10 Great Video Games You'll Never Play Again (And Why) - Commenter Edition
Replay value? Never heard of her.
Even more so than going back to your favourite films or books, revisiting your favourite video games offers such an appealing comfort blanket for fans. It's partly why overdue remasters are so successful; as a species we love things that are familiar and habitually return to the media we love to squeeze every last drop out of them.
This goes double for games, which are often replayable by design, with alternate endings, optional playstyles and secondary missions all encouraging players to return to a title time and time again.
All this said, there are some games that a good chunk of fans will never be able to face playing again. They're not bad - far from it - it's just that they were either so demanding, emotionally draining, or strangely structured that one time through is more than enough.
We've compiled a list of these before, but the following ten were entirely chosen by you.
10. Scott Pilgrim Vs. The World
Starting this list off with a bit of a cheat, Scott Pilgrim vs The World is one of the rare movie tie-in games from ten years ago that was actually damn good, but the reason you'll never play it again is simple: it's not actually available anymore.
Published by Ubisoft to coincide with Edgar Wright's movie of the same name, the side-scrolling beat-em-up actually boasted the designs of the original graphic novel series, with pitch-perfect sprites of your favourite characters battling through iconic backdrops and delivering their signature moves (all set to some incredible music, of course).
Tragically, the game vanished from storefronts and was delisted in 2014 unceremoniously, and Ubisoft hasn't commented on it since. Comic creator Bryan Lee O'Malley has apparently tried to get it back, but it's unlikely to ever materialise.
9. Assassin's Creed: Odyssey
The modern Assassin's Creed games are perhaps the biggest examples of 'content games' you can find. They're absolutely humongous - with it taking anywhere between six and ten hours before you even hit the title screen of latest release, Odyssey - stacked with activities to accomplish, story missions to partake in, and freeform exploration to get lost with.
Ubisoft's most recent entry in particular can be stunning, both in terms of its gorgeous, vibrant graphics as well as its compelling cast of characters and deep combat.
Its sheer size probably means you'll never return to it though. As mentioned, this is a game that takes over half-a-dozen hours to even hit the title screen, and one which will still have half the map unexplored by the time the main story is over (which itself can take around 40 hours).
Combine that with a repetitive gameplay structure and Odyssey is probably a game you'll be playing a lot of, but one you'll return to and chip away at a main save for, rather than experiencing the whole thing from scratch.
8. Return Of The Obra Dinn
Return of the Obra Dinn is one of the best games of the last decade, telling the tale of the titular doomed ship via ingenious puzzle gameplay.
You first step foot on the vessel at the end of its journey with everyone either dead or missing, and are tasked with using a time-travelling watch (just go with it) to return to various still scenes from across the voyage and piece together who each shipmate is, how they died and, most importantly, who killed them.
The satisfaction that comes with accurately reporting each person's cause of death is unparalleled, and each chapter of the story is more insane and gripping than the last.
Of course, you'll never play it again because not only will you have solved the whole mystery, but 100% completing the game will have you jumping through each memory so many times, analysing every angle, that you'll have exhausted every scenario and, frankly, be a little sick of them.
You might return for the one secret achievement you missed, but for the most part this game only needs one playthrough to make a lasting impression.
7. Alien: Isolation
Alien: Isolation easily ranks as one of the very best games based on the Aliens franchise (which, honestly, isn't saying too much when it's sharing space with the likes of Colonial Marines), but one common criticism at launch was that the game overstayed its welcome, and that does admittedly effect its replay value.
It's not that the game is too long to play again - after all, it only clocks in at about 14 hours which, these days, is a fraction of most blockbuster runtimes - it's the pacing that's the real 'issue' here.
Alien: Isolation takes a while to ramp up, and extends itself a good few hours past the natural end point. It's never outright bad, but the experience does feel artificially extended, to the point where you get the sense that the devs were worried about players thinking it was too short for the price tag, so they kept adding on set pieces.
However, while Isolation is probably a one-and-done affair, those extra challenge missions? Those things you'll absolutely return to.
6. MAFIA III
Despite its mixed reception at launch, Mafia III is an amazing game. Well, part of it is.
The story of revenge at the heart of it is compelling and presented impeccably, covering Lincoln Clay's brush with the crime syndicate that destroyed his family, as well as his wider conflict with the racism permeating the streets of New Bordeaux. The gameplay is solid as well, with visceral combat complimenting weighty, speedy vehicular handling.
As you all know, there's a pretty big 'but' coming. The thing that drags down Mafia III is its open-world structure. Perhaps taking the criticisms of the previous games to heart, this third release's sandbox is absolutely riddled with things to do, and packed in so much content that the game turns into repetitive box ticking relatively quickly.
