Madden 23 Wishlist: 10 Things We Want To See

Gameplay improvements, Franchise tweaks and a game worthy of John Madden himself.

By Jamie Kennedy /

Another year, another Madden.

Advertisement

EA's relentless, money-making NFL franchise leapt onto PS5 and Xbox Series X/S last year as the "first ever next-gen entry". In truth, it was another baby step onto new consoles (Madden 21 also launched on new hardware by way of an update), and that's something the developers must fix come Madden 23.

There is a first to report though: NFL legend John Madden sadly passed away aged 85 on 28 December 2021. The franchise's namesake left behind a footballing legacy to be proud of, but this will be the first Madden game to launch without the man most still call "Coach" around to see it. Surely that should spur EA on to make 23 a turning point for the series.

Glittering graphics and superior presentation isn't all Madden 23 needs to thrive however - the game should also refine several features EA has steadily been introducing over the past couple of titles. That means better animations on the field, more intelligent AI to play against, more realistic depth in Franchise and much, much more.

Go on, EA. Do Mr. Madden proud. BOOM!

10. Refined ‘Home Field Advantage’

Some Madden players hated this feature, but the 'Home Field Advantage' pendulum swing did mix up some match-ups. This time, EA should go deeper into the weeds. Playoff games at Green Bay, for example, should be a nightmare for teams - audibles should be even harder to call in louder stadiums too, and more.

Advertisement

Then, there's your own home fans. They should pile on the pressure if you're putting a poor product on the grass. This writer is a Giants fan (stop laughing), so why not have Daniel Jones get all shaky and start coughing up turnovers if MetLife is p*ssed at another failed drive from Big Blue?

Perhaps the most important thing to note here is that EA's current system is a little too erratic. LA's faithful are unlikely to get on Matthew Stafford's back after one quick three and out, so the devs must temper their desire to hammer home how NFL teams respond to success and/or failure.

Last year was a decent start, to be fair.

9. Less Locked-In Animations

Everyone knows the drill with this one.

Advertisement

Currently, players who start an animation cycle must finish it. That's...hardly fun, because it limits the craziness that can happen during NFL games. Take the recent Wild-Card clash between the Rams and the Cardinals; QB pressure on Kyler Murray forced him into all sorts of errors.

That game showed what tipped balls can do, but they're almost totally missing from Madden's animation set. Rarely, if ever, do tips lead to interceptions or touchdowns in games, which is actually kinda sad. EA are missing a whole layer of football by sticking to their ancient, rigid animations.

It's the same with tackling too. Everything needs overhauled come Madden 23. This player wants to see whiffed punts, drops, tips, and fumbles every now and then. It's vital that EA start making line-ups feel more like real human beings rather than machines with helmets and cleats.

8. AI Familiarity

This is an extension on that previous point. If you need an example, here's one; how many times have you repeated the same play over and over in Madden against AI opponents? It's probably a lot, right? That's because it's totally possible to run the same two-three plays on most downs without punishment.

Advertisement

Real NFL teams don't act like that.

Madden 23 should have some sort of algorithm built in that means CPU coaches/teams respond to repetition in a realistic way. Any self-respecting defensive coordinator would get the bullet if they let rivals hit the same corner route five times in a row during the same drive without tweaking their d-line at all.

Of course, there's a catch here. EA shouldn't make it impossible to run the same plays several times per game. If you want to use that touchdown-scoring pass play in the first quarter and deep in the third, go for it. Real, organic football is what players yearn for.

7. Tony Romo On Commentary

Admittedly, this is a selfish one.

Advertisement

Anyone who has played Madden for years will understand though. Hearing Brandon Gaudin and Charles Davis drone their way through commentary is old now - they even sound bored themselves nowadays. EA either needs to give them some fresh dialogue, or get someone like Tony Romo in there to predict everything before you do it.

The ex-Cowboys QB and Jim Nantz would be a neat addition to the presentation suite in Madden 23. If EA can't be bothered to have them record thousands of lines, then pop them in for the Playoffs during Franchise Mode. Also, just to be greedy, get Al Michaels and Cris Collinsworth in for Sunday Night Football too.

This surely isn't too much to ask. Each NFL commentary team has its own broadcast style that comes to the fore deeper into the season, but that's lost in Madden when Gaudin and Davis are saying the same sh*t they were in week one.

6. Increased Focus On Scouting

EA thankfully added in a rookie scouting suite to Madden 22’s Franchise post-launch, and it was a welcome addition. Now, the challenge is to go even further with it and iron out annoying gripes like not knowing just how good a receiver is at catching before signing him.

Advertisement

Key stats should emerge through proper scouting.

