8 Emotional Video Game Deaths (We Couldn't Help Laughing At)
What a rotten way to die.
Video game storytelling has had a lot of catching up to do in comparison to movies and TV. There's no shame in it; this is still a young industry, and the limited technology of previous generations meant that gaming stories could only gesture at being "cinematic".
This, of course, was compounded with limited budgets that meant experienced, costly actors were out of the question. A lot of older games were loved in spite of the voice acting and performances rather than because of them, with the likes of Resident Evil becoming infamous for their dodgy line deliveries.
Still, that didn't stop developers from trying to deliver serious stories that tugged at the heartstrings. Some managed to pull it off as well, with the likes of Hideo Kojima delivering cinematic plots in stylish and impactful ways. As a result, there have been plenty of character deaths in the gaming pantheon that are fondly remembered today.
Other developers though... well, they weren't quite so fortunate. The following deaths are certainly still remembered today, but absolutely not for the reasons their creators originally intended.
8. Cole Phelps (LA Noire)
Cole Phelps is such a t*t.
I mean, I love him, but the man is absolutely unhinged, and always about two seconds away from accusing some poor fool of being a sex offender.
Still, despite his, er, eccentricities LA Noire used its runtime to get you behind the troubled LAPD detective. Sure, he had his issues, but his heart was ultimately in the right place, and you wanted to see him snuff out the corruption that was rife throughout the city's biggest institutions - especially when that idealism gets him publicly disgraced and demoted to a desk where he can't cause any trouble.
In the final missions Cole attempts to redeem himself for his past sins and pave the way for a better future, ultimately finding himself in a sewer shootout with a bunch of other do-gooders. With the water rising though and coming in fast, the gang have to escape and, wanting to finally be the courageous one, Cole makes sure everyone gets out in one piece.
Ultimately he realises he's not going to be so lucky, and after a curt goodbye, is swept away by the current.
On paper, this ending should work, but in the moment it's completely jarring. It's an odd, dissatisfying way for the hero to go out, and the awkward suddenness of the drowning leaves viewers tittering out of disbelief.
7. Sonic (Sonic '06)
Now we can argue until we're blue in the spikes about just how emotional the death and then resurrection of a six foot tall anthropomorphic hedgehog with a penchant for corn dogs and gold rings is, given the wider context of Sonic making his passing utterly ludicrous, but it was at least the intention.
Towards the end of the still-derided '06 instalment of Sonic The Hedgehog, players were hit with a genuinely surprising twist: their beloved hero was brown bread. Killed by the title's villain, everyone gathers around to mourn Sonic and his massive shoes.
This, on the face of it, isn't too bad. It's melodramatic, sure, but not too shocking. Then, though, the (very human, remember that for later) princess claims to have felt Sonic's presence floating like a turd in the wind, and the surviving gang sets out to find the chaos emeralds.
They do, and in the weirdest resurrection scene, the (again, very human) princess begs for Sonic to come back, kisses his dead body, light shines from their mouths and Sonic jolts back to life, now transformed into a super saiyan.
6. Jason (Heavy Rain)
It takes a special breed of creative insanity to direct a child's death scene in a way that's funnier than it is tragic.
In the prologue of David Cage's much-anticipated PS3 thriller Heavy Rain - a game which promised to re-write how we considered interactive narratives - architect Ethan's perfect middle-class life crashes down following a fateful day at the mall.
With his mind wandering, probably in the direction of a Bon Iver 'masterpiece' or an avant-garde fusion tea concoction, the world's worst dad loses track of his ten year old son Jason. Despite stalking the trail of a telltale red balloon (keep in mind he's supposed to be ten, not five), and shouting 'JAA-SOON!' repeatedly, in a range of entertainingly melodic ways, Ethan can't locate his lost boy.
Sides are already splitting by this point, as players are encouraged to tap the "Jason" button and wander around the mall in a panic.
Somehow it only gets worse in the next cutscene, where Ethan spots his son across the road. In the most over-edited scene in gaming, Jason is splattered by a car despite his dad's best Matrix-esque attempts, while everyone continues to repeat his name over and over again.
5. Anna (Final Fantasy IV)
Emotions are understandably bound to run high in the event of the senseless death of a beloved daughter during a wartime air-raid, and you can't blame a grieving father for his unfiltered utterances in the heat of tragedy.
