Billy Bob Thornton: 5 Awesome Performances & 5 That Sucked

The best and worst of Billy Bob's career to date. Mmm-hmm.

By Padraig Cotter /

Billy Bob Thornton has come a very long way from his humble beginnings in the film business, where he€™d regularly appear in bit parts on low-budget films like Chopper Chicks In Zombietown. Even then he showed a charisma that overcame the terrible scripts he was working on, but it was only when he created his own material that people started taking notice. He wrote and starred in the acclaimed €“ but little seen €“ thriller One False Move, which soon led to him writing and directing Sling Blade, the film that made his career. Since then he€™s written, directed and starred in a wide variety of movies, ranging from tiny budget indies to massive summer blockbusters. There doesn€™t appear to be any role Thornton can€™t tackle, and he€™s equally comfortable in sily comedies or deathly serious dramas. He also has the ability to find humanity in seriously unlikable characters; a talent he€™s demonstrated more than once. He seems to be more comfortable in indie movies, stating his dislike of the Hollywood process. This might explain why - when he does show up in larger budget movies - he tends to coast a little bit. With today's UK release of Our Brand Is Crisis, where he co-stars with Sandra Bullock, let€™s take a look back on some of the highlights €“ and lowlights €“ of Billy Bob€™s eventful career.

Advertisement

5 Awesome Performances...

5. Johnny Tyler - Tombstone

Billy Bob was starting to make a name for himself as a likable character actor when he was cast in Tombstone, where he got to share one of the film€™s best scenes with Kurt Russell. In the story Wyatt Earp arrives in town and walks into a bar, where Thornton plays a bullying gambler ruining everyone€™s good time; Wyatt quickly shows him the error of his ways. Even in such a small part Billy Bob is able to make a fully fleshed out character, who quickly goes from being a loudmouth weasel to a simpering coward when confronted with a real man. Wyatt berates and embarrasses the fool in front of the bar, and when Tyler threatens to go for his gun Earp just slaps him a few times, before delivering the epic line €œAre you gonna do something or just stand there and bleed?€ He wisely takes the second option. Tombstone has plenty of standout performances, but for a relative unknown like Thornton to hold his own against such an amazing cast was proof he had something special.

4. Jacob Mitchell - A Simple Plan

A Simple Plan feels like the odd man out in Sam Raimi€™s directing career; he€™s either known for the splatstick of the Evil Dead movies or huge blockbusters like Spider-Man. A Simple Plan however is a quiet, intense drama about a group of men torn apart by greed when they come across a suitcase full of money. Thornton plays Jacob, the simple-minded brother of leading man Bill Paxton. Jacob is the innocent of the group, who is uncomfortable with how the money is affecting everyone. Thornton€™s soft-spoken turn is easily the most touching, and the audience can feel his heartbreak when his brother becomes more ruthless and single-minded in his quest to keep the money. His final scene with Paxton, when the characters realize it€™s far too late to turn back, is the most shattering of the film. Thornton was given an Oscar nod for his performance; though sadly the film seems to be forgotten about today.

3. Karl Childers - Sling Blade

Sling Blade is the movie that made Billy Bob a household name, whilst also launching a thousand €œmmm-hmm€ impersonations. He wrote, directed and starred in this indie drama about a mentally disabled man struggling to fit back into society after killing his mother, and it€™s a stunning piece of work. Thornton transformed himself physically for the role, developing the character€™s distinctive speech pattern and mannerisms over the course of many years. The scene where he describes killing his mother is a chilling look inside Karl€™s mind, and even though he's normally a gentle figure there€™s a darkness that lingers over him throughout. His dark side will eventually re-emerge; it€™s just a question of when. The heart of the movie is the friendship between Karl and a boy named Frank, which brings some much-needed tenderness. There€™s a grim inevitability about how the movie ends, but for a little while, Karl gets to be treated as an equal instead of an outcast. Sling Blade received a veritable shower of awards, with Thornton taking home a much-deserved Oscar for his screenplay.

2. Lorne Malvo - Fargo: Season One

Billy Bob reminds people every few years just how great he can be, and he delivered career-best work in the first season of Fargo. Lorne Malvo must rank as one of the greatest psychopaths€™s to ever grace television; he€™s an intelligent, manipulative predator who can €“ and frequently does - explode into violence at any given moment. Billy Bob plays Malvo with an eerie calm that€™s chilling to watch, and even when he€™s murdering people it rarely feels personal one way or the other. Lorne is also a great actor himself, with the ability to blend in and appear normal depending on who he€™s around. Thornton is never less than mesmerizing in the role, and he€™s given a number of memorable scenes €“ like meeting Sam Hess for the first time or the infamous elevator sequence €“ to display just how good he can be. Malvo is a rare combination of the perfect character for the perfect actor, and he duly won a Golden Globe for his work on the show.

