Arnold Schwarzenegger: 5 More Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked

By Simon Gallagher /

Despite apparently retiring, Arnie is back on the big screens this weekend with the release of Escape Plan, the action caper teaming the former Governator back up with Sylvester Stallone. The bones might ache a bit more, and the muscles might take more time to heal, but the pair celebrate genre conventions like old pros, and combine to make Escape Plan far more than just another film starring Vinnie Jones and 50 Cent. Schwarzenegger is a difficult prospect for anyone looking to break down his career: he is a curiously polarising figure, making films that are universally hated without necessarily offering a bad performance (like End Of Days) and generally being counted as an acquired taste. But as we discussed in our original 5 Awesome Performances & 5 That Sucked for the Terminator star, there is more than enough variety in the success of his performances to perpetuate his star even now. And it is that continued reach - which will see at least six more Arnie projects in the next couple of years - that warrants a second portrait in this very column, making Schwarzenegger only the second actor to enjoy the privilege of a sequel, rather fittingly following Expendables co-star Bruce Willis. Perhaps one day we'll complete the Expendables tri-fector, but for now attention turns back to the man formerly known as Arnold Strong, which is somewhat at odds with this image... Come with me if you want to read.

5 Awesome Performances...

5. Conan - Conan The Barbarian (1976)

Advertisement
After a number of false dawns during his early flirtations with cinema, when casting directors saw little beyond the incredible physique, Arnie's big break came after he impressed in Bob Rafelson's excellent Stay Hungry opposite Jeff Bridges, playing an Austrian bodybuilder. That role didn't exactly show off his range, but it did help land him the lead in Conan The Barbarian some five years later for John Milius, having been placed on retainer since 1976. Despite some misgivings about Arnie's imposing physique (he dropped 30 pounds to look more athletic for producer Dino De Laurentis,) he was perfectly cast as the barely vocal hulk in the hard-boiled fantasy created by Robert E. Howard. His presence, and the incredible condition of his body made him the ideal Conan for revivalist fans, and his willingness to do his own stunts adds another element to the character. It might not be nuanced or particularly complex, but Conan remains one of Arnie's greatest performances, which is precisely why it opened the door to his Hollywood career in real terms.

4. Capt. Ivan Danko - Red Heat (1988)

Red Heat is certainly not Arnie's biggest triumph, considering the mixed response it has received from critics over the years, as well as the ridicule it endures for its frankly awful portrayal of Russian culture, including the bafflingly wrong portrayal of the language, but Arnie is great as the stuffy Russian cop. In 1988 buddy cop movies were golden, and Red Heat was an unashamed attempt to cash in on that continued appeal - which becomes immediately obvious from its brilliantly corny tagline: ""Moscow's toughest detective. Chicago's craziest cop. There's only one thing more dangerous than making them mad: making them partners." Casting Jim Belushi might not be the greatest idea these days, but opposite Arnie's stoic straight man, the lesser Belushi brother is uncharacteristically good, in part thanks to the subtle work of his partner. In one of his first comedy roles, Arnie is great fun to watch, embodying the reductive Russian stereotype so well you can almost forgive the utter cultural ignorance that underpins the character. The film isn't excellent by any means, but Arnie steals the show, and his performance deserves more plaudits.

3. Himself - Pumping Iron (1977)

Arnie has played himself a number of times over the years - most notably in Last Action Hero (more of which soon) - and though most have been in works of fiction, one of his most intriguing performances comes in a documentary that remains a staple for anyone with any interest in body building. Before he made it big as an actor, famously Schwarzenegger was a champion of the sport, inspiring hyperbole from every gym-bunny focused on making the most of their body mass. He was also a competitor in Mr Universe competitions, which thrust him into focus for George Butler and Robert Fiore's 1977 documentary Pumping Iron, which also starred a pre-Hulk Lou Ferrigno. Playing the charismatic villain to Ferrigno, in a role that he himself suggested was a caricature to help the film'e entertainment factor, Schwarzenegger is irresistible, dominating every scene he appears in and offering the kind of T-Shirt slogan soundbites that continue to make him a favourite source for anyone looking for inspiration. Pumping Iron officially got Arnie the Conan gig, as well as giving Ferrigno the opportunity to play The Incredible Hulk, but it is notable more for its insights behind the artifice of Arnie than it is for his portrayal of any character.

