Oscars 2013: 5 Things The Academy Got Right

By Nick Fulton /

I don't like to make a lot of controversial statements but here goes: the Oscars often go to people who should not have won them. Yeah, I went there. From Crash to Shakespeare in Love, from Dances With Wolves to How Green Was My Valley, the Academy has a long history of overlooking greatness. These instances in the past have been well documented, and this Sunday night was no exception, as WhatCulture writer Shaun Munro's article this week detailed. But the Academy's decisions haven't been all bad. Though it didn't win Best Picture, Pulp Fiction did take home an Oscar for Best Screenplay. The Godfather and Godfather Part II both won Best Picture. And while many may disagree, Annie Hall deservedly beat out Star Wars in the '70's. While far from a perfect track record this year, the Academy did make some good choices. So grab yourself some extra-buttery popcorn and tune in as we revisit Oscars 2013: 5 awards that were well deserved....

5. Best Animated Short Film - Paperman

Coming into the 85th Annual Academy Awards, many people thought that the short animated film The Longest Daycare was the front-runner. The Simpsons, a beloved TV show that's run for well over 2 decades in prime time, submitted its nearly silent look at its most enigmatic and least well-known family member, the baby Maggie. Accompanied by a beautiful Hans Zimmer score, Maggie tiptoes through the hazards of daycare as she attempts to save a caterpillar from the threatening hammer of the monobrowed baby. The cartoon is sweet and whimsical, giving us a new look at a character we've been familiar with since the late '80's but haven't gotten to know as intimately as Homer or the rest of the Simpson clan. But the winner ended up being Paperman, a romantic short that was half-computer and half-traditionally animated. Just like the Simpsons' short, it is a whimsical story told with visuals and music alone, minimizing dialogue but still managing to capture the audience's imaginations with two characters who instantly draw us into their lives. With a chance meeting due to uncontrollable winds and loose leaf paper gone wild, we find ourselves rooting for the man to reconnect with the mysterious woman he met at the bus stop. Paperman is a beautiful short film that in less than 7 minutes manages to build a love story deeper and more profound than many Oscar award winners.

4. Best Foreign Language Film - Amour

I'm aware that this award really should've only been met with "well duh." The film by Austrian director Michael Haneke was the only foreign language film nominee which had a shot at winning the Best Picture award this year, so the fact that it would win in the Foreign Language category should've been a shoo-in. But since this is the Academy we're talking about, it still needs to be pointed out that they managed to not mess this one up. In the year's most devastating and personal film, Haneke's Amour tackles the subject of aging with crippling starkness. While nearly every other director would sugar coat the film with moments of sweetness, every touching moment that does happen in Amour-- of which there actually are many-- is truly bittersweet, as we watch the final chapter of a long and fruitful marriage. The true shock of this film is the realness of it. The comedian Louis CK has a joke in which he claims that marriages end in one of two ways; divorce or death. This is a visceral and vivid picture of the latter scenario. When I saw the film in theaters and the movie ended, it was over a minute into the hushed end-credits before anyone could even stand to get up from their chairs. It's a truly deserving award from a brutal but necessary film.

3. Best Supporting Actor - Christoph Waltz

This was perhaps my favorite award at the Oscars this year, as unlike the other winners such as Daniel Day-Lewis, Anne Hathaway and Jennifer Lawrence, Christoph Waltz seemed truly surprised to have won. Whereas in his previous Oscar win he'd swept all of the previous awards and his Academy Award appeared like a lock, the Vegas odds this year were firmly on Tommy Lee Jones and Robert De Niro. In 2009 we saw an actor who seemed cool and relaxed as he graciously won his Oscar for Inglourious Basterds. This year, he seemed shocked, nervous and genuinely ecstatic to win. Part of what made Waltz' performance in last year's Django Unchained so impressive was that just a few years ago, he received his award for playing one of the most evil and terrifying villains in recent film history. Dr. King Schultz this year is a profoundly different role, with character arcs that take him in a completely different direction from the Jew Hunter Hans Landa. Though the other nominees in this category had previously received Oscars and are solid actors in their own right, none of the performances quite had the substance and nuance of Waltz' Dr. King.

2. Best Supporting Actress - Anne Hathaway

Anne Hathaway claiming "it came true" when she won her award felt awkward and rehearsed. She then went on to thank so many people it's possible she even mentioned my name. And when she thanked her husband, it killed the collective erection nerds worldwide had for her since seeing her as Selina Kyle last summer. But all that being said, Ms. Hathaway put on a true tour de force performance last year as Fantine in the famed musical Les Miserables. She manages to equally capture the desperation of a woman putting herself through hell on behalf of her ill child, while simultaneously being stunning, leaving the audiences' collective mouths agape at her rendition of the tune "I Dreamed A Dream." Though the film isn't perfect and is rather clunky at times (specifically, those pesky scenes in which Anne isn't on screen), her portrayal of Fantine is truly worth the price of admission in every sense of the word.

1. Best Actor - Daniel Day-Lewis

This year, Oscar history was made as Daniel Day-Lewis became the first actor to win three Best Actor awards. Daniel Day-Lewis is known for his method style of acting in which he completely immerses himself in his characters. In his last Oscar-winning role, DDL created the legendary anti-hero Daniel Plainview, an oil tycoon whose heart is as black as the liquid he obtains from the earth. In Spielberg's epic biopic Lincoln, Day-Lewis manages to channel the essence of one of the most famous and important men throughout world history. In an obviously remarkable performance, Day-Lewis' Lincoln is a generally quirky and soft-spoken man, a raconteur who is dead-set on changing the landscape of racial relations within his country. In the last few years in cinema, few performances if any have even started to approach the depths and subtleties that DDL pulls off in this film. Daniel Day-Lewis does not merely act in his films, but he becomes the character, proving again in Lincoln that he's one of the greatest actors to ever grace the silver screen. Honorable mentions: Skyfall's Best Song, Zero Dark Thirty not being completely shut out. Your thoughts? Leave a comment or find me on my podcast in my bio below.