8 Video Games Where The Best Ending Is Impossible
No one got these without a guide.
Even 50+ years since their inception, all most video games will ask of the player is to overcome the obstacles in their path and defeat the Big Bad in order to secure victory and save the land, rescue the princess or take over an entire criminal empire (delete as appropriate).
Of course over time, the moral choice has become increasingly popular, rewarding players with alternate endings based on the decisions they've made throughout.
Most of the time, however, this boils down to simply choosing the option that's in red or blue text when prompted, or deciding whether you want to wedgie the patrolling guards into unconsciousness or slit them up with your overly ornate knife.
Not every game's endings are quite so heavily telegraphed, mind you.
Some titles shroud their diverging paths in seemingly innocuous dialogue choices or story decisions, leading to a dreaded downer ending you could never have foreseen without clairvoyance, or a wiki open in a different window.
Others even require the player to carry out actions so completely unintuitive and arcane that a bad ending is almost guaranteed, ensuring you don't get the best ending until some time later.
8. Papers, Please
Lucas Pope's bureaucracy-and-poverty simulator Papers, Please has an impressive 20 endings, only 3 of which could be argued to be "good". The first 17 end with either your arrest, death, or arrest and sentencing to death, while the final 3 all present some degree of cautious optimism.
Will you stay unwaveringly loyal to your oppressive nation and keep your job at the expense of your principles? Will you escape with your family to a neighbouring country that may not be much better than your home? Will you aid a revolutionary force that could be just as corrupt as the regime they overthrow?
Escaping to the neighbouring Obristan requires the player to illegally confiscate up to 6 Obri passports without being caught by officials (which will likely lead to wage deductions or arrest). Given the eagle-eyed nature of your superiors, this is no easy task.
Helping the Order of EZIC to overthrow the Arstotzkan government is even more complex and risky.
The player must allow several EZIC insurgents into the country, poison an anti-EZIC assassin and detain a foreign diplomat whilst allowing another EZIC agent through the checkpoint in disguise. If caught by Arstotzkan officials at any point during the game, you are immediately arrested and it's back to the start. Without some serious espionage chops, there's little hope for you.
7. Resident Evil Revelations 2
The endings to 2015's Resident Evil Revelations 2 hinge on a single action made by the player in its 3rd episode, and by toying with the player and their prior knowledge of the two central protagonists, Capcom had many of us falling for a devious bit of subterfuge.
The game follows Claire Redfield, Resident Evil mainstay and survivor of the Raccoon City Incident, and Moira Burton, a charity worker and daughter of Barry "you were almost a Jill Sandwich" Burton. During her childhood, Moira accidentally shot and injured her younger sister with a gun that the ever-attentive Barry had left lying around, and as such has a hatred and fear of firearms. Her gameplay is therefore based primarily using her trusty crowbar for puzzle-solving and melee support.
During the final boss fight of Episode 3, Claire and Moira are knocked down by a mutated Neil Fisher, and a quick-time event flashes up prompting Claire to grab a nearby gun and execute him. Following the onscreen prompt will set in motion a series of events that sees Moira crushed under rubble, succumbing to her fears.
However, if the player ignores the prompt and instead switches to Moira (who hates and fears guns, may I remind you), they can have her crawl towards the gun and finish Neil off herself.
This results in Moira overcoming her fears and surviving the collapse of the rubble later on. It's complicated and pretty obtuse, but it's Resident Evil - what else would you expect?
6. Oddworld: Abe's Oddysee
A grim exploration of corporate greed and ecological decimation in pursuit of profit (capitalism sucks, mobilise your union) wrapped up in a quirky and blackly comic puzzle platformer, Abe's Oddysee provided players with two potential endings. Depending on how many of the 99 Mudokons the player rescues from enslavement by meat-processing giant RuptureFarms, Abe is either rewarded for his heroic actions or brutally punished for his selfishness.
This all sounds simple in theory: liberate workers, ruin CEOs, live free. However, the game's incredibly high difficulty makes this no simple task, resulting in many Mudokons accidentally being led down bottomless pits or into the paths of patrolling Sligs. To add to this, many of the Mudokons are contained in secret areas which are extremely easy to miss.
The real kicker? It isn't until halfway through the game that the player learns that they even need to save Abe's coworkers. By this point it's likely that the player will have missed many of the potential Mudokons, making reaching that 50 rescue goal even more challenging.
Save for an offhand comment in the game's manual mentioning that saving enough Mudokons "turns you into a god", it's likely that at the end of their first playthrough most players were treated to the site of our working class hero being dropped into a meat grinder.
5. Final Fantasy X-2
Poor Tidus. After seeing his home destroyed and embarking on an epic quest to defeat a gigantic unknowable evil with his newfound friends, he finds out that he was actually a ghost all along, and must sacrifice his spirit in order to defeat Sin for good.
After a tearful goodbye with love interest Yuna, he heads off to the Farplane and the credits roll. However, a post-credits scene shows Tidus swimming to the surface of a large body of water, hinting at his return.
How unfair it must have seemed when most players of spin-off Final Fantasy X-2, expecting an emotional reunion between Tidus and Yuna, reached the end of the game only for this not to happen.
Turns out though, this reunion is possible, but it requires the player to talk to a specific character in Chapter 3, and then press X several times (completely unprompted) while walking in the flower field in the Farplane, until whistling is heard.
At the climax of the game , a character will appear and the player will have to give them an affirmative answer, later being treated to a post-credits scene in which a resurrected Tidus reunites with Yuna.