Put simply, to advance the story players are forced to complete a bunch of side-missions that repeat throughout the entire game. In isolation, these are actually quite fun, but the forced repetition makes the idea of a second playthrough daunting.
5. Days Gone
Oh, look, it's another Josh Brown list with Days Gone at the heart of it. The thing is, Sony Bend's zombie game is perfect for this particular angle, because while the release is overall a pretty special experience, it's wildly inconsistent. And some people must agree, otherwise it wouldn't have ended up on this commenter's edition.
The main roadblock is the first eight or so hours of gameplay. This PS4 exclusive is long in the tooth - far longer than I think anyone really expected - and it takes its sweet time to properly rev into gear. The tutorial lasts for a lifetime, and it doesn't help that, in order to make the late-game upgrades seem worth it, your bike at the beginning feels like it's attached to an anchor constantly slowing you down and forcing you into trees.
The New Game Plus mode, which was added after launch, alleviates these problems somewhat, but it doesn't stop the repetition that seeps in later either, or the weird structure of the story that's introducing main villains 40 hours in.
Again, Days Gone is absolutely worth playing, but you're more likely to breathe a sigh of relief by the end than find yourself craving more.
4. Firewatch
Like Obra Dinn, Firewatch isn't only one of the best indie games of the past decade, it's one of the best games of the last decade period.
It didn't please everyone though, as while it teased a mysterious, supernaturally-infused plot for the majority of its runtime, the final reveal was purposefully mundane and ordinary, purely there to draw attention to the realistically flawed characters at the heart of the story.
That's both the ace up its sleeve and also the twist that makes playing the game again unlikely though. When you know that the mystery is merely set dressing for the character-driven story, all intrigue is lost on a follow-up playthrough, and it's probably for the best to leave the rug-pull at the end as the lasting, powerful memory of Firewatch's couple of hours.
3. Metal Gear Solid IV: Guns Of The Patriots
Metal Gear Solid IV: Guns of the Patriots is either the dumbest entry in the entire series or the perfect swan song depending on who you ask, and I err on the side of the second opinion. This is a mad game, with a story that pays off decades of personal investment in sometimes ludicrously indulgent ways, and other times in a fashion that's genuinely emotional and resonant.
It's difficult to describe it as a game that's fun to 'play', though. Sure, the sneaking here is as freeform as ever, and there's a bunch of different routes and tactics to try, but the split between cutscenes and gameplay is the wonkiest in the series.
For that reason, it's not exactly a game that invites you to jump in and pick it up for a short stint. Each chapter is bookended by a lengthy cutscene, which can leave you not touching the controller for nearly an hour at a time.
Metal Gear Solid 3 isn't exactly light on cutscenes, but you always know when you pick up the controller you'll be able to enjoy an extended gameplay section that encourages experimentation. The same can't be said for MGS IV.
It also doesn't help that your only options to play it are on a PS3 or through PS Now, hardly making it all that accessible.
2. Undertale
Now, you might have taken one look at this and thought, "Josh, Undertale is massively replayable, you idiot. After all, there's at least three different runs and endings you can get, so it's unlikely you'll only play it once", and while all of that is true, all of those runs are in service of the game's final and most resonant point: that you shouldn't keep playing Undertale over and over again.
This great video by Hbomberguy goes into it in far more depth, but essentially every single time you try to squeeze the game for more content and think outside the box for different runs, the characters will literally ask, "don't you have anything better to do?"
You might think that's just a little fourth-wall breaking joke, but it also fits with the main endings. The good ending sees all of the characters freed from their underworld, the player escorted from the game, and a permanent "The End" screen that can only be removed by closing and booting up the game again from scratch. Then you'll be asked if you want to play again, which essentially dooms the characters by resetting them in the process.
Undertale champions the idea of loving a game but ultimately moving on, and after that realisation, it's difficult to ever go back.
1. Nier: Automata
Like Undertale, Nier: Automata is a game with multiple different endings depending on how many replays you accomplish (though they're all part of the same 'main' run to the proper conclusion), but one which ultimately ends on a point that encourages you to put the game down and move on.
Unlike Undertale though, this time it isn't quite as vague a suggestion. After playing through the stories of three different characters, you get to the final challenge: a bullet-hell fight against the names of the developers, with help from the IDs of other players who've already bested the fight.
After you've won, the game gives you an ultimatum: sacrifice your save data and let your own ID help other players get to the end, or refuse to pay it forward and hang on to your progress.
It's clear which outcome the story is pushing you towards, and once you've sacrificed your save for the greater good, you're left with a sense of finality that most games would never dare to broach.