2. Ben Richards - The Running Man (1987)

With The Hunger Games: Catching Fire coming to cinemas soon, it's invariably important to remember that Arnie's Running Man used effectively the same story, only with a Simon Cowell like villain and some of the finest corny quips ever to grace the action genre. Coming at the height of Arnie's late '80s/early '90s heyday, the oddly prescient film was based on a story by Stephen King, and cast the hulking actor as Ben Richards, yet another falsely-convicted man who isn't so much given his opportunity to clear his name as he is to bring down the ugly animal of grotesque populist culture in the shape of Damon Killian's The Running Man TV show. The premise is genius, pitting a wounded animal Arnie against a colourful rogues gallery featuring wonderfully silly villains like Dynamo, Buzzsaw, Captain Freedom and Subzero, and gives him an important role as the focal point for a resistance, lead unfeasibly by Mick Fleetwood, apparently playing a version of himself. Arnie might not have been happy with director Paul Michael Glazer's work (otherwise known as Starsky,) but the film remains a genuine classic of the period

1. Jack Slater - Last Action Hero (1993)

Shane Black isn't happy unless he's deconstructing film conventions as he makes them, and way back in 1993, before the action movie genre was even officially "dead," he was part of the writing team behind the criminally underrated Last Action Hero, which remains a smart pastiche of the genre, as well as a great period actioner on its own terms. The film might be hated by a good deal of critics, but it is the culmination of Arnie's career up to that point, and despite its openly comedic construct, and the nature of his character, it is also arguably Schwarzenegger's broadest role. He plays the Jack Slater caricature brilliantly, drawing obviously from his own career, but it is the growth of the character, up to his realisation that he is just a character in a movie that really marks the appeal of the performance. It's unashamedly corny, and some might say unforgivably cheesy, but Last Action Hero is a more enjoyable film that a good deal of Arnie's films that are more critically acclaimed, which is nothing short of a travesty.

5 Performances That Sucked...

5. Mickey Hargitay - The Jayne Mansfield Story (1980)

In the gap between being discovered in Pumping Iron and Stay Hungry, and making it big in Conan The Barbarian, Arnie made a couple of forgettable, and probably regrettable films, including playing his best named character of all, Handsome Stranger in cowboy parody The Villain. But the worst choice of the lot (obviously in hindsight - at the time, he had to somehow finance the many, many eggs he was probably eating every day) was this TV movie directed by the TV movie world's answer to Ed Wood, Dick Lowry. Playing Mansfield's husband Mickey Hargitay, Arnie was probably perfectly cast, given that Hargitay was a former Mr Universe wining body builder from Hungary ("close enough," they probably said) but that doesn't hide the fact that the film is dog-awful, and Arnie isn't cut out for the fairly challenging role. The creative liberties taken are somewhat derailing, with details changed for entertainment and key events skipped entirely, which might be forgivable if the result was an improvement, but the reality is a poor biopic, which could be the epitome of why "made-for-TV" is counted as an insult in some quarters.