Oh, and to get the perfect ending? All of the above, plus 100% completion. Possible? Just about. Likely? Absolutely not.
4. The Cave
Developed by Tim Schafer's Double Fine Productions and helmed by Ron Gilbert, the man who pioneered the adventure game genre during Lucasarts' formative years, there was good reason to be excited for 2013's The Cave.
The game was met with mixed reviews and proved somewhat disappointing, most notably regarding its simplicity considering it was written by a figurehead known for his sophisticated and labyrinthine puzzles.
Centring on seven disparate characters who are lured into a sentient cave that wishes to explore their darkest secrets, the game has players choose three characters to navigate the environment. On their journey, each character is confronted by their respective desires and unavoidably commits a grave sin in order to receive their most prized possession.
Upon exiting the cave, the player is admonished for their sins and can start the game again with different characters in order to...once again be admonished for their sins.
There is, however, a way to avoid such a dressing down and secure a good ending to the game, though it's not what anyone would call obvious. This being written and directed by Gilbert, surely there's an ingenious and obscure puzzle that allows the player to avoid committing their character's sins? Nope.
Upon reaching the end, attempt to give the prized possession back to the clerk three times in succession. That's it. No hint that this would make any sense, nothing. Coming from such a brilliant and influential game designer, that's both unintuitive and a little bit lazy.
3. The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt
There is some debate as to which ending to The Witcher 3 is the best one - not to mention all the smaller outcomes regarding the lands of Nilfgaard, Skellige and the Northern Realms.
The game can either end happily with Ciri ascending to the throne of Nilfgaard, using her power to affect positive change on the land, or joining Geralt on the Witcher's path. While these can both be argued to count as the perfect conclusion on either a micro or macro level, seeing Ciri continue her adventures with her surrogate father is what many would likely prefer.
However both of these endings are dependent on the player making several dialogue options throughout the game that conceal sneaky moral choices. On the surface, it might seem like a good idea to tell Ciri to remain calm during a moment of intense anger; to accompany her in a nerve-wracking meeting with the Lodge of Sorceresses, or to reassure her that she doesn't need to excel at everything when she blames herself for the death of Vesemir.
In actuality, you're suppressing her free will, undermining her self-confidence and keeping her fixated on her failures in these instances, weakening her resolve and resulting in her death during her confrontation with The White Frost.
While all these decisions may seem well-intentioned, the player has doomed Ciri - and possibly Geralt - to a grisly fate.
2. Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain
Hideo Kojima's Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain, a Hideo Kojima Production directed by Hideo Kojima, was the culmination of almost 30 years of stealth gaming, and the final realisation of Metal Gear as an open-world epic.
Sadly due to an increasing rift between Kojima and publisher Konami, the final game was heavily cut down, featuring countless repetitive missions and an ending that could charitably be described as abrupt and unsatisfying.
Even the true ending, in which Big Boss discovers he is in fact the nameless medic from Ground Zeroes, having undergone intensive plastic surgery and brainwashing, feels more like a cruel twist than a satisfying conclusion.
However, the Collector's Edition of the game contained details of a mission that was removed, titled "Kingdom Of The Flies".
Taking place after the events of the campaign, the mission would see Snake pursuing an escaped Eli and several other child soldiers through Central Africa after the hijacking of mech, Sahelanthropus. This chapter would have provided closure for several unresolved plot threads (such as the aforementioned hijacking) and allowed development of several characters leading to their appearances in later chronological events in the series.
In this context, the best ending is impossible... because it isn't in the game.
Of course we also have the Nuclear Disarmament ending, which could only be triggered when all players worldwide dismantled all their nuclear weapons - something we'll never legitimately see because, much like real-life war profiteers, we all suck.
1. Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice
Completing Sekiro's story results in the Immortal Severance ending, in which Lord Kuro's immortality is severed and he is sacrificed to end the Dragonrot sickness spreading across the land.
The bittersweet Purification ending, in which Wolf sacrifices himself, requires the player to eavesdrop on multiple characters repeatedly in a very specific order.
Whilst convoluted, the Return ending - widely regarded to be the true ending - can only be obtained by doing the following:
*deep breath*
Acquire the Holy Chapter: Infested; talk to the Divine Child Of Rejuvenation and receive rice; eat the rice, leave the area and return; acquire and eat more rice until the Divine Child falls asleep; ask for rice again, then leave the area and return; exhaust the Divine Child's dialogue and then give her a persimmon fruit; ask for rice one more time and receive Rice For Kuro; give the rice to Kuro before defeating the Divine Dragon; rest and speak to Kuro again to receive two Sweet Rice Balls; travel to the Divine Child and give her the Holy Chapter: Infested; rest so that she travels to the Illusory Hall; travel to the illusory hall and talk to her; travel to Senpou Temple and retrieve the Holy Chapter: Dragon's Return from a random corpse; rest, and travel back to the Divine Child who is now back at the Inner Sanctum; give her the Holy Chapter: Dragon's Return; retrieve both Fresh Serpent Viscera and Dried Serpent Viscera; give the Divine Child both items; rest, then eavesdrop; talk to the Divine Child and receive Frozen Tears; continue the game to the end, defeat the final boss, talk to Kuro and give him the Frozen Tears with the Divine Dragon's Tears.
It's safe to say that anyone who claims to have achieved this without constantly looking over at the Sekiro wiki... is an outright liar.