10 Ways Your Favourite Video Games Were Almost Radically Different

Grand Theft... Auto? You mean 'Race n' Chase', right?

By Josh Brown /

Video game development isn't easy. With the pressure on to create something distinct that stands out against the competition while at the same time keeping up with the features and mechanics that are making other games successful, studios have to constantly chop and change upcoming products right up until their due dates.

Advertisement

Not only that, but when you have hundreds of people working on the same product for years at a time all with different visions, there are always going to be creative ideas being optioned that could completely change the focus of development.

But while these differences are usually small and a natural result of production, sometimes a title can change massively from its first unveiling to being put in your console.

Whether it was the result of internal problems with a game's production or just last minute 'eureka!' moments that saved titles in the final few months before retail, some of the industry's most beloved games underwent radical changes before release.

With these changes available for anyone to analyse, players have been left to wonder what the world of gaming would look like if the original incarnations of these titles ever saw the light of day.

10. Uncharted 4

On the surface, when Uncharted 4 was first announced back in 2014 it looked as though Sony had everything in order for Nathan Drake's final outing. Under the surface however, Naughty Dog hadn't even decided whether this was going to be the final entry in the series at all.

Advertisement

Revealed in Jason Schreier's book Blood, Sweat and Pixels, the original vision for the game was completely different to the one that eventually shipped.

Initially, a good chunk of the title was going to involve no shooting at all, with the devs instead putting the focus on platforming, melee combat and stealth, rather than full-blown firefights.

Likewise, the story was also going to be altered, with Sam being the main villain. The twist that he was Drake's brother was originally going to be reserved for a later part of the game, in an attempt to drag out the fractured relationship between the two characters.

With the sequel not coming together in a way befitting of Naughty Dog's reputation, upper management brought in the directors of The Last of Us to steer the ship, throwing away the majority of the work already completed to craft a new finale to the series.

9. Borderlands

When Borderlands was first announced, it looked like any other first-person shooter that came out in the latter half of the 2000s. Featuring the same po-faced, serious tone and lacklustre visual design that so many video games were trying to emulate at the time, Gearbox Software's iconic FPS completely lacked the character that it does to day.

Advertisement

Knowing that so many of its competitors were following suit and creating these dreary post-apocalyptic shooters however, the team decided to delay the game and attempt to give the title a distinct identity that would set it apart from the likes of Fallout 3 and RAGE.

Changing the visual design completely to a new cel-shaded look and dropping the serious nature of the story in favour of something more inherently silly and comedic, the new and improved version of Borderlands was able to stick out from a crowd of samey shooters, becoming a beloved new franchise in the process.

8. Alan Wake

In development for over six years, the Xbox 360 exclusive Alan Wake went through multiple iterations before becoming the cult classic it is today.

Advertisement

Originally wanting to create an open world game after working on the linear third-person action series Max Payne, Remedy built the town of Bright Falls with the idea that players would be able to freely explore it in mind.

Unfortunately, after trying and failing to make the open world focus of the gameplay work with the linear nature of the storytelling, the devs scrapped the sandbox idea and instead restructured the title around a more focused, episodic design inspired by the studio's TV show influences.

Weirdly enough though, you can still see the open world DNA of original iteration in the final release. The ability to drive from one part of a mission to the next seems like a hangover from the original vision, and might indicate that Remedy didn't scrap their sandbox focus as early in development as they intitially claimed.

7. Halo

Announced for the Mac back in 1999, Bungie's Halo: Combat Evolved changed massively in the years between its original unveiling and its eventual release as an Xbox exclusive.

Advertisement

While the aesthetic and the world stayed pretty much intact in the transition from Apple to Microsoft, the gameplay itself took on a radical new focus. Originally a third-person action game, somewhere along the line the iconic title switched perspectives to become the FPS we all know and love today.

And considering how much Halo shook up the first-person shooter genre with its buttery-smooth controls and more streamlined approach to combat, it's strange how late in development this perspective was actually decided on.

The impact of the first Halo can't be overstated, and there's no denying that the gaming world would be radically different today if the original third-person, Mac-based incarnation of the game ever saw the light of day.

6. Prey

Before Prey was completely rebooted this year, Bethesda was actually going to create a true follow-up to the original 2006 game that continued the franchise's story in a new cyberpunk setting.

Advertisement

Dropping the fantasy-inspired narrative of the original in favour of a more gritty bounty-hunting tale, information on the game was difficult to come by after it was sadly cancelled after a few years of tumultuous development.

Recently though, some of the devs behind the sequel have since explained a bit more about what the focus of the game was going be, and they were working on some pretty tantalising concepts.

