10 Horror Video Game Sequels BETTER Than The Original

Silent Hill, Evil Within, Outlast - which horror games did everything better?

By Michael John-Day /

There is a common narrative in the world of entertainment that sequels often fall short. This makes a lot of sense, as once a concept has been proven to work, creators try to recreate it and often end up producing something that misses the mark.

Advertisement

This is particularly noticeable in the land of video games, as developers often seek to retain players' enthusiasm by building up well-known brands and inserting multiple instalments into that property. Thanks to this, sequels are abundant, and more often than not, they fail to exceed the quality/success of the original.

With that said, there are a fair few exceptions to the norm.

Whether it's because the creators had a new concept that stuck to the spirit of the original or simply a case of talented people using the first game as a blueprint to expand on, players have been treated to some sublime sequels that managed to overtake their predecessors.

The following horror games truly take the cake for this, all succeeding in keeping players' palms sweaty, despite the majority of us knowing what was coming.

10. Little Nightmares II

Calling this title a sequel might be a fallacy, as the game's events seem to clearly take place before the first instalment, making it a prequel. However, thanks to the canon's ambiguity and the fact that it still follows up the setting, it seems perfectly fair to count it.

Advertisement

The original Little Nightmares was a breath of fresh air for horror gamers, as the unique concept and focus on powerless characters in a 2.5D side-scroller was totally original. Still, after the first game, it seemed like there wasn't anywhere new for the property to go without recreating the same gameplay-loops and ambiguous narrative.

However, Little Nightmares II did just that, as the isolated setting of The Maw was switched up for the ever-expanding and far more diverse Pale City. Here you encountered different ideas like a schoolyard, a hospital, the streets and more.

Additionally, the variety of enemies was far more expansive. Each new antagonist gained a unique power that genuinely challenged the player to think outside the box and adjust to the new requirements to best them.

The story, while still ambiguous, also had a far more compelling side to it, as the introduction of the Thin Man and the shocking narrative beats - which will remain unspoiled here - made the plot far more elaborate.

9. The Evil Within 2

The first Evil Within game was a perfectly harmless (or armless if you played your cards wrong) title that got audiences everywhere feeling nervous, but it wasn't a ground breaker.

Advertisement

It did well enough to garner a sequel, and this instalment managed to capture all the elements that made the first game so exciting but switched it up enough to keep the series moving forward.

In both titles, you take on the role of Sebastian Castellanos, a Detective who enters into terrifying situations and ends up transported to a world full of vile monsters and gruesome imagery. The second game sees this character hit rock bottom but finding a chance for redemption when he's given an opportunity to save his daughter.

Each chapter in The Evil Within received negative responses to the characters and story. This is understandable, as the narrative was somewhat convoluted, and the characters - particularly the lead - were very unremarkable.

Evil Within 2 doesn't fully improve on this, but what it does excel in is a new and more streamlined experience, as the survival horror elements are stronger, thanks to the non-linear pacing. The new open-world makes the feeling of isolation more prominent, as you are left to your own devices far more than in the first.

8. Outlast 2

The first Outlast game took the internet by storm after it became a primetime player in the world of online playthroughs. Scores of YouTubers, Twitch streamers and viewers became obsessed with the chaotic and pulse-pounding title.

Advertisement

While the hospital setting and frequent jump scares certainly had players feeling spooked, the sequel changed this up with a compelling narrative, more powerful graphics and a far more terrifying atmosphere.

Outlast II took place in a desolate village populated by a collection of deranged cultists. These frightening antagonists are convinced that the apocalypse is coming, giving the title a tonne of stakes and adding some stronger supernatural elements.

While many people may prefer the more claustrophobic setting and scare frequency of Outlast, it is still fair to state that thanks to its unique pacing, more inventive narrative and a heavier emphasis on variety, the second does things the original doesn't. It didn't soar to the same popularity as its predecessor, but many believe it's a more potent - and scarier - outing.

It's is an entirely different experience to its original, so your preference can go either way. Still, Red Barrels certainly created one hell of a sequel here.

7. Resident Evil 2

The quality of this Resident Evil deserves so much credit, not only for improving upon its predecessor but ensuring an excellent shelf-life for the property.

Advertisement

While the first game took place in the iconic Spencer Mansion, this sequel evolved the setting and brought you to the heart of Racoon City. The mansion setting may have felt more restricting, and therefore tenser, but switching it up to a larger land made the wide-reaching impact of the T-Virus seem all the more impactful.

Resident Evil 2 improved upon its predecessor in many ways, and while it still slipped into pitfalls like clunky controls and poor voice acting, it managed to better them. The level designs were far more dynamic, and the influx of new enemies gave the players an entirely new threat to keep them freaked out, and the expanded lore of the series was enthralling.

It started to begin the new adrenaline-filled direction for the franchise and ultimately became the game that allowed Resi to remain relevant today.

6. Pathologic 2

The chronology and sequel status of the Pathologic games aren't quite so clear cut as other franchises. This game may share a numerical reference to its order, but it acts more like a remake than a direct continuation. Still, there are narrative elements that allow it to continue onwards, and the ambiguity surrounding its chronology is a perfect metaphor for the surreal adventure that is Pathologic.

Advertisement

It's setting centres on a town that has been hit by a devastating plague. You are then tasked with helping citizens to survive whilst attempting to keep your own lungs breathing. It is a harsh and brutal experience as no matter how hard you try, things will go wrong.

