10 Reasons You're Wrong About Mass Effect 3's Ending
Four years on, maybe we can finally take an objective look at this?
Somebody was going to do this eventually. And so, theorder of the day, dear reader, is to play devil's advocate in a defence case not even Johnnie Cochran would touch: the Mass Effect 3 ending trial.
The following few pages comes to you from someone who did nothing other than try to enjoy the much-maligned conclusion to the series, and who was not moved to hate it by any of the arguments found online.
To that end, even after the extended cut was releasedto appease the angry masses in 2012, some gamers just weren't (and still aren't)satisfied. Is it the perfect video game ending ever seen? Maybe not, but does that make it a complete failure as well as grounds for consumer action?This is rather harsh. Did I say rather? I meant medievally.
True, the majority of complaints are perfectly rational conversation-starters, but not arguments for completely ruining the whole trilogy. For the most part, the real problem seems to be that after having our socks knocked off for two and a half games, we could accept nothing short of abig finish blowing our legs clean off at the knees.
So read on, as Ipoint out ten reasons why maybe, just maybe, everybody has been too hard on Commander Shepard's last stand...
10. Trilogy Syndrome
Setting aside the specifics of this particular franchise, there is a bit of history going against any game/movie/etc. tasked with closing out a great trilogy. There are numerous examples, many of them recent, of the following series of events:
a) First chapter comes along, raises the bar and generates a huge buzz for things to come.
b) Sequel comes along, expands on its predecessor to the point of near-perfection, franchise evolves into classic.
c) Expressly final instalment is released, must corral a massive story into a conclusion, deemed a disappointment for the franchise despite being a top effort by normal standards.
Whereas the bookends of the trilogy have constraints and obligations such as establishing worlds or wrapping up the story, ME2 had the benefit of simply letting the story run wild. It was a superlative experience; unfortunately it also set a tone no followup could match, at least not one tasked with ending the series.
Fair to the creators? Debatable. Either way, without even getting into the merits of the game, it's worth pointing out that the bias of high expectations probably helped exacerbate the backlash against the Dark Knight Rises of video games.
And while we're on the topic of expectations
9. Unrealistic (Impossible?) Expectations For An Open-Ended Conclusion
Of all the reasons people found to hate the ending(s) of ME3 (especially before the fix,) the loudest outcry had to be severe disillusionment over BioWare leaving behind the decision/consequence system that had become the franchise's calling card.
After all the touting and trumpeting of the far-reaching impact of countless decisions you made for Shepard, how could it all boil down to threecanned options unrelated to the path you chose?
While it was perfectly normal to dream of a finale tailored to your character's past choices, it would have been an unrealistic task for BioWare to try and program all the story permutations into a decent close. They'd previously done such a nice job of carrying forward player decisions, that hopes ended up dashed when they didn't find a way to integrate it all into one last master stroke.
Imagine you just spent years painstakingly writing one of the greatest stories ever told, but your editor wouldn't release it until you wrote 20 different endings, each of them neatly and satisfyingly wrapping up the preceding magnum opus. Would you, a) squeeze their neck until their eyes bulged, or b) oh wait, this isn't multiple choice.
Which leads us to the next point
8. The Saga NeededA DefinedEnding
Let's imagine for a moment that some sort of fluid, personalized endings were possible. What are the odds that even half of them would have lived up to the whole thing from a storytelling perspective?
Either the differences between endings would have been superficial (i.e. a few added stills or cutscenes) to protect the cohesiveness of it all, or BioWare could have made patchwork endings stitching together major elements and prayed it all stuck together when viewed.
At some point, for the purposes of this whole epic reaching a cohesive and satisfying conclusion, the range of variables needed to taper off as the ending tookshape.
But, you ask, couldn't they have just worked harder to wring maximum impact out of every puzzle piece, every combined picture, every nuance? To answer a question with a question: could you have waited an additional six months before getting to play the darned thing?
And in any case, why would the fate of the galaxy hinge on the comparatively small choices you made two games earlier? How awful would it be to find out that you could have had a perfect ending somehow, if only you hadn't killed Wrex when you were still in college?
7. The Morality System Can't Do Everything
Some gamers have complained about the three given options being too ambiguous from a morality standpoint, which kept them from picking the one that best suited their moral preference. Never mind that the original two (red = kill, blue = control) are colour-coded and morally consistent with Renegades and Paragons, respectively.
Others wondered why the game simply didn't play out the right ending on its own. If Shepard had been executing mercs, decking reporters and strong-arming salespeople for the whole trilogy, why would they want to break character this close to the end? Never mind that this might be the only way the original cut could have been even more poorly received.
By the end of the game, there really is no more need for the moral ratings to play a role. It's the end of the story, and your Paragon/Renegade status simply wears out its usefulness a few scenes earlier. That doesn't mean the system has been thrown away; it's just hitting the showers after working hard for you all game long.
Can you imagineif the Catalyst gave you a choice between end this war peacefully and show no mercy? Would that have made it any better? Don't think - the answer is no.
