10 Video Game Sequels That Look WORSE Than What Came Before

What went wrong?!

By Richard C Shaffer /

Much like we all do, as years progress, gaming technology evolves. Once upon a time we had games limited by how many colors the 8-bit processor could handle, chiptune music and a two-button controller. But now we have games with Hollywood actors convincingly motion-capped, next-level voice acting, orchestral music arrangements and more buttons than ever before.

Advertisement

We're no longer in a world where Mega Man has to be blue, because the palette is limited. Nay, I say! We are in a world where sometimes you watch a cut scene and say to yourself, "Is this cut scene live action or just a really good pre-render?"

But for every leap and bound in gaming, there is a misstep and a fall.

For every Quantum Break there is a Ghostbusters - both from 2016, mind you - that fails to hit a few boxes on the 'evolution is a good thing' checklist. Or in the case of the studio-bankrupting Ghostbusters, hitting any boxes whatsoever.

Bring your rose-tinted glasses for this list, because some of these titles are real disasters to look at.

10. Penny Arcade: Episode 3

Penny Arcade is a long-running webcomic run by the iconic duo Gabe and Tycho (real names Jerry Hokiens and Mike Krahulic) which specialize in gaming humor with a touch of the dark, offensive tone that everything had back in 1998.

Advertisement

In 2008 the PA crew teamed up with newly formed studio, Hothead Games, to develop Penny Arcade Adventures: One the Rain-Slick Precipice of Darkness. Which, if you were a fan of the comic, was chock full of references and writing that fit the namesake perfectly. The game utilized an art style similar to the comic at the time and allowed for a created character to play as.

And then came Episode 3, after Hothead Games stepped away from the series and was replaced by Zeboyd Games. This moved the series from a cell-shaded artistic style like the comics into a 16-bit spritely JRPG style.

Don't take this the wrong way - Zeboyd's game still look fine, but the move to a 'retro' style is a downgrade - especially with the feature loss of your original created character no longer being in the game.

9. Mass Effect 3

Mass Effect is, at this point, a classical example of how to do things right. Bioware did so many things right with the series leading into the sequel and then into the third game. Now don't get us wrong, Mass Effect 3 is still a beautiful game - but there are clear cases where you can see that visual stimuli have not evolved along with the numbers.

Advertisement

Explosions are a noted grade lower than they were before. The character models seem to lack a bit of the polish that they had in ME 2, and in some instances the animations are lacking. A major complaint going around for a while was the the fact that Bioware seems to have gone the route of hyper realism by making everyone's faces gritty and dirty, rather than the stylized brightness apparent before.

What was once a beautiful and brilliant space opera was now a gritty space noir. That may not necessarily be a bad thing, of course, but you if you booted up the latest Mass Effect and got Mass Effect: Noir, you'd be pretty disappointed.

And speaking of disappointed we're ignoring Andromeda which could also qualify for this list, because it's low hanging fruit at this point.

8. Romance Of The Three Kingdoms 14

Koei-Tecmo has been spitting out Romance of the Three Kingdoms titles since 1985. Back then they were all pixelated maps and portraits, but by 2016 the games showcase beautifully rendered portraits, backgrounds, and cut scenes. Officers have polygonal models displayed when on screen, especially showcased during duel events. Each game an improvement over the last.

Advertisement

Well, not so much with 2020's recent release of the latest in the series: RTK 14. Major complaints of the game are poor optimization, the fact that the game is locked at 30fps no matter how good your graphics card is, and that the game suffers a major loss of quality in the officer models.

What makes the issue with the officer models even worse is the fact that some officers that used to have models for their characters don't any longer. Whether this is setting up a future of visual DLC offerings for things that used to be included in the base game, or just a visual downgrade is unsure given the game's been out for only a few months - the English release having come out at the end of February.

7. Assassin's Creed: Unity

2013's return of a Kenway character in AC IV: Black Flag had been nominated for at least 3 graphics awards, including 'Best Technical Graphics'. Largely regarded as one of the best in the series and a marked improvement over AC III, it set a new bar for Ubisoft to maintain or surpass.

Advertisement

And with the eighth major installment of the franchise, Unity, they absolutely did not even look at the bar - much less get anywhere near it. Imagine what it would look like if a pole vaulter showed up to the Olympics without his pole, or even his shoes, or even his face for that matter.

Released to scathing reviews, not only for the troubling lack of female characters (especially since the most famous assassin in the setting of the game was historically a woman), the repetitive gameplay, lackluster plotline, and poor enemy AI.

Even with all that going wrong for it what Unity is most widely known for is the missing faces, poor framerate, and horrible slew of visual glitches. In the years since Ubisoft has worked to patch most of these bugs out, but it will still forever be known, as PC World stated as, "a new low for the Assassin's Creed series."

6. Dragon Age 2

Dragon Age II was set up to be a grand sequel to the Bioware masterpiece that is Dragon Age: Origins. Bioware intended to fix what was wrong with Origins and improve on any weak points the first game may have had. And then EA gave them a short development window which forced a rushed and crunch-laden development.

