8 Video Games That Wasted Genius Ideas

They shot for the moon, but ultimately misfired.

By Joe Johnston /

Every now and then, amongst the thin grey gruel of Ubisoft-brand open worlds and barebones survival sims, a game comes along that truly brings something new to the table.

Advertisement

Think Portal's groundbreaking puzzle-solving mechanics, or Death Stranding's absolutely bonkers package delivery systems. In embracing innovation and daring to break the mould, many of these titles have rightly become classics, forever leaving their mark on gaming history.

Sometimes, however, a game will come along boasting astounding new tech, an exciting premise or never-before-seen mechanics, only to totally whiff on the swing. It's disappointing, and sometimes even heartbreaking, when a title promises a rewarding new experience and fails to deliver.

Whether it's down to a poor implementation of its mechanics, the USP being overshadowed by more generic elements or a publisher attempting to squeeze extra money out of an innovation and alienating its core audience, these games all gave players plenty of reason to buy them, but didn't live up to the hype.

Now that's not to say that every game on this list is bad. In fact, some of them are good titles - maybe even great. They're worth a look for their promise alone, but they just could have been so much more.

8. NeverDead

You can't deny that NeverDead sounds like an absolutely brilliant idea on paper. An immortal demon hunter who hacks and slashes his way through monsters with a gigantic sword and dual-wielded firearms?

Advertisement

Okay, this may all sound suspiciously similar to Devil May Cry, but could Dante pull off his own head and roll it around like a bowling ball in order to navigate tight spaces and solve puzzles? It's not every day you can market a game as Devil May Cry meets Kula World.

The game's dismemberment mechanics are initially very entertaining. Protagonist Bryce can reassemble his body in any order, so the player could potentially navigate the environment as a head hopping along on a single leg, or continuing to roll with two arms flopping about comically by the ears. Couple this with a flamboyant art style and some irreverent humour, and you've got a recipe for a hit.

Unfortunately, the one stumbling block was that NeverDead wasn't actually very good. While Bryce's ability to explode and recoup his body parts was innovative (and admittedly hilarious), the combat and puzzles grew stale very quickly and failed to evolve. Throw in enemies that could consume Bryce's head and instakill the player and it went from "NeverDead" to "InfuriatinglyDeadAlot".

7. Mirror's Edge Catalyst

First-person parkour is a mechanic that's never quite taken off in the gaming world. Mirror's Edge pioneered it in 2008, the Dying Light series uses it as a central mechanic, but that's about it really.

Advertisement

It's a difficult balancing act to present the player with the challenge of platforming from a first-person perspective whilst still making it look and feel cool and free-flowing (basically the two foremost rules of parkour). The limited field-of-view turns complex acrobatic sequences into frustrating exercises in trial and error, and pulling off a dramatic escape doesn't feel half as impressive when you've only managed it on the twelfth attempt.

Mirror's Edge learned this the hard way when it arrived on the scene and was met with a lukewarm reception. When working as intended, the parkour mechanics would feel smooth and even thrilling, but with it being such a nascent concept, there were far more 100-storey death drops than there were daring escapes.

Mirror's Edge Catalyst, a soft reboot released 8 years later, promised to refine the gameplay of its predecessor and expand to an open world setting, leaving players free to explore the rooftops of the city of Glass.

This would have been great had the city been more fun to explore than a cubicle farm, so players frequently found themselves ignoring the game's open world aspects and simply following a glowing red marker to the next objective.

6. We Happy Few

For a while, the hype for Kickstarted indie project We Happy Few was nothing short of immense. Its sinister setting of Wellington Wells, with its downtrodden inhabitants kept blissfully ignorant thanks to a hallucinogenic named Joy, was starkly reminiscent of dystopian works like Nineteen-Eighty-Four, Brave New World and Brazil.

Advertisement

The phrase "The New Bioshock" was thrown around by many, and given the game's period setting and exploration of a drug-induced nightmare city, this seemed pretty apt.

From almost the moment We Happy Few was released on early access, however, that good will basically dried up. While its visual design, voice acting and audio rightly received praise, the game itself played extremely poorly. It was rife with bugs and glitches, and the gameplay and plot amounted to little more than a generic stealth/survival game.

Also featuring completely unnecessary procedural generation, which only served to remove any sense of authorship or flow from the narrative, the whole experience was joyless and dull. At an unacceptable standard even for even an early access title, We Happy Few was a huge disappointment to everyone, most notably its Kickstarter backers.

Considering the game we could have got, having to manage the trade-off between the relative safety offered by joy and the chance to achieve our goal of escaping Wellington Wells, it's safe to say that very few were left, well, happy.

5. The Order: 1886

Released in 2015, The Order: 1886 was a PS4 exclusive with an exceptional premise: The immortal Knights Of The Round Table fight off a werewolf uprising in a Steampunk Victorian London. Go ahead and come up with a more badass sentence than that, I'll wait.

Advertisement

Now that you've given up trying to top that setting, you'll be disappointed to hear that the premise was all that The Order: 1886 had to offer save for some very impressive graphics tech. For starters, the game was only about 5 hours long, which isn't a problem in and of itself if the game is well written or rewarding to play, and several of its chapters were simply extended cutscenes.

On the gameplay front, The Order: 1886 was a bog-standard cover shooter with no more to its mechanics than that of Gears Of War, which had come out 9 years prior.