1. Willie Stokes - Bad Santa

The best Christmas movie ever €“ for people who despise Christmas €“ Bad Santa finds Billy Bob in the role of a sleazy, alcoholic thief posing as a department store Santa. His character is introduced puking outside a bar, which tells the audience all they need to know. He€™s a bitter, vile human being and Thornton has a complete blast playing him. In the wrong hands Willie Stokes could have just been a nasty, irredeemable jerk but Billy Bob gives him a little glimmer of humanity that prevents him being completely hateful. His relationship with a lonely boy is touching, but the movie stops short of being gooey and sentimental about it. It helps that he has a great comedy script full of awesome zingers, and an awesome supporting cast. In many ways, Bad Santa would be become his signature role, though the movie€™s success meant he€™d be typecast in "jerk€ roles for years to come. A sequel €“ creatively titled Bad Santa 2 €“ will be released November 2016.

...And 5 That Sucked

5. Homer Carlton - On Deadly Ground

On Deadly Ground is Steven Seagal€™s moving, heartfelt tribute to Steven Seagal. The ponytailed one also directed the film, where he€™s a mercenary working for evil oil baron Michael Caine. When he€™s betrayed by his boss he discovers the only way to prevent a devastating oil spill in Alaska is to blow up an oil refinery; which feels a little faulty in terms of logic. Billy Bob is one of the mercenaries that shows up to take Seagal down, and the film marked the last time he was cast in the bit role of a colourful redneck. He doesn€™t get a lot to do, other than offer some wry commentary on Seagal€™s superhuman antics. His biggest scene is a clearly improvised comedy bit where he€™s talking about his machine gun, and his annoying shtick is mercifully put to a stop when he€™s blown up. Thornton soon moved on from thankless roles like this, and cinema was all the better for it.

4. Jasper Woodcock - Mr. Woodcock

Mr. Woodcock was an easy paycheck role for Thornton, where he played an abusive P.E. teacher who comes into conflict with an old student. Everyone from Thornton to the director disowned the final product, and Seann William Scott admitted he and Billy Bob would regularly sit around onset discussing how terrible the movie was. This translates to Thornton€™s low energy performance, where he€™s clearly not engaged by anything going on around him. His non-reaction to the zany antics has less to do with playing it straight than him simply not caring, leaving it up to Scott to try to sell the jokes. The film manages a couple of snickers despite itself, but it mostly coasts along on tired bad taste gags. When Thornton is on form he can make people engaged with even the lamest movie; here, he's just bored and grumpy, like everyone else in the audience.

3. Douglas - Into The Grizzly Maze

Into The Grizzly Maze went through many names (Red Machine, Grizzly, Endangered) before finally being dumped to DVD, where it went unseen by the masses. The plot follows a group of people being hunted by a vicious grizzly bear, and despite the title hinting the grizzly itself has built a maze to trap them in, they€™ve just stranded in some dreary woods instead. The film liberally borrows from Jaws so Billy Bob is assigned the role of the crazy hunter, who arrives from time to time on a white horse to deliver clunky exposition. Thornton looks like he€™s having fun, which probably has more to do with getting paid well for a few days work than enjoying the material. The trouble is he€™s not in the least convincing in the part of an experienced hunter, and when he appears it feels like he€™s arrived from another film completely. Although Thornton isn€™t the biggest problem with Into The Grizzly Maze, he€™s capable of much better work than this.

2. Morris Buttermaker - Bad News Bears

Buttermaker is another one of those jerk roles Billy Bob was offered after Bad Santa, and just like Mr. Woodcock he doesn€™t look all that jazzed about it. And he shouldn€™t be either, with the film being a lazy remake of the original with some raunchier jokes added in; but nothing too raunchy, since the film is aimed at teens. Billy Bob is content to recycle his Willie Stokes routine, and with a lack of solid gags to back him up he€™s left stranded. The child actors aren€™t much better, and it€™s really hard to root for any of the characters to succeed. Bad News Bears was a rare leap into mainstream waters for director Richard Linklater, who was clearly going after the same audience that embraced School Of Rock. Unfortunately, whatever magic worked there disappeared when he made this, and both he and Thornton were just going through the motions until the check cleared.

1. Dr. Oliver Lorvis - The Big Bang Theory

Comedy graveyard The Big Bang Theory is somehow still chugging along after all these years, and Billy Bob got roped in to play the guest role of a creepy doctor lusting after Penny. Poor Thornton looks a little dazed throughout his episode, with his character being a socially awkward weirdo who instantly falls in love with any woman that touches him. He€™s lumbered with many groan-worthy gags about kidney stones and Star Trek, and the laughter track goes into overtime trying to make it all seem funny. Thornton has played some fine weirdos throughout his career, so maybe with a better script and gags that cut a little deeper than €œAh shucks, I€™m such a socially awkward dweeb!€ his appearance could have been great. Since greatness is a concept unfamiliar to The Big Bang Theory, his role is just wasted potential. What are your favourite Billy Bob Thornton performances? Do you disagree with any of the choices on the list? Share your thoughts in the comments below.