This game is filled from top to bottom with peculiar imagery, as the embodiments of the plague and general scenery are so creative and unique. Additionally, it completely wrenches gaming tropes from you, as is subverts a lot of what you'd expect from a game. For example, while other titles that give you choices make the good and evil distinctions clear, you get no such luxury in the world of Pathologic.

It's a gaming experience unlike any other, and while you get a little less story in this second instalment, you get a far better playing game, with some haunting visuals and fantastic pacing.

There is also a complete remake of the first game dubbed Pathologic Classic HD, which also deserves mention here.

5. Left 4 Dead 2

When it comes to remembering the Left 4 Dead franchise, does anyone not think of Left 4 Dead 2 first? This game truly felt like the series' primary instalment, and it was a massive success thanks to its compelling four-player set-up, awesome zombie action, and exhilarating gameplay.

Advertisement

Left 4 Dead put you into the shoes of one of four protagonists after a massive zombie apocalypse as you and your team attempt to survive the onslaught of these rabid beasts. The second game was a direct continuation of this concept, but it came with stronger graphics, new melee/firearm weapons, and massive replayability.

Sitting down with your friends - albeit not always in the same room - and going to town on some zombie foes was an easy time killer, and the absence of skill progression and the like meant that the title never got boring. Your character's never improved outside of your skills at the game, which meant that the more you put in, the more you got.

While the sequel didn't necessarily change anything from the formula, it was still more bombastic, memorable and violent than it's original.

4. Resident Evil 7: Biohazard

Resident Evil, a series so good that it makes the list twice.

Advertisement

If Resident Evil 2 was the game that proved the property's value as a series, then Biohazard was absolutely the title that brought faith back to the waning franchise. It did so by completely reinventing it, but not forgetting what made Resi so beloved in the first place. This is exactly what a gaming sequel should do, and it's hard to think of one that did better.

The previous games all featured either fixed camera angles, or over the shoulder third person perspectives. But, instead of this, Biohazard forced you into a first-person perspective as you explored a derelict property owned by a terrifying malformed family. The narrative received a tonne of praise, as the villainous characters were some of the scariest in gaming, and the exploration progression of the title gave the setting a real sense of life.

Completely changing the perspective was - at first - seen as a deformation of the typical Resi identity. Still, Biohazard truly returned to the franchises glory days, as it focussed on the horror survival mechanics of the younger titles but added in plenty of elements from the more action-packed instalments.

3. Fatal Frame II: Crimson Butterfly

The Fatal Frame series is a horror gaming masterpiece, but, unfortunately, it didn't sell as well in US markets as it did in Japan. Despite this, the focus on Japanese ghost folklore, and the fascinating combat mechanic, which saw you use a camera to defend yourself against your foes, was utterly unique and made the games incredibly tense.

Advertisement

There have been five mainline instalments, with the first three making up an impactful trilogy. However, it's the second entry that perfected the franchise and is still widely considered one of the scariest video games ever made.

Part of what makes Fatal Frame such a compelling franchise - as noted earlier - is the innovative combat. It sets you the task of waiting until just the right moment to score that Fatal Frame shot and in order to do so, you have to let the spirits and beasts get as close to you as possible.

Crimson Butterfly continued this fantastic gameplay but added in a thoroughly profound narrative to accompany the scares. It told the tale of a pair of twins named Mio and Mayu as they explored an abandoned village and uncovered an ancient ritual. The story went to some deeply emotional places and made the game even scarier than the last.

2. Castlevania: Symphony Of The Night

Symphony of the Night is an easy option for this list, as it's universally considered the strongest entry in its franchise. The Castlevania series is a beloved staple in the horror genre and was an early example of how the dark and macabre could translate to the gaming world. This sequel took everything learned in its prior iterations and perfected them.

Advertisement

The game took place four years after it's predecessor - Rondo of Blood - and gave you control over Dracula's Dhampir (half human, half vampire), son Alucard. Within the title, you explore and attempt to destroy Dracula's newly reappeared castle and try to bring down your father and the monsters inside.

Like many Castlevania games, it's filled with excellent platforming, strong boss-battles and a lavishly gothic presentation that keeps the player mesmerised.

One of the game's most significant selling points was its introduction of non-linear progression. You discovered the setting through organic exploration, uncovering magical items that helped you unlock new castle areas. This even ended up coining the term "Metroidvania" to reference the use of backtracking and exploration.

It changed the game enough, yet kept the spirit alive, making it a flawless sequel.

1. Silent Hill 2

The first Silent Hill game was a title that Konami didn't expect or even particularly want to succeed. It was created by a rag-tag group of developers who were considered to be underperformers and meant to be a simple Resident Evil clone.

Advertisement

Still, everything changed after the first Silent Hill released. It became a barnstorm hit, and people eagerly awaited a follow-up.

Silent Hill 2 deserves so much credit for being a risky venture that would define the franchise. It didn't act as a continuation of the previous game. Instead, it carved out a new path and told the story of James Sunderland, an incredibly complex character who arrived in the titular town after receiving a letter from his dead wife.

This title wasn't just a creepy as all hell horror game, as it was also a profound character study, which delved into the concept of guilt, remorse and trauma. These heavy subjects made it one of the most moving and surreal experiences you could have with a controller.

While many missed the grungy and gory imagery of the first game, the dreamlike atmosphere, cold setting and powerful story made up for it. Plus, there was still a whole load of body horror, and even the introduction of the franchise's most iconic character, Pyramid Head.

Advertisement