9 Remakes That Were More Influential Than The Original

Proving that even a remake can bring something fresh to the table.

By Padraig Cotter /

Universal Pictures

It’s almost sacrilegious to suggest a remake might be better than the original film. Remakes are generally met with scorn by critics and fans, and a fair amount of them deserve it too; anyone who’s seen the updated versions of A Nightmare On Elm Street, Total Recall or Clash Of The Titans will know this firsthand.

Advertisement

That being said, a few of these reboots took the core idea of the original and do something fresh with it. Some of them even manage to best the original, and would prove more influential on the genre as a whole. Aside from improving on the first film, they introduced new ideas or concepts others would borrow (or steal) for years to come, and they’re often cited for the impact they left.

This is a rare phenomenon to be sure, but at least it disproves the old “remakes always suck” adage. Let’s take a look at some of the most influential “reimaginings” out there, and the impact they had on their genres.

9. Scarface

The 1932 version of Scarface is rightfully considered a genre classic, and tells the story of the rise and fall of a violent gangster. It was directed by Howard Hawks, and the story is a thinly veiled take on mobster Al Capone. The film ran into some censorship issues because of the amount of violence, but it was a huge success upon release and has been called one of the best gangster movies ever.

Advertisement

It was also an inspiration on Martin Scorsese and Brian De Palma, who would go on to direct the famous 1983 remake. Al Pacino takes over the lead role, and the film is a luridly violent story of an ambitious Cuban gangster. The remake has become even more iconic than its predecessor, thanks to the great acting, quotable dialogue and, of course, the “Say hello to my little friend” scene.

The movie would go on to inspire similar movies like New Jack City and American Gangster, plus it seems like every hip-hop artist in the world cites Scarface as a personal inspiration.

8. The Thing

The Thing From Another World is a classic b-movie from 1951 and features a group of scientists in the Antarctic encountering a plant-like alien; one that looks suspiciously like a bloke in a monster suit. The film is also a favourite of director John Carpenter, who initially baulked at the offer of remaking it until he realised he could do something completely different.

Advertisement

He went back to the original book - which featured a monster who could imitate other forms of life – which led to the groundbreaking design of The Thing. Although the movie wasn’t initially a hit it’s reputation steadily grew over time, with fans loving the mix of paranoia, great acting and the amazing effects.

The film would prove to have a big effect on filmmakers like Chuck Russell and Quentin Tarantino, with Reservoir Dogs and The Hateful Eight practically being spiritual sequels. The latter movie in particular – featuring an all-male cast stranded in a snowy location and paranoid of one other – is the closest to a real sequel we’ll ever get. Hell, it even has Kurt Russell and his awesome facial hair!

7. I Am Legend

I Am Legend is a classic novel by the late, great Richard Matheson, and told the story of the last man on earth having to deal with a planet load of vampires. The book was a huge inspiration on everyone from Stephen King to George Romero, who used it as the basis for Night Of The Living Dead.

Advertisement

The book was given a glossy big budget adaptation with 1971's The Omega Man, starring Charlton Heston. The film is fun in a guilty pleasure sort of way – apparently, it’s a personal favourite of Tim Burton – but it hasn’t aged well, and it's too campy to take seriously.

Finally, Will Smith came along with his take on I Am Legend, which featured a nightmarish look at an empty New York. The CGI was dodgy in places, but the atmosphere was undeniable. Soon a bunch of movies with similar themes and visuals would pop up like Book Of Eli, The Road and even World War Z. Director Francis Lawrence even rippid himself off with The Hunger Games: Mockingjay – Part 2; the sewer sequence is almost a total copy of I Am Legend’s empty building search.

6. Dawn Of The Dead

The George Romero zombie films practically invented the genre, bringing together social commentary with top-notch gore. Dawn Of The Dead is his masterpiece, a big pulpy action film where a group of survivors take over a shopping centre and try to pretend they’re not living in a zombie apocalypse.

Advertisement

That said, there’s no denying that Zach Snyder’s supercharged remake in 2004 revived the genre in a massive way. The zombie movie had pretty much been buried for twenty years by that stage, and while 28 Days Later was a sleeper hit it was really Snyder’s Dawn that gave it a proper kick up the a***. It got rid of the slow-moving zombies in favour of feral sprinters, and the movie's huge success allowed the zombie renaissance we’re currently living through.

