10 Greatest Horror Video Game Endings

Which video game horror endings left viewers satisfied - and scared?

By Michael John-Day /

It's about the journey, not the destination. While this statement is undoubtedly true, a bad ending to an enjoyable game can easily ruin the entire experience. When you invest your time and energy into playing something and become engrossed in the narrative, it can be devastating to see it fall apart at the last hurdle. Sadly, the genre of horror in video games is often subject to this, as most titles tend to end in a lacklustre manner.

Advertisement

However, with that being said, there are plenty of developers who do an amazing job of bringing their stories to an end. Whether it's a satisfying success for the protagonist or a devastating twist, the following entries conclude their narratives with the utmost skill, making the entire gaming experience worth playing through to the finish.

The games on show here feature a vast collection of styles and gameplay, and - for the most part - are entirely excellent titles that you need to play if you are a fan of the horror video game genre.

This list will feature heavy spoilers for the entries discussed, as can be expected.

10. Little Nightmares

This Bandai Namco Entertainment title is an excellent gem in horror gaming. While leaving the player powerless is a common trope of the genre, this game takes it to the max, as you work your way through a strange prison as a minuscule character surrounded by giant and gluttonous beasts.

Advertisement

Little Nightmares sees you play as Six, a little girl who awakens in a massive underwater vessel known as the Maw. Armed with only a lighter and the help of some Nomes, you journey through the dark and frightening setting with the hope of finding an exit.

Six's size makes the player feel utterly subject to the whims and threat of the large inhabitants, and the multiple bosses all cement this idea of helplessness. However, as the game progresses, Six starts to show a more malicious side, managing to defeat these giant antagonists and even brutally eating some of the helpful Nomes.

This all comes to a front after you defeat the main boss - The Geisha - absorbing her powers and using it to drain the lives of everyone in the Maw before walking out to freedom. Seeing the roles reversed is incredibly satisfying and makes the ending an integral part of the game's appeal.

9. Condemned: Criminal Origins

In this game, you play as an SCU agent named Ethan Thomas, who investigates the scene of a murder. After he loses his gun to a strange man hiding in the shadows, it is used to kill two fellow officers, and Thomas is hunted for the crime. He intends to prove his innocence, but it's clear that not everything is what it seems, as he begins to fight against homeless men and women who have grown inexplicably insane.

Advertisement

Throughout the game, you encounter many enemies and come to learn that a dark creature known as The Hate is responsible for the chaos that has surrounded your playtime. Eventually, you get the chance to end it when you finally take this beast down.

After these events, you watch as Ethan talks with Rosa, a forensics investigator at the HQ and understand that the agency no longer trusts Ethan. Then as he goes into the bathroom, he begins to erupt with pain, and he turns to the camera, revealing that his mouth becomes that of The Hate.

It's a thoroughly dark and tragic way to end the story, ultimately matching the gritty and hopeless tone of the game itself.

8. I Have No Mouth, And I Must Scream

Harlan Ellison's short story I Have no Mouth and I Must Scream is one of the bleakest depictions of a possible future ever seen in literature. It tells of a world that has been ravaged by an artificial intelligence named AM after being programmed to fight a world war for humanity. AM is a vicious and evil being who destroys all of humanity, barring five, whom he keeps alive to torture.

Advertisement

The game sees you take on each of these five individuals' roles throughout and has multiple endings depending on how well you manage to solve AM's games. However, in five out of the seven possible climaxes, you get the same result, which happens to be one of the most horrifying culminations to any piece of gaming.

In most scenarios, the game will end with whichever character you are playing as being turned into a great, soft jelly thing, without the ability to hurt or maim yourself, in constant agony and unable to ease your suffering. This ending is ripped straight out of the source material, which is quoted verbatim by each character.

AM ultimately loses in most scenarios, but humanity's victory is offset by the barbaric and depressing punishment the player receives, ultimately reflecting the nihilistic tone that the short story encompasses.

7. Dead Space

The first Dead Space game completely reinvented the sci-fi horror genre in gaming. It gave players an utterly terrifying ride through a dark and bleak sci-fi world full of intimidating monsters and dramatic tension. It also has an ending that had players taken entirely by surprise.

Advertisement

Our protagonist for this title is Isaac Clarke, an engineer who finds himself navigating a space vessel inhabited by the terrifying Necromorphs. Throughout the game, Isaac searches for his girlfriend Nicole, who appears and communicates with Isaac on his journey.

However, by the end of the narrative, we come to learn that these messages received from Nicole are nothing more than hallucinations, caused by Isaac's damaged sanity and an alien artefact called "The Marker". After leaving the planet Aegis VII with his life, a distraught Isaac mourns the loss of his girlfriend. Soon a message appears on his screen from Nicole, which he promptly ignores, assuming it's a trick of the mind. However, he is then suddenly attacked by a violent hallucination of her.

This abrupt and shocking ending brings into question the information we know. It is a massive question of Isaac's sanity, throwing in one last shock before the title finishes, yet still ending the story satisfyingly.

6. The Walking Dead Season 1

The Walking Dead series by the now defunct Telltale Games was a ground-breaking property that turned Telltale into a highly popular development studio with ties to multiple TV shows, movies and franchises. While calling it a horror title might be a bit of a stretch, the dark and gory interactive drama was certainly brutal enough to qualify.

Advertisement

At the centre of the game was the relationship between Lee and Clementine, an older man and a child who attempt to survive the harsh reality of this zombie-infested world together. The journey they go on is filled with tension, action and adventure, and their relationship only grows to be more and more emotional, which makes this climax all the more tragic.