One interesting tidbit was that there was going to be a twist where dying didn't just result in respawning like in every other game, but was framed as the player coming back as a different clone of the protagonist.

Death wasn't just meaningless, and the game was going to reveal your character's true nature by showing you the bodies that you'd racked up over the course of the title near the sequel's finale.

5. Destiny

By all accounts, the development of the original Destiny was a bit of a shambles.

Advertisement

While the game's core was always similar to what it is today, with a focus on MMO-style gameplay and a shared-world single player design, the story and structure of the game underwent monumental shake-ups until a few months before it hit shelves.

The original idea was to give Destiny a story as expansive and as intricate as Bungie's previous Halo games. Taking place across multiple different planets and focusing on characters like Osiris (who featured heavily in the first draft but not the final release itself), the title's narrative wasn't shaping up how the developers wanted.

Unimpressed by what they'd seen and with only six months left before release, the management decided to throw the story out completely in favour of patching something else together instead.

Realising they couldn't create something new in such a small amount of time, instead of having one cohesive story Bungie split up missions into different sections to create more content. Consequently certain set-pieces were ripped out of levels to be used later outside of their original context, and entire planets like Mercury were dropped entirely in favour of a smaller scope.

4. Resident Evil 4

After the release of Resident Evil 3, Capcom's survival horror franchise was in desperate need of a shake up. Attempting to revitalise the long-running series, the publisher ordered a bunch of different prototypes for what would become Resident Evil 4, all completely different from one another.

Advertisement

Most of these were short lived, including an action-heavy prototype that eventually became Devil May Cry, but one came close to being the next instalment in the RE franchise.

Sticking with the fixed camera and tank controls of the original, this version of Resident Evil 4 still featured Leon Kennedy, only instead of shooting Las Plagas-infected villagers he was facing off against ghosts and zombies in a terrifying haunted mansion.

Putting the emphasis on supernatural rather than biological horror, despite the familiar controls and perspective this incarnation of RE4 would have moved the series far away from its roots.

It's cool to look back on now, and it's clear that a lot of the ideas did make it into the final release, but there's no denying that the actual Resident Evil 4 was a marked improvement on this original effort.

3. Grand Theft Auto

If it hadn't been for a glitch during the development of the original Grand Theft Auto, gaming might be radically different today.

Advertisement

Originally titled Race 'n' Chase, the first GTA featured none of the over-the-top violence players know and love today, and was instead an attempt to produce an open-world racing game with a heavy emphasis on reckless driving.

Casting players as either cops or criminals, the game would have had you completing street races with a crime twist. Weirdly though, a glitch during development made the police cruisers constantly ram the players off the road, and the devs realised that escaping the fury of the cops made for a much more enjoyable gameplay experience than pure racing.

Deciding to expand on this idea, Race 'n' Chase eventually became Grand Theft Auto, becoming the basis for one of the most popular video game franchises of all time in the process.

2. DOOM 4/DOOM

After shipping Doom 3, Id Software began working on a sequel that was going to take the franchise back to a place it hadn't been in years: Earth.

Advertisement

Following in the footsteps of Call of Duty, the original idea for the game was a similarly-inspired modern military shooter that swapped terrorists out for demons.

But while the enemies were different, design philosophies were the same. Dropping both the survival horror elements of Doom 3 and the fast-paced gameplay of the original titles, the then-titled Doom 4 was much more sluggish and slow-paced than any of its predecessors.

Featuring the same point-and-click style shooting as CoD, the game would have had you fighting as part of a team of soldiers pushing back against the demonic threat that had invaded Earth over huge action set-pieces.

Knowing that the series had strayed too far from its roots however, the team eventually scrapped this idea completely after trying and failing to make it work for years. It was for the best however, because what they came up with in its place was one of the greatest first-person shooters in years.

1. Bioshock Infinite

Although the location and characters of Bioshock Infinite remained intact from its initial announcement to its eventual release, the role they played in the story was constantly changed during development.

Advertisement

Originally a floating city founded by the US government as a display of power, Columbia was home to an internal struggle that resulted in Comstock, one of the founding fathers, taking control of the city for himself. Resulting in a rebel uprising, the majority of the game would have been centred around Booker and Elizabeth fighting their way through this civil war.

Likewise the gameplay focus was also completely different. Although the general shooting and weapons remained the same, the sky-rail system was originally included because the maps themselves were much larger and more open. Allowing you to quickly traverse the levels, this mechanic would allow players to scale the the epic vertical maps of Columbia.

Elizabeth's tears were also completely different, being used in the initial iteration to aid moral choices rather than being reduced to the glorified med-kit or ammo stashes they were in the final release.

Advertisement