Here's the thing; gamers have been too nice for far too long, and those in charge have finally realised just to what degree of digital monetisation-bladed murder they can get away with. This isn't 'yet another' article aimlessly bashing the current generation's whizz-bang gimmickry - there's definitely plenty of them out there already and it does play a big part in this approach - but instead it's worth addressing just how many snowballing problems are slowly coming together. When sites like IGN and Giant Bomb are struggling to fill their home pages with anything worth talking about it's a real issue; and that's before you actually really try and think of exclusive titles coming up that'll justify opting to hitch your wagon to either Sony or Microsoft's overly shiny horses. Seriously, right now just try and think of a Playstation or Xbox One exclusive that's coming this year that you're really glad you bought the console for. If you're still someone who's yet to upgrade, do the same for those titles that are making you want to lay down the half-grand cash to play... There's not really anything, is there? The biggest titles of the year - from The Witcher 3 to Rock Band 4 and Metal Gear Solid V - are all third-party, and will be nigh-exactly the same on opposing hardware, begging the question of exactly what the hell are the two most important companies in gaming doing right now to earn your money? It doesn't stop there though - pulling at this particularly dark thread only unravels every key issue that's needed to be addressed for years now.
12. There Aren't Any New, Iconic Characters
As covered in this article last week, the current state of gaming's legendary heroes is pretty dire. Sonic looks like he's been let loose with the sticky tape and Spyro's new look is more akin to him coming down with a particuarly warped skin disease than anything resembling cuteness. It's not just these old-school mascot-style characters who've been ravaged by the test of time either - put simply, there's no really iconic, industry-defining legends on the go right now; especially not for the next-generation. Can you name any character on the next-gen consoles that everyone would know by name? It certainly isn't Shadow of Mordor's Talion or the literally cobbled-together aesthetic of Knack, that's for sure. Like the film industry of 2015 you're always just one reboot away from an ancient character being brought kicking and screaming into the present day - with absolutely none of the likability, nuance or originality that birthed them in the first place. Instead, rather than taking those more modern design aesthetics and bolting them on an older foundation, why not take the financial hit that comes with zero recognisability and launch a new IP in a similar vein? It worked for Jak and Daxter following Crash, and it'd work again. However, even if those templates were seen to be bankable, nothing good would come of it because...
11. The Industry's View On Equality Ruins 99% Of All Creative Visions
It's like vultures picking apart a rather large, forever-juicy carcass at the minute whenever something releases and you look at the likes of Polygon or PC Gamer gnawing away at any reactionary angle they can sink their teeth into. Assassin's Creed took a pasting because Ubisoft didn't accurately model any playable female characters, but the intent of the developers seemed to be thrown away in the process - like, what if they simply wanted to tell a male-centric tale? It's not a damning indictment on all of womanhood to point at something and say what it isn't, just like Tim Schafer's recent comments at GDC weren't remotely racist either. It's all in the intent, not what can be spun afterwards. All that happens when creative teams have to curtail to endless amounts of criticism ranting endlessly about things that were never supposed to be controversial in the first place is you get neutered play-it-safe garbage like The Order: 1886, a game box-ticked into completion to please as many people as possible, without any of the creative implementation necessary for any worthwhile replayability.
10. You Can See Right Through Every Business Practice
Do you know what the average age of a gamer is? 35. And do you also know what pretty much every 35-year old will tell you? When they're aware of being ripped off. Juggling bills and income wages with a living cost will do that to you, and most likely far before you reach 35 too. As soon as something like Evolve announces it's being built 'with DLC in mind' or that a game is advertised with a "Pre-order now to get this exclusive gun!"-type deal, it's the most off-putting "Are you KIDDING?!"-provocation of a reaction around. Somewhere along the way the industry seems to have forgotten the people who have been there from the start are still very much alive, and they're the ones shelling out their hard-earned to buy these machines and games for either themselves or their kids. There was always an air of "Do we really need these?" when the new consoles got announced and released, and more than ever now is the perfect realisation that no, we don't. Nobody forced developers into sky-high budgeting realms that need DLC to recoup, and the more ways titles are segmented out for the sake of cashing in on peoples' love for one of the most passionate mediums around is just loading the gun for a continuous backfire.
