Assassin's Creed: Ranking The Assassins From Worst To Best

By Robert Kojder /

Assassin€™s Creed is undeniably one of the hottest new gaming franchises to come out this closing generation of gaming, and a large part of that is due to the assassins themselves. We know and have come to love how they operate; climbing rooftops with the agility of a godlike cat, sneaking around and waiting for an opportune moment to strike with their signature hidden blade, and eagle diving into haystacks from hundreds of feet above. Even though I admittedly enjoy the modern day future arc centered on the first civilization of Gods and religious conspiracy theories revolving around powerful artifacts and the predicted 2012 end of days, you simply wouldn€™t have a best-selling franchise that gamers flock to every year if you stripped the games of the white-cloaked, hooded trademark assassins. The most tantalizing aspect of Assassins Creed (and probably one of very few traits keeping the franchise from dipping too much in quality) is the surprisingly historically accurate time periods you are sucked into with each assassin. Whether you€™re fighting alongside George Washington to help win America their independence or blending into a majestic party full of fireworks during the Italian Renaissance, your environments improve the level of intrigue tethered to each assassin. In this feature we will be analyzing the positives and negatives of each assassin we have had the pleasure of getting acquainted with, and ranking them in an effort to see just who the coolest Assassin is yet.

5. Aveline de Grandpré

Aveline€™s last place position on this list may not be surprising anyone right now, but I actually think she€™s a decent character that€™s unfortunately just the victim of an uninspired and boring game. I love the fact that Aveline is a strong willed female protagonist that physically matches up to the best of the best assassins, and I also enjoyed her unconventional upbringing as the offspring of a French merchant father and slave mother. Assassin€™s Creed: Liberation as a narrative in a grander scheme just struggles to find a sense of worth and purpose. This constant internal struggle causes the narrative to never actually feel exciting but rather what we all feared Liberation would inevitably be; a game Sony tossed some money towards Ubisoft to make in an effort to give the Playstation Vita something worth playing. It€™s unfortunate for Aveline because with the production budget of an actual console experience, Ubisoft easily could have fleshed this tale out into something more.

4. Connor / Ratonhnhaké:ton

On the other side of the spectrum we have Connor, who isn€™t exactly the most favored Assassin- and rightfully so- but the fact that he is a vessel for a story revolving around American independence alleviates that. I won€™t deny that Connor constantly whined throughout Assassin€™s Creed 3 and was as sympathetic as a rock. Every 5 minutes he was questioning his allegiance to the Assassins, Templars, Americans, etc; examining who helps him the most. The setting alone though is able to mitigate Connor€™s personality shortcomings. As an American it€™s obvious I€™ve read about major historical events such as the Boston Tea Party, Paul Revere€™s Midnight Ride, and famous battles in Lexington and Concord; playing those timeless events however- as a freaking assassin to boot- is probably a personal transcendent moment in gaming for me. Connor also became the first assassin to not overly rely on the gimmick of the hidden blade. Sure, it€™s there and readily available for you to use but admit it, his Tomahawk was the real show-stealer. Assassins€™s Creed 3 was heavily criticized for the majority of its weapons being worthless but honestly, I intentionally stuck with the Tomahawk and loved every second of combat. Those counterattack executions are still sick!

3. Altaïr Ibn-La'Ahad

I have mixed feelings towards Altair, but most of his shortcomings just come from the fact that Assassin€™s Creed 1is one of the most monotonous and snooze inducing games ever made as far actually playing goes. Sitting on benches and pickpocketing people got old after the first 2 assassinations, doing it 8 more times was just torture. That€™s unfortunately just a circumstance of Ubisoft not quite knowing what Assassin€™s Creed was themselves yet. Remember the jump in quality and concept execution from Uncharted 2 to 1? That€™s exactly what Assassin€™s Creed 2 was reminiscent of, but we€™ll get into that more another time. Altair is the product of a mediocre game that hadn€™t entirely found its footing and direction yet, but he€™s still one hell of an entertaining character and the original assassin. He also had to have his finger completely lopped off to receive his hidden blade because Assassin technology was apparently still in the dark ages. Fortunately, a lot of exposition for Altair spilled over into multiple sequels, making up for a number of Assassin€™s Creed 1€™s faults. Throughout the entire franchise there€™s a brooding sensation that the legacy of the guild is only possible because of his knowledge and extreme dedication. There are even flashback sequences in Revelations where you€™re controlling an elderly Altair who is seemingly in his 80€™s, yet still fighting the Templars tooth and nail. Furthermore, Revelations may be a weaker entry in the end but Altair€™s closure was one of the most emotional and genius moments in gaming.

2. Edward Kenway

Edward is probably the most enigmatic and intriguing of all the Assassins. At first he clearly doesn€™t really care about the raging war between the Assassins and Templars but rather his own personal gain as a ship plundering pirate. His only goal in life is to go on adventures in hopes of getting rich. This results with his induction into the guild as a slow burn but also makes for a gripping personal story. Without spoiling anything, the ending to Assassin€™s Creed 4 is one of the most touching moments in gaming and caps off an amazing story that€™s entirely different from anything in the series. It's not just pirating ships and partaking in missions alongside Blackbeard that propel the experience though. Edward can also fight using 2 swords at once which is very flashy and fun to do. There€™s also the ability to utilize 4 guns in your arsenal to rapidly blast away enemies similarly to how an actual pirate would fight. Ultimately though, Edward is just very charismatic, perfectly blurring the lines between assassin and pirate.

1. Ezio Auditore da Firenze

OK, who seriously didn€™t see this one coming? Ezio is so charismatically charming that Ubisoft churned out 3 full games for him! He is young, brash, and reckless during his teenage years but grows over time into the quintessential assassin. For 3 games we played as Ezio, under the spell of his exotic Italian accent, liberating Templars across absolutely dazzling historical locales including Venice and Rome. I€™m not joking when I say that playing Assassin€™s Creed 2 and knowing that a great amount of the geography was historically accurate desperately made me put vacationing there on my bucket list. Barring Revelations- which should really only be played for more gripping narrative chunks- his trilogy of games are also the highlight of the franchise from a gameplay perspective too. It doesn€™t get much more awesome than having Leonardo da Vinci craft new gadgets for you such as the parachute. From birth, to his rascally teenage years, to his maturity, to his rebuilding of the Assassins, to his elder years, to his natural death in an animated movie, I feel like I have gotten to know and understand Ezio more than most video games could ever dream of achieving with a character. Requiescat in pace! Do you agree with this ranking of the assassins so far? Let us know below!