6 People Who Should Replace Jimmy Fallon

By J.D. Westfall /

With recent news breaking that Jay Leno might be leaving the Tonight Show, there was much media frenzy. Is this true? If so, who will replace him? All those questions were soon answered when it was officially announced Leno would be leaving, and be replaced by Jimmy Fallon. A Saturday Night Live alumni and host of his own show - Late Night With Jimmy Fallon - he is certainly qualified for the position. But that brings us to a new question... with Fallon leaving Late Night, who should replace him? Who will be the fourth host of Late Night (following in the footsteps of David Letterman, Conan O'Brien, and Fallon)? Well, as always, WhatCulture is ready to step in and offer some suggestions. Here are six people we think are excellent candidates for the hosting chair....

6. Seth Meyers

Currently the most whispered name in regard to who should take the job, Seth Meyers would certainly be at home on Late Night. He's spent the last twelve years on Saturday Night Live (having joined in 2001), and since 2006 has been head writer and host of Weekend Update. Through this, he's become adept at monologues, though all his interaction with guests is scripted, so we have no idea how well he'd handle improvised conversations with real guests. However, another thing helping his case is his role as head writer. The jokes always feel more natural from show hosts when they've had a hand in writing them.

5. Chris Hardwick

One of the foremost nerds in the world today, you may know Chris Hardwick from any number of things. Perhaps one of his stand-up routines. Perhaps his voice acting work in Back At The Barnyard. Or perhaps one of his hosting gigs - Singled Out, Wired Science, Web Soup, Talking Dead, Ministry of Laughs, or his Nerdist Podcast. He also has the clout to be able to pull in some real heavyweight guests. Some of the guests he's had on his podcast alone are Drew Carey, Jon Hamm, Weird Al Yankovic, Craig Ferguson, Nathan Fillion, and Ozzy Osbourne. To name a few. If he can manage that with a podcast, just imagine what he could pull off on a nationally televised talk show.

4. Amy Poehler

Although Tina Fey may arguably be a better choice, she's pretty much ruled herself out. However, Amy Poehler would be every bit as capable of handling the job. She has many of the same qualifications as Seth Meyers (SNL, Weekend Update, etc) but has one distinct advantage over Meyers. She has much more experience with improvisation. While both got their start in improv troupes, Poehler has done considerably more of it, and was also much more successful with it. Of course, she's currently attached to another NBC property - Parks and Recreation - but with continually lowering viewership numbers, the show may not last until 2014 (which is when Fallon is scheduled to leave). If we must lose Parks and Rec, at least we have the hope of Poehler getting the Late Night chair.

3. Kevin Hart

So maybe you don't want someone with experience in hosting or in sketch comedy. Maybe for a slight change, you want someone who made their name as a stand-up comedian. Enter Kevin Hart. While having done some film work and a little bit of sketch comedy, his strength is stand-up. Monologues are of course a vital part of the late night talk shows, but he could do one better. Hart is skilled at interacting with his audiences, sometimes going way off script to relate with his audience more. Plus, who else can make a story about eating at Panera Bread be a hilarious and riveting experience?

2. Tim Minchin

Quick, what is Jimmy Fallon best known for? That's right! Mixing music and comedy. So maybe the top dogs at NBC want to bring in someone who can fill Fallon's musical shoes. Who better than Tim Minchin? If you're unfamiliar with him, Minchin is an Australian comedian, who has some serious music skills. Jimmy Fallon is really good musically, but this guy blows him out of the water...However, he is pretty well known for having edgy and raunchy humor at time, so having to tone down his material for national television might alienate some of his fans, but would easily garner him even more.

1. Joel McHale

Easily the top choice, Joel McHale has had a busy past few years. Beginning in improvisation as so many of these people do, he eventually landed guest spots on numerous shows, and has moved into films on several occasions (appearing in The Informant!, The Big Year, and most recently Seth MacFarlane's film Ted). He also plays the lead role in one of the only truly great sitcoms ever made, and has been a frequent guest on Late Night, among many other talk shows. But perhaps his main qualification is that of his job hosting E's The Soup, a weekly show satirizing news and television of the past week. He took over from Greg Kinnear (when the show was known as Talk Soup) in 2004, and has been at it ever since, with over 400 episodes under his belt. He's also been able to lead it from being a fairly unknown show to being among E's most watched shows. So! Whaddya think? Any other excellent candidates we've missed? Sound off in the comments below!