9. There Haven't Been Any New Game Mechanics In Years
Remember when Call of Duty 4's perk-based multiplayer revolutionised the very way you played online? How about Gears of War's stop n' pop cover system that finished what Resident Evil 4's behind-the-shoulder gameplay started? The nearest thing to a new mechanic in a game that's worth copying is Shadow of Mordor's Nemesis system, and even that didn't have an end goal. It was definitely awesome and great fun to run into the same orc over and over with different dialogue and buffs packing out how each confrontation would go down as you remixed their hierarchy to your liking, but when the answer to "Why am I doing this?" comes back "Because you can!" it just isn't enough. When game budgets are as gargantuan and small island-sized as they are right now, publishers just literally can't (or won't) take a punt on anything new. The very reason that Nemesis feature got in was because the rest of the game was a carbon-copy of Assassin's Creed - albeit, y'know, actually playing well. Point to 90% of the titles coming this year and apart from No Man's Sky's world-generation (which is more of a programming feat than a worthwhile game mechanic) is there anything you're truly dying to try out that hasn't been done before?
8. Early Access And Kickstarter Are Terrible Ideas
At what point did the idea of paying full retail price (or a discounted amount depending on the developer) for a game still in development become a good thing? Games - mostly on Steam, as even Microsoft and Sony are too sensible to let loose a world of half-broken arcade titles without guaranteeing they'll work - should be the full experience before you start putting your money behind them. It's that simple. Sure you can say that people have the option to just not buy the thing right in front of them, and that's a good point - but at the end of the day we're gamers who are interfacing and looking forward to a particular product, and when said product finally releases in some state, people are going to want to buy it. Even that discounts those people who aren't fully aware of what they're buying into, leading nicely into Kickstarter - as Peter Molyneux's Godus is an absolute trainwreck besides the guy apparently having the best intentions, and now three years later with a quarter million in cash behind him and nay a full product in sight (but another started in development) it just makes you take a step back and think "Just what the hell happened to the structure of this industry?!"
7. The Complete Lack Of Polish Is Infuriating
Every game seems to be releasing in various states of alpha or beta these days, rather than anything close to a feature-complete 'retail state'. Even the games that are signed off to be fully priced, pre-ordered and delivered on Xmas morning will prompt you to download a 'day one patch' that'll alleviate any bugs the development team have found between their submission and you trying to play it. The new machines let you play anyway as the patch is applied in the background - but that's one hell of a useless feature when surely you'd rather be playing the game in the state the developers intended? Either the production budgets and software major developers are now using has changed so drastically from past generations so as to scupper any previously in-place deadlines or release schedules, or there's just a monumental lack of testing going on from the top brass. And considering even Tetris didn't launch in a playable state on the PS4 and the latest Assassin's Creed gots to retail with its hero's face melting off - you're right to be believe it's the latter.
What do Mass Effect 3 and Uncharted 2 have in common? They both had crowbarred-in multiplayer that no one asked for, momentarily enjoyed in a "I guess I'll check this out"-sort of way and then completely forgot about. Sometimes it's downright refreshing to hear about a title that's had the entire might of the production team put behind a single player component, because after all, Ocarina of Time, GTA III, Half-Life 2 and Mass Effect 2 were all died-in-the-wool single player experiences and all the better for it. The reason developers do this forced multiplayer stuff is a direct reaction to the likes of Call of Duty, Halo or Battlefield's numbers post-launch. Many titles recoup their costs after release, but if a developer can extend the playability window of their title beyond the initial "I've completed it, now what?" sensation after that main campaign is finished, they're laughing. Problems arise when you can tell games like the aforementioned would've been better just as single-player experiences, and when the industry tries to do multiplayer-only games like Evolve, Titanfall or Destiny all contingent on consistent play and a steady stream of add-ons over the following months, they fail just as hard.
5. Quick-Time Events Ruin Major Set-Pieces
Something plenty gamers thought they'd very much left in the rear-view mirror were quick-time events (QTEs) following the leap to new hardware, but as Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare and The Order: 1886 proved, they're still very much something the companies behind your biggest games want to continue pushing. Why? Because Jonny Can't-Handle-His-Difficulty likes to watch the pretty cutscenes and stab the button to win every few moments. Even though developers like Naughty Dog and Rockstar have shown you can craft a set-piece that continues to play out with the player enacting their own agency within (Uncharted 2's train sequence, for example), it's far easier to bolt the player into a particular on-rails sequence and shoot fireworks their way as an excuse for some high-octane thrills. However, like Michael Bay and the insultingly over-sexed Transformers flicks, after so many years of non-stop explosions where the only thing to do is succeed by hitting a prompt to start the next animation, it all gets too tiring. Or even worse, you fail one prompt and the game's most basic level of engagement is completely lost.
