10 Controversial Gaming Opinions You Should Keep To Yourself

Nintendo are just... alright.

By Adam Hogg /

When it comes to any form of entertainment media, opinions are always subjective. Whether it's movies, books, TV or video games, there are always a wide variety of different opinions. If you like something, then there it is guaranteed that you won't have to look far for someone who disagrees with you. And that's perfectly alright. No one has to love anything in particular.

Advertisement

But, when it comes to any form of entertainment, there are always some opinions that are generally met with the usual: "What? How can you not love/hate it? It's perfect! How dare you?"

Whilst every fandom has their rabid fanboys, more often than not there are franchises that are so beloved that they are often deemed untouchable. Questioning these gods of the gaming pantheon will earn you a one-way ticket to the internet's wrath.

It's not just beloved franchises either. Sometimes there are games that are so fervently abhorred, so despised in the eyes of gamers, that enjoying them renders you a heathen. Obviously, everyone is entitled to their opinion, but when it comes to facing the anger of the internet, it's probably best to keep some of those more controversial opinions to yourself...

10. Sonic Has Never Been Good

Sonic fans always protest that Sonic was once a great series. Instalment after instalment pushed the legacy of Sonic through the dirt, to the extent that every new game is almost an inside joke. But, through all the Sonic 06s and the questionable creative decisions, Sonic fans still profess that the series will return to it's prime soon. But... Sonic never really had a prime, did it?

Advertisement

The first game was as good as it got, and even then it wasn't that great. The original levels were such a twisted and gnarled mess, making navigation a chore. The fun parts were speeding along at the speed of sound, but they were always undercut by slow, janky and imprecise platforming.

Running fast and having precise platforming don't belong in the same sentence. They don't work well with one another and that's a conclusion that's only exemplified by the poorer and poorer quality of each of the games.

9. Rockstar Make Bad Shooting Mechanics

Red Dead Redemption and GTA V are carried on their stories and characters. People remember the exciting interactions and the colourful dialogue. Not that one time they had to go someplace and shoot some people. Or that other time that they had to go to a different place and shoot some slightly different people.

Advertisement

The shooting mechanics in these games are poor. All you do is point and shoot. Unless you turn off aim assist, there is little to no input required to clear a room. And if you do turn off aim assist, the game becomes unbelievably difficult because it wasn't designed to be played that way.

It doesn't help that all the missions in which you use the shooting mechanics are the same. It's just a constant bounce between different places and different shoot-outs, with each one lacking enough distinctive qualities to set them apart from one another.

That's not to say that the games are bad. Their stories are great, but the gameplay isn't nearly as refined.

8. Bethesda Make Terrible Games

Bethesda should stick to designing worlds. The worlds of the Elder Scrolls and Fallout are so intricate and detailed. The lore is spectacular, and wandering around these vast open spaces is simply a joy to behold. Everything is crammed with stuff to see and places to go, with small stories interwoven with locations.

Advertisement

However, the actual game aspects leave a lot to be desired. Combat is clunky and the overarching stories are clumsily handled with characters lacking any actual character. Quests amount to the same cycle of kill or fetch quests.

It's a shame, because the worlds are so engrossing. It's just interacting with those worlds needs a lot of work.

And Bethesda seems to understand this. There was a lot of effort put into Fallout 4, with the combat being given a massive overhaul. But the characters and everything else lacked in that same polish. When their focus shifts, something else is always destined to suffer as a consequence.

7. Hideo Kojima Isn't The Gaming Messiah

Hideo Kojima has had a few good ideas but constantly falls short in others. He doesn't create perfect games, not even close. He creates flawed masterpieces. He creates some interesting character and stories, but takes it too far, twisting what was once new and creative into something that requires a masters degree in linguistics and psychology just to decipher.

Advertisement

His mind for gameplay is amazing. The evolution of the Metal Gear games is a testament to how well he understands gameplay and creating experiences. But then he crams the games with a bunch of filler.

Kojima is a great and brilliant mind, full of creative and entertaining ideas. However, his status as a gaming messiah is ultimately detrimental. It's the George Lucas effect. Someone needs to tell him to stop sometimes. Because no matter which way you cut it, the character of Quiet isn't exactly a great addition.

6. Dark Souls III Is The Best In The Series

Dark Souls I has a place in the gaming pantheon for good reason. It broke ground and made waves in the industry, improving on every possible aspect from Demon's Souls. However, it is not the best in the series. It has an overbearing sphere of nostalgia that keeps people infatuated, but there is a reason people call it a "flawed masterpiece".