6. It's Not Just One Ending Tweaked Three Times
There are some who, among other exhibits against the endings, have pointed out an alleged plot hole concerning what happens to the mass relays, and thus the future of travel across the galaxy.
People quite correctly noticed that the relays explode during the final event as each one spreads a pulse of whatever colour your Shepard chose across the galaxy. However, some jump to the conclusion that this means they're destroyed. And therefore what the heck, all those squadrons from all over the galaxy, marooned in Earth space, doomed to yadda yadda yadda, not a happy ending.
Okay, so it's not going to be an easy two months, but in all three endings, the implication is that the mass relays will be restored. In the red ending, it's said that the relays were badly damaged. So it's the least hopeful ending it's still hope.
In the other two, the galaxy now has access to Reaper/Prothean technology; the entire theme is limitless potential and bright futures. It's safe to assume they fix those bad boys up in the epi-epilogue. Nobody told BioWare that some people need absolutely every detail spelled out.
Sorry, critics, no plot hole.
4. It Wasn't About Main Character Epilogues
Many complain that after a whole game of character development (or two, or three, depending) the endings told us nothing about what happened to them when the war ended. After all, what's the point of getting invested in the characters if we don't know how it all worked out for them?
But at the end of the day, what we're really invested in is the fate of the galaxy, which is why the epilogue is that much more macroscopic. The only individual who really needed a personal ending was Shepard, and we know what her fate was.
Say you're watching some sci-fi movie. Most of the time, the ending goes something like this: the world is safe, things can go back to normal and now, here's what happens next to the characters. We're used to that format, so when an ending comes along like the world is completely changed here's what happens to the world, it feels like something's missing.
Nobody is saying it wouldn't have been a really nice cherry on top to see (bad example) Garrus opening a thriving rent-a-car business on Palaven or (good example) Tali sunbathing, but it doesn't diminish the fact that they answered the most important question: what happens to everybody?
3. AllThe Options AreWell Fleshed Out
There have been many comments made that the endings are too perfect and all-encompassing to be reduced to a round of pick a door. After all the fighting, politicking and exploring, you more or less went from crisis to unmitigated victory in one button press. Dios ex martini (or something)
However, each one of them is given a plausible explanation as to why exactly the bad guys just put God's remote control in your boney human hands. Sure, one may be weaker than the others, but it still does its job of writing out the Reapers in a logical way.
But what about my heroic conquest? Why is it all talk now? What is this, Kill Bill? Actually, you were so much of a bloody hero that you made the Reapers throw out the old playbook, and now you're discussing new plays for the future of organic life. Just typing it feels grandiose.
It's also interesting that the obvious choice (namely the red ending, which up until then was the ending we all though we were building up to) ends up being the least happy option on the list.
Whichever way you go, the whole set-up is far more grounded in the story than many will give it credit for.
2. The Defiance Ending Is Basically An Easter Egg
The hidden fourth ending is a pretty smooth touch as well.
As most games would, the original release of ME3 was programmed to just wait until you triggered one of the stated options, allowing you to empty your gun at the Catalyst with no reaction.
Nobody really quipped about it; it's one of those minor reality breaks that just blends into the background of the experience. In fact, at a point like this one, most gamers think nothing of shooting at an NPC like it's part of the scenery before proceeding; others will be half-testing if it actually does something. Well, surprise!
It also takes advantage of a player's habits with conversation. For those who play full Renegade, their stubborn dialogue choices might go unintentionally too far; rather than arriving at some persuasion sentence to talk yourself into a more perfect ending, you end up with So be it
Craftier still, after getting the bleakest conclusion possible, you learn the next Reaper war would be won thanks to your advances... a sad ending with a happy ending. It makes it okay for those gamers whose fired one shot at the Catalyst either by accident or out of habit, only to be briefly treated to an elaborate You f***ed up.
1. The Synthesis Ending Is Ridiculously Feel-Good
The green ending is just about the happiest ending you could dream of. Seriously, who could have thought at the beginning of ME 2that it would all end on such a wildly optimistic note?
Seriously, the war's over, and not only are the bad guys our new BFF's, but everybody in the galaxy could be on the way to total enlightenment and even immortality.
The whole thing is bursting with uplifting imagery that tugs at the soul, albeit with the subtlety of a jackhammer. The moment the husk's eyes light up with sympathy, the Geth chatting it up with the unmasked Quarian -new advances are now making absolutely everything betterthan it's ever been, all thanks to the magic of coming together for a better tomorrow. Like really, really together. And by ending hate, we're actually going to kill death itself. Are you freakin'kidding?
Finally, although this is mentioned nowhere in-game, the whole thing implies that Joker is finally going to be able to make a flesh n' blood woman out of EDI.
If you're grouchy enough to watch this ending and leave unhappy, then this begs the question: when you go out to boo Christmas plays, do you bring eggs or tomatoes?
I rest my case... Any responses? Any additions? Give me your best shot in the comments!