When it did diverge from this formula players were treated to frustrating linear stealth missions where one wrong move saw the protagonist killed instantly; or frustrating hide-and-seek encounters with a running total of about 3 werewolves.

This brings us to the biggest insult: that for all its talk of werewolves and other monsters, about 99% of the enemies were just cockney insurgents with guns. It teased a unique and memorable world, but gave us a run-of-the-mill cover shooter instead.

4. L.A. Noire

Sigh. L.A. Noire could have been a classic. It should have been a classic. A hard-boiled crime epic that felt like a playable Chinatown, utilising groundbreaking facial capture technology to show every tiny subtlety in an actor's performance: Team Bondi and Rockstar had it in the bag.

Advertisement

The problem was that despite all of the game's strengths; the excellent world-building and writing, the stellar performances, the genuinely innovative investigative mechanics, the developers completely dropped the ball when it came to the most important aspect of L.A. Noire: the questioning of suspects and witnesses.

During these segments, the player can ask questions of other characters based on evidence they have collected. After the character responds, the player is given the choices of "Truth/Doubt/Lie".

This is confusing because A) the difference between the use of Doubt and Lie isn't at all obvious, and B) choosing Doubt frequently results in protagonist Cole Phelps shouting down the interviewee and accusing them of all the world's genocides rather than, say, gently assert that he's unconvinced.

Even worse was the fact that when L.A. Noire Remastered was released in 2017, "Truth/Doubt/Lie" was replaced with "Good Cop/Bad Cop/Accuse". This added yet more ambiguity and insinuated that there were no right or wrong answers when questioning, resulting in even more fumbled cases than before.

Nice one Rockstar, you were given an opportunity to fix things and you bollocksed it up even more.

3. Marc Eckō's Getting Up: Contents Under Pressure

Hey, who remembers Marc Eckō's Getting Up? Yeah, probably not many of you. A 2006 release for the Playstation 2 and Xbox, Getting Up's central concept was that of a young graffiti writer building his reputation by tagging the streets and subways of New Radius, a city under the control of a repressive, Orwellian government. It's clear that developers The Collective had done their homework, as its exploration of graffiti culture was authentic and well researched, and the game's intentions were very good indeed.

Advertisement

Unfortunately, despite tagging in its various forms being central to the game's objectives and plot, the mechanics felt underdeveloped and barebones.

Throwing up a tag was boiled down to simply covering a large enough area with one button held down, and while some attempt was made to elaborate on techniques such as rollers and wheat paste, the player actually spent more time fighting enemies with a finicky and over-designed combat system.

Graffiti ended up playing second fiddle, vital to move on in the game but given less time to breathe than punching guys and some truly broken and unpolished stealth.

Had resources been allocated better to focus more on creating art and less on combat, we'd have had something truly special.

2. Remember Me

Now here's another sad case of combat completely overshadowing a potentially fascinating game.

Advertisement

Remember Me's story concerns the commodification of memory, with the citizens of a futuristic Paris able to upload and share their memories, or even remove unhappy or traumatic ones thanks to the Memorize Corporation. This attempt at a utopia has resulted in Neo-Paris (and possibly the rest of the world) becoming a grim corpocracy and surveillance state at the hands of Memorize's huge monopoly.

Protagonist Nilin, a memory hunter with the unique ability to hack people's memories, altering them and effectively changing that person's entire worldview and allegiances. The game does admirably attempt to grapple with the many ethical conundrums that this kind of action would present, and the memory remixing sections themselves are well-designed and organic; there are a great number of different outcomes and fail-states possible.

The only problem is that over the game's entire runtime... you only do this four times.

Much like Marc Eckō's Getting Up, the vast majority of Remember Me is made up of beat-em-up style combat encounters with hordes of goons, with the memory remix puzzles providing all-too-sparse injections of energy.

Granted, combat is well-designed and impressively modular, and Remember Me is definitely worth a look, but Dontnod really should have pushed their puzzle mechanics far more.

1. Middle Earth: Shadow Of War

Taking the top spot is easily the most tragic example of a genius idea utterly wasted. 2014's Middle Earth: Shadow Of Mordor, while hardly a reinvention of open-world combat and stealth, introduced players to the Nemesis System.

Advertisement

This saw Uruk captains engaged in power struggles with one another, and as such the player was able to use this to their advantage, secretly allowing captains to rise through the ranks and then recruiting them as a network of sleeper agents.

2017's sequel, Shadow Of War, took this concept even further, with protagonists Talion and Celebrimbor amassing a personal army of Uruks to overthrow Sauron, bestowing each with unique abilities and hiring their most trusted soldiers as personal bodyguards.

Unfortunately, this was all undermined by a tiny little thing called micropayments. Yes, WB Interactive seized the opportunity to sell the best Uruks to players in paid lootboxes, ensuring that they'd all but have to spend extra money in order to reach the game's true ending (until said lootboxes were patched out, which must have been especially galling for the poor pillocks who had already been nickel-and-dimed).

Worse still, it was revealed in 2021 that WB had patented the Nemesis System, thus giving them the power to sue any developer who designed a game that featured any mechanic or system that even resembled it.

So many IPs, both existing and burgeoning, could have benefitted from the implementation of a Nemesis-like structure, but the greed of one publisher has ensured we'll probably never see it again. It's a tale as old as time, and a depressing one at that.

Advertisement