Everything from The Walking Dead to World War Z owes a nod to the Dawn remake, although at this point audiences might be a bit zombied out. The original is the better movie, but the impact of the remake can't be ignored.

5. The Ring

The Japanese version of The Ring is one creepy slow burn of a movie, which follows a reporter trying to solve the mystery behind a killer video before it kills her too. The movie is infamous for the TV scare, and making slow moving girls with long dark hair the scariest thing ever.

Advertisement

The film became a cult hit, but it wasn’t until Hollywood ported it over that The Ring became a worldwide smash. The Naomi Watts starring thriller beefed up the jump scares and gave a more complicated origin story for the villain, but it was better than it had any right to be; something the sequel couldn’t be accused of.

The Ring kicked off the whole j-horror remake wave that swept Hollywood for a bit, with everything from The Grudge to One Missed Call getting a new coat of paint. Even video games like F.E.A.R and Deadly Premonition took cues from it. The trend died out for a bit, but with Rings 3D and a remake of Audition on the way, the influence of The Ring is still being felt.

4. A Fistful Of Dollars

Akira Kurosawa’s Yojimbo is a classic samurai film starring his the director's favourite leading man Toshiro Mifune, and is considered one of the directors his finest; which for Kurosawa is really saying something. Italian auteur Sergio Leone “borrowed” the story for A Fistful Of Dollars, which starred a young Clint Eastwood as a mysterious gunman.

Advertisement

The movie made Eastwood instantly iconic; thanks to his trademark poncho and the fact he barely has any dialogue. Eastwood would go on to cultivate this image in more westerns like High Plains Drifter, The Outlaw Josey Wales and Pale Rider. Dollars would also spawn a whole host of Man With No Name type movies, inspiring everything from Mad Max, Django, Last Man Standing and even Drive.

3. The Fly

The original version of The Fly is quite campy and hard to take seriously now, but it does contain the rather creepy fly-man caught in a spider’s web scene. David Cronenberg’s reimagining does away with nearly everything from that version, expect for the concept of teleporters and how it’s not a good idea to get your DNA mixed with a fly.

Advertisement

Cronenberg’s version was a good deal more heartbreaking and is really about a woman caring for someone who’s dying from a terminal illness. The gooey body horror is still disturbing thirty years later (two words; vomit drop) and it’s still considered one of the director’s best works.

It would be a huge influence on the body horror genre, with movies like District 9, Hollow Man, Spider-Man and even a little bit of the Fantastic Four reboot; something Cronenberg must be really flattered by.

2. The Bourne Identity

Production on The Bourne Identity was such a nightmare it’s doubtful the studio thought it would break even, let alone become a huge franchise. The film pioneered the shaky came style of action – for better or worse – and gave Matt Damon his most iconic role.

Advertisement

What many don't realise is that the movie was preceded by a TV adaptation in 1988, where Richard Chamberlain played the forgetful spy. It’s a solid old-fashioned thriller, but the only reason people remember it today is because of the new movies, and this miniseries lacks the propulsive energy of its younger brother.

Damon’s Bourne Identity went on to influence pretty much every spy movie or show made after it. Shows like 24 adopted the jittery handheld camerawork and action, while Daniel Craig’s reboot of Bond owes a huge debt to the original. The choppy, quick cut action can also be seen in everything from The Dark Knight trilogy to the Captain America films.

1. Heat

Heat was a pet project for director Michael Mann, but after years of trying to get it funded to no avail, he threw in the towel and decided to make a TV pilot out of it. He chopped the epic script in half and renamed it L.A. Takedown. While not exactly awful, it plays like a cheap and cheerless prototype for the eventual movie; the lead actors are no Pacino or De Niro either.

Advertisement

When he finally got a chance to make it in the early nineties he seized it quickly and made an enduring modern classic. The acting is fantastic, the epic story gripping and the street gunfight is still unbeatable. The movie is considered Mann’s masterpiece with good reason, and its influence on the genre is still being felt.

Movies like The Town, Takers, Ronin, Way Of The Gun and even The Dark Knight were all heavily influenced by it. Pacino and De Niro tried – and failed – to recapture the magic with Righteous Kill, and Mann himself made similar thrillers like Miami Vice, Blackhat and Public Enemies.

Which other superior remakes belong on this list? Share your own suggestions below in the comments thread.

Advertisement