That's just basic stuff. Who wants to risk drafting a young quarterback when they don't know how accurate his throwing arm is, or if he's capable of throwing deep balls against wonky cornerbacks? Again, much like with the 'Home Field Advantage' feature, EA made a good start on this in last year's game.

It's time to double down on that hard work by making scouting a crucial part of the Franchise experience. There's a humble joy that comes from unearthing a gem and knowing he'll fit your scheme perfectly. Or, that he should fit in perfectly.

Injuries and loss of form are conversations for another day.

5. Better NFL Draft Picks

This is specifically for AI teams in Franchise.

Advertisement

Seeing the Chiefs draft a highly-rated rookie QB when they have Patrick f'n Mahomes is wild. Coaches should be smart enough to draft what they need, not just players that have high overall ratings. Andy Reid would crack some skulls if his GM went out and wasted a pick on someone who wasn't going to play one snap all season.

It's also irritating that this often takes valuable players away from squads that could use them, which isn't how the real NFL works. That's not how the league is set up - NFL top brass go out of their way to make sure that weaker teams can right the ship if they make shrewd draft choices.

Sure, this is a minor gripe, but a deceptively-important one in the context of how the sport is managed. Madden wants to balance arcade gameplay with sim elements, so EA has to fix this pronto. It's strangling development in Franchise.

4. Bigger Emphasis On Franchise Scenarios

That's not the only thing holding Franchise back - the current scenario engine, whilst fine for a season or two, is a little paper-thin. Madden 23 would become a more exciting product overnight if EA fine-tuned the way it approaches storylines, or added in a whole bunch of new ones.

Advertisement

Unless you were living under a rock, you'd have been gripped by the recent drama enveloping MetLife as Joe Judge tossed shade at everyone and anyone to save his own skin. Ultimately, this didn't work, but it did highlight the unique pressures of coaching in a dense, 'always on' market like New York.

That's the kind of thing 23's Franchise Mode needs.

Being head coach for the Giants or Jets should feel different to taking over in Jacksonville. Or, how about assuming control of a winning team like Tampa Bay compared to an emerging hopeful like the Bengals? Each territory should come with its own pros and cons, basically.

3. Face Of The Franchise Disappears

EA's on-rails single-player mode is more akin to a tutorial for some of Madden's mechanics than a fully-fleshed out thrill ride. In other words, it's hollow and more predictable than a Mahomes deep ball on a short 3rd and 2 from Kansas City's own 30 yard line.

Advertisement

Having the option to play on the defensive side of the ball was nice last time, but the cheesy sports movie scripting and total lack of individuality hurt 'Face Of The Franchise' badly. It's time to sack this one, EA. These straight-to-Netflix narratives are dreadfully contrived and not fun to plough through.

Would anybody really miss FOTF if it was gone?

Some Madden players out there probably enjoy it, but surely even those 'glass is half full' types can see that this could be so much more. There's no point in dialogue wheels or choices if those choices don't have any impact on where the story ends up.

2. Superstar Mode Returns

This would be more like it.

Advertisement

Should anybody expect the exact same Superstar Mode that launched in Madden '06? No, absolutely not. EA would even argue that 'Face Of The Franchise' in 22 was a step back towards Superstar. They're not 100% off the mark, but FOTF ended up being a bland Franchise template eventually anyway, which felt lazy.

Stepping into the shoes of a young QB like Justin Fields and developing his career both on and off the field would be fun. Fields is the ideal candidate for a mode like Superstar. He's 22 years old, has skills and is currently QB 1 for a struggling Chicago Bears team that's headhunting a new head coach.

As Fields, gamers would be tasked with delivering during games and juggling press interviews about a wide range of topics. Then, they'd have to help the new coach bed into Chicago and get the Bears back on top of the NFC North.

Y'know, just throwing out examples of things EA could do here.

1. A True Next-Gen Experience

Perhaps the biggest thing Madden fans want to see is a proper next-gen version of the game. Last year's title took steps towards this, but it was still nowhere near enough. Playing on PS5 should feel remarkably different to playing on PS4; right now, it doesn't.

Advertisement

Presentation, gameplay and more should be enhanced beyond belief. It's of paramount importance that Madden 23 blows everyone away and shows the true power of PS5 and Xbox Series S/X. EA don't have to make Madden a sh*t show on old hardware to achieve that.

They're a big enough company to have two teams working on separate products.

Tackles have to crunch, stadiums must burst with atmosphere, the AI has to be smarter than Aaron Donald at sniffing out RPOs etc etc. Madden's community can't be expected to tolerate bitesized updates forever. It's time for EA to show what next-gen really means.

What else do you want to see in Madden 23? For more like this, check out Madden NFL 22 Review: 4 Ups & 5 Downs and WWE 2K22: 10 Things 2K Must Get Right!

Advertisement