Advertisement

While still a respectable game, Dragon Age II was missing much of what had made the first game so great. With a much smaller game world - restricted to only a single city, rather than a whole country, not to mention reused assets in multiple dungeons compacted by the fact that said assets were rather bland.

Ultimately the biggest flaw was that the level design seemed far less majestic and smaller-scale than the previous game. By making a smaller world they could have utilized tighter design to make things seem - well anything, really - more hectic and tense, more crowded...more value per meter, so to speak. But in the end it was just more of the same, and all of it was basically just uninspired brownness.

5. Crackdown 2

Crackdown 2 is best described as a full-priced, numbered, expansion pack to the original game. Featuring much of the same as the original it gives little in the way of new features and also reused much of the same assets the first game utilized.

Advertisement

All that is bad enough, but Ruffian Games' second outing to the series also shipped with many of the game's textures not fully rendered. With the graphics unfinished it made what could be seen as simply a rehash of the first actually wind up looking even worse than said original.

Imagine making a grand dinner for your significant other, and they say they like it, so the next night you make another - but you don't broil it long enough and you just hand them the same dish they had last night, but undercooked. Nobody's going to be happy. Your significant other will be left hungry and underwhelmed and you'll be left sleeping on the sofa, where you belong.

The best thing about the game is Terry Crews, and though he is fantastic at just about everything he does, even Mr. Crews is not enough to make this recycled plate of leftovers palatable.

4. WWE 2K20

Oh what a disaster this game was. Aside from the buggy controls and glitches on release, the graphics were god-awful compared to the previous year's title. IGN, which has a habit of scoring even dribble highly, gave the game a 4.3 out of 10! To give you an idea, IGN scored that abysmal Ghostbusters game from 2016 that we mentioned previously as a 4.4. The game that sank an entire studio got a tenth of a point more than this one!

Advertisement

One of the major boons to the game was the inclusion of no less than 238 wrestlers to play as. But a major criticism is that many of them looked like they'd just been ported straight from one of the series' PlayStation 2 versions. Considering the series had been trending down until it got revitalized by 2K19's release, it only served to make 2K20 that much bigger of a hammer slam into the ground.

Assuming, of course, the models even loaded properly. It wasn't uncommon to have a wrestler's face just...not appear. Imagine all the buggy cut scenes with floating eyeballs from Assassin's Creed: Unity thrown into a ring and made to duke it out.

Well, no, actually that might be kind of interesting to watch. Nightmare-inducing, no doubt, but interesting.

3. Postal 3

0

The Postal series has never been one to blow away its competition visually - rather it preferred to blow away its competitors with controversy and cat-butt silencers. Needless to say the third game in the series, created by outsourcing the actual production to Russian development company Akella, came out to be more of a buggy mess of glitches.

Advertisement

While the glitches included no short number of game-crashing bugs it was also a visual mess and looks even shoddier than the brutal second game in the series. While the models, themselves, may have been improved upon the poor optimization and high amount of visual glitches made any meager improvements pointless.

Now consider this fact - Postal 2 was released in 2003 using the Unreal 2 Engine. Postal 3 - which looks like a bigger pile of grotesque garbage than half the population of Paradise once Postal Dude is done with a rampage - came out in 2011 using the Source engine. Eight years they had to develop and improve the series and this garbage was the result.

It was so bad that a year later the developers, Running With Scissors, actually removed their own game from sale and retconned it all away with a DLC release for the earlier title.

2. Devil May Cry 2

Devil May Cry was born of Kamiya Hideki taking too big of a step away from the survival horror cues of Resident Evil and his crew, colloquially referred to as 'Team Little Devils' taking inspiration from Dante Alighieri's Divine Comedy. Despite the success of the initial release, the second game in the franchise was handed off to another group within Capcom's development studio and Kamiya wasn't a part of it.

Advertisement

One of the things the new crew decided to utilize was larger, more open levels. This may not have, perhaps, been the worst choice - but in the process of opening up the levels they also made them far less detailed than the original game. Unfortunately when you increase your level by 900% you also need to put 900% more little details into it if you want it to seem roughly the same in quality.

Imagine you have a 10 square meter living room and you expand it into a 90 square meter living room, but you don't buy any more furniture. You just spread what you've got against each wall. Congratulations, now you can walk from the couch to the TV blindfolded without tripping over your coffee table. Safe, perhaps, but very boring.

1. Jagged Alliance: Back In Action

Okay, so we've written previously about the failings of the Jagged Alliance series since - well, since basically everything after 2002. The highwater mark of the series came in 1999 with Jagged Alliance 2 which had a commendable art style and utilized an isometric view along with animated portraits to add some character to the mercenaries you could hire.

Advertisement

And then the franchise changed hands - several times - and wound up getting, not a legitimate sequel, but a reboot in the form of 2012's Back in Action. A graphically upgraded remake of Jagged Alliance 2 there was little one could do to screw it up - you already had a winning formula, a good system, and even a workable source code you could just clean up and improve upon.

Nope - the new developers decided what this reboot needed was to totally scrap the game's original unique art style and replace it with a heaping ladle full of generic lookalike characters with different colored hair, plus hats and sunglasses.

It's one thing to not be an improvement, it's another thing to improve something in such a way that the improvement looks like garbage.

Advertisement