While the game focused on having multiple events dictate how the narrative unfolds, the ending will always play out the same, with Lee's final moments being utterly heart-breaking. After becoming infected, the player is given a choice to either ask Clementine to kill Lee or run away and let him turn.

The outcome is utterly gut-wrenching but was the perfect way for the game to end.

5. Fatal Frame II: Crimson Butterfly

The Fatal Frame games are some of the most haunting and unique video game titles in horror. The second instalment - Crimson Butterfly - exists with very little connection to its predecessor, but still achieves the same creepy and disturbing atmosphere, something that is captured by the perfect ending.

Advertisement

Crimson Butterfly's story follows the Amakura twins, named Mio and Mayu. After the two visit their favourite play spot, the older sister Mayu ends up following a red butterfly that she sees and Mio follows. The two then discover a haunted village that is inhabited by the tortured souls of the dead.

It is revealed that this village is home to a deep and dark tunnel system, which ends in a "Hellish Abyss", a deep hole that collects dead spirits. In order to appease this abyss and keep it from releasing the dead, a ritual was performed whereby the elder of two twins would strangle their younger sibling, allowing their spirit to act as guardian.

The villagers become insistent on Mio and Mayu enacting this ceremony to save them from a perilous fate, and the Crimson Butterfly climax sees that happen, with the now-deceased twin becoming a red butterfly, linking back to the game's beginning.

There are multiple endings to the title, but this one stands out as the most profound and heart-breaking.

4. Call Of Cthulhu

This video game adaptation of the popular board game based on the work of H.P Lovecraft was somewhat divisive upon its release. Although it looked stunning, it was stifled with lacklustre RPG mechanics and filled to the brim with unclear story elements. With all that said, it still has an utterly shocking climax that brought a sudden uptake in scale.

Advertisement

The game centres around a private investigator named Edward Pierce who travels to the strange whaling town of Darkwater. Whilst there he uncovers a secret cult with sinister intentions and ends up getting dragged into a cosmic and threatening mystery.

Since the title is a role-playing game, the player is given many options that influence the ending, with some causing the protagonist to end up dead, or living in a new nightmarish situation. The final decision rests on a climactic summoning ritual.

No matter what happens, it is never a happy story for Edward Pierce - as is expected with Lovecraft - but one particular highlight is what happens if you choose to take part in the ritual. In this instance, the Great Old One Cthulhu appears in all his horrifying glory, and although it only lasts for a brief second, it is momentous.

3. Inside

Inside is a fantastic follow-up to the hit game Limbo from Playdead. It is a title with an incredible atmosphere and a remarkable ability to play with size. The pacing and gameplay make the title tense and enjoyable, but the surprising ending is easily one of the most memorable moments.

Advertisement

The game centres on an unnamed boy, and as this character, you journey through a strange and dystopic world that has threats around every corner. There is mind-control, underwater psirens, and a violent governmental force chasing you down throughout this strange place. However, the story is left somewhat ambiguous, making the game all the more impressive.

It culminates as the boy discovers a large creature known as The Huddle, which is made up of human limbs. You end up pulled into this Huddle and collectively break out of its entrapment, bursting through a wall and making your way down to the coastline.

The ending is interpretable in many ways, with theories all over about what truly happened, but it makes for a spectacular climax no matter how you read it.

2. Soma

The story of SOMA follows Simon Jarrett, the survivor of a car crash who undergoes an experimental brain scan. After this, we awaken suddenly in the underwater geothermal centre PATHOS-II. What follows is a horrifying experience as you journey through the base encountering robots who believe themselves to be humans, and even find that you are not human either.

Advertisement

It turns out that the Earth was struck by an asteroid, wiping the majority of humanity off of the planet, and in an effort to keep the human race alive, an artificial intelligence named the Warden Unit (WAU) uploaded Simon's brain scan into a robotic body. Humanity is gone, but their minds live on in these bio-mechanical mutants.

Simon is tasked to recover The Ark, a black box with a simulated world for all the brain scans to reside in. The game ends as you sending the Ark off, but remaining in the underwater site. It turns out that the brain scan that was uploaded to was only a copy, and that you will stay here, trapped alone in the dark abyss, while a copy of your conscious lives on.

It's an unbelievably haunting concept about the nature of humanity and sentience. The depressing ending is utterly bleak, even if the post-credits reveal how the copy of Simon is living happily.

1. Silent Hill 2

Silent Hill 2 follows James Sunderland, who travels to the eponymous town after uncovering a letter from his dead wife, Mary. When he reaches the misty setting, he encounters Maria, a woman who bears a striking resemblance to his late wife, albeit with a more aggressive personality.

Advertisement

As the title progresses, you learn a lot about James and even discover that he euthanised his wife due to her illness. It then becomes clear that this strange town's monsters and torture are all a manifestation of the protagonist's psyche, designed to punish him for his wrongdoings.

The game has six endings, with the first three being achievable on an initial playthrough and the others on replay. They consist of multiple scenarios, but the most profound has to be that of the "Maria" ending. This climax sees James leave the town, taking Maria with him, and as they depart, she briefly coughs, revealing that she will likely fall ill just like Mary, and the cycle will repeat.

In addition to the profound endings come two joke climaxes, one which involves alien abduction, whilst the other shows that a dog was responsible for all the events of the game. You've got to love that Team Silent sense of humour.

Advertisement