4. Dr. Alex Hesse - Junior (1994)

Somewhat inconceivably, the same year that Arnie made the glorious True Lies, he was also the lead in Junior, a mind-bending, gender-bending, science-bending comedy re-teaming the star with Danny Devito after the success of Twins in 1988. The story, which needs no long introduction, cast Arnie as mild-mannered and least convincing gynecologist ever, Dr Alex Hesse (seriously would you allow either Arnie or DeVito to examine you?!) who ignores the strictly regulated rules of science by testing a fertility drug on himself and becoming pregnant. Ignoring the fact that the science could have been drawn up by a child with a crayon, the resolution that Hesse becomes a science hero for his work, rather than being struck off and blacklisted for reckless endangerment, and condemned to a freak show for being the only creature in existence able to grow a child without a womb, is utterly stupid. The comedy is flat, and though there is some comedy in the body shock elements that culminate in the haunting vision of a baby with Arnie's face that feels like something David Cronenberg would have rejected as too weird, the vision of Arnie in drag is the low point of a poor all round experience.

3. Mark Kaminsky - Raw Deal (1986)

Arnie hasn't made too many mistakes in terms of the films he picks: usually he is well cast, and the problems come with the overall quality of the movie (aside from the lunacy of Twins) - but in Raw Deal, the actor is horribly miscast. On paper, the concept sounds suited to Arnie: he plays Mark Kaminsky, a discredited former FBI agent struck off for over-zealously beating a child molester, who finds himself working as a small town sheriff, and is given one last chance to be reinstated to the agency if he infiltrates the mob and pulls it down from the inside. But the plot is too silly, and the quality of the writing makes it feel like it should never have made it beyond TV movie status. The film feels oddly antiquated - like it was ripped out of the industry of ten years earlier - and is plainly stupid, culminating in the final sequence, which sees Arnie basically emotionally blackmail his friend, and crippled boss of the FBI into defying medical science and walking again. Naturally it works, and the world rolls its eyes.

2. The Terminator - Terminator 3: Rise Of The Machines (2003)

It should have gone perfectly: the first two Terminator films had profited from Arnie's incredible, emotionless face, and traded on his near silent presence and unspoken charisma to create one of the most iconic hero/villain characters in the history of cinema. And by the time 2003 came around and Arnie came back on board for a threequel, he had had so much botox that his face barely moved whether he wanted it to or not, and his advancing age was making his movement more awkward than it had been in his athletic youth - surely that would serve the character? But now, T3 might not be the worst thing to happen to the Terminator franchise (which will probably be the forthcoming Terminator sequel) but Arnie's performance in it has lost enough of the spark of the first times he pulled on his leathers and shades, that it suffers hugely by comparison. Arnie is a little too old to play the Terminator, which is just about covered by the fact that he owns the role as much as Johnny Depp owns Jack Sparrow, but the writing is nowhere near as smart as the first two movies, and the thriller elements of the first two are replaced by a dumber chase movie feel.

1. Hercules - Hercules In New York (1970)

Before he got his big break, and even before he stopped body building, Arnie almost sabotaged his own career with his first, and easily his worst movie, Hercules In New York. Credited as Arnold Strong, which was presumably all that was left after the producers ruled out Arnie Muscle-Man and Bodybuilder McRippled, arnie played Hercules, who heads to a 1960s New York full of pantomime idiots and racist stereotypes for a "hilarious" (read: "torturous") culture clash caper. Before those famous monkeys at their keyboards wrote the complete works of Shakespeare, they presumably had a few abortive creations that never made it to light, because that can be the only way this God-awful film was ever made. The plot is insane and terrible, the comedy is actually painful and the whole crazy mess is about as unpleasant as could possibly be imagined. Arnie was originally dubbed out, since it was clearly deemed more appropriate for Hercules to have a stunted American accent with no personality rather than a thick Austrian one, but the version where his real voice is used is even worse if you want an extra reason not to watch it. To his eternal credit, Arnie fully recognises that the film is easily his worst: "There's this political battle over water-boarding at places like Guantanamo Bay. I think they should just say, 'Hey, if you guys don't talk, you'll have to see Hercules In New York.' I guarantee those guys would talk much faster." What do you think Arnie's best and worst films are? Share your own picks below in the comments thread, and don't forget to check out our original Arnold Schwarzenegger: 5 Awesome Performances & 5 That Sucked.