That's exactly the awful plight Final Fantasy IV's Tellah goes through, when his darling Anna is caught by the Red Wings' bombs, whilst off in neighbouring town Damcyan on a lovers' tryst with dashing songster Edward. Throwing all reason into the fires of fury, the Great Sage of Mysidia takes aim at his daughter's lover, blaming him for her demise.
Staring the lutist down in battle, Tellah unloads with a torrent of anguish:
"You spoony bard!"
With that immortal line, any and all pathos in the scene evaporates like the Mist Dragon. It's perhaps the most memorable - and most quoted - phrase in Final Fantasy history.
4. Emma (Metal Gear Solid 2)
Pant-wetting nuclear scientist Otacon's acting when his step-sister Emma Emmerich pops her clogs in Metal Gear Solid 2 is like an old English dubbing of one of his Japanese animes. Which is to say, absolutely terrible.
Should Raiden fail to protect the prodigious programmer at any point during her twilight escort mission, Otacon will break down in a ridiculously catterwaul of 'EEE-EEE!!' as though he is fervently recommending a mobile phone network. But that's just a bonus fail-state, as the story gods dictate that E.E. will expire regardless of your efforts, after she's stabbed in the side by an evil vampire (yes, really).
Raiden simply refuses to let Emma die - not before she's tap-tapped a special worm cluster to stop some supra-governmental AI, anyway. Job done, her subsequent death rattle in the arms of her teary brother is very nearly poignant.
That is until, with the corpse still warm, Otacon reveals he boffed Emma's mum, leading her father to take his own life. He's then comforted by a parrot, which causes him to do his best impression of a squeaky floorboard. Good ol' Metal Gear, eh?
3. The Hostage (Spider-Man 3)
You know you've messed up when a death scene is so unintentionally hilarious that players go out of their way to fail the QTE attached to it just so they can have a chuckle to themselves.
I am, of course, talking about Spider-Man 3 and the infamous bomb disarming sequence that occurs early in the game. Here, our friendly neighbourhood Spider-Man is tasked with saving a hostage tied to an explosive device. A QTE sees him zip through the burning building to the victim, giving the player a few button inputs to hit along the way.
Miss the final one of these though, and the old Web Head hits the floor like a sack of potatoes. As he presumably combusts, we get a quick shot of the hostage - all bug-eyed and manic having just seen this hero faceplant the floor - who exclaims "I'm going to die" before the whole building explodes.
It's probably the best thing in the whole game.
2. Trish (Devil May Cry)
Alright so this one is a bit of a cheat, but we couldn't leave it off, could we?
Devil May Cry is a bonkers, melodramatic series, and that all came from the precedent set in the very first game. About a demon hunter called Dante attempting to stop the return of the evil Mundus, he partners up with leather-clad love interest Trish to take on the forces of evil.
Just before the epic final battle, Dante is left in a grand hall, light beaming in, and standing over Trish's seemingly lifeless body. Having grown a bit fond of her in spite of her constantly flip-flopping allegiances, the demon hunter cradles her.
Here, the most saccharine music begins to play, while Dante softly whispers that he "should have been the one to save" Trish. So far so melodramatic, but nothing unintentionally hilarious. Then, though, Dante completely breaks, yelling "I should have been the one to fill your dark soul with light!" which echoes around the hall for added effect.
It's the kind of line read that truly has to be heard to be believed - something so hilariously bad that it single-handedly ruins the emotional impact of the whole scene.
I wouldn't have it any other way though.
1. Gilbert Renton (Deus Ex)
Warren Spector's Deus Ex was an absolute game-changer in the way it delivered an interactive narrative, and with scenes such as this one, it's patently obvious why.
Should Gilbert Renton, the proprietor of run-down Hell's Kitchen inn The 'Ton Hotel perish in the presence of daughter Sandra, you get some of the most memorable line deliveries in all of gaming. The only issue is, they're not really memorable for the right reasons.
After his daughter lets out a not so convincing "Oh my God, Daddy!", player character JC replies with a hilariously deadpan: "What a shame. He was a good man... what a rotten way to die." - even if it was JC himself who blew his head off!
Poor Sandra has just lost her dad, man. You gotta be cooler than that.