Dungeons And Dragons: 10 Abysmal Magical Items

Ten instances when you actually feel depressed opening a treasure chest.

By Anthony Hunt /

There are few things to get more excited about in Dungeons and Dragons than treasure. Scratch that, in life. In D&D, treasure usually comes in the form of gold and, if you're lucky, magic items. Special trinkets, weapons, and armor that augment your character's already formidable repertoire of skills and abilities.

Advertisement

As such, nothing is more disappointing than getting an item that just does absolutely nothing for anyone in the group. It makes the entire journey seem a bit of a waste, really, trekking through dangerous lands and fending off foul beasties to come away with what amounts to a magical participation trophy.

Now a bit of a preamble before this list: I'm only using items in the Dungeon Master's Guide, as supplementary common magic items would make this far too easy, and magic items in adventure modules are often tailored for that particular campaign.

Furthermore, I understand that every magic item has its place, and that factors like the campaign setting, the party composition, and creativity of the group all can play a determining factor. If some of these items have been used to great effect by you, then congrats my friend, for you have finally won at Dungeons and Dragons.

With that said, let's continue on and see what items at the top of the treasure hoard should have been left at the bottom of a trash pile.

10. Ammunition, +1, +2, +3

We start off with a the generic term of ammunition. In D&D, this can include arrows, crossbow bolts, darts, or sling bullets. While some of these can be considered viable weapon types, you'll be hard-pressed to find people using the humble sling. As such, you may want to consider buffing up your damage through the use of magical ammunition.

Advertisement

But read the description of these items and you'll realize this winds up being a waste of time. A key deficiency with this item is that once the ammunition hits the target, it reverts to nonmagical ammunition. This means that you're paying extra money for a very small attack and damage boost that really only benefits the player one time.

And this doesn't take into account the possibility of critical misses! Fire magical ammo on a boat and miss, and watch it clear off into the water, never to be seen again. There are so many ways using this item can go bad, that the risk vastly outweighs the reward.

You'd be much better off saving your money and investing in a +1 bow rather than +1 arrows, even if the cost and time to find it may be a bit more difficult. At least your bow isn't going to lose its power after you fire it.

9. Amulet Of The Planes

As was previously stated, most magic items have a feature that can be useful in the correct circumstances; the problem is how frequent that problem occurs. The Amulet of the Planes has an incredibly powerful ability that it can activate without fear of breaking, but has a huge potential for negative consequences.

Advertisement

Amulet of the Planes allows you to make an Intelligence Check in order to cast the Plane Shift spell. Now an Intelligence Check, while not terribly difficult, presents a huge problem if you do fail the check.

In the event that you do fail this Intelligence Check, you and everyone within 15 feet of you is whisked away; not just the ones you had originally intended. Not only that, but there is a 40% chance that you won't even be taken your intended destination. Looking to travel to the Feywild to talk with some forest spirits? Oops, your Amulet sent you to the Nine Hells instead. When it comes to this item, you might just want to hold off until you can cast the spell all on your own.

8. Boots Of Striding And Springing

A good deal of the abilities that this magical footwear can provide you may ultimately prove useless once you start digging deeper into their capabilities. These boots, to begin with, increase your movement speed up to 30 feet. Which....is the base walking speed for the vast majority of each race. Plus, classes like Barbarians, Monks, and others have features that gradually increase your speed anyway, making it an extremely niche feature.

Advertisement

Next, the ability prevents a reduction in speed if your character is suffering from encumbrance, whether that penalty is incurred by wearing heavy armor or too much equipment. The problem with that is many DMs, myself included, opt not to use the encumbrance rules, provided players do not abuse the system.

Tripling your jump distance is a pretty fancy feature, but not used particularly frequently. And even that is hampered by text that specifies you cannot jump in excess of your remaining movement. If all three of your main abilities come with a caveat, then you know you've got a loser on your hands.

7. Cap Of Water Breathing

The Cap of Water Breathing isn't particularly exciting, but that isn't anything to hold against it. After all, it's on the lower end of magical items, carrying only an uncommon level of rarity, it's more likely to be discovered as opposed to some of the other options on this list.

Advertisement

This magical item is pretty self-explanitory: the Cap of Water allows you to, surprise surprise, breathe under water, creating a bubble of air separating your head from the body of water around you. So far so good right?

So what's the issue? Oddly enough, the issue is a little thing called the Cloak of the Manta Ray. This cloak comes with a hood that you can use an action to put up. Not only does it give you the ability to breathe underwater, it grants you a swim speed of 60 feet, roughly 4 times faster than the standard swim speed of most characters. Oh, and this item has the same level of rarity as the Cap of the Water Breathing. The poor Cap of Water Breathing is effortlessly outclassed by it's sexier, sleeker counterpart.

6. Dust Of Dryness

One method of keeping some magic items in check is the Charge feature. Certain items have a finite number of charges that return over time, usually after sleeping or at daybreak. The Dust of Dryness offers no recovery method, and can be used, at most, ten times.

Advertisement

When you use the Dust, you can sprinkle a bit into a body of water, and capture a 15 foot cube's worth of water into the size of marble. So now you've got some water. What are you going to do with it? You can smash it against a hard surface to break the marble and let all the water out. Which means right off the bat, you have to argue with your Dungeon Master about whether or not that wording includes throwing it at an enemy if that's your intention.

