrous that it's hard to view it as anything more than a complete joke. 

2. Texas Chainsaw 3D - Where To Begin?

Texas Chainsaw 3D is a movie that doesn't just contain plot holes; it is constructed from them. Nothing about this risible legacy sequel is executed with any sort of logic.

Advertisement

This is present from the get-go, when a character who appears as a baby in the 1974-set prologue appears as an adult (Alexandra Daddario) in her early 20s in the next scene, set in 2012... she should be nearly 40 years old! That sets the tone from the off. 

The characters are constantly making ludicrously stupid decisions and getting themselves killed in the most avoidable of ways. Heather (Daddario) is given a letter from her late relative at the start, but inexplicably neglects to read it, and if she'd done so, then she could've learned the house that she'd inherited had an ageing Leatherface lurking within.

And of course, there's the ending where Heather realizes she's Leatherface's long-lost cousin and suddenly teams up with him against the police department, conveniently forgetting that he's tried to kill her repeatedly and also killed her friends. That is not believable any way you cut it. 

Because of its stupidity, Texas Chainsaw 3D is a fascinating film to dissect, and there's perhaps some ironic enjoyment to be had in places, but it's never enough to hide the fact that you're watching utter tripe.

1. Us - The Army Of Clones

It's been a good few years since Jordan Peele's sophomore feature, and now that the dust has settled, it's time for us all to admit it: Us is as dumb as a bag of hammers.

Advertisement

There are great things in it, but as a story, it contrasts with the tightly written genius of Get Out in the worst way imaginable. This story is an army of doppelgangers attacking the US, but it falls apart in the final act, mainly because the explanation for the phenomenon collapses if you think about it for even a minute.

So, the clones were part of an experiment that was long-since abandoned. Somehow, all of these millions of clones have been surviving in a network of miraculously clean underground tunnels for decades with nothing to eat but an apparently infinite supply of rabbit meat, and somehow, they've managed to organize a revolution even though they're unintelligent, mute, and have no method of long-range communication. 

Even the ending twist doesn't hold up so well now. It's revealed that protagonist Adelaide (Lupita Nyong'o) is a clone who escaped, and the apparent clone leading the revolution, Red (also Nyong'o), was the original Adelaide. At the time, that was a great shock, but that also makes less and less sense the more you think about it. Why didn't the original Adelaide just return to the surface? 

Sadly, Us was destroyed by its terrible third-act reveal, and it's an epitomizing example of how plot holes can kill a movie. 

Advertisement