Advertisement

Dark Souls III, however, is that masterpiece refined.

It is far more concise and is fundamentally more consistent than the first game. It might not reach the legendary high points from the first game, but it doesn't have those monumental dips in quality. It is a great experience throughout. The mechanics were made better, the systems refined, and the online hammered out.

The original was groundbreaking, but Dark Souls III polished the broken ground into a fine marble plateau. And then there are people who say the second one is the best one. That's an opinion that should very much be kept to yourself.

5. Nintendo Is Overrated

Nintendo has been kicking around for a long time and for good reason. They have helped build the gaming industry into what it is today. They have developed so many beloved, groundbreaking titles and have shaped the world of gaming for the better. But are they as good as people make them out to be? Simply put, no.

Advertisement

They've created many great games in the past and have pushed the boat out in the name of innovation. However, these days, they are just another developer. They are just like Sony and Microsoft. They may be the only big company that is willing to make mistakes, but they aren't worth the hype they garner.

It always comes down to personal opinion, but the cult-like appreciation they get is quite overblown. They deserve respect for what they have done, but feverishly defending their every move, even when they make mistakes, is not justified.

They aren't infallible gods who milk the nectar of deities and package it up in cheap video game cases.

4. No Man's Sky Can Be Enjoyable

No Man's Sky brought the gaming community together. By giving us all a collective punching bag, we set aside our differences and joined together to bash and criticise a developer that over-promised and disappointed us. However, the game was alright.

Advertisement

The expectations we had were inflated by Sean Murray, meaning that we could only see the game compared to what we were promised. And that left it feeling bland and empty. Had we not had those expectations, it is likely that the game would have been seen in a favourable light. It's randomly generated worlds were quite spectacular. It was just the fact that we expected so much more.

It's an enjoyable experience for the most part. Exploring planets and gathering resources is a fun time-kill. The first few hours of the game are extraordinary. Had we not expected so much, the rest of the game would have been just as awe-inspiring. But as it is, it's not the worst game. It's a surprisingly pleasant game.

3. Loot Boxes Aren't Bad

Loot boxes aren't all bad. Put the pitchforks down and listen.

Advertisement

In theory, they are a way for players who don't have the time to acquire cosmetic items with real money. In theory, they are a reasonable idea that allows companies to make bonus revenue off of people who are invested in their games but simply don't have the time. And in theory, they aren't the abhorrent mess that people make them out to be.

However, in practice, they have been implemented by greedy companies who want nothing but the shakedown their players to get the full experience from a game they have already paid full price for.

That is not to excuse companies like EA and projects like Battlefront 2. There is a distinction between badly marketted loot box systems and explicit extortion. Sure, loot boxes are a bit despicable and scummy, but they aren't the devil incarnate. They are a flawed system being exploited by greedy people. Given time, they could become something great.

2. The N64 Is A Bad Console

The N64 is a beloved console. It represents the childhoods of so many people and due to that, it is protected by a thick layer of nostalgia. No doubt a lot of people recall all the fond memories of playing Goldeneye and Mario 64. But, looking at the console critically... well, that presents some issues.

Advertisement

It is belabored by fundamental issues that go beyond simple age. Even at the time, it wasn't as well polished as it should have been. There were a lot of frame-rate issues making games clunky and jumpy.

Not to mention, the controller was designed by Satan and was only comfortably operable by extreme contortionists.

These aren't issues that are a result of time passing. Consoles of any time shouldn't have these problems. But, that janky console won the hearts of so many people. It's a gaming treasure. However, having four decent games doesn't make it the best thing going.

1. Breath Of The Wild And Mario Odyssey Are... Average

We've already discussed how Nintendo are often held upon an untouchable pedestal, however, there are two games that Nintendo has created recently that have an even higher pedestal than the developers themselves.

Advertisement

Criticising, disliking or even not enjoying the game as much as you should, are met with vapid hatred. Fans lambasted critics for not giving 10/10s, or daring to suggest that maybe Mario Odysey has a superfluous amount of filler simply designed to artificially inflate the number of moons available, even though most of them are just lying there and can be found with minimal effort.

The same can be said for Breath of the Wild. People who didn't think the game fell within the franchise very well, or those who thought there wasn't much to it besides exploring, were met with vehement hatred.

These two games definitely have their problems, but the very vocal part of the internet doesn't want to hear that. They are good games, with solid fundamentals. It's in the dressing and presentation that they fall down considerably.

Advertisement