Furthermore, it's one of those super fun magic items that uses a cube of liquid, of which will need to be defined at the table. Do any of you happen to know how much water is contained in a 15-foot cube of water? Of course you don't, you'd have to stop the game, Google it, and then determine what you can do with 117 gallons of water. It's roughly the size of a large home aquarium, if any of you were curious.

Oh, and using the dust in the hyper-specific capacity of attacking a Water Elemental does pretty good damage. You know, all those times you'll happen to have this specific item for this specific scenario.

5. Staff Of The Adder

Magic Staffs in the Dungeon Master's Book are incredibly potent items. Many of them come with a plethora of features. Several of them have charges that can be used to cast spells, saving your own resources or even giving you access to powers you may not even possess.

Advertisement

Keeping that in mind, The Staff of the Adder can transform into a poisonous snake. Yup. If your opponent fails a Saving Throw, on a single turn it will deal, on average, a whole 14 damage, half of which is poison. Those of you who play a good deal of Dungeons and Dragons will know that poison is one of the most often resisted damage types in the game.

Even better, it's a living thing now, which means that it can be attacked by enemies. With a paltry 20 hit points, the staff is destroyed if your little slithery buddy is killed.

Even better-er, the staff can only be used by Clerics, Druids or Warlocks. Oh hi there, Wizards and Sorcerers, arguably the two most popular staff-wielding classes, move along, this fella ain't for you.

4. Potion Of Animal Friendship

There are a litany of potions that are pre-made within the Dungeon Master's Guide; after all, they're some of the easiest magic items create. Here's a liquid, it does what this spell does, ta-da! Potion. So really, the only measurable value in different potions is comparing their usefulness to their bretheren.

Advertisement

Within the book are potions that can heal, can grant you the power to breathe fire, make you immune to all damage, albeit for a brief time. All of these are potent, effective, can be used well in almost every situation.

The same can't be said for The Potion of Animal Friendship. The spell itself charms an animal into believing that you do not mean them any harm. And that's...that's about it. A generous Dungeon Master might have the beast give you a little help, but that's entirely at their discretion. Beasts tend to be some of the less-challenging foes in the game, so even this isn't particularly saving you any major headaches.

Even looking at it from a resource-management perspective, the spell is only a level 1 spell offered to Bards, Druids, and Rangers which means, chances are, someone in your group already has it. Spend your money on something more useful, like a Block and Tackle. Listen to me, I don't care what adventure you're on, ALWAYS take a Block and Tackle.

3. Horseshoes Of Speed/Saddle Of The Cavalier

On a surface level, these items don't have anything inherently wrong with them. When your character is on a mount, the Horeshoes of Speed double its speed while the Saddle of the Cavalier ensures that you can't be knocked off of your mount by an opponent.

Advertisement

All of that sounds delightful up until you actually play Dungeons and Dragons for the first time. Mounted combat is very rarely implemented outside of running the Cavalier subclass of a Fighter. And looking through the options for a Fighter, you're generally far better of, mechanically, trying out Battle Master, Eldritch Knight, or Champion. I really want to include Arcane Archer on that list because I love their design, but truly it's sadly underwhelming.

I'm not saying there is any right or wrong way to play the game. If you want to be a mounted warrior, then by all means have a go, but, as is a recurring theme with many of the items on this list, it's far too rare an occurence to be of any value.

2. Talisman Of The Sphere

The Talisman of the Sphere may be unlike any other item in the existence of Dungeons and Dragons. It exists solely to provide the players with bonuses in handling the legendary Sphere of Annihilation.

Advertisement

The sphere itself acts as a D&D equivalent to a black hole. A hovering, circular orb of nothingness, the Sphere of Annihilation's only purpose is to consume everything that comes into contact with it, obliterating it entirely.

Now that sounds like an extremely dangerous force, of course. As such, the Talisman is ideal for controlling its devastating potential, giving you a bonus to understanding the nature of it using your character's Intelligence and vastly improving the distance at which you can telepathically move it.

But that's...it. That's all it does, it is literally defined by making a different magic item a little bit more manageable. If a world of incredible magical wonder and power, this little trinket is the equivalent of that little dog in the cartoon that hopped around the large bulldog and wouldn't ever shut up. Inseperable, but useless.

1. Apparatus Of Kwalish

Looking at the Apparatus of Kwalish, you'd be forgiven for assuming someone made a magic item in D&D using a Mad Libs format. This is a 500-lb. barrel that has 10 levers inside that can turn into a lobster-shaped submarine. That is a sentence I was forced to write for this article and I kind of hate myself.

Advertisement

The problems with this thing are numerous. The weight of course being one. It's considered a large barrel, which means that it likely won't fit in any extradimensional containers you have such as the Bag of Holding. You're going to be stuck lugging around this quart-ton beast likely with Tenser's Floating Disk or you'll need to invest in a horse-and-cart just to justify its existence.

There are ten levers inside, with no discernable instructions on how to operate them. Again, the Dungeon Master might be generous and provide you that if you use an Identify spell, but then again it may become a comical trial-and-error item.

Two people can fit inside the barrel with 10 hours of breathing air, while it can be used to go underwater to a depth of 900 feet. Also, did I mentioned it's lobster-shaped in this positon? And you can use its claws to do attacks? To its credit, it has a high armor class and hit points, which can make a good vehicle for characters to take underwater, but ONLY two characters.

Worst of all, it's a legendary item. LEGENDARY! On par with big boys like the Holy Avenger, the aforementioned Sphere of Annihilation, or the Armor of Invulnerability. I'm sure a good deal of thought and planning went into this crustacean abomination; I'm just not sure why.

Advertisement