4. The All-Digital Future Is Fundamentally Flawed
Either the idea of an instant-access list of all your favourite games regardless of platform (but all bound by a particular company) is the coolest thing ever, or it brings about questions of what - if anything - you'll have to show for your money when everything's said and done. The main problem is storage space. With the ballooning file sizes of newer games in the region of around 60GB - and subsequent patches like GTA's heists being 5GB - when you factor that into a hard drive size of 500GB, you've only got room for a handful of titles at any given time. Sure, you can delete them as you go and the option to upgrade your hard drive is there if you're handy with a screwdriver, but you shouldn't need to. Both these solutions feel forced when the very idea of digitisation is supposed to be streamlined, no-nonsense access to your entire library. Playstation Now has some promise, but when the idea of streaming a game (it loads on a server and you beam your controller inputs back and forth) is as laggy as it sounds, it just makes you yearn for the disc-based ways of old.
3. DLC Can Be Great, But It's Being Abused
If the internet was a person capable of verbalising a response to something, the answer of how much DLC (Downloadable Content) can expand a gaming experience would be met with a froth-mouthed fervour before whatever interface was doing the talking imploded. See, DLC inherently isn't a terrible proposition. It was supposed to come from developers continuing to work on a project after their original vision goes gold, thereby what you get after the street date is supposed to be ancillary additional content that's utterly optional. All that changed in the most egregious way back in 2012 when Mass Effect 3 had its innards scooped out and resold as DLC on day one, prompting the realisation on the industry side that "Hey, if we take an integral part of a game away, we can sell it back later!" Now, from essential story lines to content like the above Alien Nostromo stuff that just feels like it should've been in the main game, there's a bad precedent set by developers who choose to withhold some of their best content for fans to shell out for later down the line.
2. The Price Of Everything
Have you seen the price of the average game? It's 60-odd quid, and that's before you look at the likes of Destiny or Evolve's special edition which ranges over the 100s. In a climate where the game's themselves aren't offering anything particularly new, yet the thing that does advance is graphical wallop and overall production value through art assets and rendering - it only means you're paying far more buck for far less bang, and when did the law of diminishing returns ever work out in the long run? Some of the best experiences you could have over the last few years were indie titles, as good gameplay doesn't need pyrotechnics to catch your attention. Just look at Hotline Miami - it's a blocky over-pixellated mess (to most) but it plays like a neon-soaked fever-dream purpose-built to dance on your primal cortex. When was the last time you actually thought a £/$60 game was worth the money overall?
1. They Don't Know Whether To Be Films Or Games
Cinematically shot cutscenes and motion-captured footage is one thing, but to ram a game full of the stuff and forget about a key ingredient like say, gameplay, is a recipe for a game you'll clock in an afternoon, marvel at how fun and engaging it was - and then never play it again. As blasphemous as it might seem to say, that was the problem with Metal Gear Solid 4, and although creator Hideo Kojima still included some spectacular gameplay to keep things fresh, The Order: 1886 (yes that again, but it really is the perfect and most recent example) was literally just a cutscene-fest, with Gears-goes-Victorian gameplay lobbed in between. Heavy Rain's creative director David Cage said he only wanted you to play through his much-maligned title Fahrenheit once - as that would be the experience that you'd have to live with thanks to the cutscenes and branching gameplay choices all combining to form a cohesive impactful narrative. However that game had some very original control methods at the time, not to mention exploring the idea of a larger narrative whilst routing every scene in your control of the characters. These days forgoing the narrative backbone you've got a slew of titles all sitting somewhere between half-film, half-video game hybrids, with quick-time set-pieces and on-rails shooter sections taking you out of the experience altogether when you're not being told about upcoming DLC packs or sequel announcements only a week after release. It needs to change. What other gripes and grumbles do you have about the industry at the moment? Let us know in the